Was thinking of buying one. Any opinions on this? I'm not set on a sig sauer but I do want a 1911. Is the sig a good choice?

It depends on how traditionalist you are and what your price range is. If you like traditional design, you may want to consider Colt. For less money you can get the Springfield Armory GI and MilSpec models. For less than that you can get Rock Island Armory. All remain pretty faithful to original design. If you don't mind more modern style, then you have more options. The Sig is one. STI is an excellent gun, and they are competition ready if that is a possibility for you. The Smith & Wesson 1911's (particularly from their custom shop) seem to have an unparalleled reputation from the owners on this board. Some folks swear by their Kimbers, although I am not a fan. The bottom line is, unless you have some special attachment or allegiance to Sig, there is a lot of research to be done when choosing your 1911. A lot of folks around here own different models and would be happy to let you try them out. I have a Colt Series 70 repro and you are welcome to shoot it some time at Central Jersey Rifle or Shore Shot.

It depends on how traditionalist you are and what your price range is. If you like traditional design, you may want to consider Colt.

 

Chris - Don't forget that Sig now has a "Traditional" line of 1911's also. These have the traditional "round-top" slide, rather than the Sig profile slide. Sigs give you a lot of bang for your buck, when it comes to 1911's, but as Chris (lunker) pointed out, there are a lot of 1911's out there - ask ten people and you'll get ten different recommendations. Doing the research to find what you like is half the fun. Good luck.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

Check out the new Sig 1911 carry nightmare. Awesome.

Personally I like the SS version.

If you are a 1911 groupie, then go for it.

If you are a Sig groupie, then get the P220 instead. The dissembly is much easier for cleaning.

Chris - Don't forget that Sig now has a "Traditional" line of 1911's also. These have the traditional "round-top" slide, rather than the Sig profile slide.

 

Thanks Bob, I don't keep as up-to-date on brands I don't buy (I am not a Sig hater, just a lefty that can't deal with their control locations on the traditional Sig models).

I've read somewhere brands to avoid are Rock Island Armory, Armscor, Para, Charles Daly, and other non-American/Euro brands (Sub $800). Are they just snobs?

I just ordered a Sig 1911 Tac Ops Traditional and have it on layaway since I also just bought a Walther PPQ. Will take delivery after the 30 days is up and will post a short review after I receive it and shoot it. I haven't fired one, but have done a ton of research and it seems like one of the best options for an under $1k 1911. I have a S&W 1911 that was roughly the same price as the Sig, but it did have some reliability problems that were fixed after a trip back to S&W so decided to give Sig a try.

I've read somewhere brands to avoid are Rock Island Armory, Armscor, Para, Charles Daly, and other non-American/Euro brands (Sub $800). Are they just snobs?

 

Rock Island Armory guns are assembled by Armscor in the Philippines. I have not heard anything negative about them. Actually, quite the opposite. If I needed a cheap and good functioning 1911 and didn't have the money for an STI Spartan, I would get a RIA.

I'll stand by springfield. Dead accurate, great looks, great feel. And to get honest the recoil isn't that bad at all. Maybe I'm just used to it idk.

 

The sigs are nice, but not what I call a true 1911. Colt/Springfield are the two big 1911 originals in my eyes.

I've read somewhere brands to avoid are Rock Island Armory, Armscor, Charles Daly, and other non-American/Euro brands (Sub $800). Are they just snobs?

 

The first three are all made by the same company, that being Armscor in the Plilippines.

 

I'm sure that it is partially snobbery. I've read very little bad about the Armscor guns and STI uses them to build their Spartan offering. I don't have any first hand knowledge because I am a gun snob. I prefer my frames and slides forged, although admittedly I haven't seen reports of mass frame or slide failures on non-forged guns.

 

Buy what you like and can afford. Do your research.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

I'll stand by springfield. Dead accurate, great looks, great feel. And to get honest the recoil isn't that bad at all. Maybe I'm just used to it idk.

 

The sigs are nice, but not what I call a true 1911. Colt/Springfield are the two big 1911 originals in my eyes.

 

What Bob mentioned above. The Sigs now have their traditional line. The old Sig 1911s definitely had their own look. The new ones look like a regular 1911. Check their website (like I just did )

No I know, I'm saying as far as original 1911 production. I feel as though theirs is just another replica, just a good replica from a reputable brand.

Dont worry too much about where they are made. Someone correct me if I am wrong but I think some SA 1911 frames are made in Brasil. Some say they are the best shooters.

Mine...

 

Kimber Custom II

Next one...

 

I have a Sig Traditional match elite two-tone. I love it, it is my first 1911 so I don't have much to compare it two. I have a few other guns but now that I have the 1911 I am hooked on the design everything just lines up great for my hands. I am now looking for a 1911 in 9mm or if I can get one at a good price another in 45. I don't think I will be buying anything other than 1911 style guns for awhile!! So be prepared to open up a huge can of worms if you get one as I see many more in the future!! Good luck in your choice I don't think you can go wrong with anyone you choose!!

Not all Springfields use the Brazilian frame. And, sictransitjosh, you are confusing the Springfield Armory of today with the original. The two companies are totally unrelated - current one had nothing to do with military 1911's or any of the series of Springfield rifles, they are just trading on the name - so they are nothing more than "replicas" also.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

Oh wow, didn't know that, thanks

To the OP.....

 

I have a SIG TacOPS I have about 250 rds through. I personally love this gun because it came with a bevy of anhancements that I require as a lefty. ambi safety lever, rail, beveled magwell, combat night sites. I did have to eat the 80's series fps, but that is a small trade off. The firearm comes with 4 mags, a nice case and has no bling on it. it is flat, business black.

 

It shoots great. No issues so far except my own stupididty. Dont use mags without mag pads with this gun, they will not insert all the way and drop out on you when you go to chamber a round. Sort of embarrassing.....

 

I shopped for about 3 months before ordering. I passed SA offerings because I have had two before and while nice, I just wanted something more and I felt the SIG gave more value and options then the SA Loaded for about the same money. I also shopped higher end Kimbers and SA TRP as examples... I once again felt the SIG gave better value for the money. One thing that really tuned me to the SIG was shooting a coworkers E3 one night ...it was accurate and the recoil was negligible.Trigger weights about 4 pds and is not gritty or sticky.

 

try one.

It just amazes me at how knowledgeable you people are on this forum! I love this place!

If you want American made and sub 800, check out the Remington R1.

I have a sig 1911 TTT and love it. Been reliable for me for the 500 or so rounds through it. I love the looks and feel of the gun.

 

 

OK, updated the link, and on a real computer with a real keyboard now. Feel of the Sig 1911 is great, I personally prefer the style of the Sig over a more traditional 1911... Mine came with stock night sights. I do not regret getting my Sig TTT whatsoever...

Edited March 28, 201214 yr by supertelephoto

Thanks for the replies. I bought the sig 1911 scorpion.

Thanks for the replies. I bought the sig 1911 scorpion.

 

Let us know how it shoots. I really like that gun. Good for you.

 

C

good choice... same as tacops except for finish, grip panels, trigger style (curved vs flat) and you get more mags with tacops!

I actually put 50 rounds through it yesterday. Very little recoil. I did jam up twice in a row. Not sure what that was about, was thinking it might be the magazine.

I put 100rds through my tacops last night at an outdoor range in the Kanawha State Forest, Charleston WV. LOVE IT... no issues further.

 

I have heard that the ACT or cCheckmate Mags that come with the gun are not always great. I have no issues with my four, but I did pick up 4 more Chip McCormicks.

 

Funn that possible Checkmate mags would have issues... the ones In had for my M1A were the most robust mags I have EVER held. They were built like tanks and never stumbled.

The remington r1 is a pretty nice gun. Played with it at shot show and it went above my expectations.

 

Sent from my HTC EVO using Tapatalk.

IMO some problems with 1911's is the magazines. I have 2 Chip McCormick Shooting Star mags and they run flawlessly. My KImber Mag is ok too. I also have about 15 cheap CDNN mags that for the most part are pretty good. What can I expcect for $6 a mag. I plan on some Wilson Combat mags in the future.