Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

New Arizona Bill Aims To Instate Armed Militia on Border

Featured Replies

I fully support them being armed to the teeth, purely because any forces (armed or not) on the border WILL be shot at, attacked, threatened, and harassed by heavily armed drug cartels/gangs/bribed police and military.

 

Shooting at everyone crossing the border? Yeah, that might eventually work. Actually it probably will. But it is 2012 and we are not the Chinese, the Soviets, Iranians, or the Third Reich. We simply can't do that.

 

I personally think that the whole immigration thing will blow over eventually, the same way the waves of Irish and Italian immigrants came here. Most Americans nowadays claim to be Irish or Italian, but really they know nothing of the "home land" (although Italians notoriously claim that they do, trust me, its pronounced MAR-EH-NAIR-AH, not MAH-IN-NAD despite what your grandma who never spoke a word of Italian said).

 

For example, I am of Irish decent. I don't tell people who were born in Ireland that I am Irish.

  • Replies 73
  • Views 2.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Thinking about this, how about we just adopt Mexico's immigration policy, doesn't seem to upset anyone so why wouldn't that be good for the USA??

 

Sarcasm off..

Last time Ray. Offer me a solution that will work. You don't like mine, but I'll guarantee when word gets around that folks on the US side of the border are authorized to shoot at anyone and everyone that attempts to cross our borders illegally, the amount of illegals coming into our country will decrease more than 10-fold. Again, what's your solution to the problem?

 

 

Nice, "I can't think o' nuffin' better so lets go keel 'em! That'll learn 'em!!"

 

Real man of genius

Nice, "I can't think o' nuffin' better so lets go keel 'em! That'll learn 'em!!"

 

Real man of genius

 

thank you

 

It amazes me some of the idea's people have in their head.

I think I agree with militarizing and actively closing the southern border. But irregular militia? Ugh. Furthermore, I can't help but feel like you're targeting the symptom and not the disease. People come here illegally for two reasons. 1) the fact that there are millions of jobs here for them facilitated by businesses that have no consequences and 2) that the method by which people may enter legally is in surmountableCrush the business who hires undocumented workers with penalties. Establish a system by which illegal immigrants cannot access healthcare services. And bolster the guest worker program. The by product is that milk will jump to $12 a gallon. But that is the price we pay for finally getting off the teat of illegal immigrant labor.

 

 

Good points that I hadn't thought of.

Nice, "I can't think o' nuffin' better so lets go keel 'em! That'll learn 'em!!"

 

Real man of genius

 

 

No you misunderstand. In my mind, this is the quickest solution to implement and the one that has the most promise to be effective. Now, as someone already mentioned (and I did agree that I hadn't thought of), a long term solution is to make it so folks don't want to come to the US illegally. Contrary to popular belief, I'm not a total idiot. I know that we'll never have enough balls to start shooting at illegals as they attempt to illegally cross our borders and illegally enter our country. Eliminating the desire to come here will never be done in our lifetimes, so to me, that's not a viable solution.

  • 1 month later...

Last time Ray. Offer me a solution that will work. You don't like mine, but I'll guarantee when word gets around that folks on the US side of the border are authorized to shoot at anyone and everyone that attempts to cross our borders illegally, the amount of illegals coming into our country will decrease more than 10-fold. Again, what's your solution to the problem?

 

Not having the answer or solution doesn't mean that automatically any proposal or 'solution' you come up with is the right one. There is a word for that. It is called ignorance.

I fully support them being armed to the teeth, purely because any forces (armed or not) on the border WILL be shot at, attacked, threatened, and harassed by heavily armed drug cartels/gangs/bribed police and military.

 

Shooting at everyone crossing the border? Yeah, that might eventually work. Actually it probably will. But it is 2012 and we are not the Chinese, the Soviets, Iranians, or the Third Reich. We simply can't do that.

 

I personally think that the whole immigration thing will blow over eventually, the same way the waves of Irish and Italian immigrants came here. Most Americans nowadays claim to be Irish or Italian, but really they know nothing of the "home land" (although Italians notoriously claim that they do, trust me, its pronounced MAR-EH-NAIR-AH, not MAH-IN-NAD despite what your grandma who never spoke a word of Italian said).

 

For example, I am of Irish decent. I don't tell people who were born in Ireland that I am Irish.

 

This isn't going to blow over on its own. There is no valid comparison between the problem with Mexico and Irish and Italian immigration. Mexicans are entering the country illegally, get health care and whatever they can out of the system, take jobs, send as much money as possible back to Mexico, and hope to save enough to take it all back to Mexico. The Irish and Italians came here legally, sent money home so their relatives could immigrate, spent most of their money here, and were here to stay and cast their lot in becoming part of the American dream and may have wanted to go back to the old country for a visit to show everyone how successful they were.

 

The issue with the Irish and Italians (and a lot of other ethnicities that immigrated to to this country) is the "native born" white Americans felt they were stupid and unable to make any contribution to this country and just here to suck off resources. Don't compare them to what the Mexicans are doing.

 

 

Once the Chinese finish taking over the U.S. they'll simply cut off all social services to them, document them, tax them, have them fixed (at their cost) so they can't reproduce, and create an indentured servant class.

Not having the answer or solution doesn't mean that automatically any proposal or 'solution' you come up with is the right one. There is a word for that. It is called ignorance.

 

 

Call it what you will. I will guarantee that my way will work in lessening the amount of illegals that cros our borders. Again, I've yet to hear of other solutions that are guaranteed to work.

This isn't going to blow over on its own. There is no valid comparison between the problem with Mexico and Irish and Italian immigration. Mexicans are entering the country illegally, get health care and whatever they can out of the system, take jobs, send as much money as possible back to Mexico, and hope to save enough to take it all back to Mexico. The Irish and Italians came here legally, sent money home so their relatives could immigrate, spent most of their money here, and were here to stay and cast their lot in becoming part of the American dream and may have wanted to go back to the old country for a visit to show everyone how successful they were.

 

The issue with the Irish and Italians (and a lot of other ethnicities that immigrated to to this country) is the "native born" white Americans felt they were stupid and unable to make any contribution to this country and just here to suck off resources. Don't compare them to what the Mexicans are doing.

 

 

Agreed 100%.

Call it what you will. I will guarantee that my way will work in lessening the amount of illegals that cros our borders. Again, I've yet to hear of other solutions that are guaranteed to work.

 

Ok, I'll give you a couple solutions.

 

Kill everybody on the planet that isn't a US citizen.

 

Require everyone in the US to wear a US citizens ID badge at all times. Anyone caught not wearing one will be arrested and detained indefinitely, and if found to be an illegal citizen, executed. The bodies of those will be then displayed near the border.

 

Build an impenetrable structure that extends both above and below the earth surface 1361 feet and is electrified and extends the length of the border.

 

Now I just gave you 3 other solutions. Using your own logic, because I have 'solutions', and they work, that means they are good ones.

 

Or maybe they aren't and your logic just happens to suck. Call it what you want.

Ok, I'll give you a couple solutions.

 

Kill everybody on the planet that isn't a US citizen. Why in the world would you suggest something like this? Are you against all peoples of all countries throughout all the world? I have no issues with most other countries and their peoples. They do their own thing and life goes one. If they choose to come to my country and visit, I'm OK with that and welcome them with open arms. If they want to take up permanent residency and become a US citizen, great for them and I will welcome them as well.

 

You want to illegally sneak into and enter my country for any reason, then I have a problem with you and would have not problem "shooting to kill" as you attempt to cross my border.

 

Require everyone in the US to wear a US citizens ID badge at all times. Anyone caught not wearing one will be arrested and detained indefinitely, and if found to be an illegal citizen, executed. The bodies of those will be then displayed near the border. I could live with this just fine.

 

Build an impenetrable structure that extends both above and below the earth surface 1361 feet and is electrified and extends the length of the border. Why not, if it keeps the illegals out. It's more expensive then my solution, but you have the right to suggest that.

 

Now I just gave you 3 other solutions. Using your own logic, because I have 'solutions', and they work, that means they are good ones. I agree, in that most of your solutions were not good ones in my opinion. They're your thoughts and opinions, so I respect that.

 

Or maybe they aren't and your logic just happens to suck. Call it what you want. No need to be insulting.

They aren't might actual suggestions, I was merely demonstrating, contrary to YOUR point, that because you have an idea, that the lack of other ideas somehow serve to legitimatize yours. That isn't the case, or else my ideas could be somehow legitimate if nobody else had another. They aren't. I thought that was clear. I guess not. I'm sorry you felt insulted. I wasn't attempting to be insulting. I was merely stating an observation that your logic sucked.

They aren't might actual suggestions, I was merely demonstrating, contrary to YOUR point, that because you have an idea, that the lack of other ideas somehow serve to legitimatize yours. That isn't the case, or else my ideas could be somehow legitimate if nobody else had another. They aren't. I thought that was clear. I guess not. I'm sorry you felt insulted. I wasn't attempting to be insulting. I was merely stating an observation that your logic sucked.

 

 

I'm sure you would agree that something needs to be done. The issue is that we need something done now. Rather than us not doing anything, I'd like to see us do something. I'm not stupid enough to ever think that my solution would ever be implemented, but just think about it for a second. It could be implemented in next to no time at all and cost next to nothing. Some preparation would need to be taken in anticipation that these people may try to shoot back at the border. I'd bet that within 30-days of implementation, illegal border crossings would be down by at least 25%.

 

Sad, but true.

 

 

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2

Ok, I'll give you a couple solutions.Kill everybody on the planet that isn't a US citizen.Require everyone in the US to wear a US citizens ID badge at all times. Anyone caught not wearing one will be arrested and detained indefinitely, and if found to be an illegal citizen, executed. The bodies of those will be then displayed near the border.Build an impenetrable structure that extends both above and below the earth surface 1361 feet and is electrified and extends the length of the border.Now I just gave you 3 other solutions. Using your own logic, because I have 'solutions', and they work, that means they are good ones.Or maybe they aren't and your logic just happens to suck. Call it what you want.
I'll play. Dig a deep hole the length of the boarder and fill it with water, use the dirt to fill in New Orleans so they won't flood. Grab all the Alligators and put them in the water you put in he hole and that solves the Alligator problem in Florida and the Redneck Rivera. Between the fence, boarder patrol and new system I mentioned we should be good. LolSent from my iPad using Tapatalk
  • Author

I'll play. Dig a deep hole the length of the boarder and fill it with water, use the dirt to fill in New Orleans so they won't flood. Grab all the Alligators and put them in the water you put in he hole and that solves the Alligator problem in Florida and the Redneck Rivera. Between the fence, boarder patrol and new system I mentioned we should be good. LolSent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

I don't know if you're joking, or if you're brillant.

 

I don't know if you're joking, or if you're brillant.

 

Well that all depends on if you are talking to my wife or someone else. Lol

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Ha, asking the wife never works for me Harry.

 

Side notes and observations - Mexico has a very tough and demanding immigration policy. Far more stringent then ours, so adopting thier standards would raise our low standards.

 

The Coast Guard used to man the beaches (pickets) to watch and observe for any enemy vessels, small boats, frogmen or suspicious activity coming to our shores. There typically were armed with M1's and a radio. FWIW - They did manage to report some minor activity. Garands, night vision and radios ever 500 yards along all borders would be a nice start for sure.

So lets start shooting people coming across the border. Yeah, okay.

 

I Dont think Az id advocating that..the REALITY is however that incursions INTO the us by Armed groups is and has been on the rise..it's only the US government that refuses to accept that reality. Unarmed groups like the Minutmen are all well and good, until you get some Cartelista who decides to teach them a lesson like they do in Mexico, and you have a group of volunteers standing there with their peckers in their hands as a bunch of cartel asshats open up on them with military ordnance.

The problem is that people do not see the problem for what it is.. people see it as this feel good social issue.. where people come here for a better life.. they are fighting this huge struggle and coming here to overcome..

 

and unfortunately that is just a bunch of shit....

 

Illegal immigration is poisonous to our nation... first of all.. in case you haven't noticed.. we have this huge issue with unemployment... now I know what you are going to say.. you are going to say oh well illegals do jobs that Americans would not do.. and you are right.. but that is only because we allow that nonsense.. if all the illegals were removed.. there would be a huge surplus of low paying jobs.. and well at first people would continue to sit home and milk the system.. but what if the system stopped allowing it.. now you are left with only a couple options.. take that low paying job you really don't want.. or starve to death.. hungry people get motivated quickly.. far more quickly than while sitting on the couch cashing a check written on your tax dollars... so removing Illegals would certainly open up more jobs to US citizens... the other issue is this.. sure illegals spend in the US, sure they add some money back into the economy.. but how much of the untaxed US earned money is shipped back home to other nations.. this is problem number two.. we have a worker who is earning an income (in many cases untaxed) and sending a large portion of it OUT of the country... do the math on that real quick and see how it works long term.... you pay someone $50.. $20 of it goes back into where you are... $30 of it leaves where you are... multiplied over time.. does not make for a healthy economy... further.. there is the issue of crime.. ever get hit by an illegal immigrant who totals your car and has no insurance.... ever see what they do to illegal immigrants who commit violent crimes? rape... murder.. they toss them back over the border so they can sneak right back over here.... and this does not even address the violence caused by drug cartels..

 

people will think that violence is excessive.. but if I broke into your house to take some of your money and food.. so I could have a better life.. would you be OK with it?

 

these people are here.. and they are here to do us harm in every possible way.... being polite about it has gotten us nowhere.. you can scoop up the mice in your house one at a time.. take them and let them free in the yard.. but they will multiply.. and come back.. and infest your home till there is no room left for you.. and that is what is happening.. we need to view these people as intruders and get serious about it.. I want my border SECURE even if that means using violence to do so..

 

and you are right.. if gone untreated they will eventually stop coming.. they will stop once the US is turned into a completely useless wasteland.. one with nothing left to pillage.. I for one do not want to sit around and wait for that to happen..

I'd fully support allowing the militia to use deadly force on these criminals at our boarder

I'd fully support allowing the militia to use deadly force on these criminals at our boarder

 

The question is: Is it Constitutional for a state militia to patrol the federal border?

Exactly, it's Arizona's border

 

It's the United States' border. States don't have borders with foreign countries. That is what the whole debate is about. Can a state take action that is reserved to the federal government if the federal government is not doing its duty.

They should be able too but ever since the civil war the federal government has been stamping all over the states rights

They should be able too but ever since the civil war the federal government has been stamping all over the states rights

 

The Constitution prohibits the states from engaging foreign countries or dealing with immigration issues.

 

Ironically, State rights is what NJ invokes to control CCW and gun rights. You can't pick and choose what state rights you want; it cuts both ways.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.