This thread took off, this could come in handy for anyone traveling around the state who wants to get a slice.

Most pizza in South Jersey is better than all pizza in Brooklyn.

 

And most pizza in Central Jersey is better than all pizza in South Jersey, so you're much better off than Brooklyn.

 

I can tell you not to buy any pizza anywhere in the Poconos...

This thread took off, this could come in handy for anyone traveling around the state who wants to get a slice.

 

 

Now we need someone who knows how to make a POI File so we can all put them in our GPS's..

Star Tavern in Orange.

Ralph's in nutley is good

I really really like the buffalo chicken pizza from Mona Lisa in Bayonne

I will have to try Lido's. How about Brooklyn's Brick Oven Pizzeria in Hackensack? Keep em coming I need more good local pizza places!! I know it isn't Jersey but it's too close not to count. Martio's Pizza in Nanuet, NY

Martio's is that right by route 59 and the nanuet mall? If it is, they make good Pizza.

Brooklyn's Brick Oven is good, but if you are in Hackensack, try Presto's.

Lido's does no take out or slices so eat in.

Star Tavern in Orange.

 

x2 they make a good pie

Ralph's in nutley is good

I really really like the buffalo chicken pizza from Mona Lisa in Bayonne

I never got chicken on Pizza. IMHO it is one of those items that do not belong on Pizza.

I never got chicken on Pizza. IMHO it is one of those items that do not belong on Pizza.

 

oh man you missing out, buffalo chicken pizza is one of the best things ever to be invented.

 

I never got chicken on Pizza. IMHO it is one of those items that do not belong on Pizza.

I was never that type either until I had said pizza... life changing

Heresy!

Casa Di Pizza Route 22 West Union, NJ next to Maxon Mazda Large Arugula with whole wheat thin crust well done.........

a mano in ridgewood (one of my favorites ever)

kinchley's in ramsey or mahwah

grimaldi's in hoboken

emma's in cranford

benny's or gio's in hoboken

 

 

to be honest, 3 of the top 5 pies i've ever had weren't in NY or NJ

 

top honors goes to "una pizza" in san francisco

a mano, the original grimaldi's under the bridge, rosso pomodoro in naples florida, and the place in epcot "italy" in orlando florida are my top five

 

if you go to a mano, get the one with the buffalo mozzarella.

 

and if you like "brooklyn's" you'll love grimaldi's in hoboken

And most pizza in Central Jersey is better than all pizza in South Jersey, so you're much better off than Brooklyn.

 

I can tell you not to buy any pizza anywhere in the Poconos...

 

and north jersey is better than central jersey

I do remember back in the 70's Pizza Time on RT 22 just before you would get to Echo Lanes was pretty good, that and their Calzones and Zeppoli's were great. Not sure if they are still there or still any good..

No, the PX4 is the best... oh wait... wrong thread...

 

Vincent's in Merchantville. Their thin pizza is amazing, and they are close to Rayco Armory. Talk about one stop shopping...

I do remember back in the 70's Pizza Time on RT 22 just before you would get to Echo Lanes was pretty good, that and their Calzones and Zeppoli's were great. Not sure if they are still there or still any good..

 

Echo Lanes, makes me think about H.A. Winston's. Great burgers, actually, everything there was pretty damn good.

I can tell you not to buy any pizza anywhere in the Poconos...

 

Trust me, you don't have to go that far north to find shitty pizza once you cross the Delaware. Anything north of 78 is risky business. And probably even 20 miles south.

im all about that dominoes! jk

 

 

Neils pizza in Wayne is pretty good

V&J pizza in Pequannock(sp?)just off rt23

my dad was a bus driver who loved the honey mooners and like ralph we got pizza every pay day.the star tavern or casa di pizza on bloomfield ave I still remember the smell and my burnt lap from holding it in the car .1976 was the last time I remember that 95% of pizza in ocean county blows

Chimney Rock!

Trust me, you don't have to go that far north to find shitty pizza once you cross the Delaware. Anything north of 78 is risky business. And probably even 20 miles south.

Colonial Pizza in Easton, PA. Just North of 78 been going there for the last 25+ years.

Its odd, I haven't eaten pizza in 6+ months I think, don't miss it a bit.

Its odd, I haven't eaten pizza in 6+ months I think, don't miss it a bit.

you just haven't gone to the right place. what part of the state do you live in?

 

Colonial Pizza in Easton, PA. Just North of 78 been going there for the last 25+ years.

 

I discussed this earlier in this thread. There are a few good places. But, unlike NJ, most places up here are actually really really bad.

 

Its odd, I haven't eaten pizza in 6+ months I think, don't miss it a bit.

 

2-1/2 years for me since I've had a slice.

 

you just haven't gone to the right place. what part of the state do you live in?

 

I've had decent pizza, I've just changed what I eat and the carbs in pizza are not on the list. After a while, I can't even think of eating that stuff.

ah. didn't realize it was a dietary thing.

Echo Lanes, makes me think about H.A. Winston's. Great burgers, actually, everything there was pretty damn good.

Both places long gone H.A. Winston's had great burgers..

To determine the "best" pizza, I guess one first has to declare their preferences of a pizza. For example, I can't stand a pizza that is too doughy or thick or has a big crust. "Deep Dish" pizza is the worse, as far as I'm concerned. Give me a pizza that has very thin crust with allot of sauce and a touch of cheese, with the slightly brown (but not quite burnt) crust and I'm in heaven. Something along the lines of Mack and Manco in Ocean City, fits that bill.

Vesuvios in millstone twp, awesome pizza. Monmouth county

 

As for ocean county, vinnies pizza in barnegat.