Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Review - Firearms Guild Stores and 2 Rental Pistols

Featured Replies

**FYI** I didn't realize I would be writing a short book today but obviously I did. I had a lot to say about everything so feel free to read thoroughly or skim and skip to the bottom for the conclusion. I DO NOT work for any Guild stores, which might sound surprising, but when I write a review, I like to be as in depth as I can. Especially when it is something like this, where fellow gun enthusiasts (inexperienced and experienced shooters) are reading my opinion. Enjoy...

 

After the new Firearm's Guild store opening it's doors weeks ago in Branchburg, and looking around there a few times, it was time to check out the other new edition to their chain(?). They have three stores now, one in Rahway, NJ, one in Branchburg, NJ, and another in Easton, PA which is the one that the most of this thread is about.

 

Very quickly, I've been to the store in Rahway and although I forget prices, their handgun inventory amazed me. It was a nice place, somewhat of the gun-shop arrogance, but not too much. I handled a few and bought some ammo, and that was it.

 

The Branchburg store is half a gun store and half archery, even with an archery range up stairs. They are still getting in inventory, but from what I have seen, their gun room is fairly small but they are really trying to pack it full. The room I'm guessing is about 30ftx30ft(?), and has long guns standing all around the back of the room, then has glass handgun cases that are below the long guns. The setup is nice, but small and reminiscent of a sardine can. One of the sales employees (we will call him Joe) notified me that he plans to stock the room full (do they even have that much space? Not really) so I am looking forward to what they get in. So far, they have one case full of only Kimber 1911's (Joe also told me that he plans to carry ever single Kimber that is being produced presently), good selection of Glocks/XD's, M&P's, and quite a few subcomp's. I liked that they carry CZ's, they just had one 85b in stock but Joe said that 4 or 5 75b's should be coming in in the next couple weeks. I get tired of seeing Glocks and XD's at gunshops, but for their selection, they did have more than just them. I would say they had about 6-8 FNH handguns in, which I have been eying. They had the new FNX's, FNP, as well as the FNP-45T. NICE! Long gun selection wasn't bad, but wasn't great. Only a small amount of black shotguns, then some hunting rifles and such. I will say there was not much gun shop arrogance floating in the air, which I feel is a make or break situation. If a gun shop has that, I will NOT be patronizing it.

 

So off I went to the Easton Guild yesterday. I had a bunch of stuff to do in the morning so I was unable to get their early and take my time shooting, so with work glooming in a couple hours I knew I had to hurry which kind of sucked. The place is super easy to find (about 4mins off 78), with a huge logo of the name on the front of the building. Sarco is actually right next to it. I walked in and gun safes greeted me, then an area with a few leather sofa chairs and a flat screen. It opened up into a pretty BIG room. Same thing as the Branchburg store, with the long guns behind the counter and the handguns in nice glass cases outlining half of the room. I will just say that they have LOTS of handguns (I'd estimate 150-200) and maybe 100 rifles..I dunno, hard to estimate? They had a vast selection of handguns, with a whole case of old 1911's and a couple other cases filled with other old pistols (all ranging from early-mid 19th century). No CZ's, or at least from what I saw, booo. Lots of Smiths, Xd's, Glocks, blah blah blah the usual.

 

So I went to the counter (at the other side of the store, opposite guns) and a couple women greeted me. One was my age and was nice eye candy. I said I wanted to rent some pistols. I had to fill out and sign about 5 sheets of documents (I believe you can go online and fill these out prior, my mistake) then was asked if I watched the safety video (that I am guessing is online as well). I should have said yes, but I said no, and as I watched the time I was being more and more rushed. I only had about an hour to shoot now, and I was pissed I have to spend 10mins of it watching this stupid safety video. If you are new to shooting, PLEASE say you haven't seen it. It goes over the 3 NRA safety rules as well as Guild's range rules. They are the same as every other range, be safe, don't be stupid, and always keep the muzzle pointing down range. I watched the video and then went over to the cases filled with rental guns. I would estimate they have about 20+ semi-auto's, 10-15 revolvers, and an AR, lever action, and .50 Deagle. Also a S&W 500. I picked out the M&P9 (it was a pro series) as well as the FNX-9. Both guns I have done lots of research on in the past couple months as my decision to buy a new pistol has been brewing, so I was eager to shoot them both. Real quick, they had - HK usp, usp compact, p30/M&P's/XD's/FNX's and lots of revolvers that I didn't really look at to remember. I know they had 3 different 686's and the 500. They also had a black desert eagle in .50. Not sure of Glocks or Sigs anything else, my eyes focused on the M&P and FNX.

 

I bought 2 boxes of 9mm (expensive, but what can ya do) as you can't bring your own (for rental guns at least) and the employee accompanied me to the range (had my own eyes, ears, targets...I know you can rent all of them, not sure if you have to pay). I was given off to the range officer which is on the range 24/7 and led to my port. Now the actual size of this place is huge, but it is divided accordingly - gun shop/rentals, I'm guessing an 8-10 port range which was dark and I had to walk through to get to the 5 port range I shot in. I think this range is JUST for rentals, unsure though. I think it is because it was only 15yds and had 5 or 6 ports. I was talking to an employee and they told me they are planning on putting in ANOTHER 75yard tactical range on the other side of the building. It's obvious they are trying to make this the nicest place around to shoot at. I also need to add that granted it was brand new, but everything was super clean and nice. It's lit nicely, painted with light colors and is vented VERY well.

 

The RO unboxed the two guns and checked chamber, then let me have at it. Since this is already turning into a book, I will try to keep this short. I shot the M&P first, and I had a smile from ear to ear before I even finished the first mag. WOW, no wonder people are switching from Glock's to these things. I research the guns I am looking at for a while, it's easy for other peoples experiences or assumptions to change yours so I take everything with a grain of salt. A lot of people say the M&P's trigger sucks, grips just 'ok', ergo's are ok, blah blah blah. All that went out the door while I was shooting it. I hate DAO triggers but this did not feel like one at all, it was easy to feel when it would break and the reset was a little long but nothing to cry about. The ergo's on the gun are INCREDIBLE. I compare a lot of guns to my 75b which, IMO, is the smoothest nicest shooting pistol I have ever shot (and I try to shoot a lot of different ones). I must say, this thing came close! Not sure which grip pad was installed but my hands liked it! I changed distances with my target to see how the pistol performed, and everything was looking nice. I was rushing trying to fill mags and empty them since I only had about 40mins to shoot, hence why I didn't shoot as well as I'd hoped but still not bad. It is accurate, and SO MUCH EFFING FUN! It was so much fun that I planned on buying a box of 9 for each pistol, and ended up buying an extra box because I was enjoying it that much!

 

I switched over to the FNX and put one mag down range. I could already tell that this pistol, which I was looking forward to shooting possibly even more than the M&P, was not going to do it for me...whether I shot one mag or 20 mags. The SA trigger seemed rather long, and I kept on shooting low with it. Nothing awesome to say about accuracy, although I was rushing. I can't say much about this thing as I really was let down by it. It seemed to have a bit more recoil than the M&P or most polymers, and the grips were blocky and big. I have rather large hands but I found my hands struggling to hold it. The safety is very close to your thumb, and I actually flipped it up (onto safe) 2 times while shooting it. I have heard of other people doing the same thing, I didn't like that. I switched my grip and didn't have a problem with it through the 50 rounds I put through it, but it sucks having to switch your 'usual' grip for something like that. Visually, the FNX is a really nice looking pistol, but the GOD DAMN stippling on the grips is way too aggressive. I held it at Cabela's once and it was the first thing I felt, I jokingly said to the salesman 'hey, do I need gloves to shoot this thing?' I know it comes with a couple grip pads, but I can tell you it wasn't that comfortable shooting with that one installed. I couldn't imagine .40 or .45 recoil with that grip pad.

 

Conclusion:

 

The M&P pretty much blew my mind away. I liked everything about it AND it being the Pro series (which I am not sure of the differences), it MIGHT have had a better trigger than the regular model but it did have a fiber opt front sight really made it easy to point. On a scale of 1-10, 10 being best, the M&P was a 10. I am still impressed by it as I type this, the day later! I can tell you that once my permits come in, this will definitely be my next pistol.

 

The FNX was, sad to say, about a 6.5 out of 10. It just shot ok, and it just did not do it for me performance/fun-wise. I can't tell you how much I was looking forward to shooting it, with all the forum/gun magazine/online sites had to say about it (positive things). The trigger was just ok, the ergo's just ok, and the grip sucked. I found the inside of my hand, between thumb and index finger, did NOT feel good after shooting it. The grip seemed a bit blocky, literally, and instead of being smooth where that area grasps the pistol, it was squared off.

 

And by the way, because I know you are wondering, the only pistols that I have shot I have rated 10 out of 10 in terms of ergo's, performance, and fun factor are the CZ 75b, 97b, P01, a Sig p22?, Glenn P's S&W Pro 1911, and Walther P99 or PPQ I am unsure which model it was.

 

Here are two pics of my targets, nothing great but not bad...obviously shooting a little left that day. The first target is as described: M&P9Pro - top ShootNC at 10yds rapid fire with two mags, right ShootNC at 8yds slow fire, bottom ShootNC at 8yds with two mags double tap while the center holes were rapid fire two or three mags from FNX9 at 10yds. Second target is 8yds slow fire with FNX9.

 

post-2200-0-26817400-1321123871_thumb.jpg

 

post-2200-0-46479200-1321123963_thumb.jpg

  • Author

I just realized I put this in the 'Handgun' section, as I meant for this review to be a handgun only review which it didn't end up being. So mods, if you want to switch it over to 'gun shops and ranges', that's fine by me..thanks.

 

And just to add, I totally forgot to ask the employees what the difference between the regular M&P9 and Pro model is. So I am researching that right now as we speak.

Holy longass post batman. Just to touch on the M&P... the factory trigger is garbage, however the Pro Series guns have a completely different trigger which is quite nice. HOWEVER, a basic m&p with all APEX parts will be far better than the Pro. That's the route I would take. You will also have to add a FO sight, but with the cost of a base model vs the pro, you should still come out ahead.

  • Author

Hahaha after all of that and I totally forgot to include any info in reference to that.

 

$20 per hour of range time

$12 per each pistol rental

 

I am not sure if the AR, lever action, or other guns are more or less than $12 to rent. I'm guessing rifles might be more but that is just a guess.

 

I am also unsure of ears, eyes, and targets. I am guessing ears and eyes are probably free, but you probably have to buy targets.

 

My suggestion is to just bring all three, if you have them.

  • Author

Holy longass post batman. Just to touch on the M&P... the factory trigger is garbage, however the Pro Series guns have a completely different trigger which is quite nice. HOWEVER, a basic m&p with all APEX parts will be far better than the Pro. That's the route I would take. You will also have to add a FO sight, but with the cost of a base model vs the pro, you should still come out ahead.

 

I was researching the difference between the two and it seems like there are 2 differences, the trigger and sights.

 

I agree with you though. I will probably end up getting the base model and seeing how the trigger and sights are and go from there.

I was researching the difference between the two and it seems like there are 2 differences, the trigger and sights.

 

I agree with you though. I will probably end up getting the base model and seeing how the trigger and sights are and go from there.

 

 

Correct way to go.....

 

More research for you..... I am on this board also.... http://mp-pistol.com/boards/

  • Author

Correct way to go.....More research for you..... I am on this board also.... http://mp-pistol.com/boards/

 

I like researching :D Thanks for the link, boards provide tons of info.

 

Thanks again for the offer you provided! Since I thought it would probably be difficult finding time between our schedules, just thought it would be easier to go to the range. You know?

 

Availability on the m&P is harder too. So get the regular, buy apex kit and fiber optic sights.

 

Yeah, it seems like S&W can't make them fast enough. A lot of M&P owners say mags are hard to come by, so I have already researched a few sites for 10rders and will be ordering a bunch during the week.

I like researching :D Thanks for the link, boards provide tons of info.

 

Thanks again for the offer you provided! Since I thought it would probably be difficult finding time between our schedules, just thought it would be easier to go to the range. You know?

 

 

 

Yeah, it seems like S&W can't make them fast enough. A lot of M&P owners say mags are hard to come by, so I have already researched a few sites for 10rders and will be ordering a bunch during the week.

 

15 round mags from G&R

  • Author

I've found 12rounders from G&R, but no 15rders. They only have 15rders for the .40cal...I want the 9mm.

Heres a link for you.My link The ten rounders aren't the best, i've read that some people can't even put all ten rounds in. 15 rounders are nice.

I've found 12rounders from G&R, but no 15rders. They only have 15rders for the .40cal...I want the 9mm.

 

I bought my 15rnd mags from G&R. Grant was incredibly helpful in getting me that shipment pronto. Excellent service!!!

I've found 12rounders from G&R, but no 15rders. They only have 15rders for the .40cal...I want the 9mm.

The 12 rounders are for the M&Pc and to my knowledge won't work in the full size.

 

Heres a link for you.My link The ten rounders aren't the best, i've read that some people can't even put all ten rounds in. 15 rounders are nice.

I've had problems with the 10 rounders. The ones that came with my M&P were tight, but useable. The 10 rounders I bought separately were a royal PITA to use with 10 rounds. They were so tight that with 10 rounds in the magazine, the gun wouldn't strip off the top round when loading the gun. I left them loaded for a month, loaded and unloaded them a bunch of times hoping the spring would break in a little.. nothing helped. I haven't used them since finding the 15 rounders.

  • Author

Thanks for the info and thanks for the link as well!

 

Going to order some 15rders and staying away from the 10's.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.