January 12, 201214 yr It seems to come up here every once in a while. I suspect it's just ignorance that gets passed around. there is some language in the NYS penal code that introduces retreat if you can during a buglary, but it quickly follows up with no duty to retreat. I do believe the no duty to retreat is somewhat new in NYS. As with most of the issues with the laws I read people having in New Jersey, I think a lot of it comes from people getting info from across the Hudson and apllying it here. I am sure that is a big part of some of it.
January 12, 201214 yr Whatever is on the books its confusing as hell, use best judgement you can to make the case in your favor. If you can get out of your house with your loved ones and not get attacked or shot do it. If you cant get out because the robber or criminal is in between you and the door, I suggest barricade you and loved ones into a room. If and when they try to enter you shoot them and make sure you kill them the sad fact is if they live they are more trouble to you then dead.
January 12, 201214 yr Author Pardon me, but F that. Separate From wife and kids( wife armed) and stand ground. Warn. Shoot. My house. My castle. Whatever is on the books its confusing as hell, use best judgement you can to make the case in your favor. If you can get out of your house with your loved ones and not get attacked or shot do it. If you cant get out because the robber or criminal is in between you and the door, I suggest barricade you and loved ones into a room. If and when they try to enter you shoot them and make sure you kill them the sad fact is if they live they are more trouble to you then dead.
January 12, 201214 yr you shoot them and make sure you kill them You shoot to stop the threat. No more. No "safety rounds" otherwise you can become a murderer. I refuse to barricade myself in a room however.
January 12, 201214 yr Pardon me, but F that. Separate From wife and kids( wife armed) and stand ground. Warn. Shoot. My house. My castle. I agree judgement plays a huge part in how it will turn out, we shouldn't have to worry about these things but this state sucks so you have to think what is the best way to stay safe and not go to jail at the end of the day. You shoot to stop the threat. No more. No "safety rounds" otherwise you can become a murderer. I refuse to barricade myself in a room however. I agree the criminal shouldn't be riddled with bullets and if they are stopped and on the ground I am not going to "finish them", however if I am going to shoot I am going to aim for their head.
January 12, 201214 yr You shoot to stop the threat. No more. No "safety rounds" otherwise you can become a murderer. I refuse to barricade myself in a room however. The bad guy stops being a threat when he stops theatening me. While i wouldn't walk up to him laying on the ground and shoot him in the head, if he is still moving in my direction or attempting to shoot at me I will continute to shoot until either a) He stops doing things that make me think he's trying to kill me. b) I run out of ammo.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.