Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Self-Defense Tip: The Three Rules of a 911 Call

Featured Replies

This article sums it up pretty good. Don't be rude to the police, give them your basic demographic information but do not discuss the shooting without a legal advocate watching out for your rights. "My name is xxx, here's my license, I was in fear for my life, I am not comfortable discussing the incident without council present". If you feel any medical distress, be sure to get checked out. Talking to the police while you're running on pure adrenalin could land you in legal hot water.

 

----------

http://www.thetrutha...es-of-911-stfu/

 

[Click here: http://tinyurl.com/77vvlkt to listen the 911 call made from a private residence in Springville Utah where a home owner shot and killed an invader.] This series has long argued that there are two parts to armed self-defense. Defending yourself against a lethal threat and defending yourself against prosecution for defending yourself against a lethal threat. Just as the first rule of a gunfight is have a gun, the first rule for staying out of jail and/or losing everything you own due to defensive gun use is STFU (Shut The F Up). That rule starts from the moment you call the cavalry. Here’s the 411 on 911 . . .

 

1. Make the call as short as possible

911 operators are trained to keep the caller on the line as long as they can, until the first responders make the scene. You are under no legal obligation to remain in contact with the operator.

By the same token, the 911 operators are trained to extract as much information from the caller as possible. You are under no legal obligation to answer any of the operator’s questions.

f you’re in the middle of a Defensive Gun Use (DGU) talking to a 911 operator is not a particularly good use of your time (as opposed to say hiding, running or fighting). If it’s a post-game show, you don’t want anything you say to be used against you in a court of law. And yet everything you say to a 911 operator can and will be used against you in a court of law.

It’s also the way you say it. In the example above, the caller laughs nervously. Well, you and I think it’s a nervous laugh. A prosecutor might convince a jury to hear it another way. Hint: not a good way.

So communicate the basic information necessary: the situation (there’s an intruder in my house/there’s been a shooting), your address, a description of yourself and the medical condition of a wounded friendly (if applicable). After that? Nada. What else do the cops need to know? Nothing. Not a damn thing.

 

2. Either hang up or put the phone down as soon as possible

Once you’ve shared the key info, either hang up or put the phone down. The former is the best strategy if the DGU is done. The latter is the best option if the situation is in progress.

If you throw the phone down—an excellent idea from a strategic/situational awareness point of view—remember that you’re being recorded.

Use that to your advantage. If it’s safe to do so, yell a warning to the intruder. “The police are on their way. I’ve got a gun. Don’t make me me shoot you.” Over-zealous prosecutors hate that stuff. Juries love it.

Again, it’s not just what you say, but how you say it. If you start swearing, laughing (even nervously) or go for some Clint Eastwood-like line before pulling the trigger, that will NOT work out well for you.

 

3. Do not discuss the 911 call with the cops

Police/detectives arriving on scene will try to extract as much information from you as possible. The cops may try and use information from the 911 call to get you to talk before you lawyer up. Lawyer up. Tell them “My life was in danger” and “I will answer all your questions after I speak with my attorney.” And . . . that’s it. Nothing else.

Don’t be fooled by 911 operators’ good intentions (which are beyond doubt). They are not trying to get you into trouble. But by God they can.

I know it’s difficult not to tell a helpful stranger anything they want to know in a time of grave danger. But give them the basics and STFU. Don’t give law enforcement and the perp’s lawyer the ammunition they need to turn you from an armed self-defender into a victim of the legal system.

Talking to the police while you're running on pure adrenalin could land you in legal hot water.

 

2. Either hang up or put the phone down as soon as possible

Once you’ve shared the key info, either hang up or put the phone down. The former is the best strategy if the DGU is done. The latter is the best option if the situation is in progress.

If you throw the phone down—an excellent idea from a strategic/situational awareness point of view—remember that you’re being recorded.

Use that to your advantage. If it’s safe to do so, yell a warning to the intruder. “The police are on their way. I’ve got a gun. Don’t make me me shoot you.” Over-zealous prosecutors hate that stuff. Juries love it.

Again, it’s not just what you say, but how you say it. If you start swearing, laughing (even nervously) or go for some Clint Eastwood-like line before pulling the trigger, that will NOT work out well for you.

 

All great advice, but I would say that hanging up should be the default option even if things are still going on. When adrenaline is pumping sometimes you aren't in full control of what is coming out of your mouth and if you aren't a trained actor sounding cool and collected and saying the right things while being recorded may not be an option for some.

Never even thought of this. Good points.

As the guy on the other end of these calls keep keep in mind:

+ We need the address above anything else!

Now most of you will be using a cell phone in this situation and that gives us little information. Though most land lines will give us your address they can can be wrong.

 

But don't hang up if don't have to.

All the other info we need from you is not just for your safety but the officers we have coming to you.

 

  • Author

As the guy on the other end of these calls keep keep in mind:

+ We need the address above anything else!

Now most of you will be using a cell phone in this situation and that gives us little information. Though most land lines will give us your address they can can be wrong.

 

But don't hang up if don't have to.

All the other info we need from you is not just for your safety but the officers we have coming to you.

 

Clearly, the address is vital.

 

The problem comes when you ask "Is the man you shot, dead" and the guy who shot him, who's on an adrenaline rush, answers "Well, I don't think anyone can live with a giant hole in their head like that, heh". The last bit being nervous laughter....and it gets turned around by the DA as "Our shooter here was casually laughing about putting a massive hole in a man's head, and if that's not a callous disregard for human life, I don't know what is".

 

That's the point. It's not that you are trying to entrap the man, it's that your call is being recorded and will be used against the shooter if his statements or manner of speaking seem wrong or inappropriate judged through a filter that is slowed down and reviewed moment by moment in a court room.

So if asked if the man shot is dead, is the best response to say "I Don't Know"? I mean it's not like I am going to check the guy's pulse or anything.

"I don't know" is perfect or "I don't feel safe checking".

 

Either way with no castle doct. in NJ ....if you were able to flee when someone breaks in and you shoot them instead, your going to jail.

 

On the flip side if you had no choice, were unable to leave, and feared for your family's life, then your probably going to be legally in the clear.

"I don't know" is perfect or "I don't feel safe checking".

 

Either way with no castle doct. in NJ ....if you were able to flee when someone breaks in and you shoot them instead, your going to jail.

 

On the flip side if you had no choice, were unable to leave, and feared for your family's life, then your probably going to be legally in the clear.

 

Sorry but No, there is NO REQUIREMENT TO FLEE IN YOUR HOME...you DO however have to be able to articulate how the intruder was a threat to your safety. NJ Does in fact have a "Castle Doctrine", it just isnt officially referred to as such. The requirement to retreat is if you are OUTSIDE of your home..where most likely you aren't going to be armed anyway. I;ve said this before, if you own firearms, find yourself a local attorney who will accept calls 24/7 BEFORE you have an incident, and your response to the Police when they show should be something along the lines of "Officer I was in fear for my safety (or that of my family or both), i realize you have a job to do, and i dont want to make that difficult but I dont wish to make any statement or answer any questions regarding the incident until I have council present. i will answer all other questions pertaining to my personal information and that of my family"

Oh well thats a good then!

I stand corrected.

I know this sounds like a stupid questions, but this is NJ.

 

Suppose an unarmed intuder comes into your house. He is not a threat to your life, but you want hold him there so the cops can arrest him. Can you use your gun to hold the burgler in your house until the cops come? You never fire the gun, and if he runs, obviously you can't shoot him and he will get away, but what if he stays until the cops do come, will the cops arrest you anyway for pointed a loaded gun and an unarmed intruder? What if it wasn't loaded?

I know this sounds like a stupid questions, but this is NJ.

 

Suppose an unarmed intuder comes into your house. He is not a threat to your life, but you want hold him there so the cops can arrest him. Can you use your gun to hold the burgler in your house until the cops come? You never fire the gun, and if he runs, obviously you can't shoot him and he will get away, but what if he stays until the cops do come, will the cops arrest you anyway for pointed a loaded gun and an unarmed intruder? What if it wasn't loaded?

 

I've been waiting for a "what if" question. And here it is.

I've been waiting for a "what if" question. And here it is.

 

But that's a good "what if" question. Who's to say the unarmed perp doesn't have an armed buddy outside. Sounds backwards but no one ever said criminals were smart.

  • Author

I seriously doubt you would get in trouble for holding a thief at gunpoint in your own home, but there's a plethora of tools that an aggressive prosecutor can use to get you if they're inclined to do so.

It can be construed as a safety issue. If you lower your guard, you could be inviting grave injury.

 

I do know that when I spoke to one of my town's deputies after my car was broken into, he said he wouldn't have any problem with someone holding a thief at gun point if you caught them breaking into your car in your driveway but then my town has pretty reasonable police and ultimately it wouldn't be up to him. Every time that I've interacted with an officer in my town it has been a positive experience. Surprisingly, it's always been thieves. A Bear trying to steal food from my kitchen, thieves breaking into my car, My ID theft..I guess Vernon cops hate thieves as much as I do.

Okay, like what if the perp has a sharp piece of ice and I have to shoot him and then take the piece of ice from him because I don't want it to melt.

Me, I'd continue to maintain the contact with the dispatchers (without swamping them with overabundance of details, so to say). Why? In order for them to be able to relay the developing situation to the arriving squad, and not eliminate then at least reduce the possibility of said squad storming in and gunning down EVERYONE (the perp, me, my family, my dog, my pet goldfish etc).

As the guy on the other end of these calls keep keep in mind:

+ We need the address above anything else!

Now most of you will be using a cell phone in this situation and that gives us little information. Though most land lines will give us your address they can can be wrong.

 

But don't hang up if don't have to.

All the other info we need from you is not just for your safety but the officers we have coming to you.

 

While giving your address or other current location is obviously a good idea, won't any modern cell phone transmit its GPS coordinates? Or is E911 not commonly implemented yet?

 

I know this sounds like a stupid questions, but this is NJ.

 

Suppose an unarmed intuder comes into your house. He is not a threat to your life, but you want hold him there so the cops can arrest him. Can you use your gun to hold the burgler in your house until the cops come? You never fire the gun, and if he runs, obviously you can't shoot him and he will get away, but what if he stays until the cops do come, will the cops arrest you anyway for pointed a loaded gun and an unarmed intruder? What if it wasn't loaded?

 

Who says someone who is unarmed isn't a threat to your life? Plenty of people have been killed with fists and feet. However whether or not they are a threat to your life is irrelevant.

 

2C:3-4 Use of force in self-protection

 

c. (1) Notwithstanding the provisions of N.J.S.2C:3-5, N.J.S.2C:3-9, or this section, the use of force or deadly force upon or toward an intruder who is unlawfully in a dwelling is justifiable when the actor reasonably believes that the force is immediately necessary for the purpose of protecting himself or other persons in the dwelling against the use of unlawful force by the intruder on the present occasion.

 

tab.gif(2)tab.gifA reasonable belief exists when the actor, to protect himself or a third person, was in his own dwelling at the time of the offense or was privileged to be thereon and the encounter between the actor and intruder was sudden and unexpected, compelling the actor to act instantly and:

 

tab.gif(a)tab.gifThe actor reasonably believed that the intruder would inflict personal injury upon the actor or others in the dwelling; or

 

tab.gif(b)tab.gifThe actor demanded that the intruder disarm, surrender or withdraw, and the intruder refused to do so.

 

 

All that is legally required is the reasonable belief that he would inflict personal injury (or you ordering him to disarm/surrender/withdraw and he refuses), for you to be justified in using whatever level of force you believe necessary to protect yourself or others. IANAL.

I know this sounds like a stupid questions, but this is NJ.

 

Suppose an unarmed intuder comes into your house. He is not a threat to your life, but you want hold him there so the cops can arrest him. Can you use your gun to hold the burgler in your house until the cops come? You never fire the gun, and if he runs, obviously you can't shoot him and he will get away, but what if he stays until the cops do come, will the cops arrest you anyway for pointed a loaded gun and an unarmed intruder? What if it wasn't loaded?

 

Everything depends on the totality of the circumstances and each case is different. Your goal as a private citizen is to terminate an action that cannot be allowed to continue, and the choice to make a citizen's arrest is yours alone. In terms of safety, you are always better off letting the bad guy get away (removing the threat), as time is NOT in your favor while you are in close proximity to him/her while awaiting an LE response.

 

Also, many bad guys and gals are NOT afraid of guns and know enough about the use of DPF that they are as likely to laugh at you as be afraid of the weapon. Or they may try (and likely succeed) in taking it away from you before you can do anything. Remember, unless you are LE this is likely a new situation to you, whereas the bad guy or gal lives it all the time and may already have plans for such a situation.

 

Another thing to consider is whether you really want to have a weapon in your hand when LE responds because until things are straightened out, you are considered a threat, unless you are personally known to the responding officers (and this appies to civilians as well as off duty or plainclothes LE).

 

I have attached relevant pages from the NJ guide for the use of force.

Extract Pages From deadforc.pdf

While giving your address or other current location is obviously a good idea, won't any modern cell phone transmit its GPS coordinates? Or is E911 not commonly implemented yet?

 

[/size][/font]

 

When you call 911 from a cell phone, you may actually first get a 911 operator that's in another state. First you have to verify what city/state your in then they transfer you. ONce you are transferred to your local PD all the dispatcher sees is a 911 transfer from whatever cell carrier it is. They can't just know your coordinates by the phones GPS. My fiancee worked as a dispatcher for a small police department that covered a lot of territory. Many times she talked of 911 hang ups or getting someone transferred to her that was actually located a few towns over out of her jurisdiction.

 

Personally, I have my local PD's "regular" phone number on speed dial. When you call it, you get the same dispatch desk that 911 sends you to without the BS of waiting for transfers. I'm pretty sure all PD's "regular" number still get's recorded being you hear the "beep" in the background as you talk to the dispatcher.

Does anyone know of an associated news story with this call? What was the legal outcome of this confrontation? Any more details at all?

  • Author

Does anyone know of an associated news story with this call? What was the legal outcome of this confrontation? Any more details at all?

 

If you're referring to the video I linked above, the call was from February 29, so there's unlikely to be any information for a while.

 

http://www.heraldextra.com/news/local/crime-and-courts/call-reveals-terror-of-home-invasion-shooting/article_e89eb749-924d-56a2-ad30-b3be53a39a7a.html?oCampaign=hottopics

http://www.abc4.com/content/news/top_stories/story/Springville-home-invasion-911-tapes-released/gqmSFtpSwkCy_Nj4OMjtyw.cspx

 

And I blame you for the death of Penny. If it weren't for that damn death ray, she'd still be alive.

If it weren't for that damn death ray, she'd still be alive.

 

Freeze ray. Tell your friends.

sad that we even need this type of advice really. Imagine someone breaking into your house that has a violent criminal record, is intent on possibly harming you or your family, is armed and you have to worry about the 911 and police on the scene as well. I tell you, it's certifiable!

While giving your address or other current location is obviously a good idea, won't any modern cell phone transmit its GPS coordinates? Or is E911 not commonly implemented yet?

 

It's a crap shoot. I'd say the chance of getting a WPH2 call(where you get any coordinates) is about 60%, and those coordinates narrow the location down to about the size of a small city block.

 

When you call 911 from a cell phone, you may actually first get a 911 operator that's in another state. This is rare, and will only happen if you're close to a state border. First you have to verify what city/state your in then they transfer you. Again, this isn't always the case. Cell companies are getting better with routing cell phone calls to the appropriate agency automatically. ONce you are transferred to your local PD all the dispatcher sees is a 911 transfer from whatever cell carrier it is. There is nothing saying that the call has been transferred on the ANI/ALI screen. The only way to know if the call came to that dispatcher direct, or not, is if the call-taker who transferred the call stays on the line and informs the next call-taker of the transfer. They can't just know your coordinates by the phones GPS. When WPH2 works correctly, the coordinates do show up, and are fairly accurate. Location needs to be confirmed due to the coordinates being only as accurate as a small city block. My fiancee worked as a dispatcher for a small police department that covered a lot of territory. Many times she talked of 911 hang ups or getting someone transferred to her that was actually located a few towns over out of her jurisdiction.

 

Personally, I have my local PD's "regular" phone number on speed dial. When you call it, you get the same dispatch desk that 911 sends you to without the BS of waiting for transfers. Sometimes the "regular" number has an auto-attendant that answers, and you need to press 1 or 0 to speak to a human. This could be just as long as being transferred, and more importantly, nobody knows you were having an emergency until you actually say something. See my advice below. I'm pretty sure all PD's "regular" number still get's recorded being you hear the "beep" in the background as you talk to the dispatcher. Not all, but most are.

 

My best advice regarding cell phone routing from home is to use a landline in the event of an emergency. Obviously, that's not always a possibility, so the second best thing is to do a 9-1-1cell phone test call from home. Contact your local PD on the "regular" number, and ask to do a 9-1-1 test call. If they're okay with it(not busy at the time) you hang up and dial 9-1-1 from your cell while standing inside your home. When the dispatcher picks up, announce that you're making a 9-1-1 test call, and ask to confirm which PD your call was routed to. If it goes to your PD, then you can be fairly certain that when you call 9-1-1 from your cell while at home, it will go to your PD. If it does not, and you get transferred, you can try contacting your cell provider and seeing if they can adjust the routing info for your location.

 

 

Freeze ray. Tell your friends.

the status is NOT quo

 

 

It's a crap shoot. I'd say the chance of getting a WPH2 call(where you get any coordinates) is about 60%, and those coordinates narrow the location down to about the size of a small city block.

 

 

 

My best advice regarding cell phone routing from home is to use a landline in the event of an emergency. Obviously, that's not always a possibility, so the second best thing is to do a 9-1-1cell phone test call from home. Contact your local PD on the "regular" number, and ask to do a 9-1-1 test call. If they're okay with it(not busy at the time) you hang up and dial 9-1-1 from your cell while standing inside your home. When the dispatcher picks up, announce that you're making a 9-1-1 test call, and ask to confirm which PD your call was routed to. If it goes to your PD, then you can be fairly certain that when you call 9-1-1 from your cell while at home, it will go to your PD. If it does not, and you get transferred, you can try contacting your cell provider and seeing if they can adjust the routing info for your location.

 

Cool. I'll be doing that this weekend.

 

I haven't ever seen ANI/ALI written until today. I guess that why I could not find info on it. I guess it's an acronym. What's it stand for?

I know this sounds like a stupid questions, but this is NJ.

 

Suppose an unarmed intuder comes into your house. He is not a threat to your life, but you want hold him there so the cops can arrest him. Can you use your gun to hold the burgler in your house until the cops come? You never fire the gun, and if he runs, obviously you can't shoot him and he will get away, but what if he stays until the cops do come, will the cops arrest you anyway for pointed a loaded gun and an unarmed intruder? What if it wasn't loaded?

 

I appologize that I cannot site the source, as I believe I read it on the interwebs, but I think that this might be considered tantamount to kidnapping. I could be wrong, though. What say the LEO's?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.