Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Lasers for defense, a gimmick or the real deal?

Featured Replies

Again, relying on anything other than well aimed shots that hit their mark for self defense is silly. I have never seen a laser used on its own deter anyone or de-escalate a use of force incident. The dirt bags in this world know the Use of Force laws better than most cops or civilians. They know when you can and can't shoot and are more than willing to bet their lives on it when confronting good law abiding people.

 

As far as the scary sounfd of racking a shotgun, please. We have been down this road before. For the children, stop. It is useless Hollywood BS that may very well get you killed.

 

 

And that is where they will make there mistake in my house, NJ right to defend laws be damned. Kill or be killed. I will kill.

 

Racking a shotgun will get you killed huh? That's a new one. You DO realize, son, that the shotgun will actually be LOADED and the owner will be prepared to FIRE it, right? No one is talking about using the sound of an EMPTY racking shotgun to scare anybody off. I figured you would have just assumed that, being that this IS a GUN forum.

  • Author

Can it be? Me and high exposure in FULL AGREEMENT?

Racking a shotgun will get you killed huh? That's a new one. You DO realize, son, that the shotgun will actually be LOADED and the owner will be prepared to FIRE it, right? No one is talking about using the sound of an EMPTY racking shotgun to scare anybody off. I figured you would have just assumed that, being that this IS a GUN forum.

 

If the gun is loaded why are you racking it?

 

Shouldn't you be scanning for targets, calling 911, gathering family members, seeking cover, barricading your door, following your emergency plan, or doing about a million other things instead of dicking around with your primary means of defense and then listening to see if you scared anyone off?

 

So, you hear a bump in the night. You hop out of bed in nothing but your underoos and rack the $hit out of your shotgun, nice and loud so everyone hears. Now what? Seriously, now that you just gave away your position, and told the bad guy what kind of weapon you have, what do you do?

 

Since this IS a GUN forum, I just assumed that you would have your head in the game.

 

Oh, and I ain't your son.

 

Can it be? Me and high exposure in FULL AGREEMENT?

 

It can happen all the time Ray.... All you have to do is be right more often ;)

 

LOL

You must be thick. Or you are making the mistake of thinking I am. I'm not wasting anymore time explaining common sense to you. For example, did you know I take a breath every few seconds? But I shouldn't have to explain that to you. Ditto on calling 911, gathering family members, etc. Common sense. Since this IS a gun forum, I just assumed that YOU would have YOUR head in the game, and details like these wouldn't have to be spelled out to you. Apparently I assumed wrong.

 

A punk (who could very easily be a juvenile) breaking into my house will most certainly be interested in the sound of a shotgun racking, I assure you. And if he's not, and decides to continue his criminal activities, he'll be shot. And as I stated, I would much rather scare someone off and not have to deal with the police/court nightmare of shooting them. Obviously you feel differently. I guess you'd rather just pop out from behind a corner and start throwing lead? No time for the common sense actions of letting the intruder know you're home, you're armed, the police are on the way, and they will end up either dead or arrested unless they leave immediately? Obviously we have different ideas of how to go about NOT shooting someone unless absolutely necessary.

Personally, I think if you want some kind of deterrent, install an alarm. Put a bell over the door. Hell, even put a strobe somewhere. If someone breaks into my home, I'm going to make sure they realize they picked the wrong house. No racking...unless I missed.

The police actually announce they are present prior to searching a house for someone. It gives the intruder a chance to surrender without confrontation. Not unlike racking a slide on a shotgun by a home owner, thereby giving a chance for the intruder to flee.

You must be thick. Or you are making the mistake of thinking I am. I'm not wasting anymore time explaining common sense to you. For example, did you know I take a breath every few seconds? But I shouldn't have to explain that to you. Ditto on calling 911, gathering family members, etc. Common sense. Since this IS a gun forum, I just assumed that YOU would have YOUR head in the game, and details like these wouldn't have to be spelled out to you. Apparently I assumed wrong.

 

A punk (who could very easily be a juvenile) breaking into my house will most certainly be interested in the sound of a shotgun racking, I assure you. And if he's not, and decides to continue his criminal activities, he'll be shot. And as I stated, I would much rather scare someone off and not have to deal with the police/court nightmare of shooting them. Obviously you feel differently. I guess you'd rather just pop out from behind a corner and start throwing lead? No time for the common sense actions of letting the intruder know you're home, you're armed, the police are on the way, and they will end up either dead or arrested unless they leave immediately? Obviously we have different ideas of how to go about NOT shooting someone unless absolutely necessary.

 

Easy bud, your gonna hurt yourself. Take a deep breath, calm down and think. Stop with the ad hominem attacks and think critically. They had guy should not know wher you are. Until you have eyes on him and sights on him from a position of dominance in your house.

 

You also still didn't answer my question, seriously, talk me through your plan. After racking your shotgun, voluntarily giving up one of your only advantages in CQB/HD, namely surprise, what are you going to do - Search the house or stay in your room?

 

Which course of action is more likely to stop a threat - racking a shotgun for all the world to hear, or locating your threat and aimIng in from a position of dominance, resetting their OODA loop and gaining the tacticals advantage?

 

You mention "juvenile" like that matters, So what? Does someone's 18th birthday bestow some magical quality? A bad is a bad guy, regardless of age. And a 15 year old kid is more likely to drop the hammer on someone while commiting a crime than a seasoned pro.

 

"decides to continue his criminal activities, he'll be shot." I hope the criminlnal activity you are speaking of puts you and your loved ones in some kind of articulable danger, and not just trespassing, criminal mischief, or theft.

 

I am not advocating blasting away at the first sign of an intruder. In fact, the opposite is true. I am advocating being smart, stacking the deck in your favor, and using tactics that are proven to work more often then they don't in keeping you and your family safe while giving you a higher chance of ending the engagement without a shot fired, but if it comes to shots, you prevail.

 

If someone breaks into my home, I'm going to make sure they realize they picked the wrong house. No racking...unless I missed.

 

See, he gets it. The first time a bad guy should know where you are, should be when your sights are already on him.

 

The police actually announce they are present prior to searching a house for someone. It gives the intruder a chance to surrender without confrontation. Not unlike racking a slide on a shotgun by a home owner, thereby giving a chance for the intruder to flee.

 

This is 100% false. If one of my guys ever did this on a call I am calling him on the carpet to explain himself. If they tell me this is why they did it, they would be written up, counseled on proper tactics, and assigned 4 hours of officer safety training/basic patrol tactics.

Easy bud, your gonna hurt yourself. Take a deep breath, calm down and think. Stop with the ad hominem attacks and think critically.

 

You first, SON.

Wow. Very mature.

 

Anything useful to add to the discussion or are you just going to gloss over my questions and comments regarding the topic at hand and your response to an intruder in your home?

 

And to reiterate, in case you missed it the first time, I am not your son.

Look son, I don't have to explain in detail my "plan." The comment was specifically about the sound of a racking shotgun being a deterrent. You don't think it's possible. I do. Merry Christmas.

 

As far as being mature- I repeat: you first. You're the one who started this mess with your comment "For the children, stop. It is useless Hollywood BS that may very well get you killed."

 

"CHILDREN"? Now who's being immature as well as condescending?

So now that we have determined that racking a shotgun as a tactic for self defense is a debatable topic, have we determined the suitability of lasers yet?

 

:)

Oops

Edited by Bonesinium

 

 

The police actually announce they are present prior to searching a house for someone. It gives the intruder a chance to surrender without confrontation. Not unlike racking a slide on a shotgun by a home owner, thereby giving a chance for the intruder to flee.

 

 

This is 100% false. If one of my guys ever did this on a call I am calling him on the carpet to explain himself. If they tell me this is why they did it, they would be written up, counseled on proper tactics, and assigned 4 hours of officer safety training/basic patrol tactics.

I know this is about lasers but I really feel the need to comment on this. PK90 knows me, I'm not a cop, never have been and probably will never will be but isn't it safer for the police to announce themselves before entering a home. Because if I hear glass break and then a little later someone giggling my daughter's door handle and trying to bust on in without announcing themselves I'm going to shoot. End of story, no questions asked. Now If I hear the police announce themselves I can communicate where I am and I can come to them and look out the window to confirm who is actually there.

Look son, I don't have to explain in detail my "plan." The comment was specifically about the sound of a racking shotgun being a deterrent. You don't think it's possible. I do. Merry Christmas.

 

As far as being mature- I repeat: you first. You're the one who started this mess with your comment "For the children, stop. It is useless Hollywood BS that may very well get you killed."

 

"CHILDREN"? Now who's being immature as well as condescending?

 

Ruger9,

 

The phrase "For the children" is from those old Sally Struthers commercials where she askes for $0.10 a day to save the little kids with no food in the Philippines/Malasia/Central America/etc... You know - "For less than the price of a cup of coffe a day.... Please, for the Children" It is a common turn of phrase often used to impart an air of joviality to an otherwise charged conversation. It is also as a way to convey a lighthearted tone into an email, post, or whatever, as oftentimes the written word often is unable to impart any tonal context to the rest of the post. My friends and I use it a lot, in person and in emails and the like. Sometimes I forget that we all do not know each other here and may not get each others sense of humor. I apologize. It was not meant to be condescending and I was not referring to you as a child in any way - Unlike your repeatedly calling me son and taking what I am saying so personally. A bit of advice here, and again, it is worth what you paid for it - if you truly thought that I did mean it in a condescending tone, taking the high road and attempting to remain professional would probably served you a bit better. Instead you come off sounding a bit boorish.

 

Ruger9, I don't want your whole Emergency "plan", I truly just want you to think critically about what you are going to do after the racking of the shotgun. Think about what you are going to do next in a realistic way and see if maybe, just maybe, another way gives you more tactical options and opens a lot more doors for you. I am not insulting you, your family, or your favorite gun. I am asking you to examine a TTP that you prefer, to evaluate if maybe, just maybe, there is a better way. If not, fine. Do what you are going to do. But seriously Ruger9, why the resistance? I am offering a little advice, some personal experience, a bit of anecdotal evidence, and maybe a critical thinking exercise and learning opportunity, I am not asking you to divorce your wife or leave your church.

 

I think the idea of using the sound of a racking shotgun as a line of defense/deterrent is assinine at best. (And like it or not this is one of those gun handiling things that is seen on TV/Movies and taken to be a valid technique, much like some flashlight techniques and position Sabrina/Charlie's Angels) I don't come by this opinion lightly or in a vacuum. I have experience dealing with armed badguys. I have searched for them in homes and other buildings, I have held them at gunpiont, arrested them, and spoken with them afterword. I am here to tell you that it will not work against a determined bad guy, and using a TTP that won't work all the time is counter productive to the outcome you want.

 

Take it or leave it, that's fine.

 

Oh, and Happy New Year to you too.

 

And really dude, "You First"? What is next - "He started it!"? :) - please see my smiley as a way to let you know that this statement is meant to be lighthearted.

 

I know this is about lasers but I really feel the need to comment on this. PK90 knows me, I'm not a cop, never have been and probably will never will be but isn't it safer for the police to announce themselves before entering a home. Because if I hear glass break and then a little later someone giggling my daughter's door handle and trying to bust on in without announcing themselves I'm going to shoot. End of story, no questions asked. Now If I hear the police announce themselves I can communicate where I am and I can come to them and look out the window to confirm who is actually there.

 

The answer to this question as it is on most Police work is "It Depends". I am not going to go into specific Police Tactics, Techniques, and Procedures (TTPs) regarding response to home invasion/burglary/hostage rescue/barricaded person/alarm response/Warrant service etc. here.

 

I will say that my response was from a Patrol standpoint - a hasty entrance to an unknown situation, not a SWAT perspective - a warrant service/barricaded person/hostage rescue situation. The reason being is that the response you will most likely get at first is going to be patrol officers, not SWAT.

 

I wil ask you this though, Why are you indescriminatly shooting at anyone that "busts" in? Target aquisition and identification are the first to steps of engaging a target, as well as the #4 rule of Firearms safety - Be sure of your target, foreground, backstop and beyond.

Ah so we agree to disagree then- good. We both agree that each other is wrong. Good enough for me. Let's move on.

Personally, I would never give away any information until I have eyes and sights pointed at him. If racking a shotgun will scare away an intruder, so will surprising him with a loaded shotgun pointed at him. I'm all for avoiding conflict, but not if I risk losing any advantage for the sake of the bad guy.

 

As for the original topic, I'd rather have a laser than not. However, I'd rather have one that you can control rather than always on via pressure switch on your grip. You never know what situation you'll be in. How can you guarantee you'll have a good sight picture?

 

 

I wil ask you this though, Why are you indescriminatly shooting at anyone that "busts" in?

 

Why is someone indiscriminately breaking into your home, and in what circumstance is this person breaking in a benefit to you?

 

I'm certainly not suggesting to 'indiscriminately' shoot anyone that 'busts' in, just posing some other questions that I think are equally as important.

Nothing done while searching for bad guys is done indiscriminately. Have you ever cleared a house? Ever searched a dwelling for possible intruders? I cleared 3 separate houses last night. 2 were homeowners reporting coming home to what appeared to be burglaries the third was called in by an alarm company.

 

It is not an exact science and different tactics and systems will be used based on what the Officers on scene think is appropriate and safe. Rarely is announcing yourself as the Police the right call.

 

Regardless,

Why is someone indiscriminately breaking into your home, and in what circumstance is this person breaking in a benefit to you?

Is a red herring.

 

Nothing negates the need for target discrimination. Thats what a part of what being a responsible gun owner is all about. Anything else can end in tragedy. Making sure only the bad guys get the good news is what makes us the good guys.

Good thing you quoted the first part of my post and not the second. It is almost as if you were intentionally ignoring that part, which may have helped explain the first. But then again, that would have rendered your post mostly irrelevant. Oh well.

If you personally subscribe to the second part of your post, the first part is irrelevant and unnecessary to state. So why say it all?

 

It seems like you are asking questions you already know the answer to. Why do I need to respond to that? Seems trollish and argumentative.

 

BLUF: Target discrimination determines if the person entering your room is a benefit or detriment. If a benefit do, what's appropriate. If the other.... Do what is appropriate.

 

You know that and so do I. We apparantly agree, yet you insist on continuing with the disambiguation. I am clearly missing something that you feel is crucial, so what is it?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.