May 25, 201214 yr Maybe you should draw up a lease for the space you will be staying in your friend's home and pay him $1 in rent for the time you are there. At least that would make it your legal residence in NJ. I really don't think that will hold up in a court of law but you can take your chances if you want
May 25, 201214 yr I am sure I will get shot for saying this, but one other option is to just leave your guns home in Texas.
May 25, 201214 yr An argument could be made for a hotel room being a temporary residence because you are taking possession of the room and have certain rights associated with that. Except that it was not an affirmative defense for Gregg Revell. The Revell decision specifically noted that FOPA didn't cover a hotel room, but FOPA wouldn't have needed to cover the hotel room if the NJ exemptions applied to the hotel room. Maybe this post won't get deleted.
May 25, 201214 yr I am sure I will get shot for saying this, but one other option is to just leave your guns home in Texas. If the OP was flying into NJ I would agree, but I believe he is driving from Texas to NJ. There is no reason why he cannot carry from Texas to PA (get a bank box in PA) and back from PA to TX. NJ laws aside, he has a right to legally protect himself and his family along the way from Texas till before he gets to NJ.
May 25, 201214 yr I'm NOT an Attorney and NOT qualified to give legal advice. I did read the law and it seems to me that the only debate is whether or not the place of temporary residence qualfies as "his residence." Based on my expereince it does, same as a hotel room. All the other rules apply. FYI, NJ is NOT a high cap magazine friendly state. As an aside, perhaps the NRA might have a resource to help in this situation?
May 25, 201214 yr I did read the law and it seems to me that the only debate is whether or not the place of temporary residence qualfies as "his residence." Based on my expereince it does, same as a hotel room. The Superior court of NJ does not believe that a hotel room is a temporary residence.
May 25, 201214 yr The Superior court of NJ does not believe that a hotel room is a temporary residence. Agreed. If you actually rented a hotel/motel room on an entire monthly basis, that may work.
May 25, 201214 yr Agreed. If you actually rented a hotel/motel room on an entire monthly basis, that may work. Certainly a long term lease is different than a "flop down for the night". If you actually "move in" to the space I believe you have an affirmative argument that it is your residence. If you can pack all your possessions into a couple suitcases, you haven't really moved in.
May 25, 201214 yr The Superior court of NJ does not believe that a hotel room is a temporary residence. I was not aware there is case law on the subject. I'm in the insurance business and the industry treats a hotel room or the like as a temporary residence.
May 25, 201214 yr I was not aware there is case law on the subject. I'm in the insurance business and the industry treats a hotel room or the like as a temporary residence. Follow the bouncing ball. Third circuit review of the Revell case. http://www.ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/092029p.pdf The Court found persuasive the defense argument that Revell’s conduct fell outside § 926A since it is undisputed that Revell left the airport with his luggage for an overnight stay at a hotel in New Jersey, thus giving him ready access to the gun during that period. The Court also explained that “§ 926A does not address anything but vehicular travel; it does not encompass keeping the weapon – locked in a case or not – in an airport hotel overnight.” This is the court discussing that Revell fell outside of FOPA protection. In the state of NJ, you are legally allowed to have ready access to a firearm in your residence or other properties possessed by you. The court did not state that Gregg Revell had ready access to the firearm at his temporary residence in the hotel room because that would have been a legal activity. They specifically noted it was an activity falling outside of FOPA protections. You don't need FOPA protection for a legal activity!
May 25, 201214 yr Follow the bouncing ball. Third circuit review of the Revell case. http://www.ca3.uscou...rch/092029p.pdf This is the court discussing that Revell fell outside of FOPA protection. In the state of NJ, you are legally allowed to have ready access to a firearm in your residence or other properties possessed by you. The court did not state that Gregg Revell had ready access to the firearm at his temporary residence in the hotel room because that would have been a legal activity. They specifically noted it was an activity falling outside of FOPA protections. You don't need FOPA protection for a legal activity! Also, criminal statues are different than civil ones. Insurance doesn't count. Better safe than sorry. Just use your common sense.
May 25, 201214 yr So how could someone travel to nj for a two day competition and keep his guns in the hotel room? Rich
May 25, 201214 yr So how could someone travel to nj for a two day competition and keep his guns in the hotel room? Rich Mental retardation?
May 25, 201214 yr So how could someone travel to nj for a two day competition and keep his guns in the hotel room? Rich Maybe he has a FID ?
May 25, 201214 yr Security through obscurity. he postdelete fairy will be along any minute now. ever notice hotels don't have those pesky "no firearms" stickers on the doors like national park visitor sites? "Security through obscurity"
May 26, 201214 yr What would happen if he applied for a non-resident FID card? If he wasn't a bad guy, he'd get it.
May 26, 201214 yr What would happen if he applied for a non-resident FID card? We're talking about pistols here, what relevance does a FID have?
May 26, 201214 yr And don't even THINK about bringing in a slingshot! Notice how you haven't heard from Dennis the Menace since 1963? He's been rotting in a NJ jail for felony possession. Serious business! Unfortunately your best bet for personal protection is a folding knife. Slightly better than nothing..
May 26, 201214 yr Unfortunately your best bet for personal protection is a folding knife. Slightly better than nothing.. What happens if you use it?
May 26, 201214 yr What happens if you use it? You get to go to court on aggravated assault charges, possession of a weapon for unlawful purposes, and I'm sure others. You will have to prove that you were using a deadly weapon for self defense because you had no clear route of escaping imminent death or serious bodily injury from the person attacking you. You will then have to prove that you had the knife on you for legitimate legal purposes, like peeling apples or something, since self defense is not a recognized legal purpose for carrying a knife in NJ AFAIK.
May 26, 201214 yr Correct, but this is about what the OP can possess, not use. If you defend yourself with a large rock you can face similar charges if you can not prove the same.
May 26, 201214 yr Correct, but this is about what the OP can possess, not use. If you defend yourself with a large rock you can face similar charges if you can not prove the same. You would have to prove you had the rock for a "legitimate" purpose other than self defense? Great. Don't play games, just be a good NJ citizen and let them rape and kill you like you are supposed to.
May 26, 201214 yr You would have to prove you had the rock for a "legitimate" purpose other than self defense? Great. Don't play games, just be a good NJ citizen and let them rape and kill you like you are supposed to. I was talking about the charges that Dan mentioned, "You get to go to court on aggravated assault charges, possession of a weapon for unlawful purposes, and I'm sure others. You will have to prove that you were using a deadly weapon for self defense because you had no clear route of escaping imminent death or serious bodily injury from the person attacking you" Those charges would still apply with whatever you chose to use as a weapon, be it a knife or a large rock or your martial arts training. Since I carry the folding knife for both work and day-to-day utility (i.e. peeling apples) I have a legitimate reason to possess the folder. And now I am on a level playing field if I am forced to use my knife in self-defense, jury emotion aside, as with someone using any random object as a deadly weapon in self-defense. In my opinion that nullifies that the "anti- knife carry" argument in my case. It should also be mentioned that in most states carrying a firearm for the purposes of self-defense, with a concealed carry permit or under the protections of constitutional carry, is not a recognized legal purpose. If you write "self-defense" as the reason you're in applying for a concealed permit in most states, the application will be denied.
May 27, 201214 yr It should also be mentioned that in most states carrying a firearm for the purposes of self-defense, with a concealed carry permit or under the protections of constitutional carry, is not a recognized legal purpose. If you write "self-defense" as the reason you're in applying for a concealed permit in most states, the application will be denied. I beg to differ, in most states that are shall issue...a 'reason' is not needed. That is what they mean by shall issue, by law they shall issue it if one has a clean record and meets the requirements. Why would someone have to put a reason down for a permit in a shall issue state? I have not heard of anyone who met the requirements and had a clean record getting denied in shall issue states. I don't understand how self defense is not a recognized legal purpose with a concealed carry permit in shall issue states. A lot of states have Castle and Stand Your Ground Laws as well. It is a different story in those states that are may issue. Some prefer the term "may not issue". For instance in New York State it is a may issue state. In certain counties in upstate NY it is possible to get a carry permit, and a reason is needed and some have suggested a valid 'reason' as "For All Lawful Purposes".
May 27, 201214 yr I beg to differ, in most states that are shall issue...a 'reason' is not needed. That is what they mean by shall issue, by law they shall issue it if one has a clean record and meets the requirements. Why would someone have to put a reason down for a permit in a shall issue state? I have not heard of anyone who met the requirements and had a clean record getting denied in shall issue states. I don't understand how self defense is not a recognized legal purpose with a concealed carry permit in shall issue states. A lot of states have Castle and Stand Your Ground Laws as well. It is a different story in those states that are may issue. Some prefer the term "may not issue". For instance in New York State it is a may issue state. In certain counties in upstate NY it is possible to get a carry permit, and a reason is needed and some have suggested a valid 'reason' as "For All Lawful Purposes". I should not have used the word "most" there Even though your permit application doesn't ask for a reason, it doesn't make self defense a recognized legal purpose. Castle Doctrine and Stand Your Ground provide those protections for lawful self defense with the firearm. New Hampshire is one example of a shall issue state that requires a purpose that is not self-defense. Connecticut is another although their status as shall issue can be disputed theoretically (but not practically). I put "for all lawful purposes" when I applied for concealed carry in both these states. Arizona, Nevada, Utah, Florida, Virginia and Maine did not ask me for a reason on my concealed carry application. But again, that does not make it lawful to carry for self-defense
May 27, 201214 yr I was talking about the charges that Dan mentioned, "You get to go to court on aggravated assault charges, possession of a weapon for unlawful purposes, and I'm sure others. You will have to prove that you were using a deadly weapon for self defense because you had no clear route of escaping imminent death or serious bodily injury from the person attacking you" Those charges would still apply with whatever you chose to use as a weapon, be it a knife or a large rock or your martial arts training. You are skipping over the part where carrying a knife for self-defense is illegal in NJ even if you use it in self-defense. Just because you had to defend yourself does not mean you are off the hook for possession in NJ from what I can tell. I think THAT was Dan's point, but I'll let him respond. It certainly was mine. You can carry a knife for any damn reason you want or no reason at all in most of America. It should also be mentioned that in most states carrying a firearm for the purposes of self-defense, with a concealed carry permit or under the protections of constitutional carry, is not a recognized legal purpose. If you write "self-defense" as the reason you're in applying for a concealed permit in most states, the application will be denied. That is complete bs. I have never heard of any state denying on the basis of self-defense as a reason for a permit to carry. If you ever decide to apply for one, you should check or write "self-defense" or "protection" because there are laws in a few states that say it must be issued for that reason to carry in a vehicle. This issue can confuse cops if you are carrying on reciprocity in a different state and you put "fishing" because you are...well, let's politely say "misinformed." In many states, if you put "collecting" or "target practice" or "competition," when you get it back it will say "self-defense" or "protection" anyway, even though they had a spot for other choices. You couldn't be more wrong about this. Where did you come up with this stuff? I'd like to get a load of the place.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.