Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Another NYC Tourist Arrested on Gun Charges Despite Having Permit

Featured Replies

Wow, he could face up to 45 years in jail. Shame on him for not researching, but its so stupid that the taxpayer has to pay to convict this guy.

The 15 for each gun would be concurrent...not that that makes it any better.

What a dumbass. Not only do you not do your research but you leave them out for people to see. While I agree the sentence is excessive there needs to be a punishment for stupidity. Again I agree that the firearms laws do suck but they are what they are and we have to abide by them or pay the penalties.

 

Nomex suit on now. Begin flame war.

So far, 3 fairly good cases for HR822. None of it will probably make any difference but so it goes.

Funny. You never hear of people getting caught with illegal guns just the legal ones.

Funny. You never hear of people getting caught with illegal guns just the legal ones.

 

 

Not entirely true. We hear all about criminals with weapons. It's just not as glorious for the media because it's expected.

So far, 3 fairly good cases for HR822. None of it will probably make any difference but so it goes.

 

Really, Wonder what the number of years will total up for the 3 recent cases vs. how many years (zero) if they were in the FREE USA...

I feel so sorry for these people. For the whole of you here that are on the 'they need to read the laws!' side, you are brainwashd to think that these laws are normal, even common sense laws(which i assure you they are far far away from common sense). These laws make no sense and are unreasonable and unconstitutional. You cannot argue that "The law is the law!" when the Supreme Law of the land out Constitution is ignored. We have a right to keep and bear arms, that is the law!

I agree that they are unreasonable. But they are on the books and have consequences. Until they are changed we just have o abide by them. Well, you don't have to but you will pay if you don't. I don't know what bearing it has if one feels these laws are unreasonable. They are there. It's what we have now. Hopefully it changes

Funny. You never hear of people getting caught with illegal guns just the legal ones.

 

And there's the catch 22.

 

Guns that they legally jumped through hoops to purchase, own, and possess, but as soon as they cross the Hudson they're 'illegal', to own and possess.

Its a hard situation to define. I agree with SpecialK that there is a perception issue here. Consider if you live in free America your whole life, never encumbered by an out of control local government that restricts your rights even for the surrounding states. Now your visiting a place that has the lore of being dangerouse. I think there is a natural response to want to maintain your safety. I think it could be truly a very alien concept for them to think there might be a restriction on your rights because you crossed an imaginary line in the sand.....

Some how I wonder if that is correct and maybe they knew the laws. Didn't wanna be in the big bad city without some heat.

 

Think about it. Eff them NY'ers, I am gonna carry my gun and not get caught? Then they get caught and say I had no idea, I have a permit etc....

 

I wonder if this happens? May not have happened with these folks but I am sure there is somebody that has thought like this. Hell, there are people in NYC that do this illegally for this reason.

That's a damn shame. It angers me that people have to go through this BS just because one state chooses not to believe in a right granted by the constitution.

What a dumbass. Not only do you not do your research but you leave them out for people to see. While I agree the sentence is excessive there needs to be a punishment for stupidity. Again I agree that the firearms laws do suck but they are what they are and we have to abide by them or pay the penalties.

 

Nomex suit on now. Begin flame war.

. Agreed. The penalty should be a $200 fine and his stuff shipped back home via fedex

RIGHT! But I guess NYC/NJ doesnt have enough hardcore criminals so we need to make a few more.... :(

Some how I wonder if that is correct and maybe they knew the laws. Didn't wanna be in the big bad city without some heat.

 

Think about it. Eff them NY'ers, I am gonna carry my gun and not get caught? Then they get caught and say I had no idea, I have a permit etc....

 

I wonder if this happens? May not have happened with these folks but I am sure there is somebody that has thought like this. Hell, there are people in NYC that do this illegally for this reason.

 

I would agree for some instances, but not with the people who ask about checking their guns, IE the nurse from TN or the jeweler referenced in the OP's article.

I agree that they are unreasonable. But they are on the books and have consequences. Until they are changed we just have o abide by them. Well, you don't have to but you will pay if you don't. I don't know what bearing it has if one feels these laws are unreasonable. They are there. It's what we have now. Hopefully it changes

 

And please don't take this personal. When if ever do you choose not to enforce an unjust law? Which law do you choose to enforce? The white woman can't walk with a black man law? That was a law down south. When if ever does your concience come in to play? I'm sure you have a basic moral compass. Do you let that guide you or are you only following orders That only following orders didn't hold up in Nuremberg.

 

Not personal, just asking which side you line up on.

If I was in this officers shoes. He has guns and shouldn't. No grey area. Sucks for him but no screwing around when it comes to firearms. Sorry if it's unpopular but it is what it is. There are some things I choose not to enforce but they are nowhere as serious as firearms violations. If you jump a turnstile I cn let you go, write a summons or arrest you. That crime isn't that serious. If you jump and have a gun you get locked up.

I just wonder, why all these now? Unless it happens all the time and no one paid attention until the reciprocity bill.

While I agree the sentence is excessive there needs to be a punishment for stupidity.

 

There would be a lot of people going to jail.

How is it stupid to want to have the means to protect oneself? Why are firearms laws something that cannot be ignored??? Well I don't know the answer to the first question here the answer for the second is that those in charge like their subjects to be disarmed.

Despite how harsh the approach seems to be, I can kinda see where the police and the prosecutor's office come from. If they don't appear to make a whole show out of enforcing the law, the impression created among the public and the media will be that YES, YOU CAN CARRY YOUR GUNS INTO NYC -- you'll just get a little wrist slap if you get caught. Given the number of people who travel into NYC daily, even the vast army that is NYPD won't get the genie back into the bottle once it's out. Now, right or wrong the Newyorkers chose to have strict gun laws (or the representatives they had chosen chose to have strict gun laws, depending on how you look at it). Telling Newyorkers what to do is exactly the kind of thing we (or anyone else) don't like them doing back to us.

 

Besides, just leaving a loaded gun in the open in your hotel room (availalble to room service or maintenance personnel to grab) is precisely the kind of recklessness that is so easy to rally against and to make a negative example out of. A poster child of harsh gun control laws Mr. Vankirk isn't.

It's not stupid to want to protect oneself but it is stupid to ignore laws that could lead to you doing some serious time. Whether you believe in them or not. I am also in the minority in the LEO community that for the most part supports hr822.

. I am also in the minority in the LEO community that for the most part supports hr822.

 

Maybe in you department and it may also be a little higher percentage in our area just because of the crappy state we are in, but I'd think it would be just the opposite when you look at the country as a whole..

Yeh it was a little shortsighted. I really can only talk about my local region.

Is there any possibility that these recent incidents are in some way a show of defiance? Perhaps, the violators knew the law, but were making a political statement?

 

I wouldnt think this had there not been a recent arrest of the founder of Tea Party Patriots.

 

Certainly, he knew the law because it is a cause célèbre for the Tea Party to identify and speak out against government action in contravention of the Constitution.

 

 

 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.