Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

ELCAN Specter DR 1-4x scope.. what's the scoop...

Featured Replies

I am in the market for a nice set of optics for my AR. I've been looking for something that will serve a broad spectrum of service/duty. Something food for CQB Scenario's as well as some longer range shooting... I've come across the ELCAN Specter DR and i really like the versatility of it... The cost is a bit up there but for a quality item i dont mind paying a few bucks to get what i want.

 

Does any one here have any experience with them? what were/are your thoughts... please share.

 

If anyone has any suggestions for other optics for me to look at please post up. I'd love to hear some comparisons!

 

Thanks

ZAP

 

Incase you didnt know what it was here is the scope i'm looking at.

 

botach_2263_116709310.jpg

 

The ELCAN SpecterDR Dual Role Optical Sight represents a revolution in optical sight design. The world’s first truly dual field of view combat optical sight, the SpecterDR switches instantly from a 4x magnified sight to a 1x CQB sight with the throw of a lever. Unlike zoom sights, the SpecterDR offers an optimized optical path and identical eye relief in both 4x and 1x modes. Depending upon the situation, the user may adjust the sight to illuminate the entire crosshair or just a brilliant red dot in the center. In 4x mode the SpecterDR offers a generous field of view, long eye relief, and ELCAN’s legendary crystal clear image. In CQB mode, the SpecterDR has by far the largest field of view in the industry. The 4x and CQB Reticles are plainly visible even in the case of loss of electrical power due to battery failure or EMP. The SpecterDR offers the best single solution for Long Range and CQB engagements and is designed to withstand the rigors of modern professional use.

 

PM Tactical Monkey or Shane45.   thay both have alot of time behind them.

  • 2 weeks later...

No first hand knowledge but one or two of the books I've read written by SEALs had said they weren't a fan.

I played with one at the range. Eye relief was way to short. Plus sometimes its nice to have something between 1-4x

 

Take a look at the Vortex Razr 1-6x.  I have been very happy with mine

I had no issues with eye relief. It is actually quite good. The big advantage to this optic IS its ability to go from 1 to 4 and back with the flick of a lever. That and a daylight usable red dot. Mine was a later gen so I had no issues with mounting. I also had no issues with zero but I believe many who did just didnt know how to zero them properly. Its a good optic, a bit heavy for a 5.56 IMO. I ran mine on a 308. Im not a fan of the Razor myself, if Im going for more mag, I want a true mil based reticle.

the eye relief is 2.75" on the elcan, the razor 1-6 is 4"  unless you are nose to charging handle, or run a short stock, its just not enough eye relief.  Atleast with the razor you have more flexibility on placement

Negative on both. Im 6'2" with a condor wingspan so I dont run my stocks short and I dont shoot NTCH. I had no issues with eye relief. In fact I could see a 4" eye relief possibly being an issue on an AR. If your not running a monolithic upper you are probably going to need a mount that hangs the optic forward of the mounting clamp to the upper or your going to have to bridge the upper and the rail system(speculation on my part having not had one in hand). I dont care for doing either. You have to remember that the eye relief number may not tell the entire story. What really matters is the overall eyebox. Have you actually run an Elcan or are you just speculating on the posted numbers? Because once you get behind one and you see the forgiving eyebox and the very large field of view, I have yet to hear anyone complain of the eye relief. I wear glasses so Im pretty sensitive to eye relief. I ran the Elcan on 2 308 rilfes without issue.

I wrote in my first post that I had tried one,

You don't like extended mounts... so the Larue or ADMs are bad designs?

Define "played with one". Half a mag, a full mag, all day long on a course of fire? The larue is for sure. But not because of the extension. Its clamping method is. If you have a very long min eye relief scope then you may end up with no choice but to use a mount that is heavily offset or bridge the rail system. This is why Larue and ADM make mounts with various offsets obviously. But I would prefer to not run such a heavy offset. So I select optics with sufficient eye relief/eye box that works with a mount with no offset. Optics, how you see them through your own eyes, is HEAVELY individual and subjective. What you see may not be what I see. If you need a 4" eye relief, then the Vortex is for you. But I would say that the need for extended eye relief is not the common scenario. Now if we were talking about an Acog TA01NSN, that would be the other end of the spectrum. For some its ok, but for most the eye relief is to short. If/when the Razor comes out with optional reticles, id be interested in getting hands on. But having played with a US Optics 1-8, that probably is my next purchase.

Who cares how long I shot with one, as soon as I have to modify my shooting stance to accomodate an optic, its a no go.  Longer eye relief gives you more mounting options as you can only mount fixed mount short eye relief optics so far back.

 

Extended eye relief is very common.  I see almost no shooters with 1-nx that are not on extended mounts

 

The OP needs to look through one before dumping that amount of $

Again, your experience that eye relief of an Elcan is short is not the usual experience. In regards to experience, I want to hear form the guy with more than a cursury glance under his belt on any given topic. It would be far more usefull to hear about your experience with your Razor then your apparently very short experince with someone elses Elcan.

Why would I spend any time fighting with any optic. It was immediately apparent that it wasn't going to work and there was no way to adjust it so it would

You have made it clear that for you, eye relief of the elcan is an issue. Having had MANY run my rifle with the Elcan who did not have this issue, it appears to me you are in the minority. Since it didnt work for you, it appears your experience is very limited. So what is it you have to offer for info on the Elcan other than eye relief was an issue for you Im not sure why your still stuck on that??? Like I said, Id rather hear about something, I would assume, you have actual experience with, your Razor. I'd also love to hear from anyone running a Leupy Mk6 1-6. Some may want to consider an American made optic over one made in Japan IIRC.

Having researched the elcan looking for the one true optic, I came to three conclusions. 1) regarding optical quality and behavior, there are a gorup of people who think it is awesome and a group who think it is crap. 2) there is apparently a right and wrong way to set it up, and you need to read and understand the instructions, which a number of people who claim it is crap either have not, or used a gun they can't vouch for the setup on. 3) There is a lot of debate about issues with it other than optical behavior/quality such as the mounts, elevation and windage adjustments, weight, durability, etc. 

 

NOTE: in step 2 I'm not claiming everyone complaining has failed to follow set up instructions, and that if set up right it is awesome, I'm saying that if you take out those who admit they haven't seen said instructions, demonstrate they have not followed them, and those using someone else's rig, you are dealing with a very small group of people in both the awesome and the crap camp that have in theory done it correctly and still disagree with each other, and have thrown away the VAST majority of reviews, feedback, and opinions. 

 

I still think it sounds cool, but I'd REALLY like to see one in person before I committed any kind of money to one and I'd have to be able to return it. So anyone who wants to make that leap, I seriously suggest someplace like SWFA with a liberal return/exchange policy.  Oh yeah and suggest that you let me play with it ;)

I agree with those comments. Really that is the hardest thing, getting hands on high end optics. I'm fortunate that I get to get hands on most offerings out there, but when I cant, it certainly is a rough row to drop serious cabbage based on the opinion of others. What I can say is that I do not run an Elcan today. The rifle I had it on it was great. But my current rig feels the weight of the Elcan and doesnt balence as well so I have gone a different route. It is a pretty heavy optic. But it really shines in a environment that has radicle changes in target disposition. I am not a 3 gun shooter. But I have attended some private matches that were sort of like a 2 gun tactical oriented match. Targets where engaged from 5 yds to 100 yds on the move, from cover, etc etc. I posted the best single string score of the match shooting a 308 against a field of 5.56's. No consideration given for larger caliber. I absolutely attribute it to the Elcan. Im fractions of a second off an aimpoint on 1x and gained considerable time over others transitioning to 100 yd targets with the flick of a lever. The sun was foward of the targets and this gave a lot of people with red dots fits, including myself with other T1 micro outfitted rifles I ran that day. But the Elcan's ability to go near instantly 4x made picking up the targets a snap.

Straight cut and paste from a previous thread on the Elcan.  My thoughts below:

 

"So the SpecterDR 1-4, I like mine.

 

PROs:
The illum dot is VERY bright in broad daylight and equal to quality stand alone RDS (CompM4, M3, T1) when compared side by side, and is brighter than a S&B Short Dot. I wish I took pics, and I may have to add that to my to-do list when things calm down.
It has a glass etched reticle, so even without illumination (or battery/electronics failure) you can still clearly see the reticle.
It has hold-over, BDC markings on the reticle, as well as range finding capabilities if the size of your target is known (or 30" human torso)
The ease/speed of switching from 1x to 4x in a single unit is unmatched
Huge FOV - while this is usually a moot point when talking about 1X optic designed for both eyes open shooting, the elcan completely removes any tube effect and when combined with the 32mm objective, what you can see THROUGH the optic (not just your non-shooting eye matching the image) is substantial.
Good glass clarity edge to edge on 1x and 4x

CONs:
Weight - it's heavy at 23oz, just under a pound and a half with the included ARMS mount. This can make some rifles feel very top heavy.
The ARMS mount. A lot of the issues with this optics come from the mount levers snapping off, issues with holding zero, etc. I believe ARMS will replace/upgrade the mount for a small fee (I'm not 100% on this)
6 MOA dot on 4x is not for precision - this really isn't a CON, but more understanding the optics purpose. Don't buy it if you want to shoot super tight groups at 300 yards...
Eye placement/location matters - while the eye relief is fairly generous at around 2+", you still need to have solid and consistent cheek weld to get fast acquistion.
Mixed reports on "IED proof" durability

Summary:
On the SCAR 17 it balances very well, and compliments the rifle in matching capabilites. I've shot it while mounted to an LMT MWS, and a SR-25 and it performed well on all. It felt the most top heavy on the Knights. When compared to a S&B Short Dot, I prefer the 1-4 switch lever instead of dialing up to 4x. This is completely a personal choice, as I don't seem to use 1.5x, 2x, or 3x anyway. I'm either shooting close (1x) or far (4x). I either want target ID, or I don't. I have not had any loss of zero issues, but I also zero'd at 4x at 100 yards (as recommended in instructions that ship with optics). I have heard there can be a shift when changing magnification if you zero'd at 1x. This is not confirmed personally. If I were to replace it, it would be with an ACOG TA11, with a micro RDS (or T1) at the 1 o'clock position. However to that point - overall cost, weight, and capability are very close.

There is no Jack-of-all-trade-no-comprise-do-all optic, otherwise everyone would have it  :) For me the elcan gets close enough, understanding it's faults (heavy, fairly expensive and people have had issues with them). But as a point of reference my go-to rifle has a CompM4....

 

 Any other questions let me know."

. I am not a 3 gun shooter. But I have attended some private matches that were sort of like a 2 gun tactical oriented match. Targets where engaged from 5 yds to 100 yds on the move, from cover, etc etc. I posted the best single string score of the match shooting a 308 against a field of 5.56's. No consideration given for larger caliber. I absolutely attribute it to the Elcan. Im fractions of a second off an aimpoint on 1x and gained considerable time over others transitioning to 100 yd targets with the flick of a lever. The sun was foward of the targets and this gave a lot of people with red dots fits, including myself with other T1 micro outfitted rifles I ran that day. But the Elcan's ability to go near instantly 4x made picking up the targets a snap.

 

You posted the best single string at a private match...wow, that's convincing. 

You posted the best single string at a private match...wow, that's convincing. 

 

I wouldnt question Shane45's ability with his tools.  He takes his sh*t VERY serious, unlike some keyboard crusaders.

2Alpha, do you actually own anything the grown ups are talking about? Because after repeated requests for solid intel, all you have provided is keyboard commando internexpert banter.

 

IIRC I did win that match aside from having the best single run. But more to the point that you clearly do not understand, having a faster time and accuracy with a 308 against a field of 5.56 rifles(including my own!) illustrates the advantage the Elcan held. But I'm sure everyone else understood the point.

I'm still waiting on my FID to come in.  My Dad has some cool stuff that he lets me shoot.

Do folks on either side of this argument think that attacking the skills of the other side is actually helpful to what is basically a choice of underwear discussion?

 

There is no one true optic, like there is no one true cartridge and no one true gun. Not only do they all make compromises, but individual users preferences enter into it even more then the quality and performance of the device.

 

Not for nothing, but this like an argument about boxers vs briefs where people are backtracking to arguments about wedding tackle sizes.

 

Both sides need to consider that they might both be right.

2Alpha, looking at some of your other posts, they seem on track, informed, and from a position of some experience. Im not sure why this thread seems to have gone off the rails. Do you have some inner Elcan hatred going on or what LOL!

 

Vlad I think its a one sided argument. the only thing I really contested was the eye relief. I was more in the open optics discussion spirit and really wanted some razor 1-6 intel.

No hatred for the elcan,

you are the one trying to prove it works for you and all your tactical buddies ( I couldn't care less) Then try to back it up with results from some private unknown match.(I guess real match result wouldn't help your case)  Then you went with the "let the grownups talk" and keyboard commando reply. (awesome). So in the end, thanks for the entertainment 

My sarcasm followed your dickie comments. I give some actual experience, you know, what the op asked for, and all you have given is ....what? I asked you for some input on your suggestion, the vortex. Again, nothing useful. How about posting something usefull in this thread... whats your current set up? Hows it work for you. What doesnt work? Use tactical monkeys post as a template.

Vlad if the argument is a valid one then no >> it's not helpful. However there is no valid points made by 2alpha..... he apperanty doesn't have any experience with ANY of the issues brought up by TM and Shane. he actually doesn't even own any firearms .... I "played" around with a lot of firearms, optics and such >> doesn't make me an expert in anything.... and based on what TM and Shane are saying I'm actually questioning 2alphas ability and knowledge on how firearms with optics should be operated and held .....

either way mods should lock this thread.....

 

PS here i corrected it. i am sorry i didnt realize you gonna take it so personally. but, yes, proper English grammar and spelling is the topic of this thread ....

you feel better about yourself now ?

Vlad if the argument is a valid one then no >> it's not helpful. However there is no valid points made by 2alpha..... he apperanty doesn't have any experience with ANY of the issues brought up by TM and Shane. he actually doesn't even own any firearms .... I played around with a lot of firearms, optics and such >> doesn't make me an expert in anything.... and based on what TM and Shane are saying I'm actually questioning 2alphas ability and knowledge on how firearms with optics shud be operated and held .....

either way mods shud lock this thread.....

 

 "shud"   :good:

Seriously, people should lighten up. 

 

I could take a jab at TM not knowing anything due to his claim on the weight of the ELCAN being heavy. Compared to a red dot, yes. Compared to most any 1-4 stuck in a larue spr-e or either of the two american defense extended cantilever mounts? Not really. You are tlaking at least 16 oz for the scope (probably more), plus another 8oz or so for the mount. Which is right in line with the elcan. Aimpoint and a magnifier? Runs about 20 oz. depending on your mount (assuming you want one where the scope is not in your pocket and can still get out of the way).

 

Yeah, they are all heavier than a straight up red dot, but it's not remotely the same kind of optic then. And if you think 23oz is heavy, don't put a decent mount anywhere near the 1-8 USO that Shane talks about, it might start warping space time near it. 

 

All I can tell you for certain about magnifying optics for run and gun stuff is you want a generous eye box, you want a decent FOV at max magnification, and you want it to hold zero even if it gets banged around. Everything else is more or less ergonomics, and thus personal preference. 

I agree that the weight is similer between a scope and mount vs an Elcan. However, I think there is more to the story. I think the way all the weight of an Elcan is concentrated into a short chunk vs possibly a wider distribution and maybe the lever effect of hanging a scope foward makes it balence much better. However the mass is centralised on a SCAR17 the Elcan balenced well but "felt" much heavier on other AR pattern 308's. It disrupted the balance of the rifle. Even more so then a S&B 1-4 for example. Also, I believe TM's excerpt was from a previous post comparing several optics. So it may not be heavier than a comparable scope, it certainly is compared to an Acog for example.

Straight cut and paste from a previous thread on the Elcan.  My thoughts below:

 

"So the SpecterDR 1-4, I like mine.

 

CONs:

 

6 MOA dot on 4x is not for precision - this really isn't a CON, but more understanding the optics purpose. Don't buy it if you want to shoot super tight groups at 300 yards...

 

 

 Any other questions let me know."

 

 

Just to clarify, the SpecterDR 1-4 (as well as the 1.5-6x) has 6 moa at 1x and 1.5 moa at both 4x and 6x

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.