I asked the same question.... Ended up picking up a RIA 1911 Tactical and shot about 100 rounds this weekend.  All is well and very happy with the purchase!  Thanks to the folks in here for sure with great suggestions.

I really enjoy my Glock 21, but my favorite is the Wilson Combat X-Tac 1911.

I have a Smith 1911E TA and LOVE that gun. I looked at the PX4 and rented the FNX. Have not shot the PX4 yet but think I'm going to have a hard time deciding between them. The FNX was very comfortable and accurate out to 14 yds (max at the range).

 

Rent them all and then decide.

i'm new to gun ownership, my first being a glock 23 .40 cal - my next handgun will definitely be a Colt 1911.

i'm new to gun ownership, my first being a glock 23 .40 cal - my next handgun will definitely be a Colt 1911.

 

Thats what I like to hear!

If you could find one the XD compact with 5 inch barrel is nice. Compact grip and extension on full size mag makes it either a full size gun or a carry. 13 +1 full mag 9 +1 compact. I have the XDM with 3.8 barrel and absolutely love it but really wanted the other due to longer barrel. XDM has a few upgrades that are nice. Recoil does not feel like a big .45 when shooting