April 23, 201214 yr I want to move to Arizona so bad!!! The state of Arizona is doing little to play down their controversial reputation on immigration laws. This week, the state got one step closer to passing a bill which would create and fund a volunteer armed militia to patrol the border for undocumented immigrants. On Tuesday, the state's Senate Appropriations Committee passed a version of SB 1083, a law which would instate the "Arizona Special Missions Unit" with a yearly price tag of $1.4 million dollars to taxpayers. The bill, still in its early stages, would need to pass through the Arizona State House and Senate, and be signed by Governor Jan Brewer to become law. The new bill comes less than two years after the passage of Arizona's controversial SB 1070, which requires police in Arizona to question people about their immigration status if they suspect an individual is in the country illegally. The governor of Arizona, Jan Brewer, argues that the federal government is not doing enough to secure the US-Mexico and she has been forced to take action at the state level. She wrote in her recent book 'Scorpions for Breakfast: My Fight Against Special Interests, Liberal Media, and Cynical Politicos to Secure America's Border' that the people of Arizona were being "terrorized, robbed, and murdered by ruthless and desperate people who enter our country illegally." At the height of the SB 1070 debate, however, Arizona had never been safer, even with the spike in undocumented immigration, The New York Times reported. FBI statistics indicated that violent crime actually fell to 447 incidents per 100,000 residents in 2008, compared to 532 incidents per 100,000 in 2000. According to the same report, property crimes also fell during the same period. Although Governor Jan Brewer has not commented on her thoughts about the bill to fund a volunteer militia, in July of 2011 she signed into law SB 1495, a different bill in order to "free up the Governor of Arizona to establish the Arizona State Guard", in the words of the Arizona State Defense Force Foundation. According to AZCentral.com, if passed, Arizona would be the only state currently funding a militia devoted to border enforcement. http://www.huffingto..._n_1282462.html
April 23, 201214 yr I'd love this in NJ: The People's Republic of New Jersey is taking steps to heal their public image on TV. This week, the state got one step closer to passing a bill which would create and fund a volunteer armed militia to patrol the Jersey Shore for Guidos. :D
April 23, 201214 yr Author I'd love this in NJ: The People's Republic of New Jersey is taking steps to heal their public image on TV. This week, the state got one step closer to passing a bill which would create and fund a volunteer armed militia to patrol the Jersey Shore for Guidos. :D Haha, open season on guidos would be nice.
April 23, 201214 yr Good for Arizona. I just hope the volunteers are properly trained and are given the ability to "fire at will", upon those who choose to cross the border illegally.
April 23, 201214 yr I think we did do this once... didn't NJ have a Naval Militia a few years back? NJ eliminated them shortly after the terrorist attacks when the state suddenly woke up and realized that they had a bunch of people with no military experience running around as admirals in small boats looking for terrorists? I'm also kind of confused... doesn't Arizona already have a National Guard? Is this a way to do an end run around paying Guardsmen by finding volunteers who will do it for free?
April 23, 201214 yr I was just thinking about NJ's naval militia. Their mission was to observe and report suspicious activity; it was not an armed agency, except for those members who were already allowed to be armed (current law enforcement, permit carriers, etc.). They worked in full cooperation with the state police and the coast guard. As far as Arizona, I think that they should have the full right to do what they believe necessary to secure the border there. If the suits in Washington can't contain the problem, let the locals in Arizona be empowered to deal with the problem directly, in a manner they deem appropriate. Is Arizona taking donations for this project? Those volunteers should not feel they are alone.
April 23, 201214 yr Author I think we did do this once... didn't NJ have a Naval Militia a few years back? NJ eliminated them shortly after the terrorist attacks when the state suddenly woke up and realized that they had a bunch of people with no military experience running around as admirals in small boats looking for terrorists? I'm also kind of confused... doesn't Arizona already have a National Guard? Is this a way to do an end run around paying Guardsmen by finding volunteers who will do it for free? Of course Arizona has a National Guard, but the problem is they can be called up and activated for the needs of the federal government. I believe it says in the article or maybe I read it elsewhere, that the NG has deployed a few times. If Arizona had a funded militia they would serve the needs of Arizona state only.
April 23, 201214 yr I thinks its a good idea provided the Militia is properly trained and regulated by local law enforcement and state laws. States should have the right to secure their border with another country and discourage illegal entry in to the US. The right to shoot at will however is not a good idea nor would it be legal.Its not just latino people,its just about every nationality you can think of that use that border as an entry point,illegally ..Time to shut the door to illegal immigration! Im sure the the great eric holder will have plenty to say. POS
April 23, 201214 yr this_is_nascar No, lets not shoot people at will. Thanks Why not? Don't you think that would curtail illegal immigration? I do. If word gets out that Arizona or the US will shoot illegals as they attempt to cross the border, I bet you see a lowering in the number of illegals that pass through our boarders every day, every month, every year.
April 23, 201214 yr Author Half the country is up in arms because AZ. cops can inquire as to your immigration status. If they were allowed to shoot trespassers the liberals would riot. Remeber now, once you cross the border wheter legally or illegally you have all the rights of an American citizen.
April 23, 201214 yr I'm also kind of confused... doesn't Arizona already have a National Guard? Is this a way to do an end run around paying Guardsmen by finding volunteers who will do it for free? The National Guard was placed firmly under Federal control with the Militia Act of 1903. The individual States control the NG, unless the Feds call them up for service. They can do this at any time. A true State Militia answers to the State government, and is not under the control of the Feds whatsoever. They are not able to operate outside of the territory of the United States, and as such are useful only as a defensive force. The United States operated primarily with State militias until the 20th century. The organized national military took on a much larger role in the defense of individual States after that. Individual States are still able to raise and support militias, as well as train and arm them however they see fit. This is the last vestige of State power that exists to counter Federal interference and usurpation of matters pertaining solely to the States. The States lost most of their ability to resist the centralized government after the conclusion of the Civil War. Such volunteers are paid for their service to the State, it is "voluntary" only in the sense that members volunteer to serve, not that they work for free. The biggest hurdle for a State to raise a militia is funding. Half the country is up in arms because AZ. cops can inquire as to your immigration status. If they were allowed to shoot trespassers the liberals would riot. Remeber now, once you cross the border wheter legally or illegally you have all the rights of an American citizen. Illegal immigrants certainly do NOT have the exact same rights as a U.S. Citizen! They only have their inalienable rights, which can be stripped of them through due process of law. To make such a statement is to defraud and cheapen what it means to BE a U.S. Citizen!
April 24, 201214 yr Author Illegal immigrants certainly do NOT have the exact same rights as a U.S. Citizen! They only have their inalienable rights, which can be stripped of them through due process of law. To make such a statement is to defraud and cheapen what it means to BE a U.S. Citizen! I think your sarcasm detector is broken.
April 24, 201214 yr Why not? Don't you think that would curtail illegal immigration? I do. If word gets out that Arizona or the US will shoot illegals as they attempt to cross the border, I bet you see a lowering in the number of illegals that pass through our boarders every day, every month, every year. please tell me your kidding
April 24, 201214 yr please tell me your kidding I'd be interested in hearing your solution for curing the issue of illegal aliens invading/crossing the borders into the US.
April 24, 201214 yr Why not? Don't you think that would curtail illegal immigration? I do. If word gets out that Arizona or the US will shoot illegals as they attempt to cross the border, I bet you see a lowering in the number of illegals that pass through our boarders every day, every month, every year. Does that include the Cuban refugees washing ashore in FL., whoever from the Canadian brdr, Asians on the West coast too? Shooting just the men or woman and children too.
April 24, 201214 yr Screw trying to classify them, let's just shoot people that don't look like us. /sarcasm off It's a slippery slope, one that I could never advocate.
April 24, 201214 yr I commend the AZ Govt for being proactive on an issue that clearly affects them as a state on a topic that the feds have repeatedly failed them. The federal govt charged with protecting our borders refuses to solve the problem yet chastise states that attempt to to pick up the slack. As long as the plan is sound, I think this is one of the most "american" things a state has done has done in a long time. How much do you think the notion of a state controlled militia scares the shit out of the federal govt in fear of similar such regiments popping up in the other 49 states? (More politically speaking than militaristically)
April 24, 201214 yr It has nothing to do with people that do or do not look or act like us. It has to do with people sneaking into this country illegally. For those of you who have voiced an opinion that's against my method, I'm anxiously waiting to hear your solutions to the problem.
April 24, 201214 yr Yeah, close the borders. NO, shooting people. How's that? What are you talking about? The borders are already closed to illegals and have been for decades. They continue to sneak into the country anyway. You've offered no solution to the problem, yet you have issues with mine.
April 24, 201214 yr What are you talking about? The borders are already closed to illegals and have been for decades. They continue to sneak into the country anyway. You've offered no solution to the problem, yet you have issues with mine. So lets start shooting people coming across the border. Yeah, okay.
April 24, 201214 yr They should give them rifles and lots and lots of ammunition. and blindly fire into the night sky.... that would scare my a** back to mexico.
April 25, 201214 yr I'd love this in NJ: The People's Republic of New Jersey is taking steps to heal their public image on TV. This week, the state got one step closer to passing a bill which would create and fund a volunteer armed militia to patrol the Jersey Shore for Guidos. :D I swear, I think I'm the only white person in NJ who isn't at least PART Italian. It's easy for other states to criticize these moves, but if beheadings, drugs, and kidnappings were happening in THEIR states, I have a feeling their opinions would change pretty quickly...
April 25, 201214 yr Author I swear, I think I'm the only white person in NJ who isn't at least PART Italian. It's easy for other states to criticize these moves, but if beheadings, drugs, and kidnappings were happening in THEIR states, I have a feeling their opinions would change pretty quickly... There ain't no I-talian in my blood either. LOL I agree with Jack, warning shots would be a good deterrent. But overall this is just a great leap foward for states rights.
April 25, 201214 yr So lets start shooting people coming across the border. Yeah, okay. Last time Ray. Offer me a solution that will work. You don't like mine, but I'll guarantee when word gets around that folks on the US side of the border are authorized to shoot at anyone and everyone that attempts to cross our borders illegally, the amount of illegals coming into our country will decrease more than 10-fold. Again, what's your solution to the problem?
April 25, 201214 yr I think I agree with militarizing and actively closing the southern border. But irregular militia? Ugh. Furthermore, I can't help but feel like you're targeting the symptom and not the disease. People come here illegally for two reasons. 1) the fact that there are millions of jobs here for them facilitated by businesses that have no consequences and 2) that the method by which people may enter legally is in surmountableCrush the business who hires undocumented workers with penalties. Establish a system by which illegal immigrants cannot access healthcare services. And bolster the guest worker program. The by product is that milk will jump to $12 a gallon. But that is the price we pay for finally getting off the teat of illegal immigrant labor.
April 25, 201214 yr +1 woodentoe. The fact that there are illegal crossings into this country are purely symptomatic, and shooting people might curb the numbers slightly at first-- but it won't do anything to "solve the problem." As long as this country and government continue to support illegal immigration (whether they admit it or not), the illegals will come. Also, woodentoe highlighted some good considerations. I would agree that bolstering the guest worker program would be the smartest overall move. But its so much more complicated than just a few fixes here and there. The application of modernity and globalization (aka exploitation) in the different parts of the world are means of creating cheaper costs for us, here at home. This in turn creates wages for jobs in the native countries of those illegally immigrating that are far too meager to actually support anybody, hence the yearning to come to America for jobs that, while we as Americans might think are crap, are far better than what is available in their native countries. There are other markets, notably the sex trafficking market, that are actually far more destructive and detrimental in terms of the usageof illegal immigrants (mostly from Europe and Asia in this case). Yet, because of the hegemonic beliefs that surround sexual needs and desires (including shame), this is rarely even considered to be such a massive industry... and nobody does anything about it, or note anything about it. It really disgusts me that people are so casual about the sex trafficking epidemic and the usage of illegal immigrants.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.