Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Duty to retreat if you arrive at a burglary in progress?

Featured Replies

I read this article today: http://www.examiner.com/gun-rights-in-national/gun-for-hire-radio-host-takes-nj-anti-gun-laws-personally-as-we-all-should

 

I won't discuss the specifics of the article but it brings up a point about the castle doctrine.

 

A reasonable belief exists when the actor, to protect himself or a third person, was in his own dwelling at the time of the offense

 

I would think that if you are on your porch, bad guy is in your house, rushes you, you shoot him (you were coming back from the range) that it'd be a legal shoot. The person in the quoted article doesn't see it that way.

 

The other thing in the article is this:

 

If I left my handguns in my home and “accessible” to anyone in it while venturing to the store to purchase a new safe and the thieves, returning to finish the job they started, then stole my guns and used them to perpetuate, say a murder, I would likely be held accountable for the commission of the crime in which my guns were used,

 

Which has the stiff whiff of BS to me. Having guns in your locked house does not strike me as "accessible". On a lawn chair in the yard, perhaps, in your home, I don't thinks so.

  • Replies 63
  • Views 7.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Huskyjerkjohn
    Huskyjerkjohn

    Now some of my crazy neighbors up here in the Highlands have told me that should you ever be forced to shoot an intruder in your home, you must be sure to tap him a minimum of two times (preferably mo

  • My opinion only,   If this would happen and family was inside, I'm going in and damn the consequences.   No one home, "hello 911" and watch from a concealed location. My stuff ain't worth dying

  • Once I'm on my property, I take the gun out of the case, load it and put it on my hip in the holster I never took off. Now i"m armed, 100% legally. Now go back to the original question.

if you're coming back from the range, you shouldn't have a loaded firearm on you. at best, retreat to car or corner to load. i'm sure someone would object to that.

  • Author

if you're coming back from the range, you shouldn't have a loaded firearm on you.

 

Once I'm on my property, I take the gun out of the case, load it and put it on my hip in the holster I never took off. Now i"m armed, 100% legally. Now go back to the original question.

I'm not quite sure about this, so bear with me:

 

I think NJ's paper thin Castle Doctrine extends to cover your porch and patio as livable spaces. If you're on the porch or stoop or what ever the entrance to your front door is, that is considered a part of your home, and therefore do not have the duty to retreat. Once it hits your lawn though the entire situation changes to one where you DO have a duty to retreat to a safe location and call the police. As far as loading a gun on the lawn and taking it to the porch, the situation seems a bit...risky. As does loading it in the car.

 

You're right Mal. The whole guns not sitting in a safe does smell like BS. The criminal is already committing a crime, whats one more? As long as you report the theft, you're free from any legal ramifications that might come from your stolen guns.

ya but arnt nj castle laws differant like you have to pretty much be attacked with weapon to fire at someone? i heard you can be watching tv in jersey and they can come in steal your tv while watching and you shoot them you go to jail

  • Author

ya but arnt nj castle laws differant like you have to pretty much be attacked with weapon to fire at someone? i heard you can be watching tv in jersey and they can come in steal your tv while watching and you shoot them you go to jail

 

There has to be a direct threat. If there is a person rushing at you from inside your house while you are on your porch and you estimate there is a deadly threat, you would be justified in using force. If the person is armed while stealing your TV and your order them to disarm, surrender or withdraw, and they do not comply you are within your rights to use force. Of course, no rules are hard and fast in NJ. Always use deadly force as the last possible choice to prevent injury or death not because some banger is stealing your 55inch LED tv and deserves punishment.

 

(2)A reasonable belief exists when the actor, to protect himself or a third person, was in his own dwelling at the time of the offense or was privileged to be thereon and the encounter between the actor and intruder was sudden and unexpected, compelling the actor to act instantly and:

(a)The actor reasonably believed that the intruder would inflict personal injury upon the actor or others in the dwelling; or

(b)The actor demanded that the intruder disarm, surrender or withdraw, and the intruder refused to do so.

ya but arnt nj castle laws differant like you have to pretty much be attacked with weapon to fire at someone? i heard you can be watching tv in jersey and they can come in steal your tv while watching and you shoot them you go to jail

 

As I told Ron earlier, please read the statue before making assumptions.

 

2C:3-4 Use of force in self-protection.

 

Thank you.

NJ does not have a Castle Doctrine. You are not fully protected on your property from criminal charges(i.e. in your front lawn, car...) and you are never protected from a civil suit. my sig is meant as a joke as NJ doesn't follow the U.S. Constitution, so why should follow their own?

If you were to arrive home and notice that a burglar is clearly in progress (as in there there are signs of forced entry and an apparent activity within the house), and you call the police, the first thing the dispatcher is likely to instruct you to do is to be safe and to stay away from the structure. The last thing they want you to do is to storm inside with your gun drawn, or to start a shootout outside. Both acourses of action are highly likely to be ruled as premeditated violence without an immediate and clear need for self-defence.

 

If you were, however, to enter the house and only realize that there is a break-in in progress, the situation would be different, I guess.

Now some of my crazy neighbors up here in the Highlands have told me that should you ever be forced to shoot an intruder in your home, you must be sure to tap him a minimum of two times (preferably more) with one shot at extreme close range to confirm that he tried to wrestle your weapon away from you after you informed him to cease and desist his illegal activity. I would never do this, mind you, being the law abiding citizen that I am, and I pass along this advice strictly for conversational purposes. I most likely would elect to run away if I could (I'm sure my pants would be soiled from the encounter and my legs would be shaking fiercely). While cowering in the nearest big bush, I'd call the mighty police to come and save me. Perhaps by the time they arrived, I'd have regained my composure, and I could talk without crying so I could describe the perp/s.

 

Now my really crazy neighbor, let's call him Marco for this scenario, well, if he came home from the shooting range to a burglary in progress in his beloved casa, he'd calmly park his car, tell his wife to sit still, uncase and then immediately strip load his 1954 Russian SKS (oh, how he loves that gun). He'd be sure to fill little "Natasha" with a full ten rounds of his extra special 7.62 (home made hollow points- don't even ask) and then he'd waltz right in to his own house to personally greet the gentleman/men who made the mistake of trying to rip off his resources. Marco wouldn't give a hoot in hell about the NJ law, or the consequences of his action, because he deeply believes (he's personally told me this) "you either live like a man, or you are already dead!" (I guess I'm a zombie by that credo). Oh yeah, I'm pretty sure he'd leave no survivor/s for "lawsuits", either, should the gentleman/men refuse to do as he says and actively resist him. My neighbor is quite the character, for sure. By the ripe old age of 26, Marco managed to deal out 32 deathcards (eight hand to hand kills) to Uncle Ho's boys in Vietnam and Laos. Four (4) freakin' tours with the zips. Yup, that's my man Marco. Even the cops seem to like him. Keeps a wicked nice lawn, too. Silly neighbors! Go figure... :keeporder:

My opinion only,

 

If this would happen and family was inside, I'm going in and damn the consequences.

 

No one home, "hello 911" and watch from a concealed location. My stuff ain't worth dying over.

  • Author

My opinion only,

 

If this would happen and family was inside, I'm going in and damn the consequences.

 

No one home, "hello 911" and watch from a concealed location. My stuff ain't worth dying over.

 

I agree that I would not enter if I knew beforehand. I do know that when I've come upon stuff that had been burgled, there is a period of misunderstanding. Like, you come home, and your door is open and maybe you figure your kid forgot or something when in fact a crime is in progress. There is a lag of adjustment, for example, I had my GPS and sat radio stolen out of my car a few years back. As I walked out to my vehicle early am, I noticed the dome light on and I'm thinking I must have left the door ajar. When I opened the door, I saw a bracket on the seat and I still hadn't put it all together until I sat in the car and saw the ripped wires. I could easily see walking into my home and not piecing the clues together right off the bat because it's so out of the ordinary.

Always the what ifs. A million of them. Best thing to do is do what you think is right, and take your chances. I always say if you make a decision stand by it right or wrong, but at least make a decision. Is a tv or another vain appliance worth it? Maybe to some of you it is, maybe not. Maybe its the principal of the person just taking something that does not belong to them. Who knows.

Now some of my crazy neighbors up here in the Highlands have told me that should you ever be forced to shoot an intruder in your home, you must be sure to tap him a minimum of two times (preferably more) with one shot at extreme close range to confirm that he tried to wrestle your weapon away from you after you informed him to cease and desist his illegal activity. I would never do this, mind you, being the law abiding citizen that I am, and I pass along this advice strictly for conversational purposes. I most likely would elect to run away if I could (I'm sure my pants would be soiled from the encounter and my legs would be shaking fiercely). While cowering in the nearest big bush, I'd call the mighty police to come and save me. Perhaps by the time they arrived, I'd have regained my composure, and I could talk without crying so I could describe the perp/s.

 

Now my really crazy neighbor, let's call him Marco for this scenario, well, if he came home from the shooting range to a burglary in progress in his beloved casa, he'd calmly park his car, tell his wife to sit still, uncase and then immediately strip load his 1954 Russian SKS (oh, how he loves that gun). He'd be sure to fill little "Natasha" with a full ten rounds of his extra special 7.62 (home made hollow points- don't even ask) and then he'd waltz right in to his own house to personally greet the gentleman/men who made the mistake of trying to rip off his resources. Marco wouldn't give a hoot in hell about the NJ law, or the consequences of his action, because he deeply believes (he's personally told me this) "you either live like a man, or you are already dead!" (I guess I'm a zombie by that credo). Oh yeah, I'm pretty sure he'd leave no survivor/s for "lawsuits", either, should the gentleman/men refuse to do as he says and actively resist him. My neighbor is quite the character, for sure. By the ripe old age of 26, Marco managed to deal out 32 deathcards (eight hand to hand kills) to Uncle Ho's boys in Vietnam and Laos. Four (4) freakin' tours with the zips. Yup, that's my man Marco. Even the cops seem to like him. Keeps a wicked nice lawn, too. Silly neighbors! Go figure... :keeporder:

 

I like your neighbors!!

  • Author

Always the what ifs. A million of them. Best thing to do is do what you think is right, and take your chances. I always say if you make a decision stand by it right or wrong, but at least make a decision. Is a tv or another vain appliance worth it? Maybe to some of you it is, maybe not. Maybe its the principal of the person just taking something that does not belong to them. Who knows.

 

If you follow the link in the first post, you'll see that this is more than a what-if. It actually happened. I was more interested in the legal ramifications.

My stuff ain't worth dying over.

 

I generally agree, situation depending. But my question is, what is worth dying for?

 

 

I generally agree, situation depending. But my question is, what is worth dying for?

 

My family.

The last thing they want you to do is to storm inside with your gun drawn, or to start a shootout outside. Both acourses of action are highly likely to be ruled as premeditated violence without an immediate and clear need for self-defence.

 

If you were, however, to enter the house and only realize that there is a break-in in progress, the situation would be different, I guess.

I'm not well versed in other states' castle doctrine, however, I do think storming inside YOUR OWN home with your gun drawn would be acceptable in any of the free states. It is your home and you should have the right to do whatever it takes to protect it.

I'm not well versed in other states' castle doctrine, however, I do think storming inside YOUR OWN home with your gun drawn would be acceptable in any of the free states. It is your home and you should have the right to do whatever it takes to protect it.

 

 

I think there's a difference in laws as it relates to protecting your "stuff" vs. protecting "you or your family". Like it or not, you have no right to blow someone's brains across the room, just because they're ripping you off.

I generally agree, situation depending. But my question is, what is worth dying for?

 

My Family and myself, I can replace my home, all the thing that I own, I can not replace my family.

Front lawn = you're duty to retreat, if it comes down to using force to protect yourself, it has to be proportional.

 

Inside your home/dwelling = no duty to retreat, use of deadly force is authorized if you have a strong feeling that you or other people in your home (family) are in direct danger of severe bodily harm by the perpetrator. That strong feeling has to stand up in court when it comes time to justify your actions.

I would agree that if nobody is inside then one could be held liable for what might occur. If family is in there then you have to do what Is necessary to protect them. My viewpoint is lightly different as if I arrive hom and see that I no longer am the homeowner. I now m citing in an official capacity as a police officer. My first call is to the police to tell them that I will be inside and armed along with my description so I don't get shot. Family stays far away

I'm not well versed in other states' castle doctrine, however, I do think storming inside YOUR OWN home with your gun drawn would be acceptable in any of the free states. It is your home and you should have the right to do whatever it takes to protect it.

 

Ah ha...............the key words here are Free States............where does NJ fall within that realm.....?

I read this article today: http://www.examiner....s-we-all-should

 

I won't discuss the specifics of the article but it brings up a point about the castle doctrine.

 

* * *

 

I would think that if you are on your porch, bad guy is in your house, rushes you, you shoot him (you were coming back from the range) that it'd be a legal shoot. The person in the quoted article doesn't see it that way.

 

I would agree with you, provided the bad guy has a weapon or puts you in imminent fear of being injured. I wouldn't agree with you if the bad guy was an unarmed 12 year old kid.

 

NJSA 2C:3-4©(1) states that "Notwithstanding the provisions of [omitted], or this section, the use of force or deadly force upon or toward an intruder who is unlawfully in a dwelling is justifiable when the actor reasonably believes that the force is immediately necessary for the purpose of protecting himself or another person in the dwelling against the use of force by the intruder in the present occasion.

 

NJSA 2C:3-4©(2) states that "A reasonable belief exists when the actor, to protect himself or a third person, was in his own dwelling at the time of the offense or was privileged to be thereon and the encounter between the actor and intruder was sudden and unexpected, compelling the actor to act instantly and:

(a) The actor resonably belived that the intruder would inflict personal injury upon the actoror others in the dwelling; or

(b) The actor demanded that the intruder disarm, surrender or withdraw, and the intruder refused to do so.

 

In your scenario, I would maintain that porch was part of the dwelliing, and that even if it is not, the intruder(who was coming out the door) was "in the dwelling" when he rushed you. Note that under this provision, it is only the intruder who must be in the dwelling. You don't have to be in the house, only privileged to be there.

 

There are other sections that apply as well. Under NJSA 2C:3-4(b)(2)(a), a person in general may not not use deadly force unless the actor "reasonably believes that such force is necessary to protect himself against death or serious bodily injury." Even where such a reasonable belief exists, under NJSA 2C:3-4(b)(2)(b) an actor must retreat if "the actor knows that he can avoid the the necessity of using such force with complete safety by retreating[.] However, "the actor is not required to retreat from his own dwelling, unless he was the initial aggressor."

 

In other words, if you reasonaly believe you are at risk of death or serious bodily injury, you can use deadly force anywhere, unless you can safely retreat. You don't have to retreat, however, if you are in your own dwelling.

 

In addition, if you are in the dwelling, you do not have to reasonably believe that the assailant is about to kill you or cause serious injury. You only have to reasonably believe the intruder would inflict bodly injury on you. Thus, in the house, you can shoot someone who is brandishing a non-lethal weapon, but you can't do that in your front yard.

 

The term "reasonably believe " is important. Whether your belief is reasonable is a determination for the jury, and while you might actually have believed you were at risk, you can still be convicted if your belief was not reasonable in the opinion of the jurors.

 

There is a general approach under New Jersey law that you have greater rights to self protection within your house, but those rights are not absolute. If you shoot someone inside or outside of your house, you better be ready to explain why you believed it was imminently necessary.

  • Author
I would maintain that porch was part of the dwelliing,

 

Porches count. In State v Martinez the superior court ruled "a "dwelling" encompasses a doorway, threshold, porch or other similar appurtenance.".

 

As to the rest, the key issue is that you must be threatened. Inside you have no duty to retreat, outside you do.

Porches count. In State v Martinez the superior court ruled "a "dwelling" encompasses a doorway, threshold, porch or other similar appurtenance.".

 

As to the rest, the key issue is that you must be threatened. Inside you have no duty to retreat, outside you do.

We agree.

I was going to cite State v. Martinez (229 N.J. Super. 593 (App. Div. 1989)) but didn't know if it was still good law and didn't have enough time to Sheppardize it.

As to the rest, the key issue is that you must be threatened. Inside you have no duty to retreat, outside you do.

 

You are outside and you have a gun (the coming from range scenario), and BG comes out of house running towards you.

You being the law abiding citizen retreat and in the process leave your property.

 

Cops come along at that moment and arrest BG for burglary. You get arrested for carrying a loaded weapon outside of the firearm exemptions. (Yes I know, no sane cop would arrest you but by the letter of the law he should)

 

You spend 7 years in prison. BG is out in 6 months.

 

What an F%%^d up state we live in.

  • Author

You are outside and you have a gun (the coming from range scenario), and BG comes out of house running towards you.

You being the law abiding citizen retreat and in the process leave your property.

 

Cops come along at that moment and arrest BG for burglary. You get arrested for carrying a loaded weapon outside of the firearm exemptions. (Yes I know, no sane cop would arrest you but by the letter of the law he should)

 

You spend 7 years in prison. BG is out in 6 months.

 

What an F%%^d up state we live in.

 

I think that in that situation, you were compelled to break the law under duress. I'm not familiar if NJ has exemptions for laws broken in that fashion but other states certainly do.

I think the guy quoted is wrong.

 

A. You are allowed to act in self defense. Even on the street you can act in self defense. If you come home and unwittingly walk in on a burglary and happen to be armed, you are a homeowner in your house. Doesn't matter who arrived first. Say you get to your living room and start to put your firearms away and hear a noise upstairs. Say you are cleaning your guns in the backyard, no one else is home and burglars come out the back door with guns or a conduit bender and threaten you. You can take a proper response. If the burglars see you and yell "don't shoot, don't shoot" and run away... get a good description of them to tell the police. Chasing or shooting them is not allowed.

 

B. You can knowingly enter your house to look for the perps who may or may not still be present. But, that is a job for the police. Should you be armed and shoot an intruder that you went looking for when you had full knowledge you were putting yourself in harm's way, you are liable for that. Don't go looking for trouble. But, if your family is inside, you can act accordingly. That is legitimate.

 

C. A gun locked in my house is secure. I think the readily accessible law only applies to keeps minors away from guns. Not burglars.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.