Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

NJ LEO kills man in road rage incident in MD

Featured Replies

  • 1 month later...
  • Replies 72
  • Views 3.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

First degree murder?

 

http://blog.nj.com/njv_paul_mulshine/2013/07/maryland_road-rage_case_is_loo.html

 

http://www.nj.com/south/index.ssf/2013/07/nj_detective_from_mount_holly.html
joseph-harvey-jr--9fc42d0240f05dc9.jpg

 

N.J. detective from Mount Holly indicted for murder in road rage incident

ANNAPOLIS, Md.— A New Jersey police detective has been indicted on a first-degree murder charge in the shooting of another driver in a case of road rage in Maryland.

 

An Anne Arundel County grand jury returned the indictment Friday against 40-year-old Joseph Walker of Mount Holly.

 

Walker works for the Hudson County Prosecutor’s Office. He had been charged with second-degree murder and manslaughter immediately after the June 8 fatal shooting of Joseph Harvey Jr. of Millersville.

 

Authorities say Walker’s minivan cut off a car driven by Harvey. Harvey’s passenger told police that Walker pointed a gun at them. The drivers got out on a ramp, and the passenger says he heard shots. Harvey died at a hospital.

 

Walker’s lawyer said a few days afterward that Harvey initiated the fight and threatened Walker’s family.

Rule #1, if you CCW go out of your way to get out of a situation where you may have to use force. Even if you're an off duty cop.

Never ever get out of your car during a road rage incident - it never ends well...

 

Only exception of course is if staying in your car puts you at further risk...

 

If the the guy who was shot wasn't holding a weopon (bat, tire iron, gun), the shooter is probably toast.

 

I don't know the details but on the face of it, you can't shoot someone cause he is walking towards you after you got out of the car if the guy had no weopon. This will probably being considered "mutualcombat"...If the shooter stayed in the car and felt his life was threatened (by the other guy, say banging a brick on the winshield, then it may have been a legal shoot).

 

Of course it is much more complicated than this but this is my initial view.

 

Possibly another case of Cops-Gone-Wild.

Another example of only knowing and believing what the media/press is telling you. And assuming that MD state police did their due diligence in investigating. Hopefully all the facts will make it clearer for a jury to decide again.

Maryland seems to be much like New Jersey when it comes to self-defense laws. One has the duty "'to retreat or avoid danger if such means were within his power and consistent with his safety.'

 

That is to say --Maryland is not Florida. Mr. Walker's defense team is going to be facing a greater challenge than Mr. Zimmerman's team was.

 

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_of_self-defense_in_Maryland

 



The Use of Deadly Force in Self-Defense

Maryland also continues to follow common law principles on the issue of when one may use deadly force in self-defense. In the case of State v. Faulkner, 301 Md. 482, 485, 483 A.2d 759, 761 (1984), the Court of Appeals of Maryland summarized those principles, and stated that a homicide, other than felony murder, is justified on the ground of self-defense if the following criteria are satisfied:

 

See also Roach v. State, 358 Md. 418, 429-30, 749 A.2d 787, 793 (2000).

 

(1) The accused must have had reasonable grounds to believe himself in apparent imminent or immediate danger of death or serious bodily harm from his assailant or potential assailant; (2) The accused must have in fact believed himself in this danger; (3) The accused claiming the right of self defense must not have been the aggressor or provoked the conflict;

 

 

 

 

(4) The force used must have not been unreasonable and excessive, that is, the force must not have been more force than the exigency demanded.

 

 

In addition, when one is in one's home, one may use deadly force against an attacker if deadly force is necessary to prevent the attacker from committing a felony that involves the use of force, violence, or surprise (such as murder, robbery, burglary, rape, or arson). See Crawford v. State, 231 Md. 354, 190 A.2d 538 (1963).

 



Duty to Retreat and the Castle Doctrine

Maryland also follows the common law rule that, outside of one's home, a person, before using deadly force in self-defense, has the duty "'to retreat or avoid danger if such means were within his power and consistent with his safety.'" DeVaughn v. State, 232 Md. 447, 453, 194 A.2d 109, 112 (1963), cert. denied, 376 U.S. 527 (1964), quoting Bruce v. State, 218 Md. 87, 97, 145 A.2d 428, 433 (1958). See also Burch v. State, 346 Md. 253, 283, 696 A.2d 443, 458 (1997).

 

But a person does not have to retreat if it would not be safe for the person to do so. "f the peril of the defendant was imminent, he did not have to retreat but had a right to stand his ground and to defend and protect himself." Bruce v. State, supra, 218 Md. at 97, 145 A.2d at 433.

 

The duty to retreat also does not apply if one is attacked in one's own home. "[A] man faced with the danger of an attack upon his dwelling need not retreat from his home to escape the danger, but instead may stand his ground and, if necessary to repel the attack, may kill the attacker." Crawford v. State, 231 Md. 354, 361, 190 A.2d 538, 541 (1963). The Court of Appeals said in Crawford, a case in which the defendant fatally shot a younger man who was attempting to break into his home to beat and rob him:

 

Id., 231 Md. at 361, 190 A.2d at 542, quoting Clark and Marshall, Law of Crimes, (6th ed. Wingersky rev.), § 7.03, pages 436-37.

 

"* * * A man is not bound to retreat from his house. He may stand his ground there and kill an[y] person who attempts to commit a felony therein, or who attempts to enter by force for the purpose of committing a felony, or of inflicting great bodily harm upon an inmate. In such a case the owner or any member of the family, or even a lodger in the house, may meet the intruder at the threshold, and prevent him from entering by any means rendered necessary by the exigency, even to the taking of his life, and the homicide will be justifiable."

 

This principle is known as the "Castle Doctrine", "the name being derived from the bedrock (but, unfortunately, somewhat hackneyed) principle that 'a man's home is his castle' and his ultimate retreat." Barton v. State, 46 Md. App. 616, 618, 420 A.2d 1009, 1010-1011 (1980). A man "is not bound to flee and become a fugitive from his own home, for, if that were required, there would, theoretically, be no refuge for him anywhere in the world." Barton, 46 Md. App. at 618, 420 A.2d at 1010.

 

A person does not have to be the owner of the home or the head of the household in order to be able to invoke the "Castle Doctrine." Instead, "any member of the household, whether or not he or she has a proprietary or leasehold interest in the property, is within its ambit . . . ." Barton, 46 Md. App. at 619-20, 420 A.2d at 1011.

 

However, even in one's own home, the degree of force used in self-defense must not be "excessive." Crawford v. State, supra, 231 Md. at 362, 190 A.2d at 542. Quoting a treatise on criminal law, the Court of Appeals said in Crawford:

 

Id., 231 Md. at 362-63, 190 A.2d at 542, quoting, 1 Wharton's Criminal Law and Procedure (Anderson Ed., 1957), § 206, at pages 453-55.

 

"It is also essential that killing is necessary to prevent the commission of the felony in question. If other methods could prevent its commission, a homicide is not justified; all other means of preventing the crime must first be exhausted."

* * *

The crimes in prevention of which life may be taken are such and only such as are committed by forcible means, violence, and surprise, such as murder, robbery, burglary, rape, or arson.

 

"It is a justifiable homicide to kill to prevent the commission of a felony by force or surprise.

 

 

I think number 3 is even more relevant than number 4.

 

 

 (3) The accused claiming the right of self defense must not have been the aggressor or provoked the conflict;

 

No idea who the initial aggressor was. But in a road rage incident where both parties pull over and exchange words, almost always involves parties on both sides provoking each other. I'm also unclear. Did the vehicles collide or was there an accident of sorts? If so, he has a better chance of a valid self defense claim, under MD law. If not, I think he will be hard pressed to make a valid argument that he pulled over and entered into this confrontation with good intentions and not because of 'road rage'. Sounds a lot like both men were provoking each other this shooting is the unfortunate result. 

 

The other thing that makes it more questionable, is that I'm reading they (him or his wife) said they saw the guy flash a firearm at them while both were driving. Why would you pull over to confront someone you think is armed, while your family is with you, and not try and remove yourself and get away from a potentially armed and dangerous individual, and call 911 if you felt he was in fact dangerous? 

 

Lots of problems and MD law appears to not be so forgiving in situations where you intentionally put yourself in bad situations instead of avoiding them, if possible. 

i heard the officer did not pull over to continue the sitiuation, he thought the other driver had driven on.  He pulled over to check if there was damage to his vehicle.  He was suprised too see that the other guy had pulled over up the road from him and gotten out of his car and walked back  toward him. That is all hearsay but clearly there is alot of information that has yet to be shared with the public 

The 3 universal defenses in any story involving LEOs are as follows, 1. The media is all lies. 2. If you werent there, how do you know it even happened? 3. Ignore it, all the facts are not in. The only problem is do we back the decision of the shooter, or the decision of the people who decided to arrest him? Both LEO, both with different opinions of the event.

The other thing that makes it more questionable, is that I'm reading they (him or his wife) said they saw the guy flash a firearm at them while both were driving. Why would you pull over to confront someone you think is armed, while your family is with you, and not try and remove yourself and get away from a potentially armed and dangerous individual, and call 911 if you felt he was in fact dangerous? 

 

 

How could that be? Maryland has justifiable need just like NJ. They call it "good and substantial cause." In other words, carry permits are rarely issued there. So either the guy had to have been illegally carrying the firearm or he was also a cop. Or he had no firearm and the claim that he was brandishing was made up. 

Good point ^^^^.

 

I'd add that the fact that the shooter is a Cop has absolutly nothing to do with this case....

 

If anything it will work against him, he should have known better not to get out of the car.

Good point ^^^^.

 

I'd add that the fact that the shooter is a Cop has absolutly nothing to do with this case....

 

If anything it will work against him, he should have known better not to get out of the car.

"Good point" above is for gunguys post...(ryan beat me to the "post" :-)).

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.