Pete & Elda's in Neptune City good thin crust pizza

Sea Isle City

-White Pizza: Azzuras

-Regular: Basilicos(also has awesome bbq chicken pizza)

 

Ocean City

- Manco and Manco's(formerly Mack and Manco's, also in Somers Point)

 

Marmora

-Kirk's

 

Seaville

-Vita Bella

-Mama Mia's for their "Texas" pizza- bbq chicken, steak, bbq sauce and cheese

 

Ocean View

-Bayshore Pizza

 

 

Cape May

-Tony's(also has the best cheese fries around)

 

Atlantic City

-Tony's Baltimore Grill

try going to Ohio is you want some bad pizza.. its like a saltine with ragu on it...

 

If you're ever in Dayton, OH try Marion's Piazza, it is very good.

I have not found a pizzeria in jersey that I love. Generally I head back to Staten Island and go to either deninos or brothers. The two are within a 1/2 mile of each other and both very good.

OP has been updated with almost everyone's post in alpha by city... I'll do more as they come in.... hope it helps...

Anthony's in Manahawkin on Mill Creek Road. This guy makes THE BEST sausage pie around.

I am a big fan of Spiritos family restaurant in Rahway.

 

Ciao Bella in Atlantic Highlands is good too.

 

Spiritos definitely rocks.

 

I'll add 2 more places that rocks.

 

Roses in Garfield

Angelos in Elmwood Park

 

I'm shocked nobody has mentioned Nomad's in Hopewell NJ and Osteria Procaccini in Kingston NJ. Best 2 pizza joints (with Nomad's being the better) in Central Jersey for sure.

Chimney Rock Inn Bridgewater is real good!

La Strada Cafe in Neshanic Station

 

Never been here yet but its always packed----> Angelos wood fired pizza in Flemington

 

Don't know if this ones still around Famous Rays in Verona, havent been there in over 13 years, used to go all the time, Used to be a white castle next door when I was a kid

I'm shocked nobody has mentioned Nomad's in Hopewell NJ and Osteria Procaccini in Kingston NJ. Best 2 pizza joints (with Nomad's being the better) in Central Jersey for sure.

I live right around the corner and have yet to go. I like Franco's in Hopewell.

I almost forgot Kate & Al's at the Columbus Market. Great Sicilian!

Keansburg- Roma Pizzaria

 

Kearny - Big Nick's

 

North Arlington - Pizzaland

Caffaro's pizza in South River. Thin crust. Good

I used to live in jersey city and Gino's pizza on central ave uptown was always what I ordered on a Friday night

Two Tony's In Linden. Jesus Christ, they make a good pizza.

 

Reggio's in Union is also pretty good.

Pizza stop is not in Roselle Park, it's in Kenilworth. Roselle Park's best goes to Costa's.

Bruno's in Elizabeth on Morris Ave

Another vote for Gennaro's in Westfield.

Keansburg- Roma Pizzaria

 

Roma/Sammi is certainly the best in Keansburg, but is he worthy of this thread.. we live in NJ!

I just want to add Capri in Beachwood. I moved here 3 years ago and have spent far too much money here. Great pies and consistent. Nevere a bad pie.

 

Chucky cheese !!

I'm from Staten Island so my fave 3 places are Gennaros by my old high school, Brothers in forest Ave and Grimaldi's in Brooklyn right under the Brooklyn Bridge.

 

We have 10000000 pizzeria s in Hillsborough but the only on worth a damn seems to be Angelos

Best pie I've had in recent memory is at totonno's in Brooklyn. Denino's in Staten Island is the original and a fantastic pie.

 

Pizza in jersey is mostly utility pizza. Mediocre with small pockets of good.

 

Even manhattan is a tough find. There are SO MANY shitty slices to be had in manhattan that it almost becomes a wasteland of tourist mediocrity.

 

For exceptional pizza, you have to go to the boroughs.

 

OK deninos is really good too.

Just to add to the list triangulo's in brooklyn. went last night the grandma pie was the best i ever had. The garlic knots are also amazing. Its definately a spot to stop if your in that area. Only reason i went there was nino's or spumoni gardens are too far from where i was. But im glad i made that stop.

I have not found a pizzeria in jersey that I love. Generally I head back to Staten Island and go to either deninos or brothers. The two are within a 1/2 mile of each other and both very good.

Next time try Lee's Tavern in Dongan Hills, by the Train Station.  Old school joint and hands down the only pizza I'll travel for.

 

The truth of the matter is that we don't go out for pizza.  My family prefers the ones I make at home.

 

J0n mentioned Cafe Amici in Somerset but IMHO Piazza Orsillo smokes them. Unfortunately Orsillo has stupid hours (not open on Sunday for football? WTF?!)

J0n mentioned Cafe Amici in Somerset but IMHO Piazza Orsillo smokes them. Unfortunately Orsillo has stupid hours (not open on Sunday for football? WTF?!)

 

1.3 miles further away.... but on your suggestion, will try it.

Next time try Lee's Tavern in Dongan Hills, by the Train Station.  Old school joint and hands down the only pizza I'll travel for.

 

The truth of the matter is that we don't go out for pizza.  My family prefers the ones I make at home.

 

 

SV400209.JPG

SV400037.JPG

SV400039.JPG

Kids pizza night 001.jpg

SV400059.JPG

SV400060.JPG

SV400061.JPG

SV400062.JPG

+1 for Lee's.. Hole in the wall but good pie and nice bar too

There are no good pizza places in NJ , you have to goto NY to get good pizza.

Red Bank - New Corner pizzeria! Some GREAT pizza there! Highly recommend it!