February 4, 201313 yr IMO, it get's serious the second one person stands up for their liberties and is killed for it.... how many are willing to die to keep this country free from tyranny? A martyr is a very powerful thing. A martyr in the eyes of the media is a terrorist. A survivalist with Anti American views. A radical. An extremist. Perception is reality and the media dictates the perception.
February 4, 201313 yr There is a reason our government is worried about church going, gun toting veterans. I have seen this first hand since moving to PA... they are not crazy... they are not extreme... they do not sit around and conspire... but they love their country... believe in god... hold strong value over the right to own guns.. and would not hesitate to resist a government that they viewed as out of control... sometimes we think most people would just lay down and let the government roll through.. I can tell you there are a LOT of people that I am pretty confident would sooner be dead than allow their rights to be violated.. the belief systems that they subscribe to are so genuine and real.. that there would be no hesitation to "do the right thing"... some of these individuals are not even old.. they are just more off the grid.. farming community types..
February 4, 201313 yr You may be right. A man with a gun does not worry himself. But you better hope you have the populous on your side. Because everyone may have your mindset. Hope they don't need gas too... Who is to say there has to be a nuke to generate an EMP....? Ok, how about a high voltage surge? Old components and tubes could survive easier than chip technology... Regardless of any fiction or not, finding fuel wasn't easy when it was controlled. Think it any easier in worse times? As any old timer ham operator... Older units will survive over the modern electronics. Besides, you brought up radios... and not to have faith would be absurd... Are you an operator btw? Recent storm... Hmmm.... It may not have been the worse for us, but we should not hide in the shadows of what happened with Katrina... Not trying to argue here... But there are much bigger pictures.... My point about the man with the gun was a bit simplistic. Militias could provide the organization and structure to keep their members outfitted, in contact and in alliance (dispute resolution, etc). Change my original statement to: the militia with guns does not worry itself when the power is turned off. Yes I am an operator. Primarily a listener. I don't know much about Katrina other than it was every man for himself. I've only heard a personal account from a good friend was down there doing environmental contracting. He got thrown in jail for a week with the unwashed masses. In the scope of this discussion, what can we learn from Katrina? (question to all) HAM radio??? LOL..... no.....its for old geezers to talk about how many aches and pains they have....or to collect that rare grid square, or island...or far off contact..... Sure there are some that can handle traffic...but most of all it's a dead dying form of communication. You discussion on modern encrpytion and the AX.25 protocol.... How are you going to distribute the keys? How many keyloaders you have...? OTR re-keying is a trunked radio solution... AX.25 is not secure and frankly DES and DES/XL can be brute force broken with enough of a sampling.... are you planning on AES....? also the radios you speak of that handle this are point to point squad type same operational distance type radios.... not to many quantars up....to handle digi traffic...and the idea of encrypetd comms being transmitted to other supporting units during this crisis is a panacea...it wont happen. encapsualtion of digital audio across the internet is fan fare and quaint....it will not hold up... What CAN happen is broadcast in the clear tranmissions till they triangulate you and shut you down.....it is VERY easy to spot HF towers and antennas of the magnitude you need to get the message out...and oh yeah..we are now at a solar maximum....try all this near a solar minimum.... HOWEVER, that being said...having a 10m/11M rig around or a good old used HF rig for safekeeping cant hurt.... Geez, don't be so hard on those old hams My point was that the generation of people we're discussing already operate a communication network of which the equipment is ubiquitioius across the country. The infrastructure is in place. I imagine encryption keys will be distributed at your militia meeting. Their goal is not to run a secret communication network here. It's merely to communicate and always try to stay a step ahead. These networks could be developed and tested before we're in crisis mode. I have seen first hand operators and homebrew engineers rise to the challenge in patching together various networks to distribute and exchange information in simulation. A real world example of successful ad hoc civilian radio networks is the Balkans in the early 90's. Regarding triangulation, fox hunting isn't that simple. Particularly low power mobile 2M which I imagine the bulk of transmissions will be.
February 4, 201313 yr HAM radio??? LOL..... no.....its for old geezers to talk about how many aches and pains they have....or to collect that rare grid square, or island...or far off contact..... Sure there are some that can handle traffic...but most of all it's a dead dying form of communication. LOL, it is far from dying... In 2013 the number of US licensees is at an all time high. We are over 700,000 in the US alone. As for the old guys talking about medical ailments, you must be thinking of 75 meters where the colonoscopy nets are... Yes, I'm a ham but I'm more into contesting and DX than I am in just talking on the radio. You discussion on modern encrpytion and the AX.25 protocol.... How are you going to distribute the keys? How many keyloaders you have...? OTR re-keying is a trunked radio solution... AX.25 is not secure and frankly DES and DES/XL can be brute force broken with enough of a sampling.... are you planning on AES....? also the radios you speak of that handle this are point to point squad type same operational distance type radios.... not to many quantars up....to handle digi traffic...and the idea of encrypetd comms being transmitted to other supporting units during this crisis is a panacea...it wont happen. AX.25 is old but there's Pactor which is used by sailboaters, both inside and outside of the ham bands. It used to be used for MARS but they disbanded it, I suspect because you need the expensive SCS modem. But it is in widespread civilian use. I don't like it on the ham bands but it is an option. Encryption is not allowed on ham radio though, but it can be done. The military uses HF in addition to satellite comms. There are commercial products available that do encryption. There are a number of "advanced" HF stuff that hams are playing with including digital voice on HF which can be encrypted. I really doubt that ham radio is the communication medium I would want to use to be an outlaw though...
February 4, 201313 yr A martyr in the eyes of the media is a terrorist. A survivalist with Anti American views. A radical. An extremist. Perception is reality and the media dictates the perception. The media doesn't dictate perception, they cater perception to a group of individuals. The media outlets who would do as you claim are not taken seriously by ANYONE in our position.
February 7, 201313 yr Make people into criminals, they might just act like criminals right back at you. You don't stand up to them when they are expecting a fight. You bring the fight to them when they aren't expecting it. Asymetric warfare will be a **** when your job is to show up when someone calls. I know I have made the point before about being a cop is unpleasant and high risk of injury, but not really deadly. I also brought up the above. If it comes down to it, asymmetric warefare will be a **** for the police, and things might go a bit weird in a way the public may not like. Case in point http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2013/02/ex-cop-manhunt-newspaper-delivery-women-shot.html The LAPD is going a bit crazy when it is their butt directly on the line and someone wants them dead. They have shot two people without any pretense of following procedure, and opened fire on two unrelated vehicles for simply matching the make model and color. Neither had anything to do with the bad guy. How much more of this do you think the populace is going to tolerate for something that is a threat to the police and not them? http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lanow/2013/02/ex-cop-manhunt-newspaper-delivery-women-shot.html
February 7, 201313 yr I know I have made the point before about being a cop is unpleasant and high risk of injury, but not really deadly. I also brought up the above. If it comes down to it, asymmetric warefare will be a **** for the police, and things might go a bit weird in a way the public may not like. Case in point http://latimesblogs....women-shot.html The LAPD is going a bit crazy when it is their butt directly on the line and someone wants them dead. They have shot two people without any pretense of following procedure, and opened fire on two unrelated vehicles for simply matching the make model and color. Neither had anything to do with the bad guy. How much more of this do you think the populace is going to tolerate for something that is a threat to the police and not them? http://latimesblogs....women-shot.html Probably quite a bit, while not representative of most police, when this stuff does happen, it's usually swept under the rug. That is, unless they believe race played a role in the officer's decision to "shoot first, ask questions later." While I generally cannot stand the OWS movement, and I believe they got away with A LOT of BS that wouldn't be tolerated if other groups, like 2A supporters did it, I do think they had some valid points when they brought up police brutality, and unnecessary force. Of course, an officer's decision to use lethal force immediately, before it may be necessary is likely more a training issue than one of malice. The problem could probably be solved by more intensive training in areas such as threat identification, and threat response, I mean we've probably learned some lessons about that in Iraq dealing with insurgents, who blend in with the normal population, I'm sure we could apply similar techniques to police training. Back on the OWS thing, I find it Ironic they aren't big 2A supporters. After all, their whole belief that the 1% has all the power should encourage them to believe in the Second Amendment as a means to deter tyranny. After all, in the event of a ban, or confiscation, who would have all the weapons? Only the rich and powerful, too bad that idea is lost on them.
February 8, 201313 yr LOL, it is far from dying... In 2013 the number of US licensees is at an all time high. We are over 700,000 in the US alone. As for the old guys talking about medical ailments, you must be thinking of 75 meters where the colonoscopy nets are... Yes, I'm a ham but I'm more into contesting and DX than I am in just talking on the radio. AX.25 is old but there's Pactor which is used by sailboaters, both inside and outside of the ham bands. It used to be used for MARS but they disbanded it, I suspect because you need the expensive SCS modem. But it is in widespread civilian use. I don't like it on the ham bands but it is an option. Encryption is not allowed on ham radio though, but it can be done. The military uses HF in addition to satellite comms. There are commercial products available that do encryption. There are a number of "advanced" HF stuff that hams are playing with including digital voice on HF which can be encrypted. I really doubt that ham radio is the communication medium I would want to use to be an outlaw though... Ive used MARS for many years to call home and get messages relayed. HF is alive and well globally. Its still the only way to fly around the world when not in radar contact or GCA. Oceanic flights still requires HF comms. Its a bonifide life saver too.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.