Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

So, should we all get ready to say goodbye to our guns?

Featured Replies

  • Replies 88
  • Views 8.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

For him to get anything through the congress he's gonna have to bend on alot of things..Gun control would be a smart one for him to give on to appease the Rep.House majority. Like Maks said..he needs help to pass his legacy items(tax, economy , healthcare). Leaving gun and ammo alone would be an easy pill for him to swallow. I think the immediate hysteria and buying craze is not necessary and just gonna remove large amounts of money from peoples pockets..along with that OUT OF STOCK message next to everything

At this point, 4 years of gridlock is the best we can hope for.

I don't think anything is going to happen. Obama has bigger fish to fry with the economy, and with the political climate the way it is, there's no chance he can sneak legislation past both the house and the senate without the public being made aware by the NRA. I also happen to think he doesn't care that much about guns. He may have mentioned a possible reinstatement of an AWB in one debate, but it was never a primary talking point.

 

I don't see any cases going to the supreme court that will ruin gun ownership across the board. I don't see a feasible AWB (not that it would have a huge effect on us in NJ, presuming the language is identical to the federal one (that was based off NJ law anyway)).

 

Besides, Obama said he might want to get an AWB enacted. Romney actually signed one. I think a lot of this fear is being mongered by the industry and is highly exaggerated.

 

Actually Romeny didnt En act the ma AWB, he reinforced it..however it was a package deal that eased some other restrictions on Gun owners in Ma at the same time....Kind of like FOPA..FOPA brought us the Hughes Ammendment that closed the MG Registry, BUT It also ALLOWED Mail-order Ammunition, Gave protections for travelling, and several other beneficial things. Hughes was supposed to have been the "Poison Pill" that Killed FOPA, but it was passed anyway.

I'm just gonna be a criminal. I don't have to worry about CCW laws or 'justifiable need' or magazine caps or folding stocks or bayonet lugs, etc. Life is so much easier. /s

What guns? I don't have any guns.

 

Holy cow! Something just occured to me - do you guys ALL own guns?!?!

 

Oh my Goodness! We're surrounded by gun nuts on this board!

 

In all seriousness, Gun control is a liberal Shibboleth. It's one of those things that they (and yes, I'm a liberal) like to wave around to fire up the base, but they want to maintain their distance from any real laws. There were consequences for Clinton in 1996 with the AWB.

 

The president has his hands full right now. They'll roll Lautenberg out every few months and they'll wake him up, he'll mumble something anti-gun and they'll wheel him back into the crypt. But I doubt anything anti-gun will come out of it.

 

Don't forget that Republicans still own the house, and there are plenty of pro-gun Democrats in southern and midwestern states.

 

The Supreme Court is a more problematic, but if he packs the court with anti-gun democrats, there is always the option of a 28th Amendment.

 

It's a beautiful system when you think about it. Plenty of checks and balances...

I think hurricane sandy might have more to do with the next few gun rights battles in NY& NJ.

 

I know what it will makes the politicians think, but i know many more people that are now talking about getting a gun than I did before.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Don't want to hijack but were any of you guys around for the 1st AWB? How did that work, was it the features game like in NJ? Or were things like Semi auto ARs banned outright?

 

I don't remember reading about a turn in of guns just you couldn't buy them, is that how it worked? I would be most concerned about the turn in thing because like many here I paid a lot for my guns and I can't see how they could pass anything making us turn them in without reimbursement.

 

Also thankfully to us that the tv gun shows and stuff are contributing to gun sales so it would be hard to ban the sale of guns outright when these US based companies, see ruger, are thriving right now

I dont really think anything is going to change. Things will jump in prince for a while but I think that will be it. I believe it was last year when a bunch of democratic senators put forth a letter to Obama that they wont sign anything further restricting gun ownership. Granted they are politicians and change opinions on a whim, but it gives me some hope

Don't want to hijack but were any of you guys around for the 1st AWB? How did that work, was it the features game like in NJ? Or were things like Semi auto ARs banned outright?

 

I didn't own a gun when the first AWB was passed, but I got my FID during the AWB. You didn't have to turn in your guns for the federal law, you just couldn't buy new ones, although you could transfer an existing gun to somebody else.

 

Basically if someone waved a magic wand and *poof* you had an assault weapons ban re-enacted, the only thing you would see different in NJ would be that you could only have 10 round magazines. The rest of the country would be just like NJ when it came to possession - no evil features, although states would still have the same carry and purchase laws. The federal ban didn't change any of that.

 

"Assault Weapons" and standard capacity magazines were grandfathered in federally. You could still own "assault weapons" and standard capacity magazines, you just couldn't sell new weapons to the public.

 

The federal ban was modeled after New Jersey's ban. So, yes, it was a features game.

 

So in a nutshell, if a federal AWB ever appeared again in the same form, you would hardly notice. That doesn't mean that I want to see it, though. I like my 15 rounders.

we have no one to blame but ourselves really. 10% of NJ residents own firearms and yet, we don't band together to effect change we want. We have gun states voting for dems......

 

I will NEVER give them up and I feel many patriots out there feel the same way

 

I'm hoping Texas smartens up and secedes so I can move to a real American country:)

In the remote, very remote chance they managed to pass some registration legislation or 'confiscation'. The U.S. doesn't have a pot to piss in to financially implement such a radical gun control scheme, and no resources to go the proverbial "door to door" for 'enforcement'... Look what happened in Canada, there are less people in that country, and they have lower gun ownership as well and they could not manage it.

 

 

Canada spent a well over a billion dollars on their gun registration and even then there was very low compliance.

 

http://www.saf.org/journal/15/abilliondollarslater.pdf

 

Only 25 to 30% Complied

 

 

Page 20/49 "Compliance with registration, the most objectionable part of the Act, came only grudgingly. By mid-December, 2001, only 312,000 gun owners, less than 18% of the 1.76 million owners then licensed, had so far registered 1.9 million guns, including previously registered handguns. As registrations increased, by late April, 2002, 1,034,376 licensed owners had registered 3,725,195 firearms.38 This included slightly over half of then-licensed owners but only 25-30% of the best estimates of firearms numbers.."

 

The cost was astronomical

 

"It is quite possible by now that the grand-total of all-government costs of the Firearms Act may already even approach $2-3 billion."

 

 

 

Protest

 

A person from Manitoba went so far to protest the 'system' by successfully registering his soldering gun. They decided not to prosecute him.

 

 

 

They discontinued the registration in Canada. It was unpopular, unworkable, costly and not many complied.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Canadian_Firearms_Registry

 

"On February 15, 2012 Bill C-19 was passed in the House of Commons (159 to 130) with support from the Conservatives and two NDP MPs. On April 4, 2012 Bill C-19 passed third reading in the Senate by a vote of 50-27 and received royal assent from the Governor General on April 5............"

We're likely going to lose the supreme court, so I'm wondering, what do you guys think will happen?

 

Why do you think that, because of advertising?

 

Most justices in relatively recent history have served into their 80s or 90s. They get some insane health care, on par or better than sitting presidents. To sit out a 4 year term, the oldest conservative justice would be 81 or 82 by the end of Obama's term. For strategic retirement, ginsberg and bryer are more likely to go. For kennedy and Scalia to go it would likley have to be death that gets them out. Kennedy has been a swing vote going both ways on issues. Replacing him with a hard line lefty would get fillibustered, and getting 3/5ths to break it would be hard as you likely wouldn't get unanimity form the democrats. Scalia would probably roll in there running off a heart and lung machine rather than let Obama pick his replacement. ginsberg is saying she doesn't want to retire yet, which would indicate at best a strategic retirement year 3 of his term, but in 2014 the senate puts 33 more seats up with 20 being dems and 13 being republicans. With his last two nominations, he went into debt with the party, and asking them to carry water on anything too extreme is unlikely. Keep in mind we ahve had left leaning judges appointed by right leaning presidents in the past and vice versa as well.

 

Circuit court appointments are MUCH more critical than worrying about the SCOTUS, and he can't choose a solely anti 2nd tact with those appointments either. It'd backfire. Lets say by the end of 2014 we've had scalia and kennedy get replaced with lefties as well as ginsburg, AND he stacks circuit courts. It means the circuit courts are stuck with SCOTUS rulings to date as without conflicting rulings at the circuit level, nothing would likely get to them. We could get stuck treading water, but losing ground would be harder. Which leaves us in a better position RKBA wise than I have seen in my entire life. There would just be no SCOTUS fueled deus ex machina for the PRNJ.

Wisconsin hunters alone are the world's 6th largest army. Like Leonidus said, 'come and take them'

we have no one to blame but ourselves really. 10% of NJ residents own firearms and yet, we don't band together to effect change we want. We have gun states voting for dems......

 

I will NEVER give them up and I feel many patriots out there feel the same way

 

I'm hoping Texas smartens up and secedes so I can move to a real American country:)

It's funny that you say that. If any state tried to secede from the rest of the United States I'm sure the federal government would step in with the national guard and anyone else and call us home grown terrorist. If it's another country outside the USA doing it, it's civil unrest and the USA will step in and help them overthrow their government..... Weird how the same thing is completely different.

  • Author

Checks and balances ensure no lone president can't single-handedly make a law. He needs approval of congress and the senate. If it can't get the votes to go through either he won't be able to sign it.

 

Not necessarily, wait for some sort of "economic panic", claim that crimes are going to rocket up, and pass an Executive order.

It's funny that you say that. If any state tried to secede from the rest of the United States I'm sure the federal government would step in with the national guard and anyone else and call us home grown terrorist.

 

There has been talk for awhile for a number of states to secede from the U.S. So far nothing has come of it. Among them are Texas and Vermont.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Secession_in_the_United_States

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Secession_Movement

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Second_Vermont_Republic

 

From Georgia, I find this most telling

 

"Georgia: On April 1, 2009, the Georgia State Senate passed a resolution 43-1 that affirmed the right of states to nullify federal laws. The resolution also included the assertion that if Congress took certain steps, including restricting firearms or ammunition, the United States government would cease to exist."

There has been talk for awhile for a number of states to secede from the U.S. So far nothing has come of it. Among them are Texas and Vermont.

 

http://en.wikipedia....e_United_States

 

http://en.wikipedia....ession_Movement

 

http://en.wikipedia....ermont_Republic

 

From Georgia, I find this most telling

 

"Georgia: On April 1, 2009, the Georgia State Senate passed a resolution 43-1 that affirmed the right of states to nullify federal laws. The resolution also included the assertion that if Congress took certain steps, including restricting firearms or ammunition, the United States government would cease to exist."

One word to describe that, Fantastic. unfortunately that will never ever happen in NJ. And did that 1 guy against get re-elected???

The immediate thing is that the resulting panic makes everything you want more expensive, with out BHO lifting a finger.

 

Which makes me wonder who the NRA really wanted to win. Gun sales since 2008 have been the highest they've ever been. And i'm sure the next 4 years will be the same.

There has been talk for awhile for a number of states to secede from the U.S. So far nothing has come of it. Among them are Texas and Vermont.

 

http://en.wikipedia....e_United_States

 

http://en.wikipedia....ession_Movement

 

http://en.wikipedia....ermont_Republic

 

From Georgia, I find this most telling

 

"Georgia: On April 1, 2009, the Georgia State Senate passed a resolution 43-1 that affirmed the right of states to nullify federal laws. The resolution also included the assertion that if Congress took certain steps, including restricting firearms or ammunition, the United States government would cease to exist."

 

Sounds like I need to get my ass down to Georgia.

Don't want to hijack but were any of you guys around for the 1st AWB? How did that work, was it the features game like in NJ? Or were things like Semi auto ARs banned outright?

 

I don't remember reading about a turn in of guns just you couldn't buy them, is that how it worked? I would be most concerned about the turn in thing because like many here I paid a lot for my guns and I can't see how they could pass anything making us turn them in without reimbursement.

 

Also thankfully to us that the tv gun shows and stuff are contributing to gun sales so it would be hard to ban the sale of guns outright when these US based companies, see ruger, are thriving right now

 

Federally or State?? the NJ State AWB happened first. ANYTHING that qualified under the Law had to be Registered, Rendered Inoperable, Turned in, or Sold out of state. there was NO grandfather clause, and you had a VERY short window to make your choice and take action accordingly. the Federal Ban while it mirrored NJ's in many points ALLOWED firearms that were already owned to be kept, and transferred, it also allowed Pre-ban Magazines. The ONLY thing that the federal ban was more restrictive on was Capacity, the max was 10 for magazines produced during that period. Biggest thing with the NJ ban is that most people had NO idea about it until it was too late, also, most everyone truly believed that once they were registered, it would only be a matter of a year or two before the turn in order came, so we all got rid of them out of state, whether sold off, or stored with family or friends..in the end IIRC there were only a few hundred registered at most.

Doesn't Ginsberg have cancer?

 

Why do you think that, because of advertising?

 

Most justices in relatively recent history have served into their 80s or 90s. They get some insane health care, on par or better than sitting presidents. To sit out a 4 year term, the oldest conservative justice would be 81 or 82 by the end of Obama's term. For strategic retirement, ginsberg and bryer are more likely to go. For kennedy and Scalia to go it would likley have to be death that gets them out. Kennedy has been a swing vote going both ways on issues. Replacing him with a hard line lefty would get fillibustered, and getting 3/5ths to break it would be hard as you likely wouldn't get unanimity form the democrats. Scalia would probably roll in there running off a heart and lung machine rather than let Obama pick his replacement. ginsberg is saying she doesn't want to retire yet, which would indicate at best a strategic retirement year 3 of his term, but in 2014 the senate puts 33 more seats up with 20 being dems and 13 being republicans. With his last two nominations, he went into debt with the party, and asking them to carry water on anything too extreme is unlikely. Keep in mind we ahve had left leaning judges appointed by right leaning presidents in the past and vice versa as well.

 

Circuit court appointments are MUCH more critical than worrying about the SCOTUS, and he can't choose a solely anti 2nd tact with those appointments either. It'd backfire. Lets say by the end of 2014 we've had scalia and kennedy get replaced with lefties as well as ginsburg, AND he stacks circuit courts. It means the circuit courts are stuck with SCOTUS rulings to date as without conflicting rulings at the circuit level, nothing would likely get to them. We could get stuck treading water, but losing ground would be harder. Which leaves us in a better position RKBA wise than I have seen in my entire life. There would just be no SCOTUS fueled deus ex machina for the PRNJ.

Doesn't Ginsberg have cancer?

 

No idea, but a recent news article quoted her on not being ready to retire yet.

No idea, but a recent news article quoted her on not being ready to retire yet.

 

Well, that might change since she knows a fool will replace her now that Obama has won re-election.

The federal govt has the states by the balls by using the Commerce Clause. Everything from federal drug laws to gun laws use this as the basis for federal enforcement power. It is supposed to be to regulate interstate and international commerce, in order to prevent individual states from creating unfair trade agreements.

 

Over the years, the clause has been interpreted to give the Federal Govt the ability to pass laws on anything that crosses , or is believed to eventually cross state boundaries. The "is believed" part is the BS interpretation.

 

For instance, Federal drug laws use this definition. They ascertain that it is impossible to determine if illegal drugs will or will not cross state boundaries, thus they must operate under the assumptions that they do or have crossed a boundary, hence giving the Federal Govt the ability to enforce Federal drug laws. Same logic is applied to firearms laws.

 

This is why some states have passed laws stating that the Federal gun laws do not have any authority over firearms built in a single state which never crosses that state's boundaries. A gun would only be regulated by Federal law as it is traversing state A to state B. According to the Constitution that is correct, but the Federal govt doesn't want to go quietly on that one. If the Commerce clause "loophole" gets closed, there are tons of Federal laws that would need to be re-evaluated/re-written.

The federal govt has the states by the balls by using the Commerce Clause. Everything from federal drug laws to gun laws use this as the basis for federal enforcement power. It is supposed to be to regulate interstate and international commerce, in order to prevent individual states from creating unfair trade agreements.

 

Over the years, the clause has been interpreted to give the Federal Govt the ability to pass laws on anything that crosses , or is believed to eventually cross state boundaries. The "is believed" part is the BS interpretation.

 

For instance, Federal drug laws use this definition. They ascertain that it is impossible to determine if illegal drugs will or will not cross state boundaries, thus they must operate under the assumptions that they do or have crossed a boundary, hence giving the Federal Govt the ability to enforce Federal drug laws. Same logic is applied to firearms laws.

 

This is why some states have passed laws stating that the Federal gun laws do not have any authority over firearms built in a single state which never crosses that state's boundaries. A gun would only be regulated by Federal law as it is traversing state A to state B. According to the Constitution that is correct, but the Federal govt doesn't want to go quietly on that one. If the Commerce clause "loophole" gets closed, there are tons of Federal laws that would need to be re-evaluated/re-written.

 

 

 

You're about 70 years behind the times. It doesn't matter if you do anything that may or may not cross state lines under the Congressional and Progressive Supreme Court interpretation of the Commerce Clause. If you grow vegetables in your garden, the federal government can regulate it simply because, had you not grown vegetables, there is a chance you would have purchased vegetables and therefore you have affected interstate commerce.Don't blame me, blame your grandparents. Over the past 30 years it has been firmed up. The federal government can do whatever it wants, as long as violations of the Constitution are more important to the Government's interest than the consideration of yours.

Why am I behind the times. I said "over the years the clause has been interpreted", I should have been more specific I suppose. :picknose:

Why am I behind the times. I said "over the years the clause has been interpreted", I should have been more specific I suppose. :picknose:

 

 

 

Because it was only interpreted to apply to things that might cross state lines roughly 70 years and longer ago, and not in the past 70 years. As I explained.

I need to find something to be optimistic about with all that has gone on, so I choose to see some opportunity for NJ gun owners in the near future. The following is probably a stretch in many ways, but I've decided I'm going to believe it's plausible.

 

1) Christie's handling of the storm has garnered positive feedback, some of which is even coming from people who generally vote for the other side of the isle. Unsurprisingly, there is also renewed talk of Christie running for president in 2016.

 

2) Assuming Christie is interested, he'll have to start thinking ahead on positioning himself to secure the Repub nomination. Notably, he probably can't make it out of the primary without a strong pro-2A position.

 

Therefore, my hope is that in the years leading up to 2016, Christie will look to more directly support the 2nd amendment publicly and in future cabinet appointments. I think it was clear that nobody really bought Romney's claims of being a true 2A supporter, based on his track record, so hopefully Christie would be shrewd enough to actually enact some changes in NJ that he can later point to during the GOP primary. I.E. "I was in the most anti-gun state in the country and I still found a way to make things a bit better for gun owners."

 

Yup, it's a dream. But for now, it's my dream.

I need to find something to be optimistic about with all that has gone on, so I choose to see some opportunity for NJ gun owners in the near future. The following is probably a stretch in many ways, but I've decided I'm going to believe it's plausible.

 

1) Christie's handling of the storm has garnered positive feedback, some of which is even coming from people who generally vote for the other side of the isle. Unsurprisingly, there is also renewed talk of Christie running for president in 2016.

 

2) Assuming Christie is interested, he'll have to start thinking ahead on positioning himself to secure the Repub nomination. Notably, he probably can't make it out of the primary without a strong pro-2A position.

 

Therefore, my hope is that in the years leading up to 2016, Christie will look to more directly support the 2nd amendment publicly and in future cabinet appointments. I think it was clear that nobody really bought Romney's claims of being a true 2A supporter, based on his track record, so hopefully Christie would be shrewd enough to actually enact some changes in NJ that he can later point to during the GOP primary. I.E. "I was in the most anti-gun state in the country and I still found a way to make things a bit better for gun owners."

 

 

I hate to disagree, but I must. Today's republican party is not our father's republican party. And Christie is no friend to 2A. I do think he will be the GOP nominee in 2016, and I don't like the idea much. He has been great for NJ, I'll give him that... but he has "Bloomberg-itis"... HE knows better than US, it's HIS way or the highway, so get out of his way.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.