Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Poll: Would you shoot Revo Div. USPSA with an 8 shot Revo?

25 members have voted

  1. 1. Would you consider shooting Revolver division USPSA if you could shoot your 8 shot 38 spl ( S&W 627 ) Revolver.

    • Yes, i'd be more interested in shooting revolver if 8 shots were allowed
      24%
    • No, I think revolver division should stay the way it is with 6 shots only
      48%
    • Revolvers are stupid and i'll never shoot them in competition
      28%

Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Featured Replies

There is alot of chatter amongst  the USPSA Revolver shooters concerning the lack of participation in the division. It's not just here at our local clubs, it's cross country. Typically at our local matches I am the only revolver competitor out of almost 100 people. On a Really good day, there might be 3. It is one of the lowest participated divisions. Even at larger area matches, counts are still low. 

 

There as been some rumors and speculation that USPSA will allow the 8 shot revolvers compete in Revolver division declared minor. ( Currently , the most popular gun for revo division is the 6 shot .45acp S&W 625 / Major )

 

Some feel this may spike more interest in the division, others feel it would be the kiss of death for the 6 shot S&W 625 guns, even with them scored as major - the extra 2 shots the 8 shooters have in an enormous advantage with stages with 4 target arrays.

 

 

So, poll time -

 

Would you consider shooting Revolver division USPSA if you could shoot your 8 shot 38 spl ( S&W 627 ) Revolver.

Revo guys are uppity pricks.   :kingchris:

I voted but my lack of participation in any sort of organized shooting events makes my vote pointless

I think it would be interesting for 8 shot revolvers to be included.  Many stages are setup for a string of 8-10 shots in a row and then reload.  My guess is to allow easy reloading points for production and SS class.  This is really unfair to 6 shot revolvers as you are reloading at every string of target and rarely get to take advantage of reloading on the move.

 

I don't think minor or major would solve the problem as this may lead to the death of the 6 shot revolver in competition.  I think there may need for a Revolver Limited 6 and Revolver Limited class.

 

Part of the issue is also support from the firearm industry to create more competitive revolvers that people would desire.  Right now, as you said, it is really just the S&W 625 that is used.  It would be interesting to see some of the other manufacturers make a competitive gun against the 625.  Opening the 8 shot would allow owners of the TRR8, R8 and 627 V-Comp to compete which are all pretty cool to own.  Perhaps they can create a 8 shot .45 ACP if this is possible.  Again, most of the ones named are all made by S&W.  It would be good to see some competition revolvers come out from the other manufacturers (Do you hear that Ruger?).

That's a tough one, especially if it's just for minor division.  Are there really that many people shooting revo minor?  Probably not...  Especially with a 625.

 

I voted no.  

I have a hard enough time counting to 6.

Revolver is all but dead. Time to send it out to pasture (ICORE)  120 people at a stand alone nationals didn't show renewed interest.  It showed that only 120 people would rather shoot revolver than not shoot at all.

Perhaps they can create a 8 shot .45 ACP if this is possible.

 

Would be a massive cylinder.  Oh, and totally awesome.

  • Author

I would respectfully disagree with those who would include 8 shot revolvers such as the S&W 627 in revolver division.

 

Firstly, as I said before - This would completely kill off all the s&w 625 6 shooters, even scored minor - they'll have an enormous advantage over the 6 shot guns.

   Part of the fun of shooting revolver division is being limited to 6 shots, you need to be creative with your stage planning, & accurate as you dont have the room for make up shots.

 

 

Also, the S&W 627 8 shooters is already legal in 4 out of the 6 divisions currently... yet, nobody is shooting them there. You can use them in production, L-10, Limited, and  open divisions. I dont see anybody running out to shoot in them.... What would be different this time around? They arent being used there, why would they be used here.

  • Author

Revolver is all but dead. Time to send it out to pasture (ICORE)  120 people at a stand alone nationals didn't show renewed interest.  It showed that only 120 people would rather shoot revolver than not shoot at all.

 

 

At our local level , i've been pushing other shooters to start shooting the division, I've converted at least 2 or 3 over the past year. Is it alot? No.... is it something? Sure.

 

as far as ICORE being an alternative... Here in NJ, it'd be no good as we do not have any ICORE clubs , or matches in the state. 

Would be a massive cylinder.  Oh, and totally awesome.

Ohhh...massive cylinders.  That would draw interest.

 

I have put off using a permit for a revolver for competition twice already.  I did burn it on a Colt Anaconda though but I doubt I would use that in a match.  I was going to use that permit for a S&W 625.  I think the manufacturers have to create sex appeal for revolvers to get people to buy them and then shoot them. 

At our local level , i've been pushing other shooters to start shooting the division, I've converted at least 2 or 3 over the past year. Is it alot? No.... is it something? Sure.

 

as far as ICORE being an alternative... Here in NJ, it'd be no good as we do not have any ICORE clubs , or matches in the state. 

 

There is no ICORE in NJ because there is no interest to support it, therefore no place to pull competitive revolver shooters from.  Adding divisions, changing division won't increase interest

What would be different this time around? They arent being used there, why would they be used here.

Maybe because they wouldn't be competing against the semi's from production L10 & limited.  Just other revo's.

But i agree to an extent.  I don't think they should change it but If you are shooting major, what difference will it make?

I've converted at least 2 or 3 over the past year.

No $hit!

throwing-money.gif

  • Author

Maybe because they wouldn't be competing against the semi's from production L10 & limited.  Just other revo's.

But i agree to an extent.  I don't think they should change it but If you are shooting major, what difference will it make?

 

difference to what if shooting major? ConFused

 

 

 

 

USPSA sets the rules at 8 shots per standing position don't they? Assuming everybody is making their shots they are reloading at the same points, so you could say that the 8 shooters fit fine in production / L - 10 ,etc.

difference to what if shooting major? ConFused

 

Ok, so my question is, how would adding 8 shots to just the minor division, "all but kill" the entire revo division?  Especially if most revo shooters use a 625 in major.  Still don't want the change but, i just don't see it as devastating i guess.  

 

BTW, the first post in this thread was dead on...

Course design and construction must not require more than 8 scoring hits from any single
location or view, nor allow a competitor to shoot all targets in the course of fire from any single location or view.

Ok, so my question is, how would adding 8 shots to just the minor division, "all but kill" the entire revo division?  Especially if most revo shooters use a 625 in major.  Still don't want the change but, i just don't see it as devastating i guess.  

 

BTW, the first post in this thread was dead on...

 

Because there would be a huge advantage on not having to do a standing reload, so everyone would shoot 8 shot minor. no one would shoot 6 shot major.  The added points of major would not over come the time loss

  • Author

Ok, so my question is, how would adding 8 shots to just the minor division, "all but kill" the entire revo division?  Especially if most revo shooters use a 625 in major.  Still don't want the change but, i just don't see it as devastating i guess.  

 

BTW, the first post in this thread was dead on...

Time.

 

 

I think the 8 shot minor guns will inhertitly be faster then the 6 major guns. Less reloads, faster stage time, higher hit factor.

 

Figure a stage with 32 rounds, assume you hit all your shots.

 

8 shooter : 4 reloads

 

6 shooter : 6 reloads

 

Figure 2-4 seconds per reload, depending on how fast you are.

 

4-8 second advantage right off the bat with just reloads.... Now you have to figure in that a 6 shooter will need to take " the long way home " with stage planning to be as efficient as possible, where a 8 shooter can blast right through it. Also 6 shooter will be a doing a standing reload, then moving... whereas 8 shooter will always reload on the move. 

Time.

 

 

I think the 8 shot minor guns will inhertitly be faster then the 6 major guns. Less reloads, faster stage time, higher hit factor.

 

Figure a stage with 32 rounds, assume you hit all your shots.

 

8 shooter : 4 reloads

 

6 shooter : 6 reloads

 

Figure 2-4 seconds per reload, depending on how fast you are.

 

4-8 second advantage right off the bat with just reloads.... Now you have to figure in that a 6 shooter will need to take " the long way home " with stage planning to be as efficient as possible, where a 8 shooter can blast right through it. Also 6 shooter will be a doing a standing reload, then moving... whereas 8 shooter will always reload on the move. 

Ok good point...  I'm assuming that the classification were segregated by major/minor.

Yeah F$%# those 8 shot punk ass B1tches!

 

Wait, this might get me out of "D" class...  Can i change my vote?

  • Author

Ok good point... I'm assuming that the classification were segregated by major/minor.

Yeah F$%# those 8 shot punk ass B1tches!

 

Wait, this might get me out of "D" class... Can i change my vote?

Most classifiers are either 6 shots, or 6 reload 6 , so it wouldn't matter there, in fact the 6 shot majors would do better on those types of classifiers.

 

 

And oh yah, grab a snickers , it's gonna be a while d class! Oh snap ! Went there

Most classifiers are either 6 shots, or 6 reload 6 , so it wouldn't matter there, in fact the 6 shot majors would do better on those types of classifiers.

 

 

 

except for Madness, that is agonizing to watch being shot with a 6 shot revolver

Most classifiers are either 6 shots, or 6 reload 6 , so it wouldn't matter there, in fact the 6 shot majors would do better on those types of classifiers.

 

Read your last post again.  But slooooowly this time.

I'm a GM getting you to argue both sides of a debate.

  • Author

except for Madness, that is agonizing to watch being shot with a 6 shot revolver

Don't think I've shot that one, we did diamond cutter a few months back, turn and engage 4 targets. Thought I did well, made all my shots , decent reload, hit factor was pathetic. It's hard to score proper on those sort of classifiers when you have to throw a reload in.

I am classified for USPSA with revolver, I have never used anything but my 610, probably will never use anything else either. I shoot minor with my whimpy loads, it's fine for me. I don't get to participate much anyway. Think I have done three or four matches so far........... Eight shot revolvers should compete against other 8 shot revolvers, let the six-shooters stay by themselves. Hell, I really don't care, I suck anyway!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.