Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Opinions on car insurance

Featured Replies

You do realize that installing the tracking device gives Progressive all they need to deny claims? That's it's real intent. The bait they offer is a reduced rate. Did you think that somehow their pool of drivers got better because they offered this device? Their aggregate number of accidents won't change a bit but they can offer you a discount. They pay for the discount they offer you by reducing the number of claims they pay. They offer you a penny so they can save a buck on you later when they deny your claim.

 

I don't believe that's accurate. How could the fact that they know how fast you drive, turn or break be useful for denying a claim? No auto carrier's policy form currently includes exclusions that enable them to deny 1st or 3rd party coverage for a loss because their insured is a wreckless driver. That's why they get their pound of flesh in premium $$$s when you renew. Once they give you coverage, they're on the hook for just about anything you do over that policy term. Even if carriers did somehow slip sneaky exclusion clauses into their policies, the denial can still get thrown out if a court rules that the terms of the exclusion were unfairly slanted against the policy holder.

 

The standard position of insurance regulators is that circumstances where a carrier is permited to decline coverage for a loss that would normally be covered under the terms of their coverage grant are extremely rare. One of the few examples that comes to mind would be DUI. I know of a few companies that deny first party coverage if the vehicle is damaged by an accident where the insured is ultimately convicted for Driving under the influence.

  • Replies 76
  • Views 2.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I had Geico....until I got the rate change notice for absolutley no reason. They said "everybody in NJ is getting the same increase". BS!

 

I switched back to Liberty Mutual, got a lower rate and more coverage. Two claims in the past five years or so - no problem.

 

WARNING POLITICAL CONTENT FOLLOWS:

I now know who owns/controls GEICO and Progressive. They are both on my 'will never do business with them in a million years' list.

I don't believe that's accurate. How could the fact that they know how fast you drive, turn or break be useful for denying a claim? No auto carrier's policy form currently includes exclusions that enable them to deny 1st or 3rd party coverage for a loss because their insured is a wreckless driver. That's why they get their pound of flesh in premium $$$s when you renew. Once they give you coverage, they're on the hook for just about anything you do over that policy term. Even if carriers did somehow slip sneaky exclusion clauses into their policies, the denial can still get thrown out if a court rules that the terms of the exclusion were unfairly slanted against the policy holder.

 

The standard position of insurance regulators is that circumstances where a carrier is permited to decline coverage for a loss that would normally be covered under the terms of their coverage grant are extremely rare. One of the few examples that comes to mind would be DUI. I know of a few companies that deny first party coverage if the vehicle is damaged by an accident where the insured is ultimately convicted for Driving under the influence.

 

Fact: Insurance companies, and progressive in particular spend an inordinate amount of time and effort to underpay and deny paying claims. When claims get disputed they go before the court. At that time, any evidence collected by the insurance company will be used against the plaintiff. That evidence will include speed data and telemetrics to prove contributory negligence if you were braking hard or speeding. Eventually all insurance companies will offer a discount for these spying devices without which the insurance will be unaffordable.

 

Any company that sides with the killer of their insured in order to avoid paying a claim will go to any length to avoid paying claims. Imagine the company you pay your premiums to offers legal council to the man who kills you. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/18/your-money/progressives-side-of-the-insurance-case-that-blew-up-on-the-internet.html?pagewanted=all

You really need to ask yourself WHY they want to spy on you. Look, this tracking device is perfect for Grandma who only goes to and from church at 25 miles per hour (in a 50 mph zone).

 

I commute on the parkway prior to rush hour. I will not even consider this tracking doohickey. I already have one called EZpass. My privacy has already been invaded more than I like.

I've had USAA for years. No complaints, no one ever came close to beating their rates. My SIL went under my oldest daughters policy when they got married. He had a Boxster then and the insurance from USAA came in $2200 less. My youngest daughter works for a major insurance company and with her employee discount their quote was twice as much as she pays USAA. One of the ways they keep their rates low is USAA has a separate company for each class of customer. I'm a retired military officer and my

rates are based on risks and claims with officers ot enlisted personnel, those that inherited elgibility, etc.

 

 

Fact: Insurance companies, and progressive in particular spend an inordinate amount of time and effort to underpay and deny paying claims. When claims get disputed they go before the court. At that time, any evidence collected by the insurance company will be used against the plaintiff. That evidence will include speed data and telemetrics to prove contributory negligence if you were braking hard or speeding. Eventually all insurance companies will offer a discount for these spying devices without which the insurance will be unaffordable.

 

Any company that sides with the killer of their insured in order to avoid paying a claim will go to any length to avoid paying claims. Imagine the company you pay your premiums to offers legal council to the man who kills you. http://www.nytimes.com/2012/08/18/your-money/progressives-side-of-the-insurance-case-that-blew-up-on-the-internet.html?pagewanted=all

 

Nonsense. Contributory negligence relates to adjusting 3rd party claims against an insurance carrier's policy holder. Data regarding their own insured's driving habits on a day to day basis would be COMPLETELY IRRELLEVENT to that process.

 

And no, claims do not go before a court at the drop of a hat. Denied 3rd party claims can go through a state appeal process and carrier vs carrier matters can end up going to arbitration, but it would be very VERY rare that an attorney will even be interested in taking a previously denied auto claim to court. That's because the overwhelming majority of denied claims aren't worth a lawyers time because (1) the dollar amounts involved are not large for their 33.3% to be worth the time Or (2) the facts support the denial and there is virtually no chance of victory in court. If there is even the slightest chance a claimant will be awarded money by a jury, almost all companies will look to settle, because it's almost always the cheaper option.

 

Also, digging up a single bizarre claim where a carrier made some questionable calls doesn't really do a lot to support to the claim-denial conspiracy theory. You want to see how it usually turns out for insurance carriers in court, read this site http://www.judicialhellholes.org/

 

 

Also, digging up a single bizarre claim where a carrier made some questionable calls doesn't really do a lot to support to the claim-denial conspiracy theory.

 

Progressive has elevated claims denial to an art form. This company: http://shernoff.com/news/cases-filed/lawsuit-filed-against-progressive-insurance-company-for-abusing-its-claimants.html is filing a series of lawsuits against progressive for all the claims they deny.

 

Until these devices are ubiquitous and ultimately required by law, the Insurance carriers will continue to gather information. 12 separate insurance companies have filed patents for these types of devices so ultimately they all will require them. They won't use it to deny claims on a fender bender, but they will use it on claims that involve costly personal injury. That you have somehow convinced yourself that these companies are "just looking out for your best interests" and "want to give you money" suggests that either you're naive about how ruthless insurance companies can be or have some other vested reason not to believe it.

Question:

 

Why is there always a Deductable.......especially if you pay their premium as required.......I smell a scam.

I had to drive out to Philly for the ASIS show yesterday and I jacked that POS out before I left. I have an AeroForce Interceptor gauge that I use to monitor IAT2 (post supercharger air temp) and real time gas milage that connects through the ODB-II port that was more important to me than a device that beeps to inform me I've stopped every time I stop at a red light.

Progressive has elevated claims denial to an art form. This company: http://shernoff.com/...-claimants.html is filing a series of lawsuits against progressive for all the claims they deny.

 

So, a law firm is suing an insurance company and portraying them in a negative light as part of their efforts to receive 1/3 of a significant monetary settlement/judgement. And? Do you usually operate off the assumption that all of the allegations a law firm inlcudeds in a suit are always true?

 

Also, back to you your first example, just reading the whole article reveals a much different story than what the brother portrayed online, possibly because of grief or simply a limited understanding of the circumstances:

 

1) They didn't "side with the killer of their insured in order to avoid paying a claim". The whole debacle arose from the fact that they elected to PAY a third party claim, not deny it. Even if you have a problem with their decision, their actions directly contradict the claim that they are going out of their way to deny claims.

 

2) Claiming the other driver is her "killer" is an understandable reaction by a distraught family member, but isn't really supported by the available information. Her own passenger supports the police report account that she ran the red light, not her "killer". Their is another witness who claims differently. That's essentially a push. Dubious grounds for labeling someone a "killer"

 

Until these devices are ubiquitous and ultimately required by law,

 

Why would they ever be required by law?

 

the Insurance carriers will continue to gather information. 12 separate insurance companies have filed patents for these types of devices so ultimately they all will require them.

 

Or perhaps they all want to be able to offer the same technology to their policy holders, in case it really takes off and puts them at risk of playing catchup with Progressive. It would be policy retention suicide for a carrier to start requiring these devices, as they would see significant customer movement to carriers without the requirement. The free market would make any overt attempt to force the devices on customers a non-starter.

 

They won't use it to deny claims on a fender bender, but they will use it on claims that involve costly personal injury.

 

Again, how? What do their insured's overall driving habbits have to do with the damages they will be legally obligated to pay a 3rd party their insured injures in an auto accident? If anything, proof that they knowingly insured an unsafe driver would only hurt their position when adjusting the 3rd party's claim, not help it.

 

That you have somehow convinced yourself that these companies are "just looking out for your best interests" and "want to give you money"

 

Why are you putting quotes around statements I haven't made? They are in business to make a profit, like any corporation. Contrary to the iPhone tweets of over-entitled OWS children, that doesn't make them evil. If certain carriers engage in unlawful or bad faith practices in the pursuit of profit, that is obviously wrong and warrants regulatory fines & penalties, etc.

 

...suggests that either you're naive about how ruthless insurance companies can be or have some other vested reason not to believe it.

 

False dilema based off the assumption that you are undeniably correct, when you're actually almost entirely wrong. I work as an underwriter [not for progressive, thankfully], so it's clear as day to me that you don't understand claims or insurance well enough to credibly substantiate your position that the entire industry operates in an immoral manner. You seem to honestly believe that we all walk into the office every morning with the sole focus of making money by exploiting all of our customers however we can.

 

On the off chance you lose interest in the dumb-but-easy belief that insurance operates on a single, malevolent hive-mind dedicated to harming their customers, here's some grownup talk regarding the state of the insurance industry: http://www.standarda...D=1245325866103

So, a law firm is suing an insurance company and portraying them in a negative light as part of their efforts to receive 1/3 of a significant monetary settlement/judgement. And? Do you usually operate off the assumption that all of the allegations a law firm inlcudeds in a suit are always true?

 

If it were an isolated incident of one predatory law firm, I would agree. The bad faith claims against Progressive are everywhere.

 

Also, back to you your first example, just reading the whole article reveals a much different story than what the brother portrayed online, possibly because of grief or simply a limited understanding of the circumstances:

 

1) They didn't "side with the killer of their insured in order to avoid paying a claim".

 

Really? They sued the driver of the other car. Why? If he were proven at fault, Progressive would have to pay the uninsured motorist of the decedent. What did Progressive do? Defended the other driver to prevent a judgement against him which would force Progressive to pay. I'm not exactly sure how your statement rectifies with the facts.

 

2) Claiming the other driver is her "killer" is an understandable reaction by a distraught family member, but isn't really supported by the available information. Her own passenger supports the police report account that she ran the red light, not her "killer". Their is another witness who claims differently. That's essentially a push. Dubious grounds for labeling someone a "killer"

 

The driver of the other car was found at fault for the accident, ergo, the driver is now the killer.

 

 

Why would they ever be required by law?

 

Because insurance companies will lobby for it and ultimately get it.

 

It would be policy retention suicide for a carrier to start requiring these devices, as they would see significant customer movement to carriers without the requirement.

 

Exactly. Unless of course it was required by law.

 

Again, how? What do their insured's overall driving habbits have to do with the damages they will be legally obligated to pay a 3rd party their insured injures in an auto accident? If anything, proof that they knowingly insured an unsafe driver would only hurt their position when adjusting the 3rd party's claim, not help it.

 

So your position is that insurance companies have no vested interest in parsing a millisecond by millisecond examination of a costly personal injury accident in order to assign blame?

 

Why are you putting quotes around statements I haven't made? They are in business to make a profit, like any corporation. Contrary to the iPhone tweets of over-entitled OWS children, that doesn't make them evil. If certain carriers engage in unlawful or bad faith practices in the pursuit of profit, that is obviously wrong and warrants regulatory fines & penalties, etc.

 

Well, what is their motivation for offering this discount? They are in business to maximize profit. I have no issue with that at all. There must be some economic reason to offer these devices. They put them out there in the hope that someone may drive better?

 

 

False dilema based off the assumption that you are undeniably correct, when you're actually almost entirely wrong. I work as an underwriter [not for progressive, thankfully], so it's clear as day to me that you don't understand claims or insurance well enough to credibly substantiate your position that the entire industry operates in an immoral manner. You seem to honestly believe that we all walk into the office every morning with the sole focus of making money by exploiting all of our customers however we can.

 

I never said any such thing. There are a number of great insurance companies, like New Jersey Manufacturers as a whole and others as well. Progressive is a company that uses all sorts of tactics to delay, underpay and deny claims whenever possible as part of a strategy. They are not alone, for example State Farm's behavior after Katrina was despicable yet in other areas they are great. There are plenty of other examples. It's not an indictment of insurers as a whole.

USAA - no doubt about it. I'm a vet so I get a great deal from them. Check 'em out.

 

...and screw GEICO and Progressive. They each wanted almost three times what I pay with USAA. On top of it all, their politics suck out loud.

 

Before USAA I had NJM. USAA costs me less than half what I was paying NJM. When I called to cancel, the NJM guy was clearly angry with me, LOL. Pissing off an insurance geek - best day ever!

If it were an isolated incident of one predatory law firm, I would agree. The bad faith claims against Progressive are everywhere.

 

One predatory law firm? As if attorney's that seek huge settlements for flimsy reasons are paticularly rare? Claiming statements made by an attorney looking to get as much money as they can don't mean anything. There is evidence to support the notion that Progressive in particular has a bit of a track record, so you're right, but the basis for your position is flimsy. A more credible piece of evidence against Progressive would be something like this: http://www.state.nj....ntranking11.pdf

 

Really? They sued the driver of the other car. Why? If he were proven at fault, Progressive would have to pay the uninsured motorist of the decedent. What did Progressive do? Defended the other driver to prevent a judgement against him which would force Progressive to pay. I'm not exactly sure how your statement rectifies with the facts.

 

While I don't really feel all that compelled to defend a company I already dislike for my own reasons, and I think it's clear Progressive made a lot of mistakes in how they handled that case, why would the family be shocked that progressive showed up in court when they were specifically named in the family's lawsuit? It wasn't Girl's family suing other driver with Progressive butting it. It was Girls family suing other driver AND Progressive.

 

The driver of the other car was found at fault for the accident, ergo, the driver is now the killer.

 

A jury siding with them doesn't prove she didn't have some fault for the accident. Juries can & do base their decisions on sympathy. One has to wonder why her own passenger would state that she ran the red light. The passenger would have been able to get damages from either party, regardless of which one held liability, so she had no incentive to state that the person she was traveling with ran a red light. In a lower stakes he said-she said scenario with just property damage involved, this kind of case would just be considered a 50/50, in the absence of any way to diffinitively prove either version of the story. Because someone died, it was obviously a much more complicated outcome. Calling the driver a jury sides against a "killer" is melodramatic & pointless.

 

Because insurance companies will lobby for it and ultimately get it.

 

Why? A lot of companies would have zero interest in utilizing these devices and would actively oppose any law that would require them to implement them.

 

Exactly. Unless of course it was required by law.

 

Again, literally no one is interested in making them mandatory. Insurance companys have no incentive to push for such a thing. The cost of deploying & monitoring the data from such devices for EVERY SINGLE DRIVER THEY INSURE would be astronomical.

 

So your position is that insurance companies have no vested interest in parsing a millisecond by millisecond examination of a costly personal injury accident in order to assign blame?

 

What? No, that's not my point in the slightest. Lets try this again.

 

I'm an evil claims adjuster at Montgomery Burns Mutual. I write an auto policy for Driver X's 1991 Fort Tempest that includes $300,000 in coverage for 3rd party liability. One day, Driver X loses control of the car and hops a curb, striking a woman standing at a bus stop. There were 12 other people waiting for the bus and all of their witness statements support the conclusion that Driver X is 100% at fault for the accident.

 

However, I have an ace up my sleeve. Driver X has been driving with one of our electronic driving monitors for the past 4 months. I download all of the data it's collected and, EUREKA, I can prove he exceeded the speed limit by at least 10mph on more than 15 occasions! Ok, so I can prove that Driver X is a terrible driver. But wait, how does that help me avoid paying damages to the woman he injured? ...crap

 

 

Well, what is their motivation for offering this discount? They are in business to maximize profit. I have no issue with that at all. There must be some economic reason to offer these devices. They put them out there in the hope that someone may drive better?

 

I can't speak for what Progressive's goals are. That said, I'd assume they sought two outcomes:

  • Being able to retain a higher percentage of driver's they would consider most desirable, by enabling them to use the data they collect to justify the application of a filed rating credit.
  • Being able to justify applying a debit and seek additional premiums from drivers who's driving habbits they consider 'higher risk'

I never said any such thing. There are a number of great insurance companies, like New Jersey Manufacturers as a whole and others as well. Progressive is a company that uses all sorts of tactics to delay, underpay and deny claims whenever possible as part of a strategy. They are not alone, for example State Farm's behavior after Katrina was despicable yet in other areas they are great. There are plenty of other examples. It's not an indictment of insurers as a whole.

 

The majority of what you've written does not make the distinction between bad apples like Progressive and the rest of the insurance industry.

 

"Fact: Insurance companies, and progressive in particular spend an inordinate amount of time and effort to underpay and deny paying claims."

"Eventually all insurance companies will offer a discount for these spying devices without which the insurance will be unaffordable."

"12 separate insurance companies have filed patents for these types of devices so ultimately they all will require them"

"Because insurance companies will lobby for it and ultimately get it."

"That you have somehow convinced yourself that these companies are "just looking out for your best interests" and "want to give you money" suggests that either you're naive about how ruthless insurance companies can be or have some other vested reason not to believe it."

psssst...hey Zell...you're not gonna change anyone's mind about Progressive ;)

psssst...hey Zell...you're not gonna change anyone's mind about Progressive ;)

 

Psst, not trying to. F them

What did I do? :facepalm:

 

I only asked a simple question, if anyone used it, I'm so sorry. LOL

 

I got beeped at again tonight, this time driving the wife's Tahoe. Goung west on Bay Ave to make a left onto Vaughn Ave, 40 mile per hour zone, light turned amber just as I was approaching the stop line, I would not have needed to stop after the last east bound car passed except the for the fact that the assclown behind him, who didn't have a shot in hell at making the light never slowed down and ran the red light causing me to stop short and get beeped at, again. So turn infront of a speeding car running a red light, apparently no problem, stop to avoid getting T-boned and you are a bad driver. Holy crap Batman are these people nuts?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.