Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

NJ Mayor: says he'll give you $1,000 to turn in your gun owning neighbors

Featured Replies

Most importantly gun ownership is a right. It's in the constitution as the second amendment. The supreme court has decided multiple time on the meaning and the precedent currently stands that it guarantees an individual right to ownership.

 

If we were to use your driving analogy, since LEO's in this thread think firearms ownership is a privilege like driving, it would still be useless.

 

Lets say you wanted to get illegal drivers off the streets so you offered 1K for an arrest. Now you'd have tons of people calling in and you'd have no way to know if a tip was actually an illegal driver until after you pulled them over and asked for their license. 99% of the people you pull over would be legal drivers. Violates rights and not worth it at all.

 

The problem I see is that you need to be sure the act is illegal not just maybe.

  • Replies 127
  • Views 9.4k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I.really don't give a crap what anyone thinks, if this can save innocent lives its worth the hassle, stop thinking about yourself and being so selfish to "your rights" and think of how many children were killed last year due to drive bys and gun incidents, that in some cases were executed by lawful gun owners using a gun In a unlawful fashion.

 

I'd be willing to bet you a week's pay that NO CHILDREN were killed in drive-by's by "lawful" gun owners; "gun incidents" is too vague a category, but I'll definitely take you up on the first point.

cguiro, I think the salient point you are missing is that making laws under the guise of greater good, or for the children etc etc is simply the battle cry of the gun grabbers. It is NOT about keeping guns out of the hands of criminals. It just isnt. Why you ask? Becasue criminals do not care about the law!!!! You need to wrap your head around that fact. I respect your right to your opinion, but I consider it my duty to try and provide you with enough logic and reasoning to reconsider your position. Show me a law that affects the lawless! The law is only as good as those willing to obey them. So if criminals continue to disregard them, who is affected? Only the law abiding citizen. Now consider the fact you are in a gun grabing state and you have laws that are by design created to seperate everyone they can from their firearms. I can assure you there is a ton of cases proving this point ad nausium. Think about a restraining order for one second. Consider your own position. Think about the fact that all your wife or girlfriend has to do is make a complaint you threatened to kill her and pulls a RO. You are guilty until proven innocent! You will have all personal weapons stripped of you, all without jury or trial!!! Now lets add a component. Lets say the Mayor has decided that LE domestic violence is an issue and will pay $1000 to anyone turning in their spouse or any case where the wife of an Officer they know are being abused! Reaching..yes. Same thought process? YES!

 

Ill tell you something. A KEY part of the problem is the focus on the item instead of the individual. I used to believe that their should be greater penalties for crimes comitted with a gun. I no longer think that way. The item used should not matter one bit. It creates a deamonisation and in my mind can actualle lessen view of the severity of what the actual perpetrator did because it almost becomes an excuse! Because society starts thinking the item is eveil, not the person. That is what has happened with firearms. If someone puts someones brains on the counter with a rolling pin or a pistol, the focus should remain on the person that killed another, not the item used. The largest mass muders were commited with airplanes and locks and chains and a couple of gallons of gas. Person to person murders are by and far much higher by devices that bare the name luisville slugger on the side but there is no greater punishment for killing someone with a baseball bat because the item has not been demonised and the focus remains where it should, on the person that did the killing!!! But as law abiding citizens we want to preserve our right and fall into the trap of thinking there should be a greater punsihment. This is the thinking process of a lawfull citizen who knows he will never be in the catagory of criminal. BUT I think it is flawed thinking because it perpetuates the demonization.

You'd have to vacate the entire city of NEWARK................spent +20 yrs working there and carried every day.....the city is no better now then it was back then, maybe worse. IMO...........your perception is clouded by your job environment. After all, who would want to baby sit those dirty bastages in this kind of heat with no air conditiong......Yikes.

By blaming guns for the killings, theft and corruption in Newark is only a bandaid for brain surgery.....you have to change the environment, the mindset or just build a fence around it and call it what it is...............a human junkyard.

 

Well put BarkNBite!

 

And one more thing......has anybody noticed that our resident raving lunatic hasn't answered me about my Dad with his .45 from WW2? No documents, didn't need any back then. All Dad has is a DD-214 and several Campaign Ribbons and a Purple Heart. Now by today's thread he's a felon worth locking-up instead of being recognized as a member of "Our Greatest Generation" as Tom Brokaw put it. Dad barely gets around, and would be completely helpless without his "Equalizer". Am I harboring a fugitive from justice?

 

A friend of mine has a Grandmother with a revolver in her nightstand. She's in her 80's and the gun belonged to her dead Husband, who bought it decades ago before you even needed paperwork. Is She a felon to be corraled into the Perp Bus and hauled-off to County Jail or State Prison? I strongly think NOT!

 

The problem with making blanket statements and then standing behind them blindly, arrogantly, no matter how they sound when proven wrong is very evident here. The problem with FEEL-GOOD legislation is that it feels so good, UNTIL you analize it for what it is, and what it can become or lead to. Taking illegal guns off the street is a great idea! Protecting the public is a great idea! Where our debater loses his debate is "not carring" about illegal searches and seizures in private residences, and neighbors dropping a dime on someone cause the grass isn't cut or the dog took a crap on someone's lawn. In addition, the entire argument of "what do I have to hide" so "show them the papers" is just ridiculous on it's face and is no doubt a speculative opinion on his part since no papers are needed for a lot of guns in NJ. Not enough thought went into his rant. Pure FEEL-Good, pure EMOTION! Or maybe he does want to lock-up my Dad?

Not looking at the big picture? Seems you are not. It is a Newark problem in Booker's case. He could care less what is outside the box. I think Booker is trying hard to rid Newark of crime and I applaud him. He as a tough job on his hands. One that most wouldn't want, but his problem wasn't created over night, nor will it go away fast.

Looking at the big picture is looking what will happen outside of Newark too. You fail to realize that and until you do, most here will not agree with you.

 

I don't recall you once (unless I missed it), saying how would you feel if your neighbor hated you and made a call to LE that you had guns. Would you be happy if they came knocking? I wouldn't... If nothing else, the inconvenience to me and my family... Not to mention what your other neighbors might think of you not knowing.

 

One way or another, it sets a precedence and not a good one. In enables an invisible bounty that others will cash in on no matter what. A thousand bux is grand in anyones eyes these days. Are his citizens that fooking ignorant to only turn in the criminals just for a bounty? If so, they could give a rats arse about their city and thats part of the problem. As the other fellow said, I also worked in Newark years ago and I carried. From what I see, it hasn't got any better.

 

I goto physical therapy and come out to read insults, stand up human beings, you gotta look.at the big picture, sry if my views aren't the same as yours, but as gun owners we need to see the benefits of taking illegal weapons off the street and out of the hands of people who's only intention is to harm.other or to use the weapon in the commission of a crime. I'm not disagreeing that gun ownership is a right, a fundamental part of the American way. And yes nj has some of the strict laws out there making it hard for some well intentioned people to practice there right. But these outlaws are the reason we have these laws. Firearms used in the commission of a crime must of shown an increase somewhere along the time to warrant law makers to have the laws that we do. And I'm not talking about awb, I'm talking about fid and pistol permits. Ot also explains the harsh jail time given to those who choose to not follow the laws. So if we sit back, take a deep breath and think "what can we do to resolve the laws that make it hard for individuals to purchase and obtain fire arms and ammo" maybe you can see its due to the increase of straw sales, guns purchased from out of state, or even fabricated firearms (zip guns), these laws may have been put in place to protect us. I'm given the oppurtunity to carry a gun everyday, and with that oppudtunity comes with the understanding that if you need my help in any situation that a Leo has a lawful purpose to intervien I have to. If not I am able to be found liable since I didn't get involved, both departmental and civily. So take a step back and dont see it as there trying to take my rights away, think of it as there trying to get the people off the street that didn't follow the rules. The same people are the reason for the laws. And if leos want to exhuast there time and effort to investigate and prosecute those who break the laws, its there choice , and they have every right to do so. I'm done, you guys can go back to talking crap. Enjoy your day everyone.

 

 

Sent from John's iPad 2 via Tapatalk HD

Just replace the reason for preasence with the 1koffer from the Mayor......

 

Just replace the reason for preasence with the 1koffer from the Mayor......

 

 

+1 zillion!

 

And what's really scary is the stupid Cops followed ILLEGAL ORDERS! All for a chance to get "Rambo'd-Up". Every one of there sorry asses ought to be fired retro-actively! Start with the Governor and the Mayor, and work your way down to the rookie who listened to the illegal orders! So don't say "it will NEVER happen", cause it already DID!

 

And all of this was done in the name of "public good"!

I.really don't give a crap what anyone thinks, if this can save innocent lives its worth the hassle, stop thinking about yourself and being so selfish to "your rights" and think of how many children were killed last year due to drive bys and gun incidents, that in some cases were executed by lawful gun owners using a gun In a unlawful fashion.

 

Absolutely disgusted.

HOOORRAAAAY for the Oathkeepers! But I'm still sorry that they even had to form-up............

 

Posse Comitadus got thrown out the window for Katrina, and now we got Holder pulling his Crap! What's next!?

They should offer a $1,000.00 for finding a law abiding citizen in Newark.

 

Could just see these gang bangers turning in their homies for the reward money...........good luck.

lol +1

Keep drinking the kool aid, have fun guys, I guess the logic.of lifestyle can be saved isn't enough for you. Hey at your meeting what flavor are they handing out now?

Wow man, My colors are RED WHITE AND BLUE

+1 zillion!

 

And what's really scary is the stupid Cops followed ILLEGAL ORDERS! All for a chance to get "Rambo'd-Up". Every one of there sorry asses ought to be fired retro-actively! Start with the Governor and the Mayor, and work your way down to the rookie who listened to the illegal orders! So don't say "it will NEVER happen", cause it already DID!

 

And all of this was done in the name of "public good"!

 

In California, LA county I believe, they went door to door to confiscate 'raw milk'......so what's to stop them from door to door confiscation of guns?

Is that what they say they are doing? No, don't u think there is a data base that says you own firearms? Wow Joe smo saya shame next store has a gun, its up to the leos to do there homework, obtain enough probable cause, get a judge to sign off on a warrantx execute the warrant, and do there jobs.

 

this is what they could do, do you think they will knock on your door and ask, i doubt it, most likely they are going to show up with a search warrant for said firearm..

I goto physical therapy and come out to read insults, stand up human beings, you gotta look.at the big picture, sry if my views aren't the same as yours, but as gun owners we need to see the benefits of taking illegal weapons off the street and out of the hands of people who's only intention is to harm.other or to use the weapon in the commission of a crime. I'm not disagreeing that gun ownership is a right, a fundamental part of the American way. And yes nj has some of the strict laws out there making it hard for some well intentioned people to practice there right. But these outlaws are the reason we have these laws. Firearms used in the commission of a crime must of shown an increase somewhere along the time to warrant law makers to have the laws that we do. And I'm not talking about awb, I'm talking about fid and pistol permits. Ot also explains the harsh jail time given to those who choose to not follow the laws. So if we sit back, take a deep breath and think "what can we do to resolve the laws that make it hard for individuals to purchase and obtain fire arms and ammo" maybe you can see its due to the increase of straw sales, guns purchased from out of state, or even fabricated firearms (zip guns), these laws may have been put in place to protect us. I'm given the oppurtunity to carry a gun everyday, and with that oppudtunity comes with the understanding that if you need my help in any situation that a Leo has a lawful purpose to intervien I have to. If not I am able to be found liable since I didn't get involved, both departmental and civily. So take a step back and dont see it as there trying to take my rights away, think of it as there trying to get the people off the street that didn't follow the rules. The same people are the reason for the laws. And if leos want to exhuast there time and effort to investigate and prosecute those who break the laws, its there choice , and they have every right to do so. I'm done, you guys can go back to talking crap. Enjoy your day everyone.

 

Bla bla bla bla bla.

WTF... " Your never, I say Never going to stop D bags from obtaining Illegal firearms ". So lets just invent new ways to harass LEGAL firearms owners.

Man! Between all the posts and videos, just spent 20+ minutes of my train commute on this post.. Wow.

 

I.really don't give a crap what anyone thinks, if this can save innocent lives its worth the hassle, stop thinking about yourself and being so selfish to "your rights" and think of how many children were killed last year due to drive bys and gun incidents, that in some cases were executed by lawful gun owners using a gun In a unlawful fashion.

 

Think about how many citizens have been robbed, raped, beaten, carjacked, etc because NJ gun laws....That should first be addressed! While we have all these laws, unarmed citizens, and large LE ratios we still have the sme murder rate as 15 years ago & it's going up. This $1000 has been around for a while and how much safer is Newark?

 

 

If your neighbors are the type to intentionally break the law and nobody in their right mind would turn them in for $1k.

I goto physical therapy and come out to read insults, stand up human beings, you gotta look.at the big picture, sry if my views aren't the same as yours, but as gun owners we need to see the benefits of taking illegal weapons off the street and out of the hands of people who's only intention is to harm.other or to use the weapon in the commission of a crime. I'm not disagreeing that gun ownership is a right, a fundamental part of the American way. And yes nj has some of the strict laws out there making it hard for some well intentioned people to practice there right. But these outlaws are the reason we have these laws. Firearms used in the commission of a crime must of shown an increase somewhere along the time to warrant law makers to have the laws that we do. And I'm not talking about awb, I'm talking about fid and pistol permits. Ot also explains the harsh jail time given to those who choose to not follow the laws. So if we sit back, take a deep breath and think "what can we do to resolve the laws that make it hard for individuals to purchase and obtain fire arms and ammo" maybe you can see its due to the increase of straw sales, guns purchased from out of state, or even fabricated firearms (zip guns), these laws may have been put in place to protect us. I'm given the oppurtunity to carry a gun everyday, and with that oppudtunity comes with the understanding that if you need my help in any situation that a Leo has a lawful purpose to intervien I have to. If not I am able to be found liable since I didn't get involved, both departmental and civily. So take a step back and dont see it as there trying to take my rights away, think of it as there trying to get the people off the street that didn't follow the rules. The same people are the reason for the laws. And if leos want to exhuast there time and effort to investigate and prosecute those who break the laws, its there choice , and they have every right to do so. I'm done, you guys can go back to talking crap. Enjoy your day everyone.

 

Nobody disagrees that getting illegal guns off the street is a good thing. However doing it by means that jeopardize the freedoms of law abiding people under the umbrella of "for the greater good" is against everything this country was founded on. Franklin's quote can't be repeated enough "Those who would give up Essential Liberty to purchase a little Temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety".

 

Truth of the matter is goverment programs like this rest on a very slippery slope. History has proven this time and time again. You say "don't see it as they are trying to take my rights away..." but this is exactly what is happening little by litte over time. Gun ownership in NJ is no longer a right.

 

 

 

cguiro, I think the salient point you are missing is that making laws under the guise of greater good, or for the children etc etc is simply the battle cry of the gun grabbers. It is NOT about keeping guns out of the hands of criminals. It just isnt. Why you ask? Becasue criminals do not care about the law!!!! You need to wrap your head around that fact. I respect your right to your opinion, but I consider it my duty to try and provide you with enough logic and reasoning to reconsider your position. Show me a law that affects the lawless! The law is only as good as those willing to obey them. So if criminals continue to disregard them, who is affected? Only the law abiding citizen. Now consider the fact you are in a gun grabing state and you have laws that are by design created to seperate everyone they can from their firearms. I can assure you there is a ton of cases proving this point ad nausium. Think about a restraining order for one second. Consider your own position. Think about the fact that all your wife or girlfriend has to do is make a complaint you threatened to kill her and pulls a RO. You are guilty until proven innocent! You will have all personal weapons stripped of you, all without jury or trial!!! Now lets add a component. Lets say the Mayor has decided that LE domestic violence is an issue and will pay $1000 to anyone turning in their spouse or any case where the wife of an Officer they know are being abused! Reaching..yes. Same thought process? YES!

 

Ill tell you something. A KEY part of the problem is the focus on the item instead of the individual. I used to believe that their should be greater penalties for crimes comitted with a gun. I no longer think that way. The item used should not matter one bit. It creates a deamonisation and in my mind can actualle lessen view of the severity of what the actual perpetrator did because it almost becomes an excuse! Because society starts thinking the item is eveil, not the person. That is what has happened with firearms. If someone puts someones brains on the counter with a rolling pin or a pistol, the focus should remain on the person that killed another, not the item used. The largest mass muders were commited with airplanes and locks and chains and a couple of gallons of gas. Person to person murders are by and far much higher by devices that bare the name luisville slugger on the side but there is no greater punishment for killing someone with a baseball bat because the item has not been demonised and the focus remains where it should, on the person that did the killing!!! But as law abiding citizens we want to preserve our right and fall into the trap of thinking there should be a greater punsihment. This is the thinking process of a lawfull citizen who knows he will never be in the catagory of criminal. BUT I think it is flawed thinking because it perpetuates the demonization.

 

Very very well said. Could not have said it better myself. I really do not think that there is anyone on here that can say it any better than this.

This seems to be an issue more pertaining to the intent of the Fourth Amendment than the Second. I think the point that most people here are trying to make, some more colorfully than others, is that people have a right to be secure in their own homes and should not be subject to unreasonable searches or seizures. Adding an incentive for citizens to call police based on unfounded suspicion of a neighbor's activities has several problems, both legal and philosophical.

 

People in the gun community should know well that there are a lot of people in this country and especially this state that are ignorant about firearms. Few have an interest in how they operate and even fewer have any level of knowledge about what is legal and what it not. We consistently reject and condemn knee-jerk legislation based off the fear of black guns and "military-style assault weapons", because we understand that it doesn't matter what the firearm looks like or what the public perception of it is.

 

Now, with the topic at hand here, there is an incentive for people to spew that ignorance, fear, and/or prejudice at a law abiding citizen's expense. As many members here pointed out, there are some firearms that people own very legally but do not possess paperwork for because it wasn't necessary at the time. They are not breaking any law, and the idea that "if you're doing nothing wrong you have nothing to be afraid of" is inherently totalitarian and counter to the founding principles of this country. We are innocent until proven guilty and should never be subject to such actions.

 

The idea that all this changes because we are now talking about firearms is flawed because that is not the point. Should people be incentivized to call the police with the suspicion that their neighbor is driving without insurance?

 

No.

 

Law abiding citizens now have something to be afraid of, regardless of the fact that they have done nothing wrong.

 

That is the point.

Very well put Sarge! And Shane gets a +1 Zillion for hitting the nail on the head too!

  • Author

Amen Brother............

 

Next they'll be pulling out the Race Card to get what they want...........Oooops.........I see it.... yup I see it comming.

 

Wahla........Newark.

The crime ridden, gang infested cess pool that it was and.... IMO......always will be.

And us poor folk want that tousand that's comming to us.....hell I'll rat out anybody for a tousand.......and I mean anybody.....call the Mayor...get my money.

Holy crap guys... give him a break.

 

Personally, I think more people should listen to an interview Booker did with someone on Bloomberg radio about OGAM. He was against it, citing it was stupid legislation. As per him, in the past 5 or 10 years, there have been ZERO crimes committed in Newark with LEGALLY purchased guns... which he is on the record, has no issues with.

 

Honestly, I support it, for Newark.

 

For all the people who are screaming against it... what is your solution?

 

If some character is walking around the neighborhood with a gun tucked into the front of his pants, quite suspicious... or you know commits crime, why wouldn't you inform someone about it?

 

This has NOTHING to do with legal gun ownerships. As gun owners, we should be supporting lawful gun ownership, if you see a guy dealing drugs or god forbid worse... what do you do? nothing because you are afraid it will come back to you?

 

Or you know someone habitually drives drunk... do you not do anything about it because you feel it will lead to more LEO pulling you over?

 

Keep in mind, lawful people will follow the laws, it is the criminals who don't give a rats butt. stop protecting the criminals.

 

Yes, my view may be different because I have meet Booker a few times in the professional circles and believe I know what his stance is on gun ownership. For the rest of the people... stop being soooooo jaded and at the very least... take the advertisement at face value.... and not "turn in your neighbor"

 

BarknBite... I seriously expected a commercial where Booker is urging you to turn in any gun owner. -1 sir.

 

If anyone does not agree with me... I don't care. =)

This seems to be an issue more pertaining to the intent of the Fourth Amendment than the Second. I think the point that most people here are trying to make, some more colorfully than others, is that people have a right to be secure in their own homes and should not be subject to unreasonable searches or seizures. Adding an incentive for citizens to call police based on unfounded suspicion of a neighbor's activities has several problems, both legal and philosophical.

 

People in the gun community should know well that there are a lot of people in this country and especially this state that are ignorant about firearms. Few have an interest in how they operate and even fewer have any level of knowledge about what is legal and what it not. We consistently reject and condemn knee-jerk legislation based off the fear of black guns and "military-style assault weapons", because we understand that it doesn't matter what the firearm looks like or the public perception of it that matters.

 

Now, with the topic at hand here, there is an incentive for people to spew that ignorance, fear, and/or prejudice at a law abiding citizen's expense. As many members here pointed out, there are some firearms that people own very legally but do not possess paperwork for because it wasn't necessary at the time. They are not breaking any law, and the idea that "if you're doing nothing wrong you have nothing to be afraid of" is inherently totalitarian and counter to the founding principles of this country. We are innocent until proven guilty and should never be subject to such actions.

 

The idea that all this changes because we are now talking about firearms is flawed because that is not the point. Should people be incentivized to call the police with the suspicion that their neighbor is driving without insurance?

 

No.

 

Law abiding citizens now have something to be afraid of, regardless of the fact that they have done nothing wrong.

 

That is the point.

 

This is all assuming the police will knock down your door 5 mins after they get a phone call. I would expect the LEO to do some sort of an investigation before arresting you. I have faith in most of the LEO community out there.

 

If my door was busted simply because an annon person made a phone call.... I would sue the shit out of the city.

 

And us poor folk want that tousand that's comming to us.....hell I'll rat out anybody for a tousand.......and I mean anybody.....call the Mayor...get my money.

 

We do not really enforce proper english here, however at least type something that makes sense and with less spelling errors.

We do not really enforce proper english here, however at least type something that makes sense and with less spelling errors.

 

You obviously have not read any of cguiros posts. For if you have then you would have noticed the strange use of punctuation, grammar, sentence structure and spelling. Just putting it out there. Oh and the improper use of there, they're and their.

I would expect the LEO to do some sort of an investigation before arresting you.

 

I would expect you to know better than to expect that. There are plenty of documented incidents of mistaken identity, wrong address, or my daily favorite "The Wrong F-ing Shawn T Moore born in 1981"!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.