October 26, 201214 yr I'm typically not one to be alarmist. But, in the earlier thread about 2014 game proposals there is a discussion about opening up small game hunting to air rifles. Now, personally, i think this sounds like a heck of a lot of fun. BUT, I can't help but think about our cousins across the pond and their firearms laws. One of the things keeping us hunting with shotguns is an ability to say, "Hey! we're not allowed to hunt with air rifles" By allowing crossbow use during fall and winter bow season, I'm sure there is an added benefit for antis that fewer people will use firearms in favor of crossbows because of the longer season. Should we be worried that we'll find ourselves ONLY allowed to hunt with air guns? Maybe I'm off base because NJF&W set the guidelines and they are hardly mad up of anti-gunners/anti-hunters. What are your thoughts?
October 26, 201214 yr Maybe its for squirrel hunting I've seen large feral hogs taken down by large caliber air rifles on You Tube but I too thought of squirrel,rabbits and pigeons when air rifles is mentioned.
October 26, 201214 yr Author Yes. The regulation proposed is for squirrel and rabbits. Mourning Doves are apparently too beautiful to kill even though they are the most widely consumed game bird on the planet. My question is...can this be used as a back door means to restrict firearm use? In the UK, there really isn't big game to hunt. So, shotguns can be used for upland birds and waterfowl (side by side and O/U only), but only air rifles can be used for ground game. I think the ADDITION of Air Rifle as a legal hunting weapon is a great thing. I also think we should be able to hunt squirrels and rabbits with .22lr rifles and handguns. I just would hate it if other weapons use for hunting was restricted, that's all.
October 26, 201214 yr The first step in restricting something is passing legislation that controls or taxes it. At first glance, it may sound like you're "getting" something, but that's the trick: once you allow them to have control of it, it's theirs, and they can do whatever they want, with precedent. Frankly, even some people here may think this extreme, but imho EVERY gun control law, including the 1932 one banning automatic weapons, is an infringement of our 2nd amendment right. As "reasonable" as it may have sounded at the time, it's been a slippery slope ever since.
October 26, 201214 yr Tell you what, let me use the highpower airguns for deer and I'll gladly not hunt with shotguns. Another way to look at it, is that NJ is getting closer to the rest of the country where hunting small game with air rifles is NOT illegal, an no one banned shotguns in all those other states.
October 26, 201214 yr ...but imho EVERY gun control law, including the 1932 one banning automatic weapons... What law was that?
October 26, 201214 yr I'm typically not one to be alarmist. But, in the earlier thread about 2014 game proposals there is a discussion about opening up small game hunting to air rifles. Now, personally, i think this sounds like a heck of a lot of fun. BUT, I can't help but think about our cousins across the pond and their firearms laws. One of the things keeping us hunting with shotguns is an ability to say, "Hey! we're not allowed to hunt with air rifles" By allowing crossbow use during fall and winter bow season, I'm sure there is an added benefit for antis that fewer people will use firearms in favor of crossbows because of the longer season. Should we be worried that we'll find ourselves ONLY allowed to hunt with air guns? Maybe I'm off base because NJF&W set the guidelines and they are hardly mad up of anti-gunners/anti-hunters. What are your thoughts? You bring up a compelling point. I think it was no small coincidence that Sunday bowhunting and a change to the safety zone limit to 150' was implemented to accommodate and curtail the ever-growing deer population in a state with diminishing open land, while remaining a favorable solution to some by not introducing firearm hunting into the mix. And of course, added seasons, permits and doe and buck tags bring needed fee income to keep the F&W program alive. Will firearms be allowed for hunting twenty or thirty years from now? What say you? Opening game seasons up to include airguns for small game is a good way to spark interest with existing hunters and bring new hunters afield in a state where license sales continue to go down. But it could present a slippery slope as you indicate. The additional use of rifle for certain species certainly adds a new twist, but its use and breath is limited to certain areas. Some points to ponder: New Jersey loses on average 7,000 acres per year to sprawl and development. Less land each year, less places to shoot and hunt. Fewer hunters buy hunting licenses to hunt each year. The state has to be progressive for the F&W program to succeed. As for allowing handgun hunting in New Jersey, well, I doubt that will never happen. I am pretty sure there are only two states in the U.S. that don't allow handgun hunting. Rhode Island is one, New Jersey is the other. (Yes, you CAN handgun hunt in every other state, of course with some restrictions.) Dove hunting? Maybe someday, but birdwatchers think they're a songbird in this state and have expressed their displeasure to hunting them for some time now. And their voice is effective. Quoting the state's chief biologist; "The anti-hunters are more organized and better prepared than the hunters." On a side note, each year my friends get together for an early -season squirrel hunt in the Stewart Land Co-Op in New York. While that county is designated for handgun and rifle use, neither are allowed on the Stewart property. So my friends take their scoped pellet guns and sharpen their skills on some bushytails.
October 26, 201214 yr Author Let me interject here tht after some googling, I see I was very wrong. There is extensive deer shooting in the United Kingdom. High power rifles are permitted ...with SUPPRESSORS!
October 26, 201214 yr I have heard they have shotgun suppressors over there as well, but I never see any details. We certainly don't have them here. There are obvious technical challenges that supposedly make them large and not highly effective. But I'd still like to see it.
October 27, 201214 yr Let me interject here tht after some googling, I see I was very wrong. There is extensive deer shooting in the United Kingdom. High power rifles are permitted ...with SUPPRESSORS! No centerfire pump action or semi-atutomatics though. Can only have those in .22 rimfire. And don't you dare show up at a driven pheasant shoot with the Queen sporting a Beretta 391. While they are allowed, you'll be labeled a heathen despite your smart looking tweeds.
October 27, 201214 yr Author The game laws seem to require a rifle caliber above .243 on up to 30-06. Not sure if semi autos are allowed but it seems that the permission of Suppressors is as a courtesy to the neighbors. Lol. Fancy that.
October 27, 201214 yr The game laws seem to require a rifle caliber above .243 on up to 30-06. Not sure if semi autos are allowed but it seems that the permission of Suppressors is as a courtesy to the neighbors. Lol. Fancy that. Google "Hushpower." Very popular over there. Then look at the Hastings Metro Barrel. Legal here in the U.S. (only a bit awkward.) Not exactly a silencer, but it reduces noise. http://www.metrogun.com/ http://www.midwayusa...y-12-gauge-blue
October 27, 201214 yr 1932 the uniform machine gun act: In 1932, a Uniform Machine Gun Act[23] was presented by the Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws. Therein, the possession or use of a machine gun of any kind for offensive purpose is declared to be a crime. Such possession or use is presumed if the gun is found on premises not owned or rented for legitimate use by the possessor or user of the gun; if the gun is in possession of, or used by, either an unnaturalized foreigner or a person previously convicted of a crime of violence; if the machine gun is of the kind most commonly used by criminals and has not been registered as provided in the Act; or if shells adapted to use in that particular weapon are found in the immediate vicinity, thereof. ...that started it all with regards to automatic weapons.
October 27, 201214 yr 1932 the uniform machine gun act: In 1932, a Uniform Machine Gun Act[23] was presented by the Conference of Commissioners on Uniform State Laws. Therein, the possession or use of a machine gun of any kind for offensive purpose is declared to be a crime. Such possession or use is presumed if the gun is found on premises not owned or rented for legitimate use by the possessor or user of the gun; if the gun is in possession of, or used by, either an unnaturalized foreigner or a person previously convicted of a crime of violence; if the machine gun is of the kind most commonly used by criminals and has not been registered as provided in the Act; or if shells adapted to use in that particular weapon are found in the immediate vicinity, thereof. ...that started it all with regards to automatic weapons. That didn't ban automatic weapons. You said "EVERY gun control law, including the 1932 one banning automatic weapons"
October 27, 201214 yr Oh, my, please forgive me for not being 100% clear.... I also said in my last post "that started it all"... 1934 the national firearms act: It has been unlawful since 1934 (The National Firearms Act) for civilians to own machine guns without special permission from the U.S. Treasury Department. Machine guns are subject to a $200 tax every time their ownership changes from one federally registered owner to another, and each new weapon is subject to a manufacturing tax when it is made, and it must be registered with the Bureau of Alcohol Tobacco and Firearms and Explosives (ATF) in its National Firearms Registry. My point is, look up the definition of infringe. Our 2nd Amendment rights have been infringed upon for a very long time now. Regardless of what anyone may "think" about it, we have every right to own a machine gun or any other type of firearm, if we so choose. Anything restricting that is an infringement.
October 27, 201214 yr Not at all, that was just why I asked in the first place. You said there was a law banning automatic weapons in 1932 and I knew it wasn't federal and was pretty sure it wasn't jersey so I was just trying to see what you were talking about. I thought maybe you were mistakenly referring to the NFA or knew something about jersey law I didn't know. Anyway, it obviously doesn't matter, thanks for the response. And, yes, when I asked about it, I certainly should have already known that in the future you would have said something different
October 27, 201214 yr Anyway, it obviously doesn't matter, thanks for the response. And, yes, when I asked about it, I certainly should have already known that in the future you would have said something different When I research, I tend to go back to the BEGINNING.... what started things... hence my reference to 1932. For example, when I discuss the economy and fed (bank), I take it all the way back to the beginning... with Alexander Hamilton. It and it wasn't called the "fed" then, and it wasn't the EXACT same thing it is now, but that's where it all came from.
October 27, 201214 yr It is a good point to reflect on. However i am pretty sure there is a very small percentage of hunters taking squirrel with shotgun. If it were to lead to less distance from a building with a pellet gun it would mean that homeowners with enough land could actually make a dent in the squirrel population. In my area there are battalions of squirrels running around. My neighbor had some wiring in his car chewed through and said he would love it if I were to pop a few. Like ya, sure, I'll just shoot 'em with a 12 gauge in suburban morris county. Give me a whisper air rifle and a permissive law and my backyard will be the valley of death, with my neighbors blessings. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
October 27, 201214 yr Author However i am pretty sure there is a very small percentage of hunters taking squirrel with shotgun. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk What gives you this idea? Outside of the specific muzzleloader season for squirrel (.32 or smaller caliber), you may only take squirrel by way of a shotgun or bow.
October 27, 201214 yr However i am pretty sure there is a very small percentage of hunters taking squirrel with shotgun. Based on the N.J. 2011-2012 Hunter and Trapper Harvest, Recreational and Economic Survey, (in a year where the licenses sold in the State were the lowest since 1912,) of the 4,052 participants surveyed, an estimated 22,559 firearm hunters took an estimated 34,011 gray squirrels during the regular firearm season. Squirrel season opens Sept. 29., and except for days during the deer season where it's closed, goes until February 18. And there are more than a handful of people who hunt them with a regular bow or crossbow as well. An estimate of high and low harvest, broken down by shotgun vs. muzzleloader: Gray squirrel – shotgun only LOW -29,277 HIGH-37,481 Gray squirrel – ML rifle only LOW -1,899 HIGH-2,698 Squirrel total - LOW -29,720 HIGH-38,303 All of this info can be found on the State's Division of Fish & Wildlife website.
October 27, 201214 yr Well I guess i am mistaken. But 22,000 hunters taking 34,000 squirrel is barley 1.5 per hunter. I do know for me walking around the nearest WMA with a shotgun looking for squirrels... Seems there could be a better use of my time, but that's just my opinion. But in light of the stats and going back to my other post, in my neighborhood shooting squirrels with a shotgun at a WMA isn't going to do anything to reduce the population on my street. And I wouldn't be likely to take an air rifle to a WMA to do that either. So, again, if it were to mean I wouldn't need a farm to hunt squirrel with an air rifle and I could use it in my own back yard it would be a bonus. I doubt it will though. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
October 27, 201214 yr Author There were 22k firearm hunters total. Not all hunt squirrels. This figure includes deer, upland bird, waterfowl, rabbit and varmint. Daily bag limit is 5. Personally, I wouldn't hunt neighborhood squirrels just based on the density of my town and zero discharge. I for some reason would rather shot a squirrel from te woods for table fare
October 27, 201214 yr There were 22k firearm hunters total. Not all hunt squirrels. This figure includes deer, upland bird, waterfowl, rabbit and varmint. Daily bag limit is 5. Personally, I wouldn't hunt neighborhood squirrels just based on the density of my town and zero discharge. I for some reason would rather shot a squirrel from te woods for table fare Well ya, i know that it is the total number of hunters. But then numbers don't make it seem there is a great number of hunters going for squirrel. Obviously some do,i don't see it as popular. As far as table fare, you and I are on exactly opposite ends of the spectrum. Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
October 27, 201214 yr Author Meaning you wouldn't shoot one for table fare at all? Or that you'd rather take one that roots around in dumpsters over one that eats white oak acorns?
October 27, 201214 yr But 22,000 hunters taking 34,000 squirrel is barley 1.5 per hunter. But not all hunters hunt squirrel, and not all hunters are 100% successful. Small game numbers for 2011-2012: "Active firearm hunters harvested an estimated 64,981 northern bobwhite, 21,948 chukar partridge, 35,780 crows, 837 ruffed grouse, 234,748 pheasants, 4,630 woodcock, 387 eastern coyotes, 1,527 red fox, 34,011 gray squirrels, 44,451 rabbits and hares, 1,588 raccoons, 517 opossums, and 16,447 woodchucks while enjoying 286,694 recreation-days afield during 2011-12." The State takes into account game birds that are purchased, stocked and then taken on private preserves & semi-wild clubs. Hence the high numbers for quail, chukar, and pheasant. Squirrel is at the bottom of the food chart for most people. Woodcock and grouse numbers are low because there just aren't many of them around anymore, many people don't hunt them anymore, and only diehard hunters with bird dogs seem to get the most enjoyment pursuing them. They are only two of the wild native gamebirds left that the State has to offer. Quail is considered a native gamebird in New Jersey but its decline has been disastrous in the last 100 years. The State is underway with their N.J. Northern Bobwhite Action Plan now. Their goal is to reproduce the population density back to 1980 levels. On a sidenote: "Survey results estimate that small-game hunting related activities provided over $9.3 million to the State’s economy during 2011-12, compared to 11.1 million in 2009-10. In addition, the NJDFW received $3.378 million from sales of firearm licenses, pheasant/quail stamps and special coyote permits." This is another one of the important reasons the State tracks hunter numbers and game harvests.
October 27, 201214 yr Author I'm not into harvesting animals that don't wind up in the pot. I've not tried squirrel yet. If it turns out that I don't like them , I shan't be killing any more of them.
October 28, 201214 yr I'm not into harvesting animals that don't wind up in the pot. I've not tried squirrel yet. If it turns out that I don't like them , I shan't be killing any more of them. Me either. Not judging, but I don't get the killing for "sport" thing, regardless of the animal. I have a friend who shoots groundhogs out his bedroom window, "for fun". I don't get it. For me to pull the trigger and take a life- any life- there has to be a reason other than "fun", like "food" or "self defense." Just mho.
October 28, 201214 yr Any animal messes with my shit or does anything to even annoy me and I have no problem dusting it. Add that to "food" and "self-defense." That being said, I haven't killed a single mammal other than mice in 10 years so my philosophy is clearly tempered by a lack of blood lust. And not for lack of opportunity. I could shoot anything on my property at any time. Like you said, I don't kill animals without a reason. Last year there was a young crow that moved in and was calling at 0500. I decided to blast his ass but never got a good shot. Within a couple weeks he either moved on or the established crows taught him how it works. Crows don't call around these parts. They show up in large murders, eat bugs for a few minutes, keep their yaps shut, and fly away if they see people. You have to be careful to even peak at them through a window so that you don't send them away. They are very smart birds and they know some people will shoot them so they just try to keep a low profile near homes and crops. If you can shoot groundhogs from your bedroom window then you probably have a good reason to shoot them other than "fun." They are destructive. I have groundhogs on my property once in a while but they haven't dug any new holes near my house so I just yell at them and/or chase them off. If they started digging near my house, fences, or in my lawn then I'd blast them, too.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.