Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

‘We The People of New York’ To Take on Gov Cuomo & NY SAFE ACT

Featured Replies

"On February 19, we will Petition the Court by filing a lawsuit with the NY Supreme Court in Albany against the Governor for abusing his power under Article III of the New York State Constitution. On that day, we will also Serve a Petition for Redress on our government to uphold Article XII which says every citizen in New York is a member of the militia. The two actions go hand-in-hand. What happens here in New York is being watched by the rest of the Nation."

 

http://www.ammoland.com/2013/02/we-the-people-of-new-york-to-take-on-gov-cuomo-ny-safe-act/#axzz2KBEYmsy1

 

Being that SCOTUS has already ruled that if you are part of a militia you are protected from having any weapons taken away this case should prove interesting!

This seems to me to possibly be an ill-fated attempt, based on weak grounds. I think a better thought out challenge could be made on constitutional grounds and employing the rulings of Heller and McDonald. This kind of reminds me of ANJRPC's challenge of OGAM using the BB gun premise.

 

I wish them luck and hope that this isn't the only challenge to that ill-conceived piece of legislation.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

Here is what they are contesting:

 

Article 3, Section 14

[Manner of passing bills; message of necessity for immediate vote]

 

§14. No bill shall be passed or become a law unless it shall have been printed and upon the desks of the members, in its final form, at least three calendar legislative days prior to its final passage, unless the governor, or the acting governor, shall have certified, under his or her hand and the seal of the state, the facts which in his or her opinion necessitate an immediate vote thereon, in which case it must nevertheless be upon the desks of the members in final form, not necessarily printed, before its final passage; nor shall any bill be passed or become a law, except by the assent of a majority of the members elected to each branch of the legislature; and upon the last reading of a bill, no amendment thereof shall be allowed, and the question upon its final passage shall be taken immediately thereafter, and the ayes and nays entered on the journal. (Formerly §15. Renumbered and amended by Constitutional Convention of 1938 and approved by vote of the people November 8, 1938; further amended by vote of the people November 6, 2001.)

 

Article 12, Section 1

[Defense; militia]

 

Section 1. The defense and protection of the state and of the United States is an obligation of all persons within the state. The legislature shall provide for the discharge of this obligation and for the maintenance and regulation of an organized militia.

 

The shot they are taking at Gov. Cuomo is that, according to media accounts, this is was the 35th time he has used the "immediate necessity" provision and that "Cuomo said that gun violence constituted an emergency, requiring fast action by legislators." Facts of course don't support his argument as violent crime continues to decline across his state. Furthermore, I think any reasonable person would find it hard to believe that their politicians could read through all 78 pages, ask questions, have their questions addressed, and fully understand the bill in its entirety within the one hour in which it was printed and passed. The constitutional provision allowing for immediate action seems entirely too broad, so I'm not sure how much success they'll have.

 

As far as the militia part goes, I don't know if the NY courts have already interpreted the state constitution to say all NY citizens are militia members. If they have, the SCOTUS "common use" decision could be a good route to overturn the SAFE Act.

More importantly when the soonest effective date of the bill is 3 months from the date it is passed, it cannot be logically argued to require immediate action by the legislature.

This seems to me to possibly be an ill-fated attempt, based on weak grounds.

 

Weak grounds???

 

He violated NY law and the NYS constitution. They arguably violated the US constitution. Documents 2 and 1 respectively, at the top of the hierarchy. Not sure how much stronger you can go before it is no longer 'weak' I guess...

I'd love to see some of that kind of moxy in NJ.

Again, ALL these traitor states, (Yes, I said traitor) like NY, NJ, CA will put a 'Halo' around there reserved right to regulate as they please in accordance to what they read in the Heller decision, which is the ONLY thing they read and thought they understood in it.

 

 

Weak grounds???

 

He violated NY law and the NYS constitution. They arguably violated the US constitution. Documents 2 and 1 respectively, at the top of the hierarchy. Not sure how much stronger you can go before it is no longer 'weak' I guess...

 

A "message of necessity" is a very subjective determination, and probably what this case will hinge upon. He has used the "message of necessity" many times in the recent past and was never called to task for it - the case will have to be made as to why he should now.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

I think they may have ground IMHO... "Cuomo said that gun violence constituted an emergency, requiring fast action by legislators." he says...

So then, what constitutes an emergency? WHAT EMERGENCY? Something that has resided in NY in like, ...forever?

There were no mass shootings in NY, there is no uprising (yet) of any militias threatening the government or it's people.

Like a anything else, it's a knee-jerk agenda to make him the mighty turd and to advance in politics. It was his LOOP-HOLE to have a reason to be seen... I find that they are so hell-bent on worrying about gun laws, that they/he tends to ignore that people are still living in tents, streets and more from the last storm. Here it is Feb and they are facing a blizzard and people still have no permanent homes. Where the fook are political priorities these days... WTF!

I think they may have ground IMHO... "Cuomo said that gun violence constituted an emergency, requiring fast action by legislators." he says...

So then, what constitutes an emergency? WHAT EMERGENCY? Something that has resided in NY in like, ...forever?

 

More importantly, as someone mentioned above, if it was such an emergency that he couldn't follow the process and wait 3 days, why did parts of the bill not take effect for over 3 months after passing? I haven't double checked but if that's true it is a good argument against "necessity".

  • Author

This seems to me to possibly be an ill-fated attempt, based on weak grounds. I think a better thought out challenge could be made on constitutional grounds and employing the rulings of Heller and McDonald. This kind of reminds me of ANJRPC's challenge of OGAM using the BB gun premise.

 

I wish them luck and hope that this isn't the only challenge to that ill-conceived piece of legislation.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

 

On the contrary. This is an excellent argument bringing up the militia issue. Heller and McDonald have nothing to do with this. SCOTUS has already ruled that if you are in a militia in which the NY state constitution says you are then protected and can have military style weapons and large capacity mags.

 

You guys have to stop throwing this "keep and bear arms should not be infringed" at every argument. This peticular issue regarding being part of a militia is the arguing point!

  • 4 weeks later...

I wish them luck, but I lost my excitement after the word "petition". Lawsuit is the only relatively quick way...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.