Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Apartment living and home defense

Featured Replies

So my girlfriend and I will be moving out soon into our own place. We have gotten a lot of things done in preparation, but one thing that I still can't fully decide on is protection inside of our home. I will try not to make this a book and instead hit the points I feel are important or necessary in my opinion.

 

I'm basically going back and forth between a pistol and a shotgun for home defense. Where I am living now, I don't really have to worry too much about penetration, spread, damage, etc so I have a few guns loaded and ready to go, including buckshot and pistol rounds.

 

We are in the middle of a small building so we have tenants on both sides of us and above. Through quite some years of shooting and taking defensive gun classes, I am and will continue to put safety at the top of the list. Everyone that shoots with me knows safety is always a priority with me. In terms of living, that safety goes for myself, my girlfriend, using protection to defend us, but also safety for the other people around us if force had to be used. I understand people living around us can't be controlled 100%, but that is probably the biggest issue I'm having is deciding what type of round to use in an environment such as an apartment.

 

Here are my options IMO,

 

Pistol (9mm):

Pro's - it's small, can be hidden if not in a safe, a pistol safe is easier to hide than a long gun safe, I can carry while at home, can hide extra mags throughout the house

Con's - 9mm bullet travels fast and far and can travel through several walls, must be aware of surroundings and people in other rooms, collateral damage

 

Shotgun 12ga:

Pro's - I feel more comfortable with a shotgun for defense and with a full stock, I can put plenty of accurate rounds through it. 9 shells fully loaded is plenty and birdshot, if penetrates through a wall, will lose velocity immediately. A bunch of shot is less lethal going through a wall than a 9mm bullet.

Con's - I feel birdshot is unreliable for defense unless point blank distance but makes up for lethality in decreasing collateral damage, shotgun is difficult to hide outside of safe, a long gun safe is rather large and will take up closet space that we don't have much of

 

I prefer buckshot in terms of protection but with an apartment I'd probably choose birdshot although I can't say I am impressed the least with birdshot lethality. Sure, when you shoot a pumpkin from 5 feet away it does a pretty good job of putting a nice hole in it, but any farther and spread increases. I'd probably go with #6 shot as that shot is a little bigger than #7 or #8, but not too large to increase penetration and lethality through walls.

 

My personal opinion right now? 12ga loaded with birdshot. Although my girlfriend is nervous about a gun being loaded in the house and 'hidden'. I think she gets scared thinking someone breaks in, finds it, then waits for one of us to get home. And a gun safe will take up space in a closet, and we only have 2 small closets I believe. And you know 1.5 of them will be taken up by my girlfriends crap. I like that a pistol is more concealable and easier to hide, especially in a small safe that will barely take up any room, but I don't like the fact that 9mm bullets will penetrate numerous walls depending on the studs, sheetrock, other materials etc.

 

Any suggestions or opinions? Or maybe something I didn't think of/cover above? I'd prefer not to hear the "I'd rather kill the bad guy and worry about collateral damage after" type of thinking, it's important for me to take the safety of others into consideration.

There are plenty of YouTube vids of how well birdshot works for home defense. Are any of the rooms in the new place longer than 30 feet? If not, birdshot would work well in the shotgun. The bonus to birdshot it will not over penetrate the walls, unless you are shooting point blank at the wall.

They do make home defense rounds for 9mm that is suppose to cut down on penetration although I have no experience using them.

Personally I would lean towards the shotgun. For starters aim is less of an issue. More than likely after 1 shot the intruder is going to retreat. Identifying and engaging an intruder in the dark will probably happen in 12' or less. If using bird shot maybe shot one doesn't drop somebody but shot 2,3 or 4 will. Also consider your follow up shot. Center of mass becomes less critical with a shotgun. Considering muzzle rise and being left or right of center mass you could blindly rip off 4-5 shots and still easily be hitting in a lethal area. One other thing to consider is a shotgun offers an extension of your hands. But of the gun or barrel end. Similar to a Bo in martial arts. Most shotguns are pretty easy to feed extra shells into as time permits.

I have seen you on the shotgun and seen how comfortable you are with one so I see no issue there. Also as you said that's your comfort zone.

One other round to consider is the .223. From some of the reports I have seen after hitting one layer of Sheetrock they loose power quick.

As for storage there are home defense brackets that you can mount to a wall that are lockable. Takes up a lot less room than a safe and allows easy access. I think Mosseberg even makes one.

You could use your shotgun with an extra full turkey choke keep that birdshot real tight

I'm in the same boat at the moment.  I've decided on my AR15 with .223 and my .45 with federal personal defense ammo

  • Author

9mm frangible is something I never really debated. I always felt lik it's either HP's or, if anything, FMJ in pistols. I take Youtube videos, gelatin tests, etc, with a grain of salt but I'm going to search for some frangible testing videos just to see what happens.

 

I've watched some of the birdshot home defense videos and the overpenetration through sheetrock and walls was good, as in it didn't penetrate a lot, but my reservation (and my reservations may be wrong, who knows) is that unless with a point blank shot, birdshot doesn't have the pellet size to penetrate and hit vital organs and such. Even shooting pumpkins and whatnot from varying distances, at 20 feet the spread is already getting larger and doesn't create such a hole anymore like it does from 5 or 10 feet away. Yes, it depends on the choke and such.

 

None of that means I completely doubt or negate birdshot for home defense, I'm just saying I have my reservations but would still use it if I needed to.

 

In terms of .223/an AR, not gonna happen. I'm not a fan of AR's nor that caliber so that's completely out. And that Mossberg Loc-box thing I've seen probably does the job it's intended to, but I don't want a loaded shotgun sitting in that thing all day. It's going to be in some sort of safe that will be bolted to the wall/floor.

 

Socom's suggestion of a tight turkey choke isn't a bad one. I prefer a short barrel for my home shotguns though and they are all cyl bore. An option would be to thread the barrel for chokes but it seems like that's going a bit too far...or is it!?

As much as I like the AR and shotgun as my HD weapon, i have opted for the 9mm with police dept . Approved hollow Points.

 

This is why.

I lived in three apartments t in NYC and have also had a lot of MOUT training with an M16. I'm no expert, but the exposure to all that has led me the following conclusions.

 

If there is any chance of any kind of room clearing in the confines of a small apartment or my small 1930's era home, an AR is a hinderance. In the Army the MOUT training was big on teamwork. That is not going to happen with my wife.

 

Clearing tight corners, especially in my house where there are 4 doors at the end of a hallway, is easier with a handgun held in tight.

 

The distances are so short that there is little spread from a shotgun anyway.

 

That same short distance is an easy point and shoot distance with my Glock because it fits like a glove in my hand.

 

So, my opinion, based on my domiciles of course, is that very tight quarters are best served with the handgun that you get the best reflex two eyes open results with. For me that is the Glock 19 and now my LCR.

 

As for as ammo goes, if the police use Speer Gold dot, that's all I need to know.

 

 

 

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Why would you be "room clearing" in a small apt with a possible intruder in the house? Is it not prudent to stay in one place to cover the entrance and call 911? I can't speak for the op but I've never been formally trained on room entry and assault.

Why would you be "room clearing" in a small apt with a possible intruder in the house? Is it not prudent to stay in one place to cover the entrance and call 911? I can't speak for the op but I've never been formally trained on room entry and assault.

 

Yep. Operative word is "if."

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Yep. Operative word is "if."

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I'm asking why you would be doing so.

Why would you be "room clearing" in a small apt with a possible intruder in the house? Is it not prudent to stay in one place to cover the entrance and call 911? I can't speak for the op but I've never been formally trained on room entry and assault.

If you and your significant other are in the same room and you're positive you have an intruder, I'd hunker down, dial 911, use something solid as cover, and cover the door.

I'm asking why you would be doing so.

Assuming you have children you'd be going to get them.

  • Author

Of course every home defense plan has to be flexible as I could be in the living room with my girlfriend in the bedroom as someones trying to force their way into our front door. You can just say you will always be together or anything. With that said, my preferable plan would be to retreat to the bedroom, and grab my girlfriend on the way if she was not in the bedroom. I'm not trying to change the direction of this thread into home defense tactics, and although I can't speak for everyone else, the simple answer is no, I am not one to start room clearing and all that business. There is a time and a place for that, and for me, most situations don't constitute the need for that. Now if you have kids in another room or an intruder snatches a family member, that completely changes the game plan.

 

I need to check out some frangible options and some range tests. Thanks for those links ChrisJM, I'm checking them out now.

I honestly live in an apt and I use my G27 with my hand rolled .40sw

Of course every home defense plan has to be flexible as I could be in the living room with my girlfriend in the bedroom as someones trying to force their way into our front door. You can just say you will always be together or anything. With that said, my preferable plan would be to retreat to the bedroom, and grab my girlfriend on the way if she was not in the bedroom. I'm not trying to change the direction of this thread into home defense tactics, and although I can't speak for everyone else, the simple answer is no, I am not one to start room clearing and all that business. There is a time and a place for that, and for me, most situations don't constitute the need for that. Now if you have kids in another room or an intruder snatches a family member, that completely changes the game plan.

 

I need to check out some frangible options and some range tests. Thanks for those links ChrisJM, I'm checking them out now.

Don't mean to veer the thread. Just saying that we tend to over complicate things. If kids or gf are in a different room I will grab the closest gun and b-line it to their location. If its just me I grab the nearest gun and get to the bedroom if possible. My AR is preferable but I don't usually carry it around with me at home. My handgun is more accessible but I will make an effort to get the rifle.

 

If the S really HTF I will grab whatever weapon is readily available at that moment.

 

Situation more than anything will determine weapon to me.

 

I'm sorry. I did not mean to vear the thread either. I nearly meant to illustrate how I came to my own conclusions.

 

The main thing for me, I could be in a room hunkered down with the police on the phone and waiting with either a shotgun in my hand or my home defense pistol or an automatic rifle.

 

That might cover nine Out of 10 possible scenarios. But that one in 10 scenario where you're nowhere near the bedroom is what I am also concerned with. So although it is a great tactic to be prepared to do just that, wait in a room, gun pointing at the door and being prepared for someone to come through the door - I could do that with a handgun, I could do that with a shotgun, I could do that with an automatic rifle. But I believe the most 10 out of 10 flexibility -in my particular household situation - is to have a handgun.

 

Once that weapon is decided,based on the OP's question, now it's a matter of selecting ammunition.

 

 

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

personally i'd go either 9mm or AR (even though i don't have an AR at this time)

 

reason: look up these calibers vs a cinder block on youtube... it takes a few shots in the same spot for 9 to get through and could *maybe* take more for the 5.56. there are almost always firewalls between your side to side neighbors in apartments. of course you still need to worry about upstairs, but i doubt you'll need to shoot in that direction if you are ever in a home invasion situation.

Are you on the ground floor or above?  Neighbors above/below?  Honestly - I'd go with 9mm with a good HP round.  I know how you shoot - you can get the rounds on target.  Shotgun would potentially have a lot more collateral damage.

 

If you're set on using a shotgun, maybe try slightly smaller rounds?  Like #4 Buckshot?

Are you guys going to hunker down and call 911 every time you hear a bump in the night? Would you not want to go investigate a strange noise?

Are you guys going to hunker down and call 911 every time you hear a bump in the night? Would you not want to go investigate a strange noise?

I had one Sat night while house sitting. I'm sticking to a pistol for investigating, as the Saiga I had was way too cumbersome, Short barreled AR would have been fine.

 

9mm frangible is something I never really debated. I always felt like it's either HP's or, if anything, FMJ in pistols. I take Youtube videos, gelatin tests, etc, with a grain of salt but I'm going to search for some frangible testing videos just to see what happens.

 

I've watched some of the birdshot home defense videos and the overpenetration through sheetrock and walls was good, as in it didn't penetrate a lot, but my reservation (and my reservations may be wrong, who knows) is that unless with a point blank shot, birdshot doesn't have the pellet size to penetrate and hit vital organs and such. Even shooting pumpkins and whatnot from varying distances, at 20 feet the spread is already getting larger and doesn't create such a hole anymore like it does from 5 or 10 feet away. Yes, it depends on the choke and such.

 

 

What kind of walls are they? If they're drywall I'd go with frangible ammo, as FMJs are going to pass right through it. I'm not sure how JHPs will react to older plaster walls, but that would be something to look into as well if that's your situation. Any newer apartment is not likely to have insulated interior walls. It's most likely just framed with 2x4s and covered with drywall.

Carbine firing 5.56/.223 is definitely the best option IMHO. Just use standard m193

Maybe I'm wrong (it does happen at least once every 5 to 10 years) but what is with everyone's fear of being attacked in your home?  I'm curious how many people here have ever had that happen?  Maybe this is being over thought.  Maybe its just a heck of a lot more unlikely where I live than where others live, but I have never heard of this happing where I live.

 

If you live in an apartment you are already fairly secure, especially if you are not on the ground floor.  The first thing you should do is invest in a good deadbolt for the doors.  That said, probably a handgun with HP or frangible is your best bet for tight quarters where you don't want to risk killing the baby in the next apartment.

 

As far as what actions to take, the last thing you want to do is go searching for an intruder to shoot them.  Your life as you know it will be significantly changed if you ever shoot someone in this state - no matter how much in the right you are.  Your best bet is to figure a safe place to hunker down and call police.  That said a gun in hand is still a good idea, but you really don't want to be using it.  I know in my house my dogs would notify me or scare anyone away, if that failed the alarm system would likely do that.  That failing we hang out in a huge family room on the third floor with a clear kill zone for anyone coming up the steps so I have one gun up there.  Our bedroom is down a long hallway with a nice safe kill zone for any intruder so I have a weapon there as well.  But my goal would be to be on the phone with police and let the intruder know they are on the way and that we are armed and ready to off them if they poke their head in.  While prepared and capable, the last thing in the world I would want to do is pull that trigger.

Maybe I'm wrong (it does happen at least once every 5 to 10 years) but what is with everyone's fear of being attacked in your home?  I'm curious how many people here have ever had that happen?  Maybe this is being over thought.  Maybe its just a heck of a lot more unlikely where I live than where others live, but I have never heard of this happing where I live.

 

If you live in an apartment you are already fairly secure, especially if you are not on the ground floor.  The first thing you should do is invest in a good deadbolt for the doors.  That said, probably a handgun with HP or frangible is your best bet for tight quarters where you don't want to risk killing the baby in the next apartment.

 

As far as what actions to take, the last thing you want to do is go searching for an intruder to shoot them.  Your life as you know it will be significantly changed if you ever shoot someone in this state - no matter how much in the right you are.  Your best bet is to figure a safe place to hunker down and call police.  That said a gun in hand is still a good idea, but you really don't want to be using it.  I know in my house my dogs would notify me or scare anyone away, if that failed the alarm system would likely do that.  That failing we hang out in a huge family room on the third floor with a clear kill zone for anyone coming up the steps so I have one gun up there.  Our bedroom is down a long hallway with a nice safe kill zone for any intruder so I have a weapon there as well.  But my goal would be to be on the phone with police and let the intruder know they are on the way and that we are armed and ready to off them if they poke their head in.  While prepared and capable, the last thing in the world I would want to do is pull that trigger.

There is a difference between being afraid and prepared..... I don't live in fear over stuff like this... But operate under the assumption that it could happen...

I agree it "could" happen, but what are the chances?  Maybe where you live it is a lot higher than where I am.  I am more concerned with such things as the house being hit by lightning, being attacked by a black bear in the back yard, fire, etc....  If I lived in one of the inner cities in the state I would be more concerned with a bad guy breaking in.

Maybe I'm wrong (it does happen at least once every 5 to 10 years) but what is with everyone's fear of being attacked in your home? I'm curious how many people here have ever had that happen? Maybe this is being over thought. Maybe its just a heck of a lot more unlikely where I live than where others live, but I have never heard of this happing where I live.

 

If you live in an apartment you are already fairly secure, especially if you are not on the ground floor. The first thing you should do is invest in a good deadbolt for the doors. That said, probably a handgun with HP or frangible is your best bet for tight quarters where you don't want to risk killing the baby in the next apartment.

 

As far as what actions to take, the last thing you want to do is go searching for an intruder to shoot them. Your life as you know it will be significantly changed if you ever shoot someone in this state - no matter how much in the right you are. Your best bet is to figure a safe place to hunker down and call police. That said a gun in hand is still a good idea, but you really don't want to be using it. I know in my house my dogs would notify me or scare anyone away, if that failed the alarm system would likely do that. That failing we hang out in a huge family room on the third floor with a clear kill zone for anyone coming up the steps so I have one gun up there. Our bedroom is down a long hallway with a nice safe kill zone for any intruder so I have a weapon there as well. But my goal would be to be on the phone with police and let the intruder know they are on the way and that we are armed and ready to off them if they poke their head in. While prepared and capable, the last thing in the world I would want to do is pull that trigger.

My house in bridge water was broken into and burglarized 10 minutes before my mom came home with me 8 at the time and my sister6. That would have been rough to walk in on 10 minutes earlier. Fast forward 12 years and my house in warren had an attempted break in that my dog scared away while we were on vacation.

 

Things happen all the time even in "tame suburbia" and you should always be prepared because you could be the one in a million

 

 

Sent from my hidden under ground bunker between Taco Bell and the dry cleaner

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.