Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Dharun Ravi convicted in Rutgers gay roommate spying case.

Featured Replies

I tried to search forums see if this case was talked about at all and could not find anything so I apologize if there was already a thread on this topic. For those unaware

 

Dharun Ravi is accused of streaming live footage of his freshman roommate's kissing session with an older man inside their dorm room -- and then publicizing the tryst through texts and

Twitter posts.

The incident sparked a national debate over privacy rights and the bullying of gay youths when the roommate -- 18-year-old Tyler Clementi -- committed suicide by jumping off the George Washington Bridge soon after learning of Ravi's streaming in Sept. 2010.

 

 

I was reading the news a little bit ago and saw that dharun ravi who was 18 years old at the time but is now 20 was convicted of a hate crime,invasion of privacy and numerous other charges, 15 charges in total. He now faces up to 10 years in prison depending on how the judge sentences him.

 

From what I have seen and read, his roommate was locking their dorm room for long periods of time and would not give reason as to why he was locking ravi out, so he set up a webcam. He did it because he was worried about his possessions at first but after viewing the camera footage he found out his roommate was gay and was locking door to hide his sexual preference. At some point he set up a broadcast to show his friends what was going on and some time after he told clementi he knew what he was doing. Clementi committed suicide shortly after and his parents claimed they didnt know about his sexual preference.

 

Now my stance with Ravi is, he was wrong for recording his roommate thats a given, secondly he should not have shown anyone. However in the eyes of law this all sits under invasion of privacy, which usually doesn't hold jail time, some other forms of punishment are usually issued. I think its harsh that ravi's life will be pretty much ended for invading the privacy of a gay individual, I do not really see what this guy did that labeled his case as a hate crime.

If he had done it to a straight person and they killed themselves for whatever reason I dont think he would be punished so harshly. My stance is yes he deserves to be punished for what he did do, but if he gets the full 10 years this case was twisted out of control,it all rests on the judges shoulders now.

 

If I am missing something or someone has another view on this please comment I am trying to understand how this case ending the way it did.

What pretty much did him in was spying on him not once, but twice. And then broadcasting it. Your webcam doesn't automatically set itself up to broadcast over the internet. If he was really worried about his possessions, he could have just recorded it to his hard drive and kept it private, then taken the tape to the police when his possessions "grew legs and walked away." Instead, he posted this on twitter:

 

http://www.thesmokin...un-ravi-twitter

 

You can also see the other tweet 5th from the top.

 

And considering how much of a hot button topic invasion of privacy is, I can't say I'm surprised they made an example of him. I didn't see the evidence as the jurors did, so I don't know why they labeled it a hate crime, but I guess maybe it was a hate crime because he was catching him "making out with a dude" and it's interpreted with a negative connotation ("Yes, it's happening again.")

 

The other thing was that the defense thought they could get away with the "kids will be kids" defense for a then 18 year old student and didn't accept the plea deal that would have guaranteed zero jail time. Defense didn't do a good job. Prosecution did. That's how it works.

 

For the record, Ravi wasn't charged with anything related to the death of Tyler Clementi, only the invasion of privacy related charges.

 

I tried to search forums see if this case was talked about at all and could not find anything so I apologize if there was already a thread on this topic. For those unaware

 

Dharun Ravi is accused of streaming live footage of his freshman roommate's kissing session with an older man inside their dorm room -- and then publicizing the tryst through texts and

Twitter posts.

 

The incident sparked a national debate over privacy rights and the bullying of gay youths when the roommate -- 18-year-old Tyler Clementi -- committed suicide by jumping off the George Washington Bridge soon after learning of Ravi's streaming in Sept. 2010.

 

 

 

I was reading the news a little bit ago and saw that dharun ravi who was 18 years old at the time but is now 20 was convicted of a hate crime,invasion of privacy and numerous other charges, 15 charges in total. He now faces up to 10 years in prison depending on how the judge sentences him.

 

From what I have seen and read, his roommate was locking their dorm room for long periods of time and would not give reason as to why he was locking ravi out, so he set up a webcam. He did it because he was worried about his possessions at first but after viewing the camera footage he found out his roommate was gay and was locking door to hide his sexual preference. At some point he set up a broadcast to show his friends what was going on and some time after he told clementi he knew what he was doing. Clementi committed suicide shortly after and his parents claimed they didnt know about his sexual preference.

 

Now my stance with Ravi is, he was wrong for recording his roommate thats a given, secondly he should not have shown anyone. However in the eyes of law this all sits under invasion of privacy, which usually doesn't hold jail time, some other forms of punishment are usually issued. I think its harsh that ravi's life will be pretty much ended for invading the privacy of a gay individual, I do not really see what this guy did that labeled his case as a hate crime.

If he had done it to a straight person and they killed themselves for whatever reason I dont think he would be punished so harshly. My stance is yes he deserves to be punished for what he did do, but if he gets the full 10 years this case was twisted out of control,it all rests on the judges shoulders now.

 

If I am missing something or someone has another view on this please comment I am trying to understand how this case ending the way it did.

 

If he was concerned about his belongings then I could buy it but once he broadcasted the stream...he screwed himself.

  • Author

Yeah I dont think it was just him protecting his belongings and I dont think the defense should have went with the kids will be kids. What he did was very wrong and maybe should do a year maybe 2 in jail but it wasn't a hate crime in my eyes is what I am saying, Potentially serving 10 years for something like this is pretty heavy.

Yeah I dont think it was just him protecting his belongings and I dont think the defense should have went with the kids will be kids. What he did was very wrong and maybe should do a year maybe 2 in jail but it wasn't a hate crime in my eyes is what I am saying, Potentially serving 10 years for something like this is pretty heavy.

 

I can't remember why but the max for the charges was 5 years but it was doubled for some reason, I'll try to find out why.

 

Also he hasn't been sentenced yet, just found guilty. Sentencing is in May, and that's a MAX of 10 years. I don't think he'll get close to that, unless the judge decides to be a real hard@$$.

 

Edit: Found it here: http://americanpowerblog.blogspot.com/2012/03/dharun-ravi-found-guilty-of-hate-crimes.html

 

It doubled the max from 5 to 10 years due to his actions being "born of a gay bias."

 

Also, a lot of pages I saw in my search mentioned he'll likely get around 5 years and then deportation back to India. Wow, stricter than I would have thought.

I believe the reason that the penalties are compounded is that he was convicted of not only invading the privacy of Tyler Clementi, but also the man he was with during the invasion.

 

I can't remember why but the max for the charges was 5 years but it was doubled for some reason, I'll try to find out why.

 

Also he hasn't been sentenced yet, just found guilty. Sentencing is in May, and that's a MAX of 10 years. I don't think he'll get close to that, unless the judge decides to be a real hard@$$.

I can't remember why but the max for the charges was 5 years but it was doubled for some reason, I'll try to find out why.

 

Also he hasn't been sentenced yet, just found guilty. Sentencing is in May, and that's a MAX of 10 years. I don't think he'll get close to that, unless the judge decides to be a real hard@$$.

 

Edit: Found it here: http://americanpower...ate-crimes.html

 

It doubled the max from 5 to 10 years due to his actions being "born of a gay bias."

 

Also, a lot of pages I saw in my search mentioned he'll likely get around 5 years and then deportation back to India. Wow, stricter than I would have thought.

 

The Bias Crime always ramps up the penalties..In the end, the Judge will more than likely give the shortest sentence he's allowed under the guidelines, followed by Deportation.

I don't believe in "hate crimes" because if I get my a** kicked because someone doesn't like me it's no less of a crime than someone getting their a** kicked because they are gay. IMHO.

 

I didn't follow the cause too closely but what I did hear certainly made it sound like he was acting maliciously because he didn't like gay people. Regardless of why he was acting malicious his intent was to invade Clementi's privacy, broadcast it, embarrass him. He succeeded and now he can reap the rewards... too bad he isn't a fan of gay sex, seeing as how he will probably be having a lot of it in the near future! lol

In my opinion, Hate Crime=Thought Police.

There was a stipulated penalty for what Ravi did. Judges have the ability to select the harsher end of the suggested punishment range if they feel a person's actions warrant it.

In my opinion, Hate Crime=Thought Police.

There was a stipulated penalty for what Ravi did. Judges have the ability to select the harsher end of the suggested punishment range if they feel a person's actions warrant it.

 

i recall when they had that poor guy dragged to Death down in Tx, everyone criticized then Gov Bush that they scumbag Klukkers weren't charged with hate Crimes....the FACT that they had been charged and Convicted of Murder, and Sentenced to Death apparently wasnt ENOUGH...

In my opinion, Hate Crime=Thought Police.

 

 

I agree and a crime is a crime, problem is when person X it out to hurt or kill People Y just because they are People Y and nothing else fits the meaning. Problem is, it gets applied outside the original scope, precedent set and further expanded and them rendered useless down the road.

I agree and a crime is a crime, problem is when person X it out to hurt or kill People Y just because they are People Y and nothing else fits the meaning. Problem is, it gets applied outside the original scope, precedent set and further expanded and them rendered useless down the road.

 

That is why you don't limit a judge's discretion in sentencing. Hatred can be an aggravating factor.

That is why you don't limit a judge's discretion in sentencing. Hatred can be an aggravating factor.

 

Very true, and wow, if it is true, boy is Big Bubba going to like breaking in the new meat..

Up to a 10 year sentence isnt enough? They had to hit him with deportation, too? I agree that he should be punished for his role in what happened, but this punishment is way too much

Ravi should have taken the Plea Deal.

 

The entire incident is sickening & sad. And the Girl walks away after NOT trying to stop it!

At the risk of minimizing the tragic death of a terribly conflicted young man and all the pandering rhetoric that hovers over this particular issue.I see it as another young man's life basically ruined over a stupid college prank,a grieving parents need to blame anyone but themselves for their lapse of understanding and support and the public's frenzied attempts to vilify someone,anyone in a vain and self serving attempt to out PC each other.

Lost in all this (except someone mentioned it above), is that Ravi and the defense apparently turned down a plea deal that would have cost him (I believe) about 600 hours of community service, which amounts to about 1 summer. What were they thinking turning it down?

 

As a Rutgers student, I can tell you that the entire community here was outraged upon finding out what Ravi did - and I'm not just talking about the LGBT community. I'm talking about everyone. Had he not been convicted, or been facing a harsh sentence, this place would have erupted. The fact that he tweeted about it and encouraged everyone to come back and watch the encounter just sets it over the top. So you can believe all you want about him worrying about his belongings, but I'm pretty sure that making your roommate's affairs public doesn't protect your stuff in any way. Legally, is it worth 10 years? Probably not. But it's pretty disgusting.

 

For the record, though, I don't hold Ravi responsible in any way for the death of Tyler Clementi. But what he did was pretty vile. He'll probably get a portion of the 10-year maximum, followed by deportation. Harsh, but he probably should have thought about what he was doing first. You reap what you sew.

Lost in all this (except someone mentioned it above), is that Ravi and the defense apparently turned down a plea deal that would have cost him (I believe) about 600 hours of community service, which amounts to about 1 summer. What were they thinking turning it down?

 

As a Rutgers student, I can tell you that the entire community here was outraged upon finding out what Ravi did - and I'm not just talking about the LGBT community. I'm talking about everyone. Had he not been convicted, or been facing a harsh sentence, this place would have erupted. The fact that he tweeted about it and encouraged everyone to come back and watch the encounter just sets it over the top. So you can believe all you want about him worrying about his belongings, but I'm pretty sure that making your roommate's affairs public doesn't protect your stuff in any way. Legally, is it worth 10 years? Probably not. But it's pretty disgusting.

 

For the record, though, I don't hold Ravi responsible in any way for the death of Tyler Clementi. But what he did was pretty vile. He'll probably get a portion of the 10-year maximum, followed by deportation. Harsh, but he probably should have thought about what he was doing first. You reap what you sew.

With all due respect, I rather doubt that "this place would have erupted",perhaps some bored and overly contentious individuals would have protested as they do for what ever cause celebre that's on FB this week,whether it be Kony ,Sudanese slaves or the lack of gluten free pizza in the cafeteria.

I have no doubt however, that Ravi wanted to play a prank at his roommates expense but to be sentenced to a possible 10 years in prison as well as deportation because a confused young man with little or no support system decided it easier to jump instead of confront reality is excessive and a obscene miscarriage of justice.

We see some applaud the verdict but IMO they see it as a way to sooth some perceived guilt and moral outrage and pay lip service to an increasingly confused and sheepish societal norm.

 

By the way, you sew clothing but sow grain.

Being a fellow Rutgers student, I agree wholeheartedly with what Luke_WO said. The reaction when the incident first occurred during the Fall 2010 semester was relatively large. Maybe not in the public-sphere (in terms of national news like CNN, FNC, etc.), but the reaction was fairly widespread across campus-- and notably with more social-based news (MTV had coverage, my class was actually one of those that was interviewed, as was my Prof [who led the movement]). The buzz has been fairly low key on campus regarding the trial itself; and I think that's mostly because the trial itself was ongoing, and there were certain legal boundaries that couldn't be crossed in terms of those who testified coming out and publicly speaking about it. I know this firsthand as I know one of those who did testify personally. I think once the sentencing wraps, and the case itself is in the past, there will be a secondary, widespread reaction across campus-- and possibly that spreads further.

 

Personally I don't know what to think. Ravi is from my hometown, and being a relatively small town of 20K (albeit Plainsboro and West Windsor are pretty much joint communities), the whole thing has been tough on the community. He hasn't brought shame per se, as his actions are not indicative of the young people that are produced through the system here... but it doesn't lessen the impact of the lack of social awareness that apparently either did not exist within him, or was so blatantly forgotten by Ravi-- which is arguably fault of the community.

 

As for hate crimes, I have to respectfully disagree, Chris/lunker. You're a good guy and I like and respect you, and I normally agree with you so I'm not calling you out at all, I promise! But I think hate crimes need to be labeled and addressed because prejudice and race are still polarizing aspects in American culture. Whether or not I agree with that principle (I don't), it exists. And while the topic of 'race' is often times approached in PC ways that actually end up being wholly stupid (Affirmative Action for example), there has been some good that has come out of it (Equal Opportunity, though that is twisted in the wrong way sometimes). As a minority, I can say firsthand that the American system (socially, culturally, legally) still does look down on minorities, and they do need some level of protection. Should it be a crutch? No. Should it make the sentencing more harsh? No. But should it be addressed? Definitely a yes.

As for hate crimes, I have to respectfully disagree, Chris/lunker. You're a good guy and I like and respect you, and I normally agree with you so I'm not calling you out at all, I promise! But I think hate crimes need to be labeled and addressed because prejudice and race are still polarizing aspects in American culture. Whether or not I agree with that principle (I don't), it exists. And while the topic of 'race' is often times approached in PC ways that actually end up being wholly stupid (Affirmative Action for example), there has been some good that has come out of it (Equal Opportunity, though that is twisted in the wrong way sometimes). As a minority, I can say firsthand that the American system (socially, culturally, legally) still does look down on minorities, and they do need some level of protection. Should it be a crutch? No. Should it make the sentencing more harsh? No. But should it be addressed? Definitely a yes.

 

So, you think litigation is the way to changing the way folks think? You must be pre-law. Passing a law won't change anything. Thinking otherwise is naieve and quite idealistic. If it worked, speeding wouldn't be an issue and there would be no DYFS. Unfortunately, those things along with a myriad of others are still in existence regardless of the laws passed and (sometimes) enforced.

 

This guy, Ravi, screwed up. Bad. Personally I abhor people that do sh*t like this. Yup, check on your stuff. However, when you find out what's really going on, there is no reason to broadcast it. I think he should be made to do 2000 hours of community service in an AIDS clinic and then deported. Maybe then he would get a glimmer of empathy and realize what he has done. Plus, we wouldn't have to feed him while he "serves" his time. Might be cheaper.

 

C

As for hate crimes, I have to respectfully disagree, Chris/lunker. You're a good guy and I like and respect you, and I normally agree with you so I'm not calling you out at all, I promise! But I think hate crimes need to be labeled and addressed because prejudice and race are still polarizing aspects in American culture. Whether or not I agree with that principle (I don't), it exists. And while the topic of 'race' is often times approached in PC ways that actually end up being wholly stupid (Affirmative Action for example), there has been some good that has come out of it (Equal Opportunity, though that is twisted in the wrong way sometimes). As a minority, I can say firsthand that the American system (socially, culturally, legally) still does look down on minorities, and they do need some level of protection. Should it be a crutch? No. Should it make the sentencing more harsh? No. But should it be addressed? Definitely a yes.

 

No worries Ben. There is plenty of room for different opinions here. One of my biggest problems with hate crime laws is that there is so much room for differential application of the law. the prosecutor might feel pressure from the community to apply a hate crime tag to a crime where it's not applicable. And you have a possibility that the exact same crime may or may not be a hate crime because of the color/gender/orientation/hair color/ethnicity/etc of the victim versus that of the assailant. The opportunity for ridiculous scenarios abounds. How about if an angry liberal suffering from white guilt targets and kills a bunch of white people because he is so mad about our historically bad treatment of African Americans. Would that qualify?

Basically my point is that hate crime laws place too much discretion in the hands of people who can't be trusted, elected officials, judges, etc, whose judgements can be based on politics instead of law and justice. It makes me think of all the institutional obstacles we face in NJ for ccw. Abuse is system wide.

Up to a 10 year sentence isnt enough? They had to hit him with deportation, too? I agree that he should be punished for his role in what happened, but this punishment is way too much

 

I don't understand what you mean here... He violated the law, his action lead to the death of another citizen of this country. I think he got off easy with deportation. It was a hate crime because he knew what he was doing when he decided to publish that stream.

Up to a 10 year sentence isnt enough? They had to hit him with deportation, too? I agree that he should be punished for his role in what happened, but this punishment is way too much

He's a resident Alien, he committed a Felony..he goes

I don't understand what you mean here... He violated the law, his action lead to the death of another citizen of this country. I think he got off easy with deportation. It was a hate crime because he knew what he was doing when he decided to publish that stream.

 

That is a Stretch.....the reaction of Clementi's MOTHER had much more to do Directly with his death than Ravi's actions...if the prosecution hadnt ensured that the Suicide note would be supressed, then that would have been MUCH more clear.

How can you be against hate crime law? They aren't punishing people for their thoughts, just actions. You don't have to like gay people, but if your going to beat one up just because you dont like them i see no reason not to justify harsher penalties.... Hate crime is across the board for those of you who don't know, any group can fall under a hate crime. I don't really see anything negative about it.

 

I understand that the media manipulates a lot of crap into hate crimes, i see that downfall.

 

and lunker, they abuse the system, period. If they think they will get a conviction they will charge anyone with anything. After all a prosecutor would actually have to show the defendant's bias towards which ever group.

 

Honestly, i don't even know why we put the burden on us to send him to prison, just deport him and be done with it.

Jack, i don't see why there is a need. we have laws against invasion of privacy against murder, and many other crimes. they all carry penalties. Do we really need an extra oomph just because the person committing the crime is a bigot. That is why there are ranges in sentencing. The judge can go max or lenient depending on circumstances.

How can you be against hate crime law? They aren't punishing people for their thoughts, just actions. You don't have to like gay people, but if your going to beat one up just because you dont like them i see no reason not to justify harsher penalties.... Hate crime is across the board for those of you who don't know, any group can fall under a hate crime. I don't really see anything negative about it.

 

I understand that the media manipulates a lot of crap into hate crimes, i see that downfall.

 

and lunker, they abuse the system, period. If they think they will get a conviction they will charge anyone with anything.

A standard knee jerk,overly emotional reaction to a hot topic and not fully thought out law.I understand the dire need of the young and unworldly to be current and pertinent in these confusing and conflicted times but stay still and actually think for a moment...consider the ramifications of pursuing these broad laws. Who decides what constitutes hate and to what degree? You? our trusted legislators? in jersey? Aren't we living with their flawed laws right now?

Think sir.... for a moment....and consider the future of us allowing them to legislate us essentially out of existence so that you and your counterparts can slap each other on the backs,claim victory for the unfortunate and rest well and safe in the dream that all is now right with the world.

Sorry for the late response, Chris, was at work.

 

But I do agree with what you're saying, that hate crimes are perceived to add unnecessary weight to a decision... often resulting in a public-favor skew to the sentencing, and tipping the scales of "balanced" justice (whatever that means in America). However, there are many, many cases in which hate crimes were committed as the basis, with homicide or aggravated assault being the tool. In these cases where someone is targeted specifically for their beliefs (and I leave this wording ambiguous because I do believe non-Latino whites can be victims of hate crimes by minorities [aka "reverse-discrimination"]), if these are not addressed as such-- arguably the cycle continues.

 

I definitely see what you mean though, and it makes logical sense... "common sense," but when has common sense ever been so common here in America? The way the justice system operates, and has always operated, has always pushed back against minorities... the whole damn system has always pushed back against minorities. If crimes were committed that were blatant hate crimes, but were simply categorized as just "homicide," then while it may be PC (in a way), it would be covert vs. overt discrimination... but regardless that discrimination would continue to exist (whether or not it is acknowledged). By acknowledging it as the precedent, the issue comes to the forefront... and, as I noted before, there is a large danger in that. However, ignorance never resulted in any good... a problem that this country, specifically, continues to grapple with today regarding racial and sexual discrimination.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.