Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SCOTUS denies Kwong v DeBlasio (SAF suit against permit fees)

Featured Replies

SCOTUS refused to take up the case of Kwong v DeBlasio (formerly Kwong v Bloomberg) where the $340.00 permit fee for NYC premises handgun permits was challenged. 

 

Therefore the lower court ruling stands and the fees have been ruled constitutional there. 

 

You read that right. It costs you $340 plus $100 for fingerprinting just to keep a gun in your home in NYC. This, apparently, is constitutional. 

 

Makes you wonder if NJ will pull that stunt when Governor Fulop takes office. Charge $1000 for FID cards and that excludes a lot of people. 

Tyranny would be officially in when legislative, executive and judiciary branches all become one and repeatedly fail and/or delay justice to People.

 

Despite being under threat of religious nuts, crazy military and power hungry dictators, judiciary system in Pakistan does lot better.

i cant wrap my head around why scotus is denying all these cases, this one was cut and dry and wouldn't really affect the 2nd amendment at all, this seems like the type of case scotus would want to take

 

in my own opinion im thinking that probably about 50% of new yorkers cant own guns now because they don't have the funds, scotus doesn't find anything wrong with this? 

 

on an unrelated note i wouldnt mind paying $440 a year for a cc permit in NJ if the extra money would make them happy and shut their mouths, i believe a $500 dollar yearly fee was already recommend by a legislator though in NJ and they didnt seem too interested, weird considering all NJ cares about is money 

Tyranny would be officially in when legislative, executive and judiciary branches all become one and repeatedly fail and/or delay justice to People.

 

Despite being under threat of religious nuts, crazy military and power hungry dictators, judiciary system in Pakistan does lot better.

funny but true, Pakistanis judiciary system is more effective than ours at this point in time 

Not only is it non-refundable, but that $340 permit needs to be renewed (repaid every 3 years).

ryan do you think it would be wise for our legislators to make a law that basically says that if a majority of the house, senate and the president believes a case should be heard by scotus they have to hear the case then, a law like that might actually make them take cases that have affect on the ordinary Americans 

ryan do you think it would be wise for our legislators to make a law that basically says that if a majority of the house, senate and the president believes a case should be heard by scotus they have to hear the case then, a law like that might actually make them take cases that have affect on the ordinary Americans 

You're assuming that any of those entities actually give a fat-ratsass.jpgabout what ordinary Americans think.  Most of them think that they are above the "average American".  They can't be bothered to make decisions about laws that would affect the majority unless it in some way benefits THEM personally (or financially).

ryan do you think it would be wise for our legislators to make a law that basically says that if a majority of the house, senate and the president believes a case should be heard by scotus they have to hear the case then, a law like that might actually make them take cases that have affect on the ordinary Americans 

You don't want that.  We have enough of three branches in bed with each other, if anything, we need more separation.

That case had no chance to begin with on cert. So the outcome does not surprise me.

The case I want to see someone try to get into the Supreme Court is a pure Second Amendment Constitutional Carry Case based on preemption where State laws would not matter. I think that would have a shot because it would have universal application and not turn on a good cause or justifiable need analysis.

  • Author

ryan do you think it would be wise for our legislators to make a law that basically says that if a majority of the house, senate and the president believes a case should be heard by scotus they have to hear the case then, a law like that might actually make them take cases that have affect on the ordinary Americans

No because it would subject the court to political will. The judiciary has to be independent.

  • Author

That case had no chance to begin with on cert. So the outcome does not surprise me.

The case I want to see someone try to get into the Supreme Court is a pure Second Amendment Constitutional Carry Case based on preemption where State laws would not matter. I think that would have a shot because it would have universal application and not turn on a good cause or justifiable need analysis.

Peruta may be one such case because of the way California banned permitless open carry while the case was going on. It's also good because it deals purely with the application of the statute and not the law itself.

  • Author

Not only is it non-refundable, but that $340 permit needs to be renewed (repaid every 3 years).

True and NYC can deny you for petty stuff such as your driving record.

i cant wrap my head around why scotus is denying all these cases, 

They view these cases as adjudications of relatively minor state laws. That's why they only take cases that, at least in legal circles, will make headlines. 

 

You forget that firearms law was fairly restrictive nationwide until around 25 years ago. That was the norm. 

They view these cases as adjudications of relatively minor state laws. That's why they only take cases that, at least in legal circles, will make headlines. 

 

You forget that firearms law was fairly restrictive nationwide until around 25 years ago. That was the norm. 

true but for some reason i believe that if a small out of no where town started charging 440 bucks for a permit to protest scotus would be all over that in no time 

No because it would subject the court to political will. The judiciary has to be independent.

i guess that's true but i just wished there was a way that such unconstitutional laws could be dealt with, when all other methods fail (legislators and courts) were a republic to protect the minority from the majority so it shouldn't matter how few people the law affects, i just wish scotus would see it that way  

Based on the Obamacare precedent that fee would just be seen as a tax, and the Supreme Court does not get to say what level of taxation is reasonable.  If the cost of the permit was $10 then no one would care.  At $340 it is a stiff tax but every tax in NY is pretty high.  If it was $1,000,000 then it would be a backdoor violation of Heller and that might draw their interest.  I'd rather the Supreme Court take a more important gun case like Drake or Peruta.

  • Author

i guess that's true but i just wished there was a way that such unconstitutional laws could be dealt with, when all other methods fail (legislators and courts) were a republic to protect the minority from the majority so it shouldn't matter how few people the law affects, i just wish scotus would see it that way

You deal with it by getting your butt out to the ballot box. Obviously the other side is better at doing that than we are. That is what needs to be fixed

i cant wrap my head around why scotus is denying all these cases, this one was cut and dry and wouldn't really affect the 2nd amendment at all, this seems like the type of case scotus would want to take

 

in my own opinion im thinking that probably about 50% of new yorkers cant own guns now because they don't have the funds, scotus doesn't find anything wrong with this? 

 

on an unrelated note i wouldnt mind paying $440 a year for a cc permit in NJ if the extra money would make them happy and shut their mouths, i believe a $500 dollar yearly fee was already recommend by a legislator though in NJ and they didnt seem too interested, weird considering all NJ cares about is money

 

Well you missed the point completely. Its 440 just to own a gun in your resodence not carry.

 

Blantantly unconstitutional, but hey a judge said so so it must be okay. 6 bucks for an id to vote is unconstitutional but 440 is okay.

 

The system is permanently broken.

true but for some reason i believe that if a small out of no where town started charging 440 bucks for a permit to protest scotus would be all over that in no time 

Not sure what you mean by a permit to protest. If you mean that literally, then one could argue that the town is under no obligation to provide a special means or venue for protesting, as there are an infinite number of them available these days. Certainly I'd be able to charge you $450 to protest if it was on my land, no?

  • Author

They view these cases as adjudications of relatively minor state laws. That's why they only take cases that, at least in legal circles, will make headlines. 

 

You forget that firearms law was fairly restrictive nationwide until around 25 years ago. That was the norm. 

 

 

Truth is, nobody knows why they are denying cert on all these cases. The secrecy of the conferences is the stuff of legends. If the justices do not say publicly or privately to someone else and they blab, they will go with it to their graves. 

 

The most plausible theory is that there is at least one justice on the fence and the conservative wing wants to make sure they have five votes. This could be Kennedy as he is usually the swing vote. The liberal wing wants to kick the can down the road as much as possible until the court becomes liberal. 

Not sure what you mean by a permit to protest. If you mean that literally, then one could argue that the town is under no obligation to provide a special means or venue for protesting, as there are an infinite number of them available these days. Certainly I'd be able to charge you $450 to protest if it was on my land, no?

private land is completely different than public land 

Not sure what you mean by a permit to protest. If you mean that literally, then one could argue that the town is under no obligation to provide a special means or venue for protesting, as there are an infinite number of them available these days. Certainly I'd be able to charge you $450 to protest if it was on my land, no?

also last i checked the 1st amendment gives us the right to protest, peacefully that is, so we can use public land to assemble and what im saying is im sure scotus would find it unconstitutional if a town wanted to start charging 450 bucks for a permit to assemble  

also last i checked the 1st amendment gives us the right to protest, peacefully that is, so we can use public land to assemble and what im saying is im sure scotus would find it unconstitutional if a town wanted to start charging 450 bucks for a permit to assemble  

Towns charge all sorts of fees for parades and other gatherings on public land, including for police and sanitation. Those local laws have never, to my knowledge, been ruled unconstitutional. You really want the Supreme Court getting to rule on whether the fee should be $250, $350, or $450?

 

I don't remember ever hearing of a case based on this level of triviality. These are cases that are best resolved at the ballot box, a remedy that (as I've pointed out numerous times) is rarely exploited. You can't expect the Supreme Court to take hear the case of every disputed parking ticket. 

 

In other words, you can't expect the Supreme Court to do YOUR job, which is to elect responsible, honest office holders. Which, by the way, may be why they did not hear Drake. It's OUR responsibility to get out and vote.

Ummm....NYC does require a permit to assemble in certain circumstances, http://www.nyclu.org/content/know-your-rights-demonstrating-new-york-city

 

"Do I need a permit?

It depends on what you want to do. If you want to distribute handbills on a public sidewalk or in a public park; have a demonstration, rally or press conference on a public sidewalk; or march on a public sidewalk and you do not intend to use amplified sound, you do not need any permit. If you want to use amplified sound on public property; want to have an event with more than 20 people in a New York City park; or wish to conduct a march in a public street, you will need a permit. You will also need a permit if you want to conduct a procession involving 50 or more vehicles or bicycles in a public street. If you wish to have an event on the steps of City Hall or in the plaza in front of the steps, you need to make special arrangements with the Police Department."

 

This has been battled numerous times with the most prominent being the 1999 ban on a KKK rally where "Al Sharpton's National Action Network and African-American newspaper Amsterdam News filed papers backing the white supremacists in their bid to overturn a ban on the march imposed by the New York city police department." http://www.theguardian.com/world/1999/oct/22/janemartinson

 

 

Yes...Sharpton supported the KKK holding a rally in NYC....although, I'm pretty sure that he filed for a permit to hold his own "rally" at the same time.  At least someone was trying to uphold the Constitution (well..the part that benefited them at that particular moment)

......

 

In other words, you can't expect the Supreme Court to do YOUR job, which is to elect responsible, honest office holders. Which, by the way, may be why they did not hear Drake. It's OUR responsibility to get out and vote.

No one (largely) goes out to elect irresponsible, dishonest office holders. Even the scum of the scum is elected because the majority (right or wrong) looked at them as responsible and honest.

 

When a dispute is not resolved through lower courts (or there is split), it the job (atleast expectation) of the SCOTUS to listen and rule based on rule of the land, of which CONSTITUTION is THE Supreme Law.

 

I like to see if SCOTUS will deny cert if the case was about everyone having to pay $10 much less $340 + 100 for FP for a right to vote or even drivers license.  Someone should not be able to make it prohibitively expensive to exercise rights, specially the ones that goes to protection of life.   There are standards and way to measure what is "prohibitive".

No one (largely) goes out to elect irresponsible, dishonest office holders. Even the scum of the scum is elected because the majority (right or wrong) looked at them as responsible and honest.

 

When a dispute is not resolved through lower courts (or there is split), it the job (atleast expectation) of the SCOTUS to listen and rule based on rule of the land, of which CONSTITUTION is THE Supreme Law.

 

I like to see if SCOTUS will deny cert if the case was about everyone having to pay $10 much less $340 + 100 for FP for a right to vote or even drivers license.  Someone should not be able to make it prohibitively expensive to exercise rights, specially the ones that goes to protection of life.   There are standards and way to measure what is "prohibitive".

1) By not voting you are allowing the takers to make the selection for you, and who do you think they'll vote for? It's the majority of VOTERS who determine the winner, not the majority of CONSTITUENTS. And as we know voter participation in this state is piss poor.

 

2) Wrong. The court usually, overwhelmingly, lets lower court rulings stand by denying to hear cases. The current court's stand on the 2nd Amendment follows common law and practice for the last 250 years. Since the supreme court has rarely ruled on 2nd amendment issues, "the right to bear arms" as we in this forum believe it to exist has been practically speaking a legislated right. If you want gun laws similar to PA, VT, AZ, etc. THEN VOTE FOR LEGISLATORS WHO BELIEVE IN GUN RIGHTS. I believe that is the message the court is sending out when it turns down cases. 

 

3) Voting is not a right, it is a privilege based on certain criteria, which the states -- under the Constitution -- are permitted to set. At least in theory. Charging $350 for the "right to assemble" may or may not be reasonable, depending on the situation, and given the fact that this is an established part of law for hundreds of years. As I've posted previously, the right is obviously not absolute because you cannot and should not be able to hold a rally on 2nd and Washington Sts. at 8:30 am on a work day without first checking with the town (after which they have every right to deny you).

 

Posters in these forums forget -- maybe most are too young to remember -- that until quite recently gun policy nationwide was approximately the same as New York's today. Maybe a bit looser, give or take a few nonsensical NY restrictions. Shall Issue concealed carry was rare. And quite frankly the spectrum of rights we have today, from constitutional carry to DC's draconian laws, is about what one would expect for a right that has ALWAYS, traditionally, been heavily regulated. 

 

You will understand what I'm talking about as the "conservative" cadre on the high court fades and are replaced by liberals over the next decade or so. The states that have concealed carry will continue to enjoy that right provided their legislatures preserve it. Those that don't will continue not to enjoy it.

 

But don't blame the Supreme Court for the sewer that is NJ politics.

 

"The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars but in ourselves."

We can agree to disagree. Practically being a "legislated right" is not an excuse for SCOTUS to continue ducking on the issue.  SCOTUS reminding us to exercise our voting power is good imagination at best.

 

Going out and voting is all dandy. But if Voting is the ONLY recourse, minority will always lose (not just on 2A) and no need for SCOTUS.

we pay $70+ to own a gun.  they pay $100 a year.  add that there are fees for CCW permits all over the country.  i didn't really think this one had a chance.  even if NY is crazy.  the supreme court probably doesn't want to say that they can't charge you at all, but then why would they pick what is "reasonable"?

We can agree to disagree. Practically being a "legislated right" is not an excuse for SCOTUS to continue ducking on the issue.  SCOTUS reminding us to exercise our voting power is good imagination at best.

 

Going out and voting is all dandy. But if Voting is the ONLY recourse, minority will always lose (not just on 2A) and no need for SCOTUS.

i agree with this, were a republic to protect our rights regardless of what the majority thinks, if congress all of sudden wanted to ban free religion by an overwhelming majority well the constitution is there to stop them and when it doesn't the courts kick in or they're at least supposed to

Ummm....NYC does require a permit to assemble in certain circumstances, http://www.nyclu.org/content/know-your-rights-demonstrating-new-york-city

 

"Do I need a permit?

It depends on what you want to do. If you want to distribute handbills on a public sidewalk or in a public park; have a demonstration, rally or press conference on a public sidewalk; or march on a public sidewalk and you do not intend to use amplified sound, you do not need any permit. If you want to use amplified sound on public property; want to have an event with more than 20 people in a New York City park; or wish to conduct a march in a public street, you will need a permit. You will also need a permit if you want to conduct a procession involving 50 or more vehicles or bicycles in a public street. If you wish to have an event on the steps of City Hall or in the plaza in front of the steps, you need to make special arrangements with the Police Department."

 

This has been battled numerous times with the most prominent being the 1999 ban on a KKK rally where "Al Sharpton's National Action Network and African-American newspaper Amsterdam News filed papers backing the white supremacists in their bid to overturn a ban on the march imposed by the New York city police department." http://www.theguardian.com/world/1999/oct/22/janemartinson

 

 

Yes...Sharpton supported the KKK holding a rally in NYC....although, I'm pretty sure that he filed for a permit to hold his own "rally" at the same time.  At least someone was trying to uphold the Constitution (well..the part that benefited them at that particular moment)

im talking about fees not actual permits.............. i dont think its so hard for scotus to rule that they can charge a fee if that fee is used to cover the amount it takes to issue the permit.  ie a fee to cover the material and time, not a fee to make it harder to exercise that right 

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.