January 25, 201313 yr So I've seen this sentiment here and on many other gun forums. "If you don't reload, you aren't properly prepping!" Now, I don't reload for a few reasons: I have carpal tunnel syndrome in both hands which makes fiddling with very small items (no penis jokes, please )for any length of time miserable. Secondly, I'd rather do something else with my free time. That said, if you enjoy reloading, that's great. So I'd like any who adhere to the "If you aren't reloading, you aren't ready for the SHTF!" types to answer the following questions: #1. Why are 1000, 5000, or 100,000 sets of brass, projectiles, primers and powder better than the same amount of factory loaded rounds? #2. In the unlikely event the S really does HTF do you think reloading components are going to be easier to find than loaded ammo?
January 25, 201313 yr Cost Tailoring a load to a gun That being said, I wouldn't want to be shot with a " factory " round, or a reloaded one.
January 25, 201313 yr The only reason that I'm not reloading my own ammo is because its not my own house. I know a couple people that are on the same boat. It might not sound like a good enough reason, but obviously I'm not the only one that feels that way.
January 25, 201313 yr Who are these survivalists? I'm sure the entire reloading gear will pack & fold up nicely for quick mobility.
January 25, 201313 yr The reloading only benefits you if you don't run out of the powder, primers, brass, projectiles. If civilization doesn't pick up at some point after the SHTF event everyone runs out of ammunition at some point unless they have access to the raw materials to make powder and primers have the machinery. Having a good stock pile and using the ammo conservatively when the time comes will keep up your odds of survival with the re-loaders. I reload and I know tons of guys that are alot better prepped then I am on the ammo end. I can only produce a few thousand rounds with the materials I have left if they have cases of ammo to match it then we are equal.
January 25, 201313 yr Author Cost Tailoring a load to a gun That being said, I wouldn't want to be shot with a " factory " round, or a reloaded one. I'm in no ways dissing reloading. If you like to do it, more power to you. For a serious bench shooter, it's a must. But I'm talking about guns that would be used in a bad situation. AKs, ARs, etc. These folks are somehow implying people who don't reload will be SOL when the SHTF and it makes no sense whatsoever.
January 25, 201313 yr Author I The reloading only benefits you if you don't run out of the powder, primers, brass, projectiles. If civilization doesn't pick up at some point after the SHTF event everyone runs out of ammunition at some point unless they have access to the raw materials to make powder and primers have the machinery. Having a good stock pile and using the ammo conservatively when the time comes will keep up your odds of survival with the re-loaders. I reload and I know tons of guys that are alot better prepped then I am on the ammo end. I can only produce a few thousand rounds with the materials I have left if they have cases of ammo to match it then we are equal. They are even better off because they don't have to take the time to reload!
January 25, 201313 yr Youre not ready for shtf if you dont have a concentrated supply of .22lr. honestly... 10-15k rounds would be really tough to blow through no matter how much reloading components you have.
January 25, 201313 yr I think the mentality is that if shtf ano would be scarce...I guys for done resin they also think the components would be really available and shipped to their door? I agree with rubberbullets. I'd rather have a ton of ammo on hand and ready to go. It's easier to move ammo than it is reloading gear.
January 25, 201313 yr Once you use up your factory ammo your done, with reloading you replace your stock over and over again , also gun powder isn't just for ammo.
January 25, 201313 yr Author Once you use up your factory ammo your done, with reloading you replace your stock over and over again , also gun powder isn't just for ammo. So, you are reusing your primers, bullets and powder, too?
January 25, 201313 yr You reload because it cheaper and you can make bullets to match your rifle. You will gain accuracy and save money. If shtf I'm staying home until it gets too bad and I need to leave. When I leave you can bet I will be bringing every round of 22lr I have. 22lr is just plain lighter to carry. I can do small game hunting and feed my family.
January 25, 201313 yr Author You reload because it cheaper and you can make bullets to match your rifle. You will gain accuracy and save money. If shtf I'm staying home until it gets too bad and I need to leave. When I leave you can bet I will be bringing every round of 22lr I have. 22lr is just plain lighter to carry. I can do small game hunting and feed my family. You are missing the point. Reread my initial post.
January 25, 201313 yr Right, so the key is, you'd have to have ALL the supplies(and a lot of it) in order to reload. This would be a pretty good discussion actually. IF you had to bug out you have to bring all your reloading stuff with you. I guess it would have to depend on what kind of SHTF scenario takes place.
January 25, 201313 yr If it the SHTF it would be better to have $5K worth of factory or components? I think not having all your eggs in one basket is better, so I've added one more tool to my toolbox. I would use my reloads as long as I could & save the factory ammo if I had to relocate.
January 25, 201313 yr Guys, you live in NJ. Bugging out is mostly a non-starter. For all practical purposes you live on a island with 8 million other people with relatively few ways of leaving. You can try to cross the few bridges into PA (with 8 mil other people) or you can head north and run into the 8million residents of New York City moving across your path. Whatever disillusion you might have about bugging out and heading for the hills to starve with your 8 million closest buddies when the mythical manure hits the rotary air circulation device, you need to re-consider your options. If your plan A is to leave behind a solid structure and most of your assets and trade it for the cold hills of PA (where, lets not forget, there are already armed people who may not take kindly to it) you really need a plan B. You might consider actually moving out of state if this is something you really worry about. Back to reloading, the main reason one reloads is to shoot more for the same money. You never save money, you just get to use the money better. If the world goes to the crapper where you need to reload as your only source of ammo, you will fail to do that. Most powders come from Australia, do you think they'll still be available? Primers are very hard to make as an individual. Bullets you can cast, but try shooting cast bullets in a fast cartridge like .223. If you think the world will fall back that badly, then consider a flintlock and learning how to cast your own balls and make your own black powder.
January 25, 201313 yr Can you get 2k of 556 right now reasonably priced???? And I mean right now!???? I reload......I can... BTW substitute you Caliber above....45 38 9mm 38 super 3006 308 303 8mm etc Can you get reasonably priced reloading components now? I thought panic buying raises all boats equally?
January 25, 201313 yr The only way it's beneficial is if you have a stockpile of components that greatly outweigh the amount of ammo already made. The ability to produce you're own ammo is great. What's better in a shtf scenario though? Having 10k rds, or 10k bullets, cases, primers, and a ton of powder, plus all the tools/presses to move if you need to? My vote is stockpiling ammo, not components...at least for this scenario.
January 25, 201313 yr I would rather have the 10k rounds of reloaded ammo because it cost me half the price and the ammo is of better quality and more accurate.
January 25, 201313 yr Guys, you live in NJ. Bugging out is mostly a non-starter. For all practical purposes you live on a island with 8 million other people with relatively few ways of leaving. You can try to cross the few bridges into PA (with 8 mil other people) or you can head north and run into the 8million residents of New York City moving across your path. Whatever disillusion you might have about bugging out and heading for the hills to starve with your 8 million closest buddies when the mythical manure hits the rotary air circulation device, you need to re-consider your options. If your plan A is to leave behind a solid structure and most of your assets and trade it for the cold hills of PA (where, lets not forget, there are already armed people who may not take kindly to it) you really need a plan B. You might consider actually moving out of state if this is something you really worry about. Back to reloading, the main reason one reloads is to shoot more for the same money. You never save money, you just get to use the money better. If the world goes to the crapper where you need to reload as your only source of ammo, you will fail to do that. Most powders come from Australia, do you think they'll still be available? Primers are very hard to make as an individual. Bullets you can cast, but try shooting cast bullets in a fast cartridge like .223. If you think the world will fall back that badly, then consider a flintlock and learning how to cast your own balls and make your own black powder. After thinking about that, I think I would rather be shot with someone's reload.
January 25, 201313 yr The only way it's beneficial is if you have a stockpile of components that greatly outweigh the amount of ammo already made. The ability to produce you're own ammo is great. What's better in a shtf scenario though? Having 10k rds, or 10k bullets, cases, primers, and a ton of powder, plus all the tools/presses to move if you need to? My vote is stockpiling ammo, not components...at least for this scenario. But the other thing to look at is that you can reload for about 1/2 the price of factory ammo. So for what it would cost you to buy 10k of factory ammo you could get the components to reload 20k+ for the around the same price.
January 25, 201313 yr Who are these survivalists? I'm sure the entire reloading gear will pack & fold up nicely for quick mobility. That was funny, I almost pee'd my panties.
January 25, 201313 yr What does it matter? Only Tom Cruise and Tim Robbins will have guns! Didn't any of you ever see War of the Worlds? Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
January 25, 201313 yr So I'd like any who adhere to the "If you aren't reloading, you aren't ready for the SHTF!" types to answer the following questions: #1. Why are 1000, 5000, or 100,000 sets of brass, projectiles, primers and powder better than the same amount of factory loaded rounds? #2. In the unlikely event the S really does HTF do you think reloading components are going to be easier to find than loaded ammo? I wouldn't say it's not being prepared if you don't reload at all, no matter what, you can be prepared, one just uses more coin. As far and reloading, heck to many of us, it's a hobby in a hobby. 1. Round count is round count doesn't matter if you have 10k of factory or reloads, it's still 10k, so no advantage. What I will say, many people who reload will a lot of components on hand to be able to load a lot more rounds than most would have on hand with factory ammo. 2. Everything would be hard to find, but people who reload would probably have more stuff on hand to get then through a longer period of time. Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
January 25, 201313 yr Author Can you get 2k of 556 right now reasonably priced???? And I mean right now!???? I reload......I can... BTW substitute you Caliber above....45 38 9mm 38 super 3006 308 303 8mm etc Yes. I can open the door to my gun room. People are missing the point of my original post. It's not about cost or accuracy or any of the other points brought up. Reread the original post.
January 25, 201313 yr Author I wouldn't say it's not being prepared if you don't reload at all, no matter what, you can be prepared, one just uses more coin. As far and reloading, heck to many of us, it's a hobby in a hobby. 1. Round count is round count doesn't matter if you have 10k of factory or reloads, it's still 10k, so no advantage. What I will say, many people who reload will a lot of components on hand to be able to load a lot more rounds than most would have on hand with factory ammo. 2. Everything would be hard to find, but people who reload would probably have more stuff on hand to get then through a longer period of time. Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk That may be true in some cases. But I'm still comparing rounds vs loadable rounds with identical numbers of each. And wouldn't you rather be patrolling or guarding your house instead of sitting at a reloading press? And I heartily agree w. the poster above who mentioned .22 LR ammo. That coupled w. a few inexpensive .22 rifles would have some serious bartering value.
January 25, 201313 yr Like I said, 10k of reloads vs 10k of factory is not different. Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
January 25, 201313 yr This discussion is going in circles. A round is a round, but I'd rather pay half price. And if I come across reloading components I'm gonna know what to do and you won't.
January 26, 201313 yr In light of the current situation all i can say it is best to have both. I learned years ago that ammo prices are like the stock market. What is cheap one day is expensive the next. Buy it cheap and stack it deep. But the same applies to reloading components. When I see it cheap i stack it deep. Often times the best value is reloading components. They sell far cheaper than the cheapest loaded rounds. Who cares if i have to take the time to load them up into complete rounds. I already have a stash of loaded ammo so i have the time and backup ammo if i ever need it. This philosiphy is why i am at all the panic buyers right now. Really you are that desperate for ammo that you are paying $.75 for a round that was $.25 a month ago...... wow. Talk about poor preparation. Kinda like having a generator in your house before a hurricane but only having a gallon of gas.
January 26, 201313 yr It's very cheap to stock powder and primers... enough to load +30k for around 1100 bucks. Cast your bullets, buy lead....and or stock up on bullets... re-use brass. The idea is that your can get more out of your preps per dollar. When i shoot up my stock ammo i have the ability to replace it by re-using the brass and supplies i have allocated. I can therefore STOCK more bullets primer and powder to make more rounds per dollar then if i just flat out bought production ammo. If we spent the same amount of money on ammo, but i decided to put mine towards components i would effectively have more rounds stocked, although i would be limited in disposable stock. People miss the idea that reloading isn't beneficial after the SHTF. If you invest the same amount of money pre-shtf you will undoubtedly have access to more rounds by reloading. The point is IT IS CHEAPER, you can effectively stock more ammo by stocking components.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.