Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Change law to 20 round mag limit

Featured Replies

Asking for anything besides unrestricted magazines is a head nod to the idea that it is ok to restrict them.

 

 

Great point.

  • Replies 76
  • Views 9.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • As an outsider, I'll give a couple of ideas. This is going to be a long post, but important. I remember years ago NJ ham radio operators were trying to overturn the old 'scanner laws' . The old la

  • IMO you aim too low.   Mag limits do nothing - criminals will carry 30, 50, 100 rd magazines. Only Joe Law Abiding Citizen worries about mag limits.

  • What argument would you make for setting the limit to 20? There is an argument to be made for no limit but and argument for a different limit makes no sense, even to a politician.

NJ has always had gun laws............heck, they had laws for hunting of deer back in the 1750's.

IMO........the people of this state love to be told what to, when to and how to.....that's why we have the laws in place that we do and our elected officials telling us............they forget......they work for us.

 

Change it........at the Voting Booth.

Make term limits..not mag limits

But the problem is that NJ2AS seems only concerned with CCW. Not all gunowners are concerned about CCW. Now I understand that they are a grassroots organization that can only tackle one issue at a time, so right now there is currently no organization that is persuing anything that pertains to mag capacity or AWB.

 

That's all I've seen. I support them, and would like to join sometime down the road, but I mean, how long has the fight for CCW been going on? I really think we need to fight this not only in the courts, but to get boots on the ground. Start contacting politicians, start showing up places, show that we're serious about this. That's why they push us around, because they know we won't say anything, we'll take whatever laws they push down our throats.

Eric, highly untrue. CCW was the first thing they tackled, as it was being worked together with the SAF. They are also working, and have had some wins with local towns on FID/Extra paperwork.

We may need to view though, how much time, and money has been spent on OEC. Sure, it's inconvenient that towns make us jump through hurdles to exercise our rights, but honestly, a few wins for paperwork? That's not really much of a victory to be touting.

well ill be the "4th" member and ill bring a suburban full of friends to show numbers.... give me some info on our next date

 

If they do have a date in Trenton, I'd be down. This is what I've been saying we have to start doing in addition to fighting this in the courts. I like the CCW fight, but it doesn't seem like it's making any grounds. I really believe it's up to us to show the politicians that we're tired of being pushed around.

These laws are created for (1) simple reason, $$$$$$$. Now that "they" got it, they aint giving it up. Who's "they"? I don't want to cause anyone, including myself, heartburn tonight by putting forth my observation so I'll leave it to the individual to make their own. Two groups are obvious, but think about the associated groups and infrastucture involved. If you make one human mistake prior to or after obtaining any type of gun permit, you are going to pay.... big time. Trust me.

 

I don't know how many reads and reply's to this post there are but I know it is quite a bit. This topic is like a bright light that attracts all the creatures of the night big and small. The mass of bugs fly madly towards a light, bumping and crashing into it with all their energy accomplishing nothing, then they see another light, and they they fly off to that one accomplishing nothing, and the next, and finally ZAP. The bugs are the New Jerseyans and the Zapper light is NJ gun law.

 

Here is my list of gun laws:

1.) All schools are required to provide weapon safety classes to all children starting in Kindergarten and extending through 12th grade. (Right after the alternative lifestyle classes)

2.) Crimes commited using a gun will have minimum sentences that are long and require work on a chain gang. Yes, I said chain gang.

3.) Everyone must possess at least one gun.

 

That's it.

 

Someone once said to me, "If you want justice, stay away from the court house".

 

That's all I've seen. I support them, and would like to join sometime down the road, but I mean, how long has the fight for CCW been going on? I really think we need to fight this not only in the courts, but to get boots on the ground. Start contacting politicians, start showing up places, show that we're serious about this. That's why they push us around, because they know we won't say anything, we'll take whatever laws they push down our throats.

 

We may need to view though, how much time, and money has been spent on OEC. Sure, it's inconvenient that towns make us jump through hurdles to exercise our rights, but honestly, a few wins for paperwork? That's not really much of a victory to be touting.

 

 

If they do have a date in Trenton, I'd be down. This is what I've been saying we have to start doing in addition to fighting this in the courts. I like the CCW fight, but it doesn't seem like it's making any grounds. I really believe it's up to us to show the politicians that we're tired of being pushed around.

 

I disagree..OEC had a very good aim. Why is it that one person can get their permits back in ONE town in 2 weeks, but it takes me 7 weeks, and others 6 months??? There is NO standard, and NO Accountability. Since the state is the Ultimate Authority they are NOT doing their job by enforcing the 30-day STATUTORY rule...Right now towns are setting their on Gun Control laws by dragging their feet.

I still believe that in order to overhaul the gun laws in New Jersey, another law must take its place. Part of a success of a new gun law overhaul is that new law must have repealers in there. I agree that a CCW bill/legislation is a great idea. In my opinion, the CCW legislation will remain that...a great idea until you get some politicians on board, more people on board, a mass education of the populace.

 

I think what would get a lot of attention across the board is a comprehensive new gun law is written to replace/repeal the ENTIRE swath of antique gun laws still plaguing NJ gun owners on the books since 1898, 1912, 1924, 1958, 1966, 1990 (take your pick).

 

The 1966 FID laws (and earlier) should have been thrown out after 1968 GCA came in. (Other than the challenge in 1968 with Burton vs. Sills,) I don't have information if there was an attempt to replace the State Law 1966 FID law system with only the 1968 GCA as the State gun law. 68 GCA worked in most of the states of the U.S. as the primary gun law.

 

(Please: I am no fan of 1968-GCA or any gun control act for that matter. I am just using 1968 GCA as a illustration that Sills 1966 could have been repealed in favor of 1968 GCA).

 

 

I can even start the draft myself..... anyone can. Just start writing a draft for a new gun law initiative today. Start a separate thread here, call it Gun Law Draft thread and let everyone put their collective minds together. We have LEO's and lawyers here to give their expert opinions on which way the bill should go.

 

Pick another state, say Florida...and start a draft based on their gun laws. (I would say Kentucky or Arizona but that won't fly in Trenton)...Florida would be a good choice because a lot of people from the Northeast moved their over the years.

 

Florida has big cities, it is made up of diverse population demographics like NJ, and some areas in the state has a high population density, it has concealed carry and some good laws dealing with criminals. But whatever direction one would go, the first thing the gun bill should have is ...repealers (that is a NJ legal term used in the legislation I have looked at, it means sentences and paragraphs repealed).

 

Bottom line, in my opinion a complete overhaul top to bottom is needed. Repeal Sills 1966 outright and replace it with the Federal NICS or State POC NICS. That is where to start the new GUN LAW draft thread....but start the thread... it can snowball from there...

 

The arguments for repealing the assault weapons ban and the mag limit is that the ban had ZERO effect on crime (show facts and figures to back it up) but those are valid arguments for repeal. The Graves Amendment needs some definite changes to it. (A person with a BB gun in their car should not have to faces charges under the Graves Amendment). Use these ideas for drafting the new gun law and as basis for the repealers.

 

If there was no mag capacity limit I'd still use 10 rounders/15 rounders. I wouldn't go off and buy a

30 round hi cap mag. I'm sure most people would not either.

 

 

Why not? And I think you would be wrong. 30 rounds is not hi cap, it is standard capacity. a 30 round AR magazine is standard capacity, a 60 round, or 100 round drum/mag is high capacity.

 

Then again, there is a legal arguement to be made for no magazine limits, but there is no reason for one arbitrary number. The problem with "10 or 15 rounds should be enough anyway" is what got us into this mess in the first place. By having the mindset that at 10 rounds you are ok, but god forbid you have a 17 round magazine, you are going to go postal and shoot up a mall.

 

By the logic of "I'm sure most people would not either", then how come we have to beg and plead for companies to make 15 round magazines for NJ? If most people would only use 10/15 round mags, then why isn't everyone?

 

You can make a logical statement that you would buy standard capacity mags, and only load them to 10 rounds, or 15 or whatever, but to say most people would not either is just baseless.

 

I will give you the argument that for existing guns, people may not want to go spend money on more magazines, but if it is a new gun, why would anyone spend more on a limited capacity magazine?

 

10/15 rounds are not Standard Capacity.... they are Limited Capacity. As in our rights are LIMITED/RESTRICTED in this state.

 

Just a refresher... all guns and ammo are ILLEGAL in NJ, UNLESS it falls into an EXEMPTION. Those exemptions are where we operate.

 

That's all I've seen. I support them, and would like to join sometime down the road, but I mean, how long has the fight for CCW been going on? I really think we need to fight this not only in the courts, but to get boots on the ground. Start contacting politicians, start showing up places, show that we're serious about this. That's why they push us around, because they know we won't say anything, we'll take whatever laws they push down our throats.

 

We may need to view though, how much time, and money has been spent on OEC. Sure, it's inconvenient that towns make us jump through hurdles to exercise our rights, but honestly, a few wins for paperwork? That's not really much of a victory to be touting.

 

 

If they do have a date in Trenton, I'd be down. This is what I've been saying we have to start doing in addition to fighting this in the courts. I like the CCW fight, but it doesn't seem like it's making any grounds. I really believe it's up to us to show the politicians that we're tired of being pushed around.

 

Kaiser, you seem like an energetic kid, may I ask how many NJ2AS meetings you have been to or spoken with the leadership there?

 

More than one battle is being fought at the same time. the CCW battle is not going to be solved in a week, and will be solved one of two ways... our case is heard at the Supreme Court level, or another national case is. The CCW case in NJ right now is not going to be won here. Unfortunately, it has to go through the process. It will be another year or two, until I feel we will have a resolution.

 

CCW is also the EASIEST battle to fight as there is a legal foundation for the arguments based on national cases.

 

There are no legal basis for anyone to fight the FID system. That will take alot more effort.

This however does not mean we should start that fight and drop all else. The fact is, if the towns oblige by the laws already on the books, the system would be that much better. THEN we take the fight to them.

 

You can't start driving cross country when your own car is broken. Operation Establish Compliance is trying to do just that. In alot of cases, a simple phone call to the mayors, helps, and progress has been made. If you go to the meetings, you would be able to know. Quite easy to shout behind a keyboard.

 

If you want to help, come and help. Contact any of the board members, go to the meetings and help! A ton of people all scream yes, let's do it, but when it comes time to actually doing something, getting a starbucks, dunkin, wawa coffee is more important.

 

I will be doing more with NJ2AS in more capacity, however from my past experience as a board member, there were alot of calls for help, yet very few actually did stuff. People are just glad to send in their $25 for the year and thats it. Unfortunately, to make great change, we need physical help for people to do stuff.

 

A few posts ago, I asked you to reach out to them and offer help, did you?

I still believe that in order to overhaul the gun laws in New Jersey, another law must take its place. Part of a success of a new gun law overhaul is that new law must have repealers in there. I agree that a CCW bill/legislation is a great idea. In my opinion, the CCW legislation will remain that...a great idea until you get some politicians on board, more people on board, a mass education of the populace.

 

I think what would get a lot of attention across the board is a comprehensive new gun law is written to replace/repeal the ENTIRE swath of antique gun laws still plaguing NJ gun owners on the books since 1898, 1912, 1924, 1958, 1966, 1990 (take your pick).

 

The 1966 FID laws (and earlier) should have been thrown out after 1968 GCA came in. (Other than the challenge in 1968 with Burton vs. Sills,) I don't have information if there was an attempt to replace the State Law 1966 FID law system with only the 1968 GCA as the State gun law. 68 GCA worked in most of the states of the U.S. as the primary gun law.

 

(Please: I am no fan of 1968-GCA or any gun control act for that matter. I am just using 1968 GCA as a illustration that Sills 1966 could have been repealed in favor of 1968 GCA).

 

 

I can even start the draft myself..... anyone can. Just start writing a draft for a new gun law initiative today. Start a separate thread here, call it Gun Law Draft thread and let everyone put their collective minds together. We have LEO's and lawyers here to give their expert opinions on which way the bill should go.

 

Pick another state, say Florida...and start a draft based on their gun laws. (I would say Kentucky or Arizona but that won't fly in Trenton)...Florida would be a good choice because a lot of people from the Northeast moved their over the years.

 

Florida has big cities, it is made up of diverse population demographics like NJ, and some areas in the state has a high population density, it has concealed carry and some good laws dealing with criminals. But whatever direction one would go, the first thing the gun bill should have is ...repealers (that is a NJ legal term used in the legislation I have looked at, it means sentences and paragraphs repealed).

 

Bottom line, in my opinion a complete overhaul top to bottom is needed. Repeal Sills 1966 outright and replace it with the Federal NICS or State POC NICS. That is where to start the new GUN LAW draft thread....but start the thread... it can snowball from there...

 

The arguments for repealing the assault weapons ban and the mag limit is that the ban had ZERO effect on crime (show facts and figures to back it up) but those are valid arguments for repeal. The Graves Amendment needs some definite changes to it. (A person with a BB gun in their car should not have to faces charges under the Graves Amendment). Use these ideas for drafting the new gun law and as basis for the repealers.

 

I agree the way to approach reforming NJ gun laws is to sell it as a wasteful, antiquated system in need of modernization. The problem is the attitude of many of the politicians and the general public in this part of the country, they have been indoctrinated to believe guns are inherently evil and should be completely banned. The majority of people here have no experience with firearms and absolutely cannot see any reason people should own them. There are enough politicians that would look at the system we have now and say that if the current system slows down gun sales it better to keep it, even if it is costing a lot of money. They simply just don't get the whole gun thing at all.

 

This is slowly starting to change with more people being exposed to the sport through friends and the many shows on TV now that show firearms in a positive light. If 822r ever passes, it will be a complete game changer since people here will see civilians carrying guns, which is just not the case at all now, after a few years of that without problems, attitudes will change.

 

But give you an analogy - Gun reform is as pressing an issue to NJ politicians as legalizing gay marriage is to the legislators in a state like Mississippi.

 

 

A few posts ago, I asked you to reach out to them and offer help, did you?

 

I have in the past. I haven't heard anything about meetings, etc. If they have meetings that aren't on nights I'm in class, or working, I'll go.

 

If there was no mag capacity limit I'd still use 10 rounders/15 rounders. I wouldn't go off and buy a

30 round hi cap mag. I'm sure most people would not either.

 

I'd buy a ton in a heartbeat. I guarantee you lots of people would by >15 round mags simply because it would be the cheapest choice for a quality magazine for lots of guns.

Maybe we should pass a Constitutional Amendment which automatically repeals legislation after 5 years... It's win win for us in that bad laws just disappear, and a win for politicians in that it gives them busy work to harp on about... :p

 

They would find a way to rubber-stamp re-instate those expiring laws. These are politicians, they play political chess like Big Blue and think 16 moves ahead, in general have ambulance chasing lawyer skills and care not for their constituents.

 

NEXT!

I'd buy a ton in a heartbeat. I guarantee you lots of people would by >15 round mags simply because it would be the cheapest choice for a quality magazine for lots of guns.

 

Gee...$20-25 for Nj legal mags, or $10 for brand-new standard GI or if you get them on sale, P-mags

You can buy more standard magazines at better prices than any modified magazine. A standard ak magazine is about $10 and a used gi magazine can be had for as little as $8 each when bought in bulk. So yea it will make things plenty easier for a hobby that is very expensive in itself. Not to mention taxes if people can purchase more magazines in local stores this is good for businesses and it makes the PRNJ happy because they can get more tax dollars to waste on other useless projects that is something that can be used as a talking point to encourage the ban to be lifted.

I think surplus AK mags were going for something like $3-5 on AIM surplus a short while back.

I am pretty sure you can order a case of 100 from russia for almost nothing or call Al-Quaida and ask if they have extras they want to sell.

NJ treats a BB gun exactly like they treat a .50 Cal Desert Eagle. With those types of laws, I'm surprised they allow magazines of any kind.......

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.