Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

NJSA 2C:3-4 Self Defense, Use of Force in Self-Protection

Featured Replies

I was just curious about the supposed absence of a "Castle Law" in NJ. Am I mistaken in my reading of this statute? It appears that there is NO expectation that one must retreat in their dwelling. See below:

 

 

(2)The use of deadly force is not justifiable under this section unless the actor reasonably believes that such force is necessary to protect himself against death or serious bodily harm; nor is it justifiable if:

(a)The actor, with the purpose of causing death or serious bodily harm, provoked the use of force against himself in the same encounter; or

(b)The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no duty to take, except that:

(i)The actor is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling, unless he was the initial aggressor;

 

 

 

3)Except as required by paragraphs (1) and (2) of this subsection, a person employing protective force may estimate the necessity of using force when the force is used, without retreating, surrendering possession, doing any other act which he has no legal duty to do or abstaining from any lawful action.

c. (1) Notwithstanding the provisions of N.J.S.2C:3-5, N.J.S.2C:3-9, or this section, the use of force or deadly force upon or toward an intruder who is unlawfully in a dwelling is justifiable when the actor reasonably believes that the force is immediately necessary for the purpose of protecting himself or other persons in the dwelling against the use of unlawful force by the intruder on the present occasion.

(2)A reasonable belief exists when the actor, to protect himself or a third person, was in his own dwelling at the time of the offense or was privileged to be thereon and the encounter between the actor and intruder was sudden and unexpected, compelling the actor to act instantly and:

(a)The actor reasonably believed that the intruder would inflict personal injury upon the actor or others in the dwelling; or

(b)The actor demanded that the intruder disarm, surrender or withdraw, and the intruder refused to do so.

Sounds simple.................wait 'till a NJ prosecutor gets hold of a SD case and see where it goes from there.

How far south can you go before you run out of land.........that would be about right there.....IMO.

Who said there is no castle law?

 

No retreat is required in your dwelling. That's a castle law. Search the threads here, we've gone over it a number of time.

  • Author

I don't understand. According to the letter of the statute, one is not obligated to "go south." The actor (person defending life) is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling (home) and is permitted to use deadly force in the defense of him/herself and other persons in the home.

  • Author

One of the inaccurate things I've been told in person at ranges and during training is that one must retreat from their home.

One of the inaccurate things I've been told in person at ranges and during training is that one must retreat from their home.

 

That advice was incorrect. No retreat in the home at all. You may stand at the door way and use any necessary force to repel an aggressor.

 

NJ Superior court in state vs Martinez found that:

 

We are satisfied, however, that the trial court failed to properly instruct the jury with respect to an exception to the duty to retreat. Defendant contends that, in its instruction to the jury, the trial court should have explained not only that one has no duty to retreat from one's dwelling, but that a "dwelling" encompasses a doorway, threshold, porch or other similar appurtenance.

 

http://nj.findacase....41569.nj.htm/qx

 

Also:

 

It is clear that whether or not defendant was required to retreat in this situation was dependent, in part, upon whether the jury believed that defendant was in or at his dwelling house when he employed deadly force in self-protection. In failing to instruct the jury that a dwelling house includes "a porch or similar appurtenance" or that a defendant may "meet the assailant at the threshold of the home and prevent him from entering by any means," the trial court may have led the jury to believe that defendant had a duty to retreat and, therefore, his use of deadly force was not justifiable when, in fact, the jury could properly have concluded that no such duty to retreat existed.

 

Consequently, the trial court erred in failing to instruct the jury that a dwelling house includes a porch or similar appurtenance, or other language to that effect.

One of the inaccurate things I've been told in person at ranges and during training is that one must retreat from their home.

You may have misunderstood, or they may have misinformed, you are required "to" retreat to your dewling or home. If you are on your property u must first make it "into" your house before defending yourself...., you may defend yourself on your property, but u need to prove that u tried and were not able to retreat. pretty lame.

You may have misunderstood, or they may have misinformed, you are required "to" retreat to your dewling or home. If you are on your property u must first make it "into" your house onto your porch or similar appurtenance before defending yourself...., you may defend yourself on your property, but u need to prove that u tried and were not able to retreat. pretty lame.

 

Just a minor correction. This "porch or similar appurtenance" is established precedent in NJ superior court.

  • Author

It seems as though this is the sort of thing that gets bandied about when we talk about how crappy NJ Gun Laws are. It get's added to the list of gripes.

 

"You have to lock up your ammo in a separate box inside your trunk"

 

"Hollow points are illegal"

 

"A loaded magazine is a loaded firearm"

 

"You can't stop for lunch"

 

"You have to retreat inside your home"

 

Sometimes in the heat of pointing out all the bad and lack of common sense in our gun laws, it seems that things get conflated.

It seems as though this is the sort of thing that gets bandied about when we talk about how crappy NJ Gun Laws are. It get's added to the list of gripes.

 

"You have to lock up your ammo in a separate box inside your trunk"

 

"Hollow points are illegal"

 

"A loaded magazine is a loaded firearm"

 

"You can't stop for lunch"

 

"You have to retreat inside your home"

 

Sometimes in the heat of pointing out all the bad and lack of common sense in our gun laws, it seems that things get conflated.

 

If you only have long guns and a Firearms Purchaser ID, you're perfectly legal to stop for lunch anywhere you choose.(cept maybe a school cafeteria or other prohibited place)

 

If you have handguns and stop at the drivethru on the parkway, my opinion is that you are fine.

 

If you divert a couple miles over to the Brazillian barbeque for a 2 hour sit down meat laden lunch, I think you're taking a big risk.

Wait a minute. I could have sworn several weeks ago there was a huge discussion about NJ's implimentation of the Castle Doctrine and it was determined that you can only shoot/use deadly force to an intruder after you've attempted to vacate. Meaning, someone enters you house through the front. You are in the back with your family. You can't decide to blow the perp's brains out, when you could have easily just got everyone out the back door.

  • Author

If you only have long guns and a Firearms Purchaser ID, you're perfectly legal to stop for lunch anywhere you choose.(cept maybe a school cafeteria or other prohibited place)

 

If you have handguns and stop at the drivethru on the parkway, my opinion is that you are fine.

 

If you divert a couple miles over to the Brazillian barbeque for a 2 hour sit down meat laden lunch, I think you're taking a big risk.

 

 

I do like a Brazilian BBQ.

 

What about stopping to pick up a fellow shooter on the way to the range? Would you classify that as a reasonable deviation?

  • Author

Wait a minute. I could have sworn several weeks ago there was a huge discussion about NJ's implimentation of the Castle Doctrine and it was determined that you can only shoot/use deadly force to an intruder after you've attempted to vacate. Meaning, someone enters you house through the front. You are in the back with your family. You can't decide to blow the perp's brains out, when you could have easily just got everyone out the back door.

 

 

Herein lies the crux of my question.

 

 

sorry for double post. *facepalm*

I do like a Brazilian BBQ.

 

What about stopping to pick up a fellow shooter on the way to the range? Would you classify that as a reasonable deviation?

 

I believe it does.

Herein lies the crux of my question.

 

 

sorry for double post. *facepalm*

 

 

Like I said, I was part of that huge debate and that was the end result. If you're able to vacate your home and no family members remain and are in danger, you can not just shoot at the person because he broke into your house. Even if he threatens you, you must 1st access whether or not you and your family are able to vacate the premises to avoid the confrontation.

Wait a minute. I could have sworn several weeks ago there was a huge discussion about NJ's implimentation of the Castle Doctrine and it was determined that you can only shoot/use deadly force to an intruder after you've attempted to vacate. Meaning, someone enters you house through the front. You are in the back with your family. You can't decide to blow the perp's brains out, when you could have easily just got everyone out the back door.

 

That's certainly not required by law. As a note, the law is fairly specific that if the danger is immediate; i.e. the guy bursts through the door, you can defend yourself. Alternatively, if he's standing there, menacing you and you ask him to "disarm, surrender or withdraw, and the intruder refused to do so", you may defend yourself.

 

I know there's been people who say their instructor said this or that, it simply isn't law. The statutes say there is no retreat and State V Martinez is a superior court precedent. There is NO DUTY TO RETREAT!.

Look.....NJ fiream statutes are confusing at best and are meant to be that way......LEO's are not even well versed nor NJSP that I've spoken with......varying opinions of the same thing mostly....due to the "Gottcha" clause in everything NJ.

Like I said, I was part of that huge debate and that was the end result. If you're able to vacate your home and no family members remain thus not being in danger, you can not just shoot at the person because he broke into your house. Even if he threatens you, you must 1st access whether or not you and your family are able to vacate the premises to avoid the confrontation.

Just so we're clear on this, NJ does not have a Castle Doctrine. That is the issue.

Just so we're clear on this, NJ does not have a Castle Doctrine. That is the issue.

 

NJ provides criminal immunity in self defense shootings within your castle. That a friend of Anthony from GFH said we don't is meaningless. The Superior court, in the case listed above shows that we do.

  • Author

NJ provides criminal immunity in self defense shootings within your castle. That a friend of Anthony from GFH said we don't is meaningless. The Superior court, in the case listed above shows that we do.

 

 

I would say that it is clearly so in the statute. The only thing that State v Martinez establishes is that the threshold of your dwelling is considered "your dwelling"

 

I don't think it could be more explicit. If you're in your house and there is an intruder that in your mind presents a physical danger to you or any other inhabitants, the use of deadly force is permitted. You are not obliged to retreat within or out of your dwelling.

Like I said, I was part of that huge debate and that was the end result. If you're able to vacate your home and no family members remain and are in danger, you can not just shoot at the person because he broke into your house. Even if he threatens you, you must 1st access whether or not you and your family are able to vacate the premises to avoid the confrontation.

 

Not sure what you mean by end result of a debate on this forum, when there are other things that actually hold water, like statues and case law. Let us take a look at the statue for a second.

 

(2)The use of deadly force is not justifiable under this section unless the actor reasonably believes that such force is necessary to protect himself against death or serious bodily harm; nor is it justifiable if:

(a)The actor, with the purpose of causing death or serious bodily harm, provoked the use of force against himself in the same encounter; or

(b)The actor knows that he can avoid the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating or by surrendering possession of a thing to a person asserting a claim of right thereto or by complying with a demand that he abstain from any action which he has no duty to take,

 

Ok, so you cannot use force, if these 2 things are present. Them being you either provoked the other person so you could use force, or that person is claiming the right to something AND you know you can avoid force by letting them take it or retreating.

 

So, to say that you must retreat if able, isn't necessarily true. In fact, it is only true if that person it asserting a claim of right to one of, what you would call, your possession. Somebody who has broken into your house with the intent to rob you does not qualify. And you have no obligation to retreat. Your ex taking your microwave because she claims it is hers, would qualify, and you can't shoot her if you know just letting her take it will avoid physical force, for example.

 

except that:

(i)The actor is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling, unless he was the initial aggressor;

 

 

 

3)Except as required by paragraphs (1) and (2) of this subsection, a person employing protective force may estimate the necessity of using force when the force is used, without retreating, surrendering possession, doing any other act which he has no legal duty to do or abstaining from any lawful action.

 

This reasserts what was stated above. It also defines some things. As it says, YOU HAVE NO LEGAL DUTY to abstain from ANY lawful action. As it says specifically before, you should also be able to infer that staying in your own home would be a lawful action, so you have no legal duty to do otherwise.

 

c. (1) Notwithstanding the provisions of N.J.S.2C:3-5, N.J.S.2C:3-9, or this section, the use of force or deadly force upon or toward an intruder who is unlawfully in a dwelling is justifiable when the actor reasonably believes that the force is immediately necessary for the purpose of protecting himself or other persons in the dwelling against the use of unlawful force by the intruder on the present occasion.

(2)A reasonable belief exists when the actor, to protect himself or a third person, was in his own dwelling at the time of the offense or was privileged to be thereon and the encounter between the actor and intruder was sudden and unexpected, compelling the actor to act instantly and:

(a)The actor reasonably believed that the intruder would inflict personal injury upon the actor or others in the dwelling; or

(b)The actor demanded that the intruder disarm, surrender or withdraw, and the intruder refused to do so.

 

Now we get even further. Basically it says

 

1. You can use deadly force to protect yourself or others, against force by the intruder. It further says you don't even have live there. If you are over a friends house, you have the same right to protect yourself or others, as the home owner.

 

2. You can use deadly force if the incident occurs suddenly and unexpectedly and you feel someone in the home is threatened.

 

3. You can use deadly force if the incident occurs suddenly and unexpectedly and you demanded the intruder disarm, surrender, or withdraw, and they refused.

 

So the only time you are obligated to retreat is in a scenario that is NOT a home invasion. It would in most situations, be a situation involving someone you know. And even then you can still use force if you are threatened and don't think you can retreat safely. Furthermore, you can use deadly force in a home invasion scenario or break and enter in some cases even if you or others are not threatened.

 

Now unless there is another statue, there is nothing in the above that prevents civil action against you in a justified incident. So that is another story. I see there was a 2008 bill that prevented this, but I am unclear if that ever passed.

If that's the case, that's actually good news. All I know is that was not the conclusion drawn at the end of the other debate I was talking about. I don't have the time right now to find it, but if you don't have to retreat and can stand there toe to toe and defend yourself, that's awesome. That's the way it should be.

I would say that it is clearly so in the statute. The only thing that State v Martinez establishes is that the threshold of your dwelling is considered "your dwelling"

 

I don't think it could be more explicit. If you're in your house and there is an intruder that in your mind presents a physical danger to you or any other inhabitants, the use of deadly force is permitted. You are not obliged to retreat within or out of your dwelling.

 

I would say it also affirms that there is no retreat required from your dwelling and that you may stand at the threshold and resist with any means. This is the counter to "you must retreat until you no longer can retreat" within the home.

I would say it also affirms that there is no retreat required from your dwelling and that you may stand at the threshold and resist with any means. This is the counter to "you must retreat until you no longer can retreat" within the home.

 

If it didn't affirm that, then that is one jacked up statue...being that is says "the actor is not obliged to retreat from his dwelling"! ;)

 

BTW, where did this "must retreat until you no longer can" thing even come from?

 

 

BTW, where did this "must retreat until you no longer can" thing even come from?

 

It seems to come up here every once in a while. I suspect it's just ignorance that gets passed around.

  • Author

It seems to come up here every once in a while. I suspect it's just ignorance that gets passed around.

 

It doesn't just come up here. It is perpetuated. I think it is a byproduct of the frustration over how convoluted some of the laws seem to be (i.e., transportation). It all gets conflated, and because things are bad...folks have a tendency to overblow and drift away from facts.

You are right, it doesn't just come up here. A while back I was talking with a coworker who had a bit of a scare with someone potentially trying to break in one night, and thought the same thing. I had to explain to her that it wasn't true (talking about retreating that is).

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.