Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Someone please explain to me...why would being a "victim" of "gun violence" give you more say on gun control related matters?

Featured Replies

I am just trying to understand the rationale here.

So, for congressional hearings on proposed gun control laws, we've all seen it - they routinely bring in these victims, their family members, etc.

Are they saying that, due to their "victim" status, their words and their personal viewpoints should carry more weight?

I am not saying I don't sympathize with many of these people. All I am trying to do is get down to the underlying premise.

Does "victim" status mean that you somehow "paid your dues," or that your viewpoint is somehow more enlightened than the next person, or that your opinions should carry more weight?

Funny how they trot out all these examples and quickly brush off Amanda Collins, or worse yet, insult her with stupidity and irrelevant statistics.

"victim" means that "gun violence" has impacted you.. and it qualifies you to speak out on how violence can impact lives.. it is reasonable to ask individuals that have been impacted by something to speak about it.. unfortunately the cause of the problem is being overlooked..

 

the cause of "gun violence" is criminals.. not guns..

Shouldn't it make them less knowledgeable to speak since they weren't smart enough to know how to protect themselves?

  • Author

I pay more taxes than the next guy.

I have more "hands on" experience with this issue, and it has had a significant, direct impact on my life.

I am a bigger "victim" of the tax system...

Does that give me more say on how the government should be run?

 

I am a father.

I have more "hands on" experience with this issue, and it has had a significant, direct impact on my life.

I am faced with the challenges and obstacles of raising children...

Does that give me more say on abortion related issues?

 

Funny... because I bet the typical argument against both of these two above points would be... those two factors actually cut *against* your credibility on those two issues. They make you biased on those particular issues, watering down the value of your personal viewpoint...

 

 

I pay more taxes than the next guy.

I have more "hands on" experience with this issue, and it has had a significant, direct impact on my life.

I am a bigger "victim" of the tax system...

Does that give me more say on how the government should be run?

 

I am a father.

I have more "hands on" experience with this issue, and it has had a significant, direct impact on my life.

I am faced with the challenges and obstacles of raising children...

Does that give me more say on abortion related issues?

 

Funny... because I bet the typical argument against both of these two above points would be... those two factors actually cut *against* your credibility on those two issues. They make you biased on those particular issues, watering down the value of your personal viewpoint...

 

no.. your missing the point completely...

 

I am not saying it affords someone the right to dictate your life... I am saying it is more logical than it sounds... like for example.. would you ask a farmer in amish country to testify as the the impact of gang violence in New York.. no.. of course not..

 

misapplying the blame of violence to an inanimate object (like a gun) is the mistake.. but having someone impacted by it is really not that ridiculous IMO..

  • Author

Vlad - believe me, I agree with you.

I just don't think that those who are pushing all of these First Responder Disarmament Laws (my term for gun control laws) see it that way.

 

I guess what I'm saying is, I don't think being a victim of gun violence gives you any more of an enlightened view than a non-victim has.

 

If anything, I think there's an argument to be made that the viewpoint is biased.

 

A victim of gun violence shouldn't expect to have any more of a seat at the table on gun control issues than anybody else.

 

If you ask a bunch of millionaire lottery winners what they think about the idea of buying lottery tickets, they'll probably tell you it's a very smart thing to do.

 

 

Vlad - believe me, I agree with you.

I just don't think that those who are pushing all of these First Responder Disarmament Laws (my term for gun control laws) see it that way.

 

I guess what I'm saying is, I don't think being a victim of gun violence gives you any more of an enlightened view than a non-victim has.

 

If anything, I think there's an argument to be made that the viewpoint is biased.

 

A victim of gun violence shouldn't expect to have any more of a seat at the table on gun control issues than anybody else.

 

If you ask a bunch of millionaire lottery winners what they think about the idea of buying lottery tickets, they'll probably tell you it's a very smart thing to do.

 

we put people up there to tell stories about how they saved the day with a gun...

they put people up there to tell stories about their loved ones shot to death...

 

at the end of the day we are both guilty.. we scream from the roof tops about how a gun was used to save a life.. but it is not the gun.. it is the hero behind the gun.. just like it is the criminal and not the gun that commits crime.. you can not expect one side to not create propaganda when the other side is... trust me.. I am totally against gun control.. I think most of the legislation proposed is ridiculous.. but the game is the game... and both sides are playing.. IMO of course..

They do that for one reason only. To bolster their arguments with people who can testify to the emotional side of the argument. They're blowing smoke by using victims, and their families. It doesn't bring credibility to the table, only emotions.

Shouldn't it make them less knowledgeable to speak since they weren't smart enough to know how to protect themselves?

 

Exactly.

 

Will the Newtown superintendent tell you how they did everything wrong that allowed the shooting to happen?

Will Giffords, ever say she was so unaware of her surroundings as to let wacko boy get so close?

 

How about they bring up people who actually stopped something from occurring?

  • Author

I should probably mention the thing that got me fired up about this issue.

 

I read that the parents of the Newtown victims were upset that Congress/Obama didn't consult with them - at least not enough - as lawmakers formulated their ideas for proposed new gun control measures.

 

I am very sad for these families. Thinking about their losses breaks my heart to this day...

 

...But they have ZERO more say on the substance of proposed new gun control laws than I do.

  • Author

Sorry, I misspoke in my prior post.

 

I said gun control laws.

 

I meant to say First Responder Disarmament Laws.

 

We are the first responders.

If I get run over by a car, what does that make me? A traffic expert or a vehicle engineering expert?

  • Author

The thing that really gets me is that some "victims"/families of gun violence fully EXPECT to have some sort of enhanced seat at the lawmaking table.

 

As if it is some sort of justice or quid-pro-quo for the suffering they went through.

 

What a dangerous and flawed concept this is.

Send them to me. I was robbed at gunpoint once. I support an absolute RKBA. :o

Sorry, I misspoke in my prior post.

 

I said gun control laws.

 

I meant to say First Responder Disarmament Laws.

 

We are the first responders.

When you say we a "responders" you're implying that we are called to an incident are are expected to act to diffuse the incident, that is not the case. I think a more appropriate way to say what you are trying to say would be Victim Disarmament Laws. If someone tries to rob, rape, murder you, you are a victim not a responder.

I am definitely the first, last, and only responder in my household.

 

Anyone else is just coming to take away the bodies.

In your house, I can see your point. But that right isn't the one that's currently denied to us...........

the only reason they trot out these victims is because they have no logical reasoning. the statistics aren't on their side, they show the reality of the situation, that rifles are rarely used in crime (compared to handguns and other weapons), but since the data doesn't support the hypothesis, they MUST go the emotional route. otherwise they have absolutely no leg to stand on. it kind of reminds me of the terrorists using planes to kill innocent people, you could ask a terrorist sympathizer why they could possibly sympathize with someone who murders innocent people. their response? "It's the only weapon they have. they don't have F-18's and tanks and satellite night vision tracking, they use the only resources they have to strike fear into people's hearts" same with the anti's. emotional tugging at the heart strings for slain children is the only argument they have to use against us. that's why logic and reason and real common sense doesn't enter into their cries for "reform". It's especially useful in this day and age when most adults have the attention span of a 6 year old (see facebook and twitter) It takes anywhere from 2 to 20 hours or so (by my amateur estimation) for a neutral person to read, understand, and assess the complexity and ramifications of the existing and proposed gun laws in their state and/or country. it takes about 2 minutes to read an emotionally biased article and be persuaded that guns are bad because sometimes psychos use them to kill children. that is why they play the emotional card constantly- who can argue in favor of dead children? they will not debate fact or statistics (factual ones) with us because they know the facts don't lend credibility to their argument. but our hands are tied on the emotional front, if we argue the opposite side of the coin, we become heartless monsters. i forget who said this quote, but it definately applies to the anti's train of thought; "Don't ever get into a fight you know you can't win." They can win the emotional fight, they can't win the logical one.

They do that for one reason only. To bolster their arguments with people who can testify to the emotional side of the argument. They're blowing smoke by using victims, and their families. It doesn't bring credibility to the table, only emotions.

 

Its more than just the emotional side of the argument, IMHO. By hiding behind the victims and their families, it allows their argument to go out un-checked (and un-fettered) by the facts. By trying to have any sort of debate with these "victims"; YOU become the one "opening old wounds", or making them "re-live that horrible event". Never mind that THEY decided to interject themselves into the discussion; they are on some sort of pedistal and you become the monster. Trying to have a rational discussion with them is impossible.

with respect, a buddy of mine's dad was murdered in an armed robbery and yes, it gives him the right to speak his mind. that's also part of our constitution. the problem is that our so called leaders posture and bulls##t and have zero interest in having a genuine fact based conversation.

with respect, a buddy of mine's dad was murdered in an armed robbery and yes, it gives him the right to speak his mind. that's also part of our constitution. the problem is that our so called leaders posture and bulls##t and have zero interest in having a genuine fact based conversation.

 

with respect as well, the robbery doesn't give him the right to speak his mind. Being an American does. His story, while sad and terrible to hear, does not give him any more right to speak about anything than someone like me, who has never been the victim of a violent crime. our soldiers who fought and died for all of us, did it to ensure that every American, from the poorest illiterate hick to the richest educated elitist, has THE SAME VOICE IN OUR SOCIETY. unfortunately, sometimes people forget this.

I am just trying to understand the rationale here.

So, for congressional hearings on proposed gun control laws, we've all seen it - they routinely bring in these victims, their family members, etc.

Are they saying that, due to their "victim" status, their words and their personal viewpoints should carry more weight?

I am not saying I don't sympathize with many of these people. All I am trying to do is get down to the underlying premise.

Does "victim" status mean that you somehow "paid your dues," or that your viewpoint is somehow more enlightened than the next person, or that your opinions should carry more weight?

 

it is nothing more than a dog n pony show. they do this, because the sheep amongst us will follow them unquestioningly.

My father died when I was young. I was fortunate that my sisters were older teens when my father died. They both married men, great men, while they were young. I was fortunate to benefit from this by having two additional father figures. One was a very religious Jewish man, hippie, music lover and very liberal. The other was a Protestant, conservative, music lover who was rejected from joining the military during Vietnam due to medical issues, yes he tried to volunteer, in multiple states. I am Catholic and I had the best that a young boy without a father coul have. I had two very different, very positive male role models added to my life by the time I was 8 years old.

 

Both taught me several things, humor, patience, compassion, sense of self respect, determination and a desire to succeed. Both taught me things that the other didnt and both shared the burden of teaching lessons together.

 

My brother in law, friend, and role model, Allen Stone Winslow, was shot and killed in prospect park in Brooklyn twenty years ago on this coming June 1st. It has been a rough twenty years for me, not to mention my sister, neice and nephew.

 

He helped me become the man I am today. I am pretty happy with myself and the path I have chosen. This man taught me to learn as much as I can. He attended nearly every boy scout meeting, camping and fishing trip, helped me build my pinewood derby car and best of all he taught me how to shoot and how to safely handle firearms. He would take me and my younger brother to his parents house in massachusetts and let us shoot all of his and his father's rifles. He taught us about the constitution, the bill of rights, to be self reliant and to be prepared for anything (he was an eagle scout, I unfortunately aged out before I could receive mine, was a big disappointment to him, but he understood). He was a confidant and a great source for advice (as is, my other brother in law, Shelly). Sometimes his advice was that I needed to make a choice and handle whatever the outcome was.

 

My loss was great. It was unbearable at the time (compounded with my younger brothers death six months prior). But what got me through was how he lived and what he taught me. I tried to, hope I did, help build the foundation of my nieces and nephews, the way he did for me.

 

Again, he was shot and killed by a single round from a .22 handgun by a group of thugs looking to steal a bike. Had they asked, he probably would have given it to them. But he was shot in the back while he rode a path, the bullet struck his aorta and he bled out in the arms of a complete stranger who showed more respect for human life than the four thugs that killed him ever could or would.

 

I could call myself a victim, so could my sister and her children (and maybe they are), but they never acted like victims. Not one of us took the path of victim. I took the other path, I mourned his life. I went to court whenever I could, saw his killers convicted and moved on.

 

I hunted and shot whenever I could. I taught nieces, nephews, friends to shoot and hunt. I take pride in the lessons I was taught an try to share those lessons. I have developed many friendships through our right and our sports. I take pride in being an AMERICAN CITIZEN WHO EXERCISES HIS RIGHTS. I share the knowledge of these rights and have turned several anti gun people closer to our way of thinking and have completely turned some to our side.

 

I could have made the choice to be a victim, but I am not anyone's pawn. I am self reliant and a proud AMERICAN.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.