Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SCOTUS denies Kwong v DeBlasio (SAF suit against permit fees)

Featured Replies

Towns charge all sorts of fees for parades and other gatherings on public land, including for police and sanitation. Those local laws have never, to my knowledge, been ruled unconstitutional. You really want the Supreme Court getting to rule on whether the fee should be $250, $350, or $450?

 

I don't remember ever hearing of a case based on this level of triviality. These are cases that are best resolved at the ballot box, a remedy that (as I've pointed out numerous times) is rarely exploited. You can't expect the Supreme Court to take hear the case of every disputed parking ticket. 

 

In other words, you can't expect the Supreme Court to do YOUR job, which is to elect responsible, honest office holders. Which, by the way, may be why they did not hear Drake. It's OUR responsibility to get out and vote.

 i dont think its so hard for scotus to rule that they can charge a fee if that fee is used to cover the amount it takes to issue the permit.  ie a fee to cover the material and time, not a fee to make it harder to exercise that right, which is clearly what NYC is doing, i dont think it costs 340 bucks in material and time to get that permit made 

 

if you dont want scotus getting involved in that than we just have different views on what the job is of scotus 

 i dont think its so hard for scotus to rule that they can charge a fee if that fee is used to cover the amount it takes to issue the permit.  ie a fee to cover the material and time, not a fee to make it harder to exercise that right, which is clearly what NYC is doing, i dont think it costs 340 bucks in material and time to get that permit made 

 

if you dont want scotus getting involved in that than we just have different views on what the job is of scotus 

My friend, this is on the level of a high-priced traffic ticket. Once the law permitting fees is settled, there is no constitutional issue. It's bupkes. You really want the Supreme Court of the United States to arbitrate permit fees for rallies in Lower St. Scrotum, Pennsylvania?

 

MILLIONS of issues like this arise each and every day in this country. The way to solve them is through local action, not in the Federal courts or the Supreme Court.

i agree with this, were a republic to protect our rights regardless of what the majority thinks, if congress all of sudden wanted to ban free religion by an overwhelming majority well the constitution is there to stop them and when it doesn't the courts kick in or they're at least supposed to

I believe that Heller established that the 2nd Amendment applies to self defense in the home. Please correct me if I'm wrong. 

 

Justly or unjustly, self defense outside the home has always been regulated. That's just the way it is. The only way to un-regulate it is to vote for strongly pro-2A politicians.

 

By now, after 238 years, the Supreme Court might have defined 2A more rigorously. Instead it has pretty much left the finer points of that issue to the states. Which you'd be EXTREMELY happy about if you lived in Vt, Az, AK, PA, etc. etc. Because what if the Court heard Drake and decided that the 2nd Amendment does NOT provide the right for concealed carry outside the home? At least now the issue remains suspended in ether, the plain language reading notwithstanding.

 

This is exactly what will happen soon as a test case hits the 6-3 liberal majority court in 2025-2030 or so.

 

Unfortunately for us we are one of three states that do not recognize the right to self defense with a concealed handgun outside the home. And for us it's probably just as well that the Supremes did not hear Drake, because the result was not foregone by any means.

This is exactly what will happen soon as a test case hits the 6-3 liberal majority court in 2025-2030 or so.

 

Happily if I still somehow manage to be breathing at that point, I will be old enough that I will not worry about resorting to blood and fire to preserve my rights.

No because it would subject the court to political will. The judiciary has to be independent.

 

Court already is controlled by political will........

Happily if I still somehow manage to be breathing at that point, I will be old enough that I will not worry about resorting to blood and fire to preserve my rights.

The machine, the undying/undead regulatory state, the inexorable devolution toward tyranny, will outlive us all.

 

Be grateful for the occasional silver linings. This is as good as it gets, and I'm not just talking about guns.

I am sure this permitting scheme just gave NJ a GREEN LIGHT to solve future budget problems. Since New Jerky likes to sniff New York ass.

 

As long as we have blind automoton non critical thinking voters in NJ, it will and has and can ONLY get worser.

True and NYC can deny you for petty stuff such as your driving record.

 

As can NJ per the nebulous "public health, safety or welfare" clause found in N.J.A.C. 13:54-1.5(a)5.

 

Can happen and does happen.  And I'm talking about a driving record of 2-point moving violation every couple years, no points accumulation, no serious offenses.

  • Author

As can NJ per the nebulous "public health, safety or welfare" clause found in N.J.A.C. 13:54-1.5(a)5.

 

Can happen and does happen.  And I'm talking about a driving record of 2-point moving violation every couple years, no points accumulation, no serious offenses.

 

Difference is that NYC actually routinely does this. 

Just for the kicks, SCOTUS has been so busy with "other" important things such as... wait for it......

 

------------

Supreme Court to Hear T-Mobile Cell-Tower Case
Justices to Decide If Local Governments Must Give Detailed Written Reasons When Towers Denied
 

 

The court will hear an appeal by a T-Mobile US Inc.TMUS -1.01% subsidiary that was turned away for a permit in Roswell, Ga. The company said certain city council members raised various objections to the T-Mobile tower proposal and voted it down. But the city never provided an official written explanation for the denial, the company argued.

------------

  • Author

Just for the kicks, SCOTUS has been so busy with "other" important things such as... wait for it......

 

------------

Supreme Court to Hear T-Mobile Cell-Tower Case

Justices to Decide If Local Governments Must Give Detailed Written Reasons When Towers Denied

 

 

The court will hear an appeal by a T-Mobile US Inc.TMUS -1.01% subsidiary that was turned away for a permit in Roswell, Ga. The company said certain city council members raised various objections to the T-Mobile tower proposal and voted it down. But the city never provided an official written explanation for the denial, the company argued.

------------

 

 

Well, to be fair that one does seem important. Telecoms infrastructure is blocked up by NIMBYs and BANANAs and it affects safety of life and growth of the economy, with mobile being a big component of our economy these days.

 

But you are right, they seem to be taking up "softball" cases, such as Pom Wonderful v Coca Cola and ABC v Aereo. I mean, who the hell cares? 

Wait til the SCOTUS just start hearing cases regarding that Kardashian lady. Nothing surprises me anymore.

 

I am awed by the classic Saul Alinsky tactics used by those secret radicals and their LONG term radical agendas, which now seems to have utterly rendered or outright defeated the US Judicial Third Branch. Utterly awed.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.