Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Big news in the fight to carry

Featured Replies

I hope the NJ attorney general doesn't kick his dog when he goes home tonight...

 

I've recently, informally adopted a stray dog on a probationary basis. I named him Jersey.

  • Replies 62
  • Views 6.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • reloaderguy
    reloaderguy

    Don't hold your breath for any change in NJ CCW laws anytime soon cause it ain't gonna happen!

  • And we're 100% SOL if we lose a justice under an Obama administration.

  • DirtyDigz
    DirtyDigz

    Finally, a judge that gets it!:  

This will end up going to Supreme Court eventually. If Obama get re-elected and stacks the deck with antis, this won't mean a hill of beans.

Don't hold your breath for any change in NJ CCW laws anytime soon cause it ain't gonna happen!

 

I agree, NJ will go the way of Illinois if it is ever forced to be a shall issued state.

ooooooooo-kkkkkkkkk I guessss we'll never have the righhht tooo carrry a firearm leeegallly

 

pic_1294145062_4.jpg

 

Such a ray of sunshine you guys are.

I just say stuff like "That'll never happen" because what I say is usually wrong. Haha!

I agree, NJ will go the way of Illinois if it is ever forced to be a shall issued state.

 

FYI, Illinois is being sued for their lack of carry.

 

It is Alan Gura's (SAF) opinion that if SCOTUS stays on the same track as they ruled in the Heller and Mc Donald cases, they will force ALL states to adopt some form of carry. This will not be discretionary for the states to decide who can carry, but rather only what form of carry to allow (open and/or concealed).

FYI, Illinois is being sued for their lack of carry.

 

It is Alan Gura's (SAF) opinion that if SCOTUS stays on the same track as they ruled in the Heller and Mc Donald cases, they will force ALL states to adopt some form of carry. This will not be discretionary for the states to decide who can carry, but rather only what form of carry to allow (open and/or concealed).

 

And we're 100% SOL if we lose a justice under an Obama administration.

And we're 100% SOL if we lose a justice under an Obama administration.

 

True....... well, one of the 5 anyway.

 

Lets hope that doesn't happen :nea:

This will end up going to Supreme Court eventually. If Obama get re-elected and stacks the deck with antis, this won't mean a hill of beans.

 

Unfortunately SCOTUS choses which cases to hear so there is no guarantee they will hear it.

 

 

And we're 100% SOL if we lose a justice under an Obama administration.

 

Or a Romney administration. We got the devil and the deep blue sea.

 

 

Unfortunately SCOTUS choses which cases to hear so there is no guarantee they will hear it.

 

When there are conflicting rulings on the same topic on different circuits, they are much more likely to hear a case. I don't know how the 3rd circuit will rule on our appeal, or if MS will apppeal to the 4th circuit, but the conflicting rulings so far make it more likely.

Or a Romney administration. We got the devil and the deep blue sea.

 

i disagree..while it's not a guarantee of getting a conservative if Romney makes the nomination there is still the chance..there is Zero, Zip, Nada, Nichevo, possibility of getting a Justice under Obama who will be anything but a raving Anti. Kagan has already stated that she would like to see Heller and Mcdonald overturned and all it takes is ONE of the 5 that went the right way on those cases to lose it all.

 

 

i disagree..while it's not a guarantee of getting a conservative if Romney makes the nomination there is still the chance..there is Zero, Zip, Nada, Nichevo, possibility of getting a Justice under Obama who will be anything but a raving Anti. Kagan has already stated that she would like to see Heller and Mcdonald overturned and all it takes is ONE of the 5 that went the right way on those cases to lose it all.

 

Romney is antigun, has signed antigun laws, including AWB, invented Romney Care, the guy is Obama but with more accomplishments under his belt. It also worries me that the Republicans won't stand up to Romney like they do to Obama. Republicans are not our friends by and large. I trust them less with an antigun liberal that is one of their own as President.

Kagan has already stated that she would like to see Heller and Mcdonald overturned

 

I haven't seen that, not that it would be surprising. I'm curious, where did she state that?

There is no question, after Heller, that the Second Amendment guarantees Americans ‘the individual right to possess and carry weapons in case of confrontation.

 

-Elena Kagan

 

 

 

 

I haven't seen that, not that it would be surprising. I'm curious, where did she state that?

There is no question, after Heller, that the Second Amendment guarantees Americans ‘the individual right to possess and carry weapons in case of confrontation.

 

-Elena Kagan

 

Doesn't state anything about overturning heller.

 

Isn't it extremely difficult to overturn a SCOTUS decision.

Correct. This is the only thing I found of kagan referencing heller. I think it is unlikely that she has "already stated" that she wantsto overturn it. The fact that heller is settled law carries with it mug gravity. The ball has been moved downfield towards MORE freedom and not less. It would be tough to reverse course.

 

 

Furthermore, while I agree that overturning heller or further restricting the 2A would be bad, Im less than convinced of POTUS ability to restructure the court in some Orwellian nightmare. Take a long look at the appointment of Robert Bork to SCOTUS. So great was the panic that a conservative would replace moderate Lewis Powell that a witch hunt the likes of which have never been televised occured besmirching the record of Robert bork. Party lines were crossed in confirmation to avoid an ideological restructuring of the judiciary.

 

Our founders were smart. They were certainly smarter and bolder than any modern politician. Have a little faith.

Yeah, I didn't think that Kagan said what KdPipes claims she said. Unfortunately, "our side" is not immune to inaccuracy and hyperbole. Odds are certainly very, very strong that Kagan will vote with the "anti" 2A justices, but I think there is at least a remote chance that she could be a pleasant surprise on 2A issues.

My point is that I'm not sure it is relevant what Kagan thinks about 2A. Who was she appointed to replace? STEVENS..a "Liberal Activist Judge" appointed by Gerald Ford. Sotomayor was appointed to replace SOUTER, another "Liberal" appointed by George HW Bush.

 

The confirmation process exists as a bulwark against the desires of the executive branch. The supermajority needed to accomplish such action is unlikely and has only happened once per administration in the last 2 POTUS. The last one was used to pass Health Care Reform. The prior majority was used to swing the voting block of SCOTUS by replacing Sandra Day O'Connor with Samuel Alito. (Renquist's replacement by Roberts maintained the balance)

 

Quite certainly, there was much quaking in boots when Alito was confirmed on the part of left leaning Americans.

 

I tend to think that it will be unlikely for Obama to create this swing in the Judiciary in his second term because even if re-elected...I don't think there will exist a majority in both houses to pass confirmation. Establishment Party politicians want to maintain the status quo. And, contrary to what many critics say of Obama, he is just as much an establishment politician as Romney, George HW Bush, and John McCain.

Just to help clarify, it was Justice Sotomayor who said the same thing Justice Kagan said at their confirmation hearings, that Heller was "settled law". When McDonald vs Chicago was decided, Justice Sotomayor joined Justice Breyer in his dissent, which said, "I can find nothing in the Second Amend-ment’s text, history, or underlying rationale that couldwarrant characterizing it as “fundamental” insofar as itseeks to protect the keeping and bearing of arms for private self-defense purposes. Nor can I find any justification for interpreting the Constitution as transferring ultimate regulatory authority over the private uses of firearms fromdemocratically elected legislatures to courts or from theStates to the Federal Government."

 

IOW, she does not believe the 2nd amendment is a fundamental, individual right for the purpose of self-defense. Even though that is exactly what the "settled law" decision in Heller found. So when Kagan sang the same tune at her confirmation hearing, we all pointed to Sotomayor as an example of why that statement can't be trusted coming from an Obama nominee.

 

Oh, and about Romney. I'm no Romney fan, but I'd rather have him than the alternative. Remember, Bush was a liberal RINO too. He was going to sign a renewal of the AWB. We didn't get national concealed carry. Hell, we didn't really get anything except the expiration of the AWB, and that was due to inaction by Congress. But Bush had a limited pool from which to draw judicial nominees. Remember Harriet Myers? She wasn't on the approved list and her nomination went down in flames. And we got two excellent justices from the Bush administration. Make no mistake, if Romney becomes president, we will stand a much better chance of keeping a conservative majority on the bench.

 

Nationally, we're facing the same bad decision we had here in NJ a few short years ago. Rabid anti-gunner Corzine, or not-our-friend-but-not-quite-our-enemy Christie. Does anyone want to really make the argument that we would've been better off with Corzine?

Just to help clarify, it was Justice Sotomayor who said the same thing Justice Kagan said at their confirmation hearings, that Heller was "settled law". When McDonald vs Chicago was decided, Justice Sotomayor joined Justice Breyer in his dissent, which said, "I can find nothing in the Second Amend-ment’s text, history, or underlying rationale that couldwarrant characterizing it as “fundamental” insofar as itseeks to protect the keeping and bearing of arms for private self-defense purposes. Nor can I find any justification for interpreting the Constitution as transferring ultimate regulatory authority over the private uses of firearms fromdemocratically elected legislatures to courts or from theStates to the Federal Government."

 

IOW, she does not believe the 2nd amendment is a fundamental, individual right for the purpose of self-defense. Even though that is exactly what the "settled law" decision in Heller found. So when Kagan sang the same tune at her confirmation hearing, we all pointed to Sotomayor as an example of why that statement can't be trusted coming from an Obama nominee.

 

Oh, and about Romney. I'm no Romney fan, but I'd rather have him than the alternative. Remember, Bush was a liberal RINO too. He was going to sign a renewal of the AWB. We didn't get national concealed carry. Hell, we didn't really get anything except the expiration of the AWB, and that was due to inaction by Congress. But Bush had a limited pool from which to draw judicial nominees. Remember Harriet Myers? She wasn't on the approved list and her nomination went down in flames. And we got two excellent justices from the Bush administration. Make no mistake, if Romney becomes president, we will stand a much better chance of keeping a conservative majority on the bench.

 

Nationally, we're facing the same bad decision we had here in NJ a few short years ago. Rabid anti-gunner Corzine, or not-our-friend-but-not-quite-our-enemy Christie. Does anyone want to really make the argument that we would've been better off with Corzine?

 

I agree

I tend to think that it will be unlikely for Obama to create this swing in the Judiciary in his second term because even if re-elected...I don't think there will exist a majority in both houses to pass confirmation. Establishment Party politicians want to maintain the status quo. And, contrary to what many critics say of Obama, he is just as much an establishment politician as Romney, George HW Bush, and John McCain.

 

You are sorely mistaken my friend. Obama will absolutely appoint someone who mirrors his own beliefs. Supreme Court justices are confirmed in the Senate only, not the house. What party controls the Senate, Democrats. If Obama get re-elected he could possibly appoint 3 justices that will throw this country into a socialist spin that could drastically change what this country has been about. It will be a sad day for gun owners in this country. Bet on it!

You are sorely mistaken my friend. Obama will absolutely appoint someone who mirrors his own beliefs. Supreme Court justices are confirmed in the Senate only, not the house. What party controls the Senate, Democrats. If Obama get re-elected he could possibly appoint 3 justices that will throw this country into a socialist spin that could drastically change what this country has been about. It will be a sad day for gun owners in this country. Bet on it!

 

I am a bit confused on this. Lots of folks make statements that if Obama gets reelected he will automatically throw liberals on the bench. Don't conservative justices first have to retire or die? Too me doesn't seem automatic and the probability of three new jusitces being appointed seems low. However I do agree we should pray Obama doesn't get reelected for a host of reasons. Am I off on this?

There are for justices over the age of 70. Scalia, Kennedy, Breyer, and Ginsburg. The most likely to die first is Ginsburg. Replacing her with a more liberal justice will be tough for she makes even the most bleeding hearts seem moderate. So that one doesn't mater. Breyer is another left leaning justice. Replacing him with a liberal is redundant. Kennedy is the next most likely to retire or die. I'd be most concerned about him. But he also isn't a lock for 2a rights and it typically a swing vote.

 

Scalia shows no sign of retirement and will likely not die while a democrat is president because he's so full of piss and vinegar that he, unlike most of us, decides when he dies..lol

 

Personally I think it is moot because I do not believe that the democrats will hold the senate even if Obama is reelected. Furthermore, I view Obama as a pretty functionary democrat leader and don't subscribe to the alarmist rhetoric that he's destroying the country. Rather, you either agree with him or you don't. If we've survived 40 of these other assholes ( I subtract the first three), we will survive this. The union is strong and the arc of history bends towards freedom.

You are sorely mistaken my friend. Obama will absolutely appoint someone who mirrors his own beliefs. Supreme Court justices are confirmed in the Senate only, not the house. What party controls the Senate, Democrats. If Obama get re-elected he could possibly appoint 3 justices that will throw this country into a socialist spin that could drastically change what this country has been about. It will be a sad day for gun owners in this country. Bet on it!

 

It would be a sad day for more than just gun owners, and while I don't wear a tinfoil hat, I think it could a bigger change in what will be in history books in the future than many people think.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.