Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Antonin Scalia says gun control is heading to Supreme Court

Featured Replies

  • Replies 83
  • Views 8.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

Extremely rare interview with Supreme Court Justice Scalia:

 

 

Well we should all contribute to his doctors wallet because we are always a heart attack away form a 5/4 the other way.

The only thing those scumbags have ever done is fugg us and shred the Constitution. They are political hacks of the worst sort.

  • Author

Well we should all contribute to his doctors wallet because we are always a heart attack away form a 5/4 the other way.

 

At the rate this is moving it might be in the SCOTUS before summer. I think Scalia is asking for someone to bring it!

  • Author

The only thing those scumbags have ever done is fugg us and shred the Constitution. They are political hacks of the worst sort.

 

What about Heller and Mcdonald?

The only thing those scumbags have ever done is fugg us and shred the Constitution. They are political hacks of the worst sort.

 

Examples?

Ok, so I can't carry around my common and the rocket launcher is questionable, ok I can live with that, the cannon is a younger mans arm, and it's tough to get standard pistol and rifle ammo and the price increase on that is rough, I probably can't afford rockets anyway.

 

So can we carry??

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

What about Heller and Mcdonald?

 

Tremendous losses.

 

- Right to keep and bear arms is an individual right.  Duh, it's in the Bill of Rights.

 

- Subject to restrictions, such as types of guns, where you can have them, licensing, restrictions on carrying guns, government buildings obviously - may not have been a ruling in the case, but those words are the rule of law in the US according to our legislators and clearly the shape of things to come.

  • Author

Obamacare

 

They didn't make up obamacare, they just ruled on it. Take it up with Barry.

Heller II was remanded by the Court of Appeals, so it will be years before it comes back up to SCOTUS.

 

I am not seeing any other cases of AWB rising to SCOTUS anytime sooner. State AWB take a while, and Federal AWB doesn't look likely to pass.

  • Author

Tremendous losses.

 

 

 

What the hell is wrong with you? They affirmed your right to Keep and Bear arms.

  • Author

 

I am not seeing any other cases of AWB rising to SCOTUS anytime sooner. State AWB take a while, and Federal AWB doesn't look likely to pass.

 

I think NY is going there in a hurry

Examples?

 

1. Wickard v. Filburn - Federal Government can do anything it wants because anything you can do affects interstate commerce even when it does not affect interstate commerce.

 

99% of what the federal government does it has no power to do, and 95% of it is outright illegal.  Thanks to the US Supreme Court.

 

2. Obamacare - Federal government has the power to tax.  Therefore, they CAN tax you a flat $500,000 per year if you don't eat broccoli every day.

 

3. Heller and MacDonald - Federal government can ignore the Second Amendment.

 

4. Almost every single ruling since FDR.They gave themselves the power to give Congress the power to do anything they want and completely ignore the Constitution.  There is no rule of law in this land.

What the hell is wrong with you? They affirmed your right to Keep and Bear arms.

 

What the hell is wrong with me?  See,

Duh, it's in the Bill of Rights.

 

Did you need some affirmation?

 

No affirmation was needed, and they certainly didn't affirm my "right."  They said it was open to reasonable restriction.

 

What the hell is wrong with you?  You need the US Supreme Court to tell you that you DON'T have a right to Keep and Bear Arms, when you had one before they opened their political pie holes?

 

Why do you think Obama and some of Congress are doing what they are doing?  Because the US Supreme Court has defended the Bill of Rights?  The Constitution?  No, the opposite, the US Supreme Court has said for the last 75 years that the Bill Of Rights and the Constitution are nice when it doesn't inconvenience the Federal Government.  They did this to us, and they continued it with Heller.  

 

I am, however, delighted to hear that you are pleased with your new found privilege.  Subject to restrictions, or participation of Obama, void where prohibited.

 

 

I think NY is going there in a hurry

 

They only filed notice.

Then within 3 months they have to file the lawsuit.

Then the court sets dates.

Then the court hears evidence.

Then court thinks about it.

Then court announces a decision.

Then decision gets appealed to Court of Appeals.

Then appeals court decides when or not to grant review.

.....

Then appeals court remands the case back for further evidentiary hearing...

...

It will probably be a while.

And State AWB tends not to do too well.

Reference 2001 Kasler v Lockyer.

  • Author

What the hell is wrong with me? See,

 

Did you need some affirmation?

 

No affirmation was needed, and they certainly didn't affirm my "right." They said it was open to reasonable restriction.

 

What the hell is wrong with you? You need the US Supreme Court to tell you that you DON'T have a right to Keep and Bear Arms, when you had one before they opened their political pie holes?

 

Why do you think Obama and some of Congress are doing what they are doing? Because the US Supreme Court has defended the Bill of Rights? The Constitution? No, the opposite, the US Supreme Court has said for the last 75 years that the Bill Of Rights and the Constitution are nice when it doesn't inconvenience the Federal Government. They did this to us, and they continued it with Heller.

 

I am, however, delighted to hear that you are pleased with your new found privilege. Subject to restrictions, or participation of Obama, void where prohibited.

 

Well, unfortunately it was needed, and you got it.

 

And what the hell are you so twisted about? You live in PA, home of the free, most unlike NJ.

 

Wow, and I thought I like conspiracy tendencies. I suggest you run for office and make your perfect world happen.

 

It might be time to become a realist someday and realized you almost never get all you want.you might even realize that the constitution is not perfect and that sometimes the supreme court decision might not be what you want but might indeed be correct.

 

Of course they are human and sometime they make mistakes. If you think you can do better then I hear they have law schools.

Well we should all contribute to his doctors wallet because we are always a heart attack away form a 5/4 the other way.

 

LOL. Yes, you know it.

 

But I think we already do have a 5/4 the other way, with Justice Kennedy and Roberts...

So you and I may not like it some days but there are always limits on right. Beating our chests about it is pointless. Poke a shark and then complain about your constitutional right to life. Nature will laugh in your face. Kill someone and tell me about your right of liberty.

 

Every right is limited, including the right to bear arms. If you believe it isn't I'll ask you if you think it is ok for me to walk into a nuclear missile silo with grenade launcher. Of course there are sensitive place I can't bring weapons in, even if I technically own a small fraction of the place. To make the example extreme, do mentally unstable people have a right to own a nuclear weapon? Can I spread lies about anyone in print without getting sued? Can I create a successful news outlet and then claim that aliens are coming and everyone should kill themselves? Do you have a right to block a river a village depends on to survive because it passes through your property? You don't have to like Kelo to realize that property rights are not absolute either.

 

As soon as you say those are extreme examples, I'll reply that there are indeed limits and they are probably somewhere between my extreme examples and the absolute prohibition of those rights. Well at some point we'll have to clarify where those limits are, and sometimes the line moves. There were no nuclear weapons during the revolutionary war so we don't know what Jefferson would have thought about them but I'm fairly sure if you explained to those guys how one of them worked they might have mentioned that the village idiot shouldn't have one as a toy. We conveniently forget that many of the people involved in writing the constitution owned slaves, so their idea of liberty might not have been what we think it is.

 

I'm going to keep this about guns, so lets discuss how mipafox's contention about Heller and McDonald is ridiculous. The SC did not wake up one morning and decided to limit your rights. You and me, and your parents and your grandparents kept on sending idiots to Washington and approve of their moves. Eventually the idiots went a bit to far and restricted our rights beyond what a lot of considered to be reasonable. So we **** about it, hired some lawyers and sent them to the SC. Just like we sent the village idiots to rule us, we sent someone somewhat sane to SC and asked to have the idiots decisions revised.

 

In Heller and Mcdonald, the SC did its job. They didn't pass a laws, they look at laws we allowed to happen and said, sorry, you passed the line of sanity, back it up. They didn't rule on machine guns, or bazookas, or field artillery, or ICBMs because that was not what we complained about. They didn't draw a clear line, because that is not their job. Whenever they say something it become cannon for future generations so drawing a line which technology may run over with dump truck is pointless. They ruled on the question we asked, which was can someone own a gun for self defense? The answer was yes. Then we asked them again .. hey we are not clear, does that mean in all the states, and they said yes. They AFFIRMED a right. They didn't draw a line, they just said this specific laws you asked us about, are on the wrong side of the line given current technology.

 

They also, wisely, warned that there is a line. Again, grenade launcher in a missile silo. Of course there is a line. Do you want murderers or clinical sociopaths to own guns? Maybe you do, but me and lots of people don't and frankly your freedom to swing your fist ends right at my nose.

 

For some reason some people don't get this. If you want absolute freedom, you feel free to build a spaceship and go live by yourself on a asteroid, that is the only time you will have absolute, pure, do what you want, no one can tell me no freedom. If you want to live in a world where someone picks up your garbage or delivers you a paper you won't have it. I too think in some ways we've gone to far on many issues, but if you think your life is hard, go live anywhere else in the world and write me a letter about your freedom, let me know how it is working out for you.

 

The reason this attitude pisses me off, is because it is counterproductive. Whenever you walk up to someone and tell them you think you want to own and bear arms and follow that by telling them that there are no limits and you should have your bazooka in a silo they are going to think you are crazy. When I later walk up to them and say I should own and bear arms and I mean an AR and a concealed handgun they are going to assume I mean your bazooka in a silo and start thinking there are lots of crazies there and maybe we should watch out for them.

 

Do do us all favor and before you wrap yourself in the flag, and claim your liberty is absolute, think first. It will not only be better for the rest of us, but it might be better for yourself as well by not always thinking about how oppressed you are. Before you claim that the biggest affirmation of the rights you say you hold dear was in fact a limitation of your rights you might want to actually bother to understand how our imperfect legal system actually works instead of making the rest of us look like fools.

Thank you Vlad. Reason and rational thinking over defeatist absolutes any day.

Problem with Kelo is that for the fist time in US history the USSC decided that the greater good for which private property could be taken away from its owners is not limited to building schools, highways and such. No, according to the supremes, private corporations can use their influence to have the state expropriate your property for the profit of said corp.

 

This decision, for all intents and porposes, eliminated private property. It's completly different from limiting "my right" to piss on a stream that crosses my property that my downstream neighbour uses for drinking water. Completely different.

This sounds like a personal attack , why not respect his first amendment rights and skip lines like "do us all a favor", lets not speak for all of us when some may be more tolerant of others views. Just saying.

I agree with Vlad. I'm hoping this gets up to the SC soon. Can you imagine if they rule "Your AWB is unconstitutional" and then suddenly EVERY AWB throughout the US is invalidated? The deathcry of the Brady campaign and the rest of those assholes will be saccharine to my ears.

I agree with Vlad. I'm hoping this gets up to the SC soon. Can you imagine if they rule "Your AWB is unconstitutional" and then suddenly EVERY AWB throughout the US is invalidated? The deathcry of the Brady campaign and the rest of those assholes will be saccharine to my ears.

 

That would be very nice.

 

I am not sure SCOTUS has the balls for it, but one can dream.

 

Honestly I don't understand why folks like Brady and McCarthy give a same about AWB. Brady was shot with a 22 revolver and McCarthy with a 9mm. Just goes to show the irrationality and fear of blaming the tool instead of the person.

Honestly I don't understand why folks like Brady and McCarthy give a same about AWB. Brady was shot with a 22 revolver and McCarthy with a 9mm. Just goes to show the irrationality and fear of blaming the tool instead of the person.

 

Because without guns, they have no argument, no substance, no reason for existing. When the Brady group and McCarthy say they don't want to outright ban guns, THEY'RE telling the truth because without guns, they have no relevance. They NEED guns and gun violence to exist for them to continue being relevant.

I agree with Vlad. I'm hoping this gets up to the SC soon. Can you imagine if they rule "Your AWB is unconstitutional" and then suddenly EVERY AWB throughout the US is invalidated? The deathcry of the Brady campaign and the rest of those assholes will be saccharine to my ears.

 

+1

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.