Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Ok so I think I'm in the market for my first .22

Featured Replies

Got a couple permits ready next week and debating what to get. I dont have a .22 yet and like the thought of having a cheap ammo in large supply. I have a short list which I am sort of on the fence about. You'll notice the Buckmarks and Mark iii's and such arent appealing to me. I'm looking for what I hesitate to call a "fighting" style pistol.

 

1. Sig 1911-22 in OD I dont know if I ought to just buy the AA .22 conversion for my Colt

2. Ruger SR22 Reviews seem good but I'm not sure if its too small and heard not great things about the trigger

3. M&P22 Seems like a nice pistol but I'm not a huge fan of the M&P line.

4. Walther P22 Tried it once and it felt like a toy. Kinda why I'm afraid of getting the Ruger. Pretty much last.

 

Looking to spend around 400. Anyone have thoughts or any other suggestions?

I'm a HUGE fan of the Ruger Mark 2/3 series, so I'd like to reccomend you to reconsider, but if you already made your mind up so be it.

 

 

I've shot the M&P22, which belongs to a shooting buddy. It's been problematic for him, And personally I do not like they way they feel. Feels to much like a toy ( as do most the all plastic 22s )

 

The Sig 1911-22 / GSG 1911 - From what i've observed, they've been hit or miss. I've seen more than one that cannot get through a string of 25 rounds without jamming at least once or twice. But i've also seen the odd ball out, who runs pretty good most the time. Again, IMO - They are hit or miss.

 

Lastly, IMO - a Ruger Mark 2/3 w/ bull barrel is the best .22 pistol money can buy. It actually feels like a real gun and has some weight to it due it's steel design. Mine has been the most accurate / fastest / and realiable pistol I own. I've shot probably over 10,000 rounds through it so far this year and I can count on one hand how many times i've had a issue ( mostly ammo related )

 

Good luck with your choice.

  • Author

Well here's the thing, my other permit will be going to a ruger 22/45 that I will be keeping in my possesion until my brother has the adequate licenses. (No its not a straw purchase, It will be my gun in my possesion at all times until he is ready to buy it off of me.) So I'll have that for the time being. I don't really like them to begin with so I'm exploring other options.

 

I definitley know abouty their great reliability and accuracy. No debate there.

those smith model 41 are real nice if you can cough up the $$$ or find a used one.

the important thing for me is how easy or difficult it is to dissemble them for cleaning.

check out some youtubes to find out more

The walther and ruger are too small and toy like. The m&p is full sized, just like a m&p9 without the changeable back straps. It is a little on the light side and just doesn't have a solid feel to it. I have one with about 5000 rounds through it and it runs great as long as I don't load the mags to 12. I also have a Sig 1911-22 waiting for me as soon as my permits get here. It definitely feels more like a real gun and not toy like at all. I'm just hoping I get a good one.

What about a used Hi Standard they are great guns accurate as hell and dont have that toy feel.

If you like the feel of the full size pistol you might just want to get a 1911 .22 conversion. If you are looking for a dedicated my brother purchased a sig 1911 .22 which is basically the GSG pistol with a lifetime warrenty. He has had it for over a year and its been an excellent gun. The only drawback is the slide is light and the mag holds ten rounds but they are really nice! If you wanted greater capasity you could go wth a Sig Mosquito.

 

http://www.sigsauer....ls/1911-22.aspx

 

http://www.sigsauer.com/CatalogProductList/pistols-mosquito.aspx

  • Author

I purposefully left the mosquito off becuase ive heard terrible reviews on them. So far the sig 1911 is my first choice.

Browning Buckmark Camper. Cannot recommend it enough. Accurate, eats any ammo, easy to clean.

I'd skip the mosquito as well, good call.

 

We saw one break in two , slide cracked in half, at a steel challenge match last weekend. Pretty ridiculous for a 22

  • Author

I'd skip the mosquito as well, good call.

 

We saw one break in two , slide cracked in half, at a steel challenge match last weekend. Pretty ridiculous for a 22

 

What the hell? Do they make them out of?

What the hell? Do they make them out of?

 

aluminum-zinc alloy

aluminum-zinc alloy

 

Same thing the sig and GSG 1911 .22s are made of....

  • Author

Is it just the design then? A slide cracking in 2 seems odd

Probably a rare occurrence ... Maybe that gun took a big fall or something to damage the slide -- I can't imagine it being a common problem and still on the market

It was a clean break, like you cut it in half with a saw.

I have big hands, and still feel comfortable with my SR22. Its a great gun. I have about 1000rds through without a single malfunction. It has a much more solid feel than the M&P in my opinion. The trigger kind of sucks in DA, but SA is great. I would buy again definitely

Alec, stop watching me shoot mine... lol While I do have the occasional issue with my GSG1911-22 but I do use bulk ammo but really like the gun and it's fun to shoot.

 

My father picked up the SR22, I like it, but for a plinker it's fine, if you plan on shooting OBRAMS or Static Steel I'd pick another.

 

With that said, if I could only have 1 22LR Handgun, it would be the Ruger MKII or MKIII, especially the MKIII Hunter like my wife has. Just an all around great gun for anything you want to do with it IMHO.

  • Author

Alec, stop watching me shoot mine... lol While I do have the occasional issue with my GSG1911-22 but I do use bulk ammo but really like the gun and it's fun to shoot.

 

My father picked up the SR22, I like it, but for a plinker it's fine, if you plan on shooting OBRAMS or Static Steel I'd pick another.

 

With that said, if I could only have 1 22LR Handgun, it would be the Ruger MKII or MKIII, especially the MKIII Hunter like my wife has. Just an all around great gun for anything you want to do with it IMHO.

 

Would you consider the 1911-22 a better gun for steel? I'm not shooting any now but may in the future.

I have big hands, and still feel comfortable with my SR22. Its a great gun. I have about 1000rds through without a single malfunction. It has a much more solid feel than the M&P in my opinion. The trigger kind of sucks in DA, but SA is great. I would buy again definitely

 

I'll second that (although I don't have big hands). Plus, as others have noted, it handles any ammo. I run Federal bulk through mine without any problems.

Would you consider the 1911-22 a better gun for steel? I'm not shooting any now but may in the future.

 

a lot of us run 1911 .22s for steel -- none of us have had zero malfunctions -- everyone I've seen is running bulk pack ammo - switch to Mini Mags and it'll probably run better

 

Now the ruger MK series usually runs flawlessly with bulk pack ammo -- I guess it just depends how serious you are shooting steel -- I find the 1911 a ton of fun but if I want to be fast I'll shoot the MKIII hunter

  • Author

I think the sign is still in the lead. I'm gonna have to call around and get some prices.

If my PD holds true to form, I should have my permits this week. As soon as I get them, i will be picking up my Sig. You are welcome to try the Sig and M&P side by side.

a lot of us run 1911 .22s for steel -- none of us have had zero malfunctions -- everyone I've seen is running bulk pack ammo - switch to Mini Mags and it'll probably run better

 

Now the ruger MK series usually runs flawlessly with bulk pack ammo -- I guess it just depends how serious you are shooting steel -- I find the 1911 a ton of fun but if I want to be fast I'll shoot the MKIII hunter

 

I hear good things about the upgrades for the sig/gsg1911-22.

 

i think most are here:

http://www.cwaccessories.com/Products.html

  • Author

If my PD holds true to form, I should have my permits this week. As soon as I get them, i will be picking up my Sig. You are welcome to try the Sig and M&P side by side.

 

I appreciate the offer but by the time we're both free I'll probably have bought one haha.

i have the sr22. i love it. i dont think it feels like a toy at all. i love that it eats up any ammo you feed it. From the research i did, alot of .22 pistols are picky on ammo. ruger shoots cheap bulk ammo with no problem. plus its the cheapest on your list i think. its on sale right now for 288. thats a steal

http://www.kygunco.com/ruger-sr22-pistol-22lr-black-35-10rd-57389

  • Author

Is there any reason some of you guys say that the Ruger ISN"T a good pistol for steel? The more reviews I read the better it looks.

I have an m&p 22, 6-7k through it amd its been pretty much flawless on various bulk. It's a little light, but its full size and everything is in the sane place as my m&p 9.

Is there any reason some of you guys say that the Ruger ISN"T a good pistol for steel? The more reviews I read the better it looks.

 

I don't know that it's not good for steel. I guess the shorter sight radius would make the longer shots a little tougher. Nothing a little practice wouldn't fix though. My only problem with the SR22 is the overall size of the gun.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.