Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Watch the live hearing on HR 822 now

Featured Replies

Maks that's pathetic!

 

As far as liability goes for a legitimate carry. Group liability insurance.

 

Edit: I know you live in a world of finite numbers and don't want to leave anything to chance. But #1 you probably have equal or more firearms skills than the average LEO.

#2 Some gangsta or two or three can shove that knife where the sun don't shine.

I hope the few times you do carry is when you're out with your wife because unless she is Ziva David she relys on you as well.

 

Let me qualify what I stated.

 

I carry where I feel comfortable, such as business meetings, etc. I did not carry at Disney or conferences, where there are a ton of people. (dont want the gun to flop out on a coaster when I am wearing shorts.) :locomotive:

 

when I go to PA, I do carry if I am there for a longer time, I don't when it will take me longer to pull over, holster/unholster, get the gun, etc.

 

 

 

DA,

 

How about we let someone more qualified than you answer that. Get a self defense expert to chime in, such as Chris @ mdts, or Rob Pincus, or Anthony or any of his staff who actually have experience with this.

  • Replies 133
  • Views 11.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • DA- BTW it was Barney Frank and Chris Dodd, your government, that wrecked the ecomomy. With their "everyone is entitled to own a home" $hit.

  • no way.. it is again just a tool to limit access.. going to make people qualify with every gun they own and or intend to carry? training doesn't stop stupid.. just look at driving.. you have to pass

  • Well, if you are serious, you might also want to consider the Communists and Satan. Both are very real players right now, and they are not making empty promises. They intend to deliver. If there ar

 

Mark, btw, thank you for insulting Russians. :facepalm:

 

 

How did I insult Russians? You said "shots fired with drunk Russians"

 

I responded "Then the problem is with drunk Russians"

 

How is that insulting? You're the one who claims it's drunk Russians causing a problem.

Maks- Correction--- You can HATE whoever you want as long as you don't act on it. We haven't gotten to mind control yet.

 

And yes someone pissed in my Cherios

Speaking of permits... you cant do the $50 for training, $500 for none. What about us poor folks who cant spend on a permit? You will get that arguement.

 

 

That's another story all together, What other RIGHT do we have to pay for to exercise?? Glad they don't charge for the 1A or we wouldn't be having to convo..

And yes someone pissed in my Cherios

 

Frank, just think about the cute blond you were talking about seeing during the HR822 thing on the boob-tube. (you see what I did here??)

That's a lame argument... you can't cure stupid, nor should you punish responsible folks for the actions of the irresponsible. Not to mention, there isn't an invisible barrier to the world which denies entry to those who carry guns without a CCW permit... They'll just carry anyways. But guess who won't carry? You. Because you're a Mr. Goody-two-shoes law abiding citizen who tries to do everything on the level, but will still be denied a right by folks who think they can make society better by forcing their world-view on everybody else. Morons and criminals will go out there with guns in their waistbands regardless of training requirements and all the laws in the world you can pass...

 

So true... look at all the trouble people go through to get their drivers license and there are so many idiots on the road. The problem is not the training but the RESPECT for others. Courteous drivers are taught courtesy through their lives and therefore show up in their driving habits. Courtesy breeds respect along with awareness, they all work hand in hand. Someone that is taught to respect others will not draw a gun unless there is absolutely no other option available. There is no teaching aid that can ingrain this properly.

 

I believe the honest, law abiding citizen would not even pull out his/her firearm even if it was warranted in a training class. Who wants to live with the death of someone else unless you had absolutely no available options.

Mark, my apologies, I misread what you wrote as I was rushing between meetings. =) Sounded or I thought it read that all russians are drunks, and that is the problem. =P

 

Maybe I have too much faith in people.

 

This is my personal opinion, as someone who was not born in this country.... so get your hats on.

 

As much as I hate people on both sides of the aisle, both spread the wealth ultra libs, to ultra conservatives, I think people, and not saying anyone here in particular, but clinging on to 2A being completely unconditional is stupid. Things have changed in the past 300 years.

 

If we are saying constitutional, unrestricted carry, then you also have to say, get rid of all gun laws, get rid of nics, the whole 9. If so, I completely respect that opinion..... however it is hypocritical to state you want constitutional carry (as per 2a), yet agreeing that criminals should not have guns, or agreeing that NICS is a good idea, and stating that a educational/live fire class as part of CCW license is bad.

 

I respect what the states do, such as Arizona, (who still has a CCW license anyway, which lets you carry in more places), and understand living in Manhattan is different than living in Alaska. If the population of those counties/states have a strong opinion, that is for them to do as they please and we must respect that.

 

My own personal opinion, a CCW should be like hunting? (or at least my understanding of it). We should not charge any fees for licenses, if you can own a gun (pass nics), you can CCW, after you take a classroom/live fire class where unless you prove that you are unsafe in gun handling, you are permitted to carry wherever you want, unless the business owner wants otherwise.

 

Frank, to follow back up on the earlier posts.... even without carrying, I really don't feel unsafe, unless I am traveling through or am in a ghetto. I sometimes carry around the office, I have firearms at home obviously. When I am out and about, I am in the car, traveling on highways, don't stop much, and typically find myself in good areas. God forbid I get carjacked, they can have it, that is what insurance is for.

 

Where do I feel unsafe? Thinking about it, the last time I felt unsafe was at ShoreShot on a very busy night, around a ton of new people who can barely keep a muzzle pointed downrange.

 

Before that, it was at Ft Dix where a father and son were shooting, the kid was like 12 to 15 years old, took a loaded AR and muzzle swept the line.

 

Before that, it was almost any time commuted to NYC through Newark, and had to walk from the train station to my car 2 blocks away.

 

In the past 3 years I felt more unsafe at public gun ranges and gun stores, then during my daily life.

don't stop much, and typically find myself in good areas. God forbid I get carjacked, they can have it, that is what insurance is for.

 

Where do I feel unsafe? Thinking about it, the last time I felt unsafe was at ShoreShot on a very busy night, around a ton of new people who can barely keep a muzzle pointed downrange.

 

 

 

 

That is the exact reason i never feel comfortable in an indoor range. I spend more time concentrating on other people than i do my own shooting!

822 is a good start and I do believe we should have some sort of State to State training standards. I know I will catch poop for saying this because I own a school but let us be realistic. When you go to a range, observe the "shooters" around you and see how many you would really want to carry a firearm, not many. We are on this forum because we are of a different mindset and we understand the need to be prepared. My guys will tell you that police officers only hit about 44% of the time that they shoot.

 

Now the NRA will not advocate training because to own a gun is a right and to drive a car is a privilege but the NRA just happens to have a very large education and training department that does provide when needed! Nice!. Many States have requirements for training and they all vary, I believe that should stay the same so that 822 is just a bill to turn a permit into a sort of drivers lisc.

 

If you are going to make the decision to carry a firearm you damn well better have some training under your belt, this will be the first thing a prosecutor looks for after they check the firearm for non stock modifications.

 

Attached to every bullet you fire a lawyer is attached to it so a stock type firearm that is widely accepted by police or military with equivalent ammo is the way to go. The more credentials you have the better should you ever have to use it.

 

Anthony

I carry pepper spray (Pepper blaster II by Kimber)... from Midway USA. It's something that is unexpected and if it can buy me 3-10 seconds, well that is better than nothing. I bought some for my daughter and wife as well. I guess I have to make due in the meantime until either they sort this out or we have no choice but to carry.Back to carry, I believe GOOD, honest citizens of the USA will never pull out their firearm unless they absolutely have to. Please don't under-estimate the majority of US citizens. We are a country (great majority) that are honest and willing to help first and pull a firearm if only there is no possibility for escape.

 

Maks,onto what you were saying about "unsafe" areas: I am seeing more and more things that concern me. Just Friday night we found ourselves caught in the middle of a scuffle at a gas station. Some guy was totally on drugs and attacked the cashier. I had no choice but to step in and it was a bit scary. I am 6' and 235 lbs and lift weights and that is something I never want to experience any time soon.

 

Speaking of some other things I have seen, I have also witnessed some arguments at convenient stores that get a bit out of control. These are in areas that historically have been very good until recently. With more and more people out of work and prices going up expect to see more hostility in rural areas. At least with the Pepper spray I have a "legal" option without a death hovering over me for the rest of my life.On the other hand, that death could be mine.

Who said I concealed?

 

Back to reality, I doubt the federal government has recorded anywhere who has a PA LTCF. I believe that, because it's true.

 

Now, why the fugg do you want the federal government to actualy register everybody that can carry? Why don't you answer that question?

 

The road to Hell is paved with people that say, "They already kind of do or think that so what's the big deal?"

 

The "big deal" is America is free, New Jersey is in chains, and you want the world to meet in the middle. There have been wars started over crap like this.

 

Keep it in New Jersey. Why do you want to screw America? And keep in mind, once the US falls into New Jersey's trap, it's over. Forever. For Humanity. There's not going to be a new spring of freedom somewhere in the future. We are it. The US is the only hope (present company excluded)

 

 

So - you refuse to be registered? :sarcastichand:

 

Sorry - SBR and surpressor man - we know you already have submitted to registration with the Feds... But that's ok - stand over there on that side of the river in your glass house and throw your stones. We're big boys over here - we can take it.

So only people in NJ are untrained and can't shoot?

 

Also, what is the population density in Vt, Arizona, or Alaska?

 

If you are the only person in an area of 5 miles, I don't care what you do.

 

If I am sitting in a Princeton cafe, or some local sbux, or hell, a shoprite... can you honestly say you would feel safe?

 

My brother has a CCW in PA, if he was ever in a situation I use it, I would rather not be there. Here is someone that has shot before, used to go a few times a week to the range, but has never drawn from a holster, fired under stress, or taken any defensive carry courses. He has a photography business where he does event photography at philly restaurants.... there have been cases before where there were fights, shots fired over some arguement after drunk russians were involved.

 

If some new owns a gun, they are shooting it at the range. Or where I am not around. If someone has a CCW, better they be trained. If it is a license to carry, whats wrong with an educational requirement?

 

Whether I lived in Florida, Alaska, NY, or wherever, I would not feel differently. I have seen poor marksmanship in every state I travel. I still don't carry all the time when I go to PA or travel to FL because I do not feel 110% that I would be safe if that situation came up, and hence why I carry a knife. I have no doubt if it came for me to draw, by nature (and because of gun games), every target gets two rounds, and I don't ccw a race holster. :icon_mrgreen:

 

If an education/firearms live fire exercise works for states like Colorado and Utah, why is it too much to ask for everyone to adopt the same standards? I absolutely believe in state's rights and it is up to them, but it is, in my opinion, irresponsible for someone to have monkeys walk around with live grenades. It is why people wear Kevlar going to the BH, and why I don't shoot at a public range unless I have no alternative.

 

 

The exact point I was trying make last week!

Maks-

 

Situational awareness and avoidance of danger gets Maks another A+.

 

I see alot of nimrods at ranges and gunshops as well and I think there should be penalties for unsafe firearms handling.

 

But here is the BIG question. Does anybody know what the REAL intention of the Second Ammendment was. It had nothing to do with CCW.

 

And Maks- That it's 300 years later stuff is Liberal BS. The Constitution is NOT a living document, it defines the rights of the people and the states.

 

I really think that, as I understand it, HR822 is a violation of "States Rights".

 

Rant -off-

Have you seen some people shoot?

 

So lets get rid of driver's licenses, educational requirements for brokers, attorneys, doctors. :sarcastichand:

 

Oh, that's easy... have you driven on the roads in New Jersey lately? Yeah, those requirements for drivers licenses are really keeping the streets safe...

 

As for educational requirements for brokers, we actually have those?? You'd think with all those requirements, they woulda never broken the economy a few years ago...

 

Just because you have educational requirements doesn't mean people leave educated. The only difference for Doctors and Attorneys is that they tend to lose their livelihoods should they miss out on their continuous learning, and then we as a society really don't have to worry about them practicing law or medicine.

 

Find some statistics on how many rounds fired even hit the target, or look at all the ccw cases where people shoot the person in the arm.

 

Mark, btw, thank you for insulting Russians. :facepalm:

 

When you defend yourself in a home, I could care less what you do, or anyone does. I think mag limits are stupid, folding stocks, etc. Own whatever the heck you want to own.

 

Speaking of permits... you cant do the $50 for training, $500 for none. What about us poor folks who cant spend on a permit? You will get that arguement.

 

Having free, required training, along the lines of a 4 hour class, as they now have in Utah and Colorado is not unreasonable. Should be right of the states to determine what that is. If you live in a state where the vast majority of the people truly dislike guns, well, tough crap for us. People have the right to their opinion, that is why we live in the United States. You can't kill/hate someone because they are Jewish, Muslim, Indian, etc. We can't do that with anti gun people. They have that right to their opinions. We can only hope to get them to see that guns are not evil.

 

You of all people know that such training is never 'free'. Who provides the ammo? Who pays the instructors? Sounds to me like another place where bureaucratic inefficiencies can mess it all up and pass the bill to the taxpayer. Training is something for a person to do on their time and dime. Not mandated by a bunch of politicians and police.

 

Also: No. It's not the right of the state to decide what laws they should have. The 2nd Amendment, through the 14th applies to all Gov't, not just the Federal morons. That includes the states and localities. Otherwise we have crap like segregation, suppression of religion, and other gross civil rights violations.

DA,

 

How about we let someone more qualified than you answer that. Get a self defense expert to chime in, such as Chris @ mdts, or Rob Pincus, or Anthony or any of his staff who actually have experience with this.

 

As much as I respect the instructors here, people learned to shoot and carry guns before folks like them were around to offer classes on the subject. As much as I encourage people to take formal lessons, it shouldn't be a mandatory requirement, but something folks should do if they want to be more prepared. Kinda like golf lessons. You don't need em to play, but they can help in making the game more fun.

Since when do I need training for a "right"? Wow, undercut by my own brethren. The right to KEEP and BEAR arms SHALL NOT BE INFRINGED.

DA,

 

read my post above.

 

Yes, brokers are licensed and please get your head out of your butt, brokers did not cause the financial meltdown, the people who overextended themselves did. Most brokers, financial advisors are good people. If you are refering to bankers, are you saying they are not entitled to a profit? If so, I expect you to be with the Occupy Wall St crowd and not here.

 

Home Health Aides, Brokers, Insurance people, Realtors, etc are all licensed. It is because of this sue happy society why it is there.

 

Frank has a very valid point, we really don't know what the intent of the law was. there were no RPG's, Beta Mags, SBR's, and Full Auto Saiga 12's. There were no airplanes either. By your logic, where in the 2a does it not say I can't have an RPG and a Saiga 12 with a 20 round drum to take in my carry on bag on the airplane. WE have no clue what the founding fathers would say regarding gun rights had they been living now, all we can do is try to figure out what their intention was, and that right there is the battle for gun rights. People who believe in getting rid of nics, and allow me to walk around with a Saiga 12 with a 20 round drum on the airplane, are equally as nuts as the complete anti gunners who think a gun will kill you if you look at it the wrong way, or that a 50 cal will take down an airplane.

 

I can certainly promise you, Smith Wesson, Glock, Ruger, Sig, Beretta and others will gladly pitch in to support a CCW class, where you fire their ammo through their guns.... great advertising. Their sales will go through the roof. At the same time, I don't think too many gun store owners and trainers will pass up the opportunity to teach and solicit business for 50 people who want to carry.

DA,

 

read my post above.

 

Yes, brokers are licensed and please get your head out of your butt, brokers did not cause the financial meltdown, the people who overextended themselves did. Most brokers, financial advisors are good people. If you are refering to bankers, are you saying they are not entitled to a profit? If so, I expect you to be with the Occupy Wall St crowd and not here.

 

I'm not gonna get into the intricacies of the financial collapse, but to suggest that mortgage brokers (some of whom willingly pushed crap mortgages and loans on those who did not warrant them) and stock brokers (who did a bang up job repackaging those mortgages regardless of the actual risk of default) were not part of the whole mess, simply rings false. They're just as guilty as the bankers and politicians. There is a drive for profit, and then there is breaking the whole system for everyone and getting away on a golden parachute and gov't bailouts.

 

We had folks who hailed from some of the more 'prestigious' universities in the world working on our financial system and within the gov't, and they dropped the ball big time. The only thing they were smart about was ensuring their assets were protected while the rest of us got screwed.

 

Home Health Aides, Brokers, Insurance people, Realtors, etc are all licensed. It is because of this sue happy society why it is there.

 

Licensing predates our litigious society and was once voluntarily enforced by those who were in these professions to protect the "legitimacy" of their profession. As I mentioned earlier, just because you're licensed doesn't necessarily guarantee you're any good.

 

Frank has a very valid point, we really don't know what the intent of the law was. there were no RPG's, Beta Mags, SBR's, and Full Auto Saiga 12's. There were no airplanes either. By your logic, where in the 2a does it not say I can't have an RPG and a Saiga 12 with a 20 round drum to take in my carry on bag on the airplane. WE have no clue what the founding fathers would say regarding gun rights had they been living now, all we can do is try to figure out what their intention was, and that right there is the battle for gun rights. People who believe in getting rid of nics, and allow me to walk around with a Saiga 12 with a 20 round drum on the airplane, are equally as nuts as the complete anti gunners who think a gun will kill you if you look at it the wrong way, or that a 50 cal will take down an airplane.

 

While Frank's argument is sound, the process of going about the regulation is wrong. Our right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed... not 'reasonably' infringed. The Constitution was designed to be amended to keep with the times, not to be side-stepped by the actions of the legislature, the president, or the SCOTUS. That's the lazy way to fix things and requires compromises on what are inalienable rights and freedoms.

 

If you don't like the way the 2A was written, then maybe the country needs to sit down and think hard about its rights and decide whether or not to repeal it, or amend it to get with the times. Any other way is simply half-assing it.

 

I can certainly promise you, Smith Wesson, Glock, Ruger, Sig, Beretta and others will gladly pitch in to support a CCW class, where you fire their ammo through their guns.... great advertising. Their sales will go through the roof. At the same time, I don't think too many gun store owners and trainers will pass up the opportunity to teach and solicit business for 50 people who want to carry.

 

Great, but why aren't they doing that now eh? If it's such a brilliant business proposition, then we would've seen it already.

So answer the question...

 

if the 2A is so crystal clear, do I have the right to take a Full Auto Saiga 12 with a 20 round drum and an RPG on an airplane in my carry on?

 

Obviously, the 2A is not crystal clear as we have NICS, we have an NFA registry, we have gun laws.

To Maks and all others- We DO know why the Founding Fathers insisted on the Second Amendment. It was to provide the people the means to overthrough an oppressive government. Like protection granted in the Forth Amendment

 

Get with it guys!

So answer the question...

 

if the 2A is so crystal clear, do I have the right to take a Full Auto Saiga 12 with a 20 round drum and an RPG on an airplane in my carry on?

 

Obviously, the 2A is not crystal clear as we have NICS, we have an NFA registry, we have gun laws.

 

The 2A is very clear, and you can travel state to state under protection of FOPA.

So answer the question...

 

if the 2A is so crystal clear, do I have the right to take a Full Auto Saiga 12 with a 20 round drum and an RPG on an airplane in my carry on?

 

Obviously, the 2A is not crystal clear as we have NICS, we have an NFA registry, we have gun laws.

 

Yes. If you don't like it, then call to have it repealed or amend it to better suit the advances in technology since 1789... Until then, it shall not be infringed. Things like NICS, NFA, and other gun laws are all infringements of our rights and raise unnecessary barriers to the keeping and bearing our arms as a society.

Right Old School, and unfortunately, we could never over keep our government in check because we WOULD lack the firepower to do so. Not that i think it would ever come to that, but think about it. If we had to, could we?

 

NOPE

DA- BTW it was Barney Frank and Chris Dodd, your government, that wrecked the ecomomy. With their "everyone is entitled to own a home" $hit.

I do believe we should have some sort of State to State training standards.

 

 

no way.. it is again just a tool to limit access.. going to make people qualify with every gun they own and or intend to carry? training doesn't stop stupid.. just look at driving.. you have to pass a drivers test but yet how many accidents are there? people who are not disqualified from owning a gun should be allowed to carry one.. provision on top of provision is just a tool that empowers the government to limit you.. maybe today you have to take a class and qualify by this number.. then next year they up it a little more.. until the point where civilian qualification is harder than LEO qualification.. government involvement is imo rarely the best answer.. unless the type of involvement you are talking about is LESS involvement.

no way.. it is again just a tool to limit access.. going to make people qualify with every gun they own and or intend to carry? training doesn't stop stupid.. just look at driving.. you have to pass a drivers test but yet how many accidents are there? people who are not disqualified from owning a gun should be allowed to carry one.. provision on top of provision is just a tool that empowers the government to limit you.. maybe today you have to take a class and qualify by this number.. then next year they up it a little more.. until the point where civilian qualification is harder than LEO qualification.. government involvement is imo rarely the best answer.. unless the type of involvement you are talking about is LESS involvement.

 

Still love ya Ant.

Yes to Old School and Vladtepes, no to Maks and GunForHire

I absolutely believe in state's rights and it is up to them, but it is, in my opinion, irresponsible for someone to have monkeys walk around with live grenades.

 

correction....its NOT states rights, its state POWER.

it's OUR rights! (thks GFH radio, #24) :icon_e_wink:

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.