Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Shooting a person in self-defense - tell your story

Featured Replies

I just wonder how many people here have ever actually run into a situation in their homes, or business where they needed to have a gun, and how many have actually fired one at a person.  I am sure there are cases, I just have never heard of anyone I know being put in that situation.  Maybe where I live is very different than where you live.  I just question when I hear people telling about the 12 guns they have scattered through the house, "just in case".

 

So who here has actually used a gun in self defense and what ramifications followed ?????

 

{feel free to add info about another person that you know very well that has gone through this -- not a thirds hand story please}

I doubt anyone with a brain would really discuss on the web about having to handle business in NJ. Think about it.

Not a good topic IMHO. If something has happened no matter how long ago you NEVER open your mouth about it especially on social media. That is what's wrong with people today.

  • Author

Gee, I guess you can be paranoid and still have real enemies.  :)

 

No one is asking for names or locations - just say "my friend" if you want to keep it hypothetical.  I really think this would be good information for people to be able to understand what really happens if you shoot a person in this state.

NOBODY is going to talk about it. It's going to be traumatic for sure. The best way to find out is actual court cases but I don't know of any (although I am sure there are some). 

But anyway I will talk about a story. 

 

Some robbers tried to hold up his hardware store with machetes. Yes, stupid. My uncle had his licensed 9mm pistol with him. They came in and pretended to be looking at stuff. One came up with the machete and tried to hold him up. He drew and fired. He had plenty of practice plus he used to dry fire a lot but with a cordless drill. 

 

One bullet grazed an attacker because they fled as soon as they saw the gun. Not sure whether cops caught up with them but they never were robbed again as far as I know. They also have big dogs guarding the place when it's closed (they live there). 

 

Don't worry, my uncle is deceased (natural causes, probably heart disease) and this is in a foreign country, so it's safe to tell. Oh and I think it was in the papers too. 

  • Author

I find it very interesting that there are many many threads here and on other boards about how everyone has all these guns laying around the house with all sorts of special rounds for home defense and that they are ready to take action.  Don't you think it makes sense to understand what you might be in for if you do take action?

 

I for one think people should be aware of what potential consequences they might be in for if they take action.  If everyone here is chicken then perhaps some LEO's on the board could comment about their experience when they arrived at the scene in NJ of a self-defense shooting.

I don't plan to shoot anyone. Let me get that out there. I don't WANT TO EVER SHOOT ANYONE. I value human life quite a lot. 

 

But being prepared to defend yourself is reasonable. An absolute last resort. That's why we prepare.

 

We also want to make sure that we don't injure our families if we ever (god forbid) have to defend ourselves. That's why we train, that's why we use defensive ammo and frangible ammo. 

I've got 2 stories, one involves my friends grandfather and I heard it second hand, the second is my dad (almost shot but didnt). I'll post them when I get to my pc.

Howard, there are one million different scenarios and none of which may apply to you. Being most here are from NJ, it doesn't take much to know that the state is screwed especially with gun laws. You shoot someone, you will probably be under a lot of scrutiny. If that lady in the home invasion video shot that guy, he would probably be suing her.

I find it very interesting that there are many many threads here and on other boards about how everyone has all these guns laying around the house with all sorts of special rounds for home defense and that they are ready to take action.  Don't you think it makes sense to understand what you might be in for if you do take action?

 

I for one think people should be aware of what potential consequences they might be in for if they take action.  If everyone here is chicken then perhaps some LEO's on the board could comment about their experience when they arrived at the scene in NJ of a self-defense shooting.

 

 

Completely different.

 

Showing a personal collection of firearms

 

&

 

Explaining " tactical " scenarios of what you might / plan on doing in a home defense situation 

 

 

is worlds apart from the actual story of having to take somebodies life in self defense... All the legal parameters aside, it's just not something you would go around telling people.

Completely different.

 

Showing a personal collection of firearms

 

&

 

Explaining " tactical " scenarios of what you might / plan on doing in a home defense situation 

 

 

is worlds apart from the actual story of having to take somebodies life in self defense... All the legal parameters aside, it's just not something you would go around telling people.

^^ This.  It's similar to  asking someone who's been in the military and has seen action, "Hey, did you kill someone?" IMO, it's not for us to ask and not for us to tell.

Oh god this is not something to be talking about on the internet... use your brains!

  • Author

I understand where some of you are coming from, but I don't agree.  All knowledge is good.  Just like you prepare by going out and getting a weapon and going out and training and plan for the unlikely; you should also be prepared for what might come after you have to pull that trigger.  The only way to be prepared is to understand what others may have gone through when they had to do that.  If people don't want to share that info that is fine, but please don't claim it is not important information to have in hand.  That is why I also asked if any NJ LEO's could chime in with what they experienced happened when they were involved in one of these cases.  So, enough of saying it does not belong, if you don't want to share and learn why not just.....  oh forget it.

Pick up some law books. Read case law. Thats it.

Not a good topic IMHO. If something has happened no matter how long ago you NEVER open your mouth about it especially on social media. That is what's wrong with people today.

I don't see the big deal. It's never happened to me and hopefully it never does.

Dear god stop bitching if you dont wanna post a story or dont think its a good idea then dont and let ppl with some balls post theres... I dont know anyone that has had to defend themselve from home intruders but i live in newark (on the white side) and i sleep with my gun at arms reach , if someone comes in hes getting shot.

I don't see the big deal. It's never happened to me and hopefully it never does.

I agree Rob, don't know what the big deal is. If it has already happened & you have been cleared of any wrong doing, it's already on public record. The OP is just asking if anyone has had to shoot or shot at an intruder for self defense.And what happened to you as far as legal ramifications.

 

I wouldn't post anything specific, like peoples names or location were it happened.

 

For example:

 

I shot at a guy with my handgun after he kicked my front door in and lunged at me with a knife, he turned and ran after I shot at him, I called the police, they started their investigation, took possession of handgun for ballistic testing, ect..

 

BTW this ^ is only an example, I have never had to shoot or shot at anyone.

Not a good topic IMHO. If something has happened no matter how long ago you NEVER open your mouth about it especially on social media. That is what's wrong with people today.

+10000

 

at least. 

 

Possibly more. 

The reason people don't want to post if it dd happen is that once its out there on the net it is there for ever. You may be cleared o the charges but what if you go for a job and someone sees this. What happens if you involved in a law suit over say a fight that you protected yourself in a lawful way the other attorney could use this as previous cause that you are a violent person. Also we know how the media can twist things what if what you post is taken out of context and use against you. It is not a question of Balls it is a question of Brains

Here is a bigger reason not to post this kind of bullsh!t :facepalm:

 

If someone readings these accounts gets their panties in a bunch, what some of you guys are thinking of as "no big deal" could turn into a real ass-ache for Maks. He could be subpoenaed to court and/or forced to start turning over records, screen-names, and personal info on members here to investigators, lawyers or Police. Doesn't matter if it happened this morning or 50 years ago. New info could be a reason to open the case again, and a previously justified incident could be looked at again civilly.

 

Why in the world would you want to open that can of worms and put this site under that kind of scrutiny for such a stupid topic as this? This could potentially affect everyone here, and ultimately shut this whole place down.

True Story: I read a thread like this on another forum and 100% of the people involved say it's the worst thing you can do. Avoid at all costs.

I just wonder how many people here have ever actually run into a situation in their homes, or business where they needed to have a gun, and how many have actually fired one at a person.  I am sure there are cases, I just have never heard of anyone I know being put in that situation.  Maybe where I live is very different than where you live.  I just question when I hear people telling about the 12 guns they have scattered through the house, "just in case".

 

So who here has actually used a gun in self defense and what ramifications followed ?????

 

{feel free to add info about another person that you know very well that has gone through this -- not a thirds hand story please}

 

Search the 'net for real incidents as they've happened in your home state of New Jersey. I'll bet they are few and far between.

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.