Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Suggested questions for the Westfield meeting

Featured Replies

This is the good chance to hold some really bad guys' feet to the fire.

 

I've been thinking of high impact questions to ask and am wondering about the wisdom of discussing them here, in a semi-open forum. I don't think Cryan has spies registered on this site, but who knows.

 

Any opinions? If I get a "no" from NJ2AS-LLC, that will override any other opinions.

 

In any case, I'll print out my questions and distribute them at our 6:30 pre-meeting meeting.

a a Do you have any stats on how many gun crimes/what % of gun crimes were committed by NJ FID holders?

 

Do you have any stats on how many guns used in crimes originated as legal purchases by NJ FID holders versus originated from sales in other states?

 

Are you aware that many online retailers require the verification of a NJ FID card in order to ship ammo to a NJ address?

 

How many .50 cal rifles have been used in crimes in NJ or in other states?

 

 

Why do the states with the most restrictive gun laws have the highest violent crime rates.

NJ FPID/P2P rate/1,000 residents for municipalities versus violent crime rate/1,000 residents for municipalities.

 

Here's the violent crime rate half of it:

 

http://www.njsp.org/info/stats.html

 

http://www.njsp.org/...2011/index.html

 

http://www.njsp.org/...2011_sect_7.pdf

 

What I haven't been able to find -- and I have no doubt CC and the NJSP know -- is the FPID/P2P rate by municipality. It's fairly obvious that NJ rural and suburban municipalities have less violent crime and more legal guns than the urban areas but I can't find FPID data.

a a Do you have any stats on how many gun crimes/what % of gun crimes were committed by NJ FID holders?

 

Do you have any stats on how many guns used in crimes originated as legal purchases by NJ FID holders versus originated from sales in other states?

 

Are you aware that many online retailers require the verification of a NJ FID card in order to ship ammo to a NJ address?

 

How many .50 cal rifles have been used in crimes in NJ or in other states?

 

Thats the #1 question I keep submitting in my emails etc. It is THE overall bit of info that seems to be lacking. If they can substantiate that the good(legal) guys are causing all kinds of havoc well then they may have an argument. However I'll bet that there is a stat out there and it is so irrelevant that they "aren't aware" of that particuler info. Its all just reckless legislation w/o that fact.

not a question.....but could it be helpful to print and take with you statistics showing the correlation of violent crime rates being lower in states with more lax laws?

  • Author

OK, here are mine regarding mental health:

 

"Assemblyman Cryan and Senator Weinberg have introduced 20 and 9 bills, respectively, targeting gun ownership. Between the two of them, they have introduced none to improve resources for identification and treatment of dangerously mentally ill patients. Given that almost all of the recent mass shootings were committed by individuals with mental disorders, given the recommendations of the SAFE committee, and given the almost universal opinion of physicians that the current mental health infrastructure is dangerously inadequate, why have you completely neglected this important an non-controversial opportunity for violence prevention?"

  • Author
not a question.....but could it be helpful to print and take with you statistics showing the correlation of violent crime rates being lower in states with more lax laws?

I think that would be a good addition to the flyer I suggested. Could you post links to the data?

  • Author

Question for Cryan:

 

Bill A3799 is a cut and paste of Governor Cuomo's SAFE Act. It would ban, amongst other things, a safety device that prevents a marksman from burning his hand on a barrel (barrel shroud), and the attachment of a plastic handle to allow a more secure grip on an otherwise legal firearm. Could you explain how banning either of these safety devices would enhance gun safety?

 

As a followup, given the remarkable similarity between your bill and Governor Cuomo's bill, it seems you must have studied it carefully. What do you consider its greatest weakness?

  • Author

Question for Florio:

 

"The NJ AWB was one of the centerpieces of your time as governor. It is a cut and paste of the federal AWB in effect from 1994 to 2004. It banned certain firearms based on safety and ergonomic features, such as adjustable length stocks and devices to prevent burn injuries to firearm users. Following expiration of the federal law, a study commissioned by the Department of Justice determined that, unsurprisingly, it had no discernible effect on firearm violence. Based on the results of this study, what is your opinion on efforts to double down on this approach by imposing stricter bans on firearm safety features?"

How many of the "Gun Crime" victims have a criminal

record?

Criminals are defined by the fact they do not follow laws.

If a criminal is planning on KILLING someone, why do you think any laws will stop them?

  • Author

Question for the "2A scholar."

(assuming he's going to give a leftist interpretation....")

 

"Thank you for your insightful analysis of the second amendment. We continue to welcome academic debate on the subject. That being said, at the policy level, the debate on two points of contention were decisively closed with the Supreme Court ruling on the 2008 Heller case. 1) The second amendment protects an individual right, and 2) It protects the ownership and possession of "arms in common use at the time." Given the fact that the AR-15 is the most popular and fastest growing segment of the firearms market, how do you interpret the current NJ ban on this category, in light of the Heller decision?"

 

I would pose the same question to Florio, except that I would replace the introduction above with "given your expertise as an attorney, you are aware that the debate...."

  • Author

For Weinberg or Cryan:

 

"Newark mayor Corey Booker recently stated that, looking over many years of gun violence statistics in Newark, he was able to identify only one crime committed by an FID holder. Another source states that there has never been an incident of gun violence by an FID holder in Jersey City [need reference.] Given the near perfect track record of the current licensing system in denying legal gun purchases to potentially violent individuals, what benefit do you foresee to for a system that would spend tens of millions of dollars a year by forcing legal gun owners to reapply for a "high tech" FID every 5 years?

  • Author

For Weinberg or Cryan:

 

"Local police departments are currently overwhelmed by the workload of issuing initial FIDs and P2Ps. NJ law mandates issuance within 30 days, yet 6-9 month delays are common. Under your proposed bills, there will be approximately 500,000 reapplications next year, another 500,000 the year after, and 200,000 every year thereafter....in addition to the current workload imposed on PDs. How much do you estimate this workload will cost? Under this burden, how long do you anticipate it will take for someone to replace an FID invalidated under your law? Given the nearly zero rate of firearm violence by existing FID holders, how much do you believe this effort will reduce firearm violence?

  • Author

For Florio and Cryan:

 

"Firearms falling under your definition of 'assault weapon' account for less that 2% of overall firearm violence in this country, with fewer homicides committed by these firearms than by hammers. Why have you chosen to focus your efforts on a category responsible for such a vanishingly small share of violence, rather than on more serious threats to public safety, such as illegal hammers?"

  • Author

Last one for now....

 

"Regarding the requirement for FTF purchases of ammunition.....Modern technology allows for secure authentification of identity without a face to face meeting. This is the reason why we are able to transfer tens of thousands of dollars without physically presenting ourselves to a bank teller. Currently, most online retailers of ammunition require an FID card, a photo ID, and a credit card, all with addresses matching the shipping address. Thus, online purchases are, in fact, far less "anonymous" than FTF purchases. Can you conceive of a scenario where an ineligible individual would forge an FID card and document his illegal purchase through an online purchase rather than just drive 1 hour to PA and purchase ammunition with cash and no ID?"

 

Note: In the Assembly committee hearing, Cryan brought up the fact that the CO shooter had 6000 rounds of ammunition, purchased over the internet. If he brings this up again, point out that, if online purchases were illegal, he could just as easily have purchased as much as he wanted at the same place where he purchased his gun.

Last one for now....

 

"Regarding the requirement for FTF purchases of ammunition.....Modern technology allows for secure authentification of identity without a face to face meeting. This is the reason why we are able to transfer tens of thousands of dollars without physically presenting ourselves to a bank teller. Currently, most online retailers of ammunition require an FID card, a photo ID, and a credit card, all with addresses matching the shipping address. Thus, online purchases are, in fact, far less "anonymous" than FTF purchases. Can you conceive of a scenario where an ineligible individual would forge an FID card and document his illegal purchase through an online purchase rather than just drive 1 hour to PA and purchase ammunition with cash and no ID?"

 

Note: In the Assembly committee hearing, Cryan brought up the fact that the CO shooter had 6000 rounds of ammunition, purchased over the internet. If he brings this up again, point out that, if online purchases were illegal, he could just as easily have purchased as much as he wanted at the same place where he purchased his gun.

 

I don't think the point to push is the availability of the ammunition, but rather that the accumulation of ammunition is neither an indicator of violent behavior nor abnormal behavior. There is no evidence bearing on the assertion that individual stocking of ammunition is a bad thing. It's a solution looking for a problem and the burden should be placed on Cryan an his ilk to provide evidence to prove their assertion, not on us to disprove it. Besides, claiming that the same amount of ammunition can be purchased at a gun store is not entirely true and can be easily countered by proposing limits on the quantity of ammunition that can be purchased ( a far worse scenario).

 

Their game that puts us on the defense and forces us to disprove their baseless assertions is a losing game and they know it. We need to push the idea that what can be asserted without evidence can be dismissed without evidence, and that the biggest tenet of 'common sense' is supporting evidence.

What % of gun crimes in New Jersey were committed by persons who were previously convicted for a violent felony and released prior to committing their gun crime?

 

What % of gun crimes in New Jersey were committed by persons who are repeat offenders for violent offenses?

My question for the panel.... 'isn't your supposed desire to reduce gun violence really just a ploy to gain attention and media coverage by exploiting the deaths of children?'

I think that would be a good addition to the flyer I suggested. Could you post links to the data?

 

looking for info nowq.......

Question for Florio:

 

"The NJ AWB was one of the centerpieces of your time as governor. It is a cut and paste of the federal AWB in effect from 1994 to 2004. It banned certain firearms based on safety and ergonomic features, such as adjustable length stocks and devices to prevent burn injuries to firearm users. Following expiration of the federal law, a study commissioned by the Department of Justice determined that, unsurprisingly, it had no discernible effect on firearm violence. Based on the results of this study, what is your opinion on efforts to double down on this approach by imposing stricter bans on firearm safety features?"

 

Doesn't New Jersey's AWB date to 1990?

 

Like many bad ideas, didn't it start in New Jersey?

 

draft_lens8039491module127210611photo_1287450206south-park-new-jersey.jpg

  • Author

Doesn't New Jersey's AWB date to 1990?

 

Like many bad ideas, didn't it start in New Jersey?

 

draft_lens8039491module127210611photo_1287450206south-park-new-jersey.jpg

I didn't know that. Thank you for the correction, as it would be embarrassing to present such a factual error to Florio. I'll take out the "cut and paste" part.

The problem is that politicians won't answer any question asked of them. They prepare 3 talking points and no matter what the question, they choose one of their 3 talking points. They will not answer a single question unless it's an insider who was prepped to ask a specific question.

I was in Westfield yesterday for a bday party Edgar st.

Assemblyman Cryan:

 

Let's assume, just for arguments sake, that the current law -- which for over 20 years has deemed 15 round magazines to be safe, standard capacity magazines --, must now be changed and the limit reduced to 10 rounds. If these 15 round magazines are now so incredibly dangerous, why was the assembly bill amended at the very last minute to specifically allow retired police officers to keep their 15 round magazines while all other citizens are faced with the choice of destroying them, finding a way to sell them out of state, or become instant felons? If these magazines are now suddenly so dangerous, shouldn't we be trying to get ALL of them out of circulation?! If you will claim that it's because that retired police officers have greater training than mere "ordinary citizens" -- which in many cases is patently not true -- why don't you impose a training requirement for keeping these magazines? In any event, isn't training completely irrelevant when it comes to using a 15 vs a 10 round magazine. For that matter, why should you, a former bartender who became an "undersheriff", be allowed to keep YOUR 15 round magazines. According to many news reports, you have a close family member -- your son -- who was convicted of assault and according to othe recent reports you yourself are of questionable character. Why shouldn't these dangerous "large capacity assault magazines" be kept out of YOUR hands and out of YOUR home in the interest of public safety?

I've been thinking of high impact questions to ask and am wondering about the wisdom of discussing them here, in a semi-open forum. I don't think Cryan has spies registered on this site, but who knows.

 

You're giving him way too much credit. He uses his entire intellectual reserve walking erect, finding booze and sniffing soiled leather panties.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.