Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

N.Y. bill would force gun owners to buy at least $1M in insurance

Featured Replies

We're next. California was first, NY was next, we're third in the barrel.

 

$1600-2000 annual premium to have guns.

 

Jackass Cuomo will sign it.

 

We can thank Justice Roberts for allowing government to force us to have insurance. Confiscation will result in deaths. No way around it. Citizens and security agents will die over this. All at the stroke of a pen.

 

---------

http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2013/feb/19/ny-bill-would-force-gun-owners-buy-least-1m-insura/

 

 

A bill introduced in the New York State Assembly by Assemblyman Felix Ortiz, a Democrat, would require the state’s residents to acquire liability insurance as a condition for gun ownership.

“Any person in this state who shall own a firearm shall, prior to such ownership, obtain and continuously maintain a policy of liability insurance in an amount not less than one million dollars specifically covering any damages resulting from any negligent or willful acts involving the use of such firearm while it is owned by such person,” the measure, dubbed S2353, reads.

SEE RELATED: Mayor Emanuel: Minority males are majority of Chicago’s shooters

Any person who has not purchased insurance in compliance with the law within 30 days of its passing would be in violation of the law.

Such an occurrence “shall result in the immediate revocation of such owner’s registration, license and any other privilege to own such firearm.”

The bill also states that if a gun is stolen, the legal owner of that gun is responsible for any damage incurred until a loss or theft is reported to the police department.

Liability insurance for $1 million in coverage for gun owners is estimated to cost between $1,600 and $2,000 annually, the Examiner reports.

The bill has been referred to the Assembly’s Insurance Committee.

Mr. Ortiz represents a district in the New York borough of Brooklyn

Is that policy on each gun? It seems like it might be the way it is written.

 

As a constitutional right, I think tax payers should be able to deduct 100% of the premiums from their taxes.

 

Can't we require politicians to have insurance against corruption, etc? Surely it should be several thousand dollars a year as well. It might get expensive for some of them, though, because they don't always pay taxes.

 

And, perhaps we should invite them in for some tea in Washington State as we discussed these continued assaults on personal freedom and as we read the fine print:

 

Sheriffs can inspect homes for safe gun storage in Washington state ...

 

 

I agree with you completely, Malsua, I fear that these reckless and irresponsible politicians and foes to our nation will have blood on their hands.

.

Can't we require politicians to have insurance against corruption, etc?

 

this ^^^^^^

Hell no!! Our backround checks already prove we are upstanding citizens. What percentage of FID holders have damages resulting from any negligent or willful acts involving the use of such firearm. Very, very low I am sure.

 

Hey, if LEOs are always exempt, let's all become LEOs! Got to be a way to do it. Problems solved.

 

I know, I know, from my lips to God's ears.

$1600-2000 annual premium to have guns.

 

 

Is there any actuarial reason to pick this number????

 

(Except extrapolating from the premiums asked for those NRA-endorsed policies. Which are probably overpriced, and seem to be directed towards CCW permit states. In any case, underwriters of life, health and homeowners insurance policies don't care if you have guns or not, the risk is so small.)

 

I'm not a lawyer, and I don't stay at Holiday Inns any more, but I just looked at the "Liability Coverage" and "Exclusions" sections of our homeowner's insurance policy. I don't see any exclusion of liability for injuries from firearms. So I suppose I'd be covered. For a total premium that's much less than $1600, which also includes everything else plus an "umbrella". Read your homeowner's insurance policy.

“Any person in this state who shall own a firearm shall, prior to such ownership, obtain and continuously maintain a policy of liability insurance in an amount not less than one million dollars specifically covering any damages resulting from any negligent or willful acts involving the use of such firearm while it is owned by such person,” the measure, dubbed S2353, reads.

I'd have to see how or if they define "willful acts."

 

Presently, the liability coverage under your homeowner, condo, or renters insurance, would respond in the case of an accidental shooting. If they are looking for coverage for intentional acts, that's going to be an issue. You can't buy 3rd party liability coverage for your intentional acts. The industry doesn't work that way.

but I just looked at the "Liability Coverage" and "Exclusions" sections of our homeowner's insurance policy. I don't see any exclusion of liability for injuries from firearms. So I suppose I'd be covered. For a total premium that's much less than $1600, which also includes everything else plus an "umbrella". Read your homeowner's insurance policy.

You are correct.

This country is dying from the inside out. I am ashamed to call these people Americans.

You are correct.

 

That all depends on your amount of coverage. CA for instance is proposing a 1mil dollar coverage. Im not sure where the 1600 number comes from if an umbrella policy is acceptable.. I have a 1mil policy that costs 175 a year that covers me and my family.

 

Maybe the numbers where taken from a business liability policy in reference to firearms. Those were the numbers I was getting when I was considering dipping my toes into the firearms industry.

Jamal doesn't even have car insurance, what makes you think he's going to purchase it for his illegal firearm?

 

With all these laws coming out and being passed you can see how the saying "The pen is mightier then the sword" has a lot of truth to it.

That all depends on your amount of coverage.

I was speaking to his comments that firearm accidents aren't excluded under his homeowner policy. I can't speak to the premium because each situation is different.

 

Generally speaking you can get a $1,000,000 "Personal Excess Liability Policy" (we don't call them Umbrella's anymore) for under $200.00, and this would also include accidental firearm related accidents.

Homeowners liability will NOT cover "willful" acts. Accidental, yes, on purpose, no.

 

I dont even know of a policy that WILL cover that.

If they "**allow** us the privilege of having another hearing I am going to spend my 2 minutes as such:

 

" are you people on fu#$ing crack!!???!! "

Homeowners liability will NOT cover "willful" acts. Accidental, yes, on purpose, no.

 

I dont even know of a policy that WILL cover that.

 

Yeah, this! What insurance company in their right mind would ever write a policy that pays damages if you do something on purpose?

 

I guess that begs the question, if they can force us to buy it (like health insurance) and nobody sells it, are we in compliance with the law or not?

" are you people on fu#$ing crack!!???!! "

 

If NY passes a law requiring law-abiding citizens to purchase liability insurance to cover criminals when they break the law -- they've crossed the Rubicon, and there's no turning back.

This is already signed law in California?

If NY passes a law requiring law-abiding citizens to purchase liability insurance to cover criminals when they break the law -- they've crossed the Rubicon, and there's no turning back.

 

This.

 

From what I remember reading the proposed bill it is not meant to cover something YOU do accidentally with YOUR firearm in your home.. as others have mentioned this is usually covered under existing homeowners insurance (for accidents anyway).

 

This bill does two things:

1) You are liable for ANYTHING done with a firearm you own. If it is stolen, not reported, and used for a crime then YOU are liable for the damages from that crime.

2) Once liability is established in #1, you are required to have insurance to cover that liability. This is not normal homeowners insurance.. this is something NEW, which is why it is believed it will be expensive.

 

This bill is bad on MANY levels.. it establishes liability, it uses that liability as a huge stick for reporting stolen firearms, and it requires insurance to protect against it's self-installed liability.

Time to overthrow the gov't and all their laws they are trying to pass.

 

How about the justice system buys insurance for career criminals they put back on the streets!

Reason and logic will not answer your questions. This is just another way to kill the second amendment. They will chip away untill we surrender, they use the two most important features of any terrorists, creativity and persistance.

This country is dying from the inside out. I am ashamed to call these people Americans.

 

Alec, I believe these people are already ashamed to call themselves Americans. These are the same people that constantly say, "lets be more like Europe" and "Cuba has free health care for everyone."

 

IDIOTS!

Such an occurrence “shall result in the immediate revocation of such owner’s registration, license and any other privilege to own such firearm.”

The bill also states that if a gun is stolen, the legal owner of that gun is responsible for any damage incurred until a loss or theft is reported to the police department.

 

 

Wrong on so many levels it is difficult to prevent my head from exploding, but the bold word above written into law is just re-writting the Constitution. Next we will need insurance to open out mouths...

And how does THIS ONE stop violence?

 

Stopping violence isn't really their goal. It's getting guns out of our hands.

Jamal doesn't even have car insurance, what makes you think he's going to purchase it for his illegal firearm?

 

Neither do the illegals coming across the border. Ask anyone in SoCal who has gotten into a car accident lately.

This.

 

From what I remember reading the proposed bill it is not meant to cover something YOU do accidentally with YOUR firearm in your home.. as others have mentioned this is usually covered under existing homeowners insurance (for accidents anyway).

 

This bill does two things:

1) You are liable for ANYTHING done with a firearm you own. If it is stolen, not reported, and used for a crime then YOU are liable for the damages from that crime.

2) Once liability is established in #1, you are required to have insurance to cover that liability. This is not normal homeowners insurance.. this is something NEW, which is why it is believed it will be expensive.

 

This bill is bad on MANY levels.. it establishes liability, it uses that liability as a huge stick for reporting stolen firearms, and it requires insurance to protect against it's self-installed liability.

 

Wait, the government wants to hold one responsible for the criminal actions of another? WTF

There is nothing stopping anyone right now from making a civil suit.

 

I believe most general liability umbrella policies should cover this anyway if this monstrosity comes to pass. Should not be more than $100 a year for most people.

Wait, the government wants to hold one responsible for the criminal actions of another? WTF

 

The most ridiculous thing is that, to my knowledge, we don't even have a law that specifically targets straw purchasing. Yet in NY, they propose a law that specifically targets law abiding owners that have had their property stolen.

 

If they really wanted to do something useful they'd pass a law that severely punished people who knowingly straw purchase and/or actively traffic firearms. Make those people at least partially responsible for the crimes that are committed with those firearms, similar to how the driver in a bank robbery turned murder can be charged with murder.

This will never pass constitutional muster. More than stopping poor people from buying guns, it is a way for the Dems to make insurance companies regulate guns for them.

 

Think of insurance companies only willing to insure single shot bolt action .22s to keep down liability.

 

 

 

Something tells me that this may eventually rip the country apart. If thats what it takes to insure all civil rights, I am ok with it. I worry that by the time I retire and can leave this shit hole, the govt will have destroyed all our civil liberties and it wont matter where you move.

 

I also dont think Texas will remain a free state with the influx of democrat voting Mexicans, it has gone from Red to Pink and soon to Purple.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.