Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Traveling to Range Together, or, how many felonies?

Featured Replies

This topic, and the responses, combine two of my pet peeves. The first are posters who accuse individuals who obey the letter of the law of wearing tinfoil hats. In the business world risk is defined as the product of probability and severity of consequences. For me, five to ten getting butt-fukced by Bubba means my life is over. Pretty dire consequence, don't you think? Probability is of course very slim, but my car has been searched twice in the last 35 years, and almost one other time (he saw the back seat covered with flowers!). The chance of my house burning down is infinitesimally small, but I still have insurance. Bending over backwards to obey the letter of the transportation laws is, to me, a type of insurance. It sucks but I know I'll never get into trouble.

 

The second point involves the "who would know" scenario I've brought up several times, which usually brings the thread to an untimely end, to a screeching halt. I'm usually talking about much more illegal acts in those cases, like acquiring a gun through an estate or through private purchase. Always theoretical, of course, as I do not have access to such opportunities. 

 

Life is about managing risks. If a 110 year old woman sells me a brand new, never-fired handgun at an estate sale and she dies the next day, and I get home safely, it no longer matters (according to NJ law) how the gun was acquired. 

I agree with you Newtonian.  I used to have the same mindset as many of the posters above you.

 

But after personally witnessing someone go through hell after being snared by NJ's nebulous firearms laws I have a very different opinion now.

 

In this incident the defendant had his local reputation ruined, was denied his 2A rights for the duration of the ordeal and had spent over TEN THOUSAND dollars in lawyers fee (multiple retainers).  The decisions of a corrupt township and incompetent judge were eventually reversed but the damage was already done.  The best part were other NJ gun owners insinuating that he must have done something wrong because they do the same thing and they've never gotten in trouble for it.

 

You don't need to be arrested for this behavior for it to affect your 2A rights in NJ.  All you need is the fact to be mentioned in a police report.  Then on a subsequent FPIC renewal or P2P application the investigator can view the incident as bad judgement on your part and deny your application.  Then a judge that always sides with the State can complicate your appeal.  Your right to due process are abridged in these proceedings as the rules for introducing hearsay as evidence are relaxed and the court will make its decision by considering such nonsense.

 

These things can and do happen.  Talk to any NJ firearms attorney and you will hear some real horror stories.

 

In my opinion these are the worst kinds of situations because the defendant's peers behave the same way and have never gotten in trouble for it.  So they assume the defendant must have done something really bad.  "There must be more to this story", etc..

 

I don't cower either.  But I shudder at "selective prosecution" and its derivatives.  And those who support it by accusing those concerned of being "tin foil" types.  Shame on you!

I agree with you Newtonian.  I used to have the same mindset as many of the posters above you.

 

But after personally witnessing someone go through hell after being snared by NJ's nebulous firearms laws I have a very different opinion now.

 

In this incident the defendant had his local reputation ruined, was denied his 2A rights for the duration of the ordeal and had spent over TEN THOUSAND dollars in lawyers fee (multiple retainers).  The decisions of a corrupt township and incompetent judge were eventually reversed but the damage was already done.  The best part were other NJ gun owners insinuating that he must have done something wrong because they do the same thing and they've never gotten in trouble for it.

 

You don't need to be arrested for this behavior for it to affect your 2A rights in NJ.  All you need is the fact to be mentioned in a police report.  Then on a subsequent FPIC renewal or P2P application the investigator can view the incident as bad judgement on your part and deny your application.  Then a judge that always sides with the State can complicate your appeal.  Your right to due process are abridged in these proceedings as the rules for introducing hearsay as evidence are relaxed and the court will make its decision by considering such nonsense.

 

These things can and do happen.  Talk to any NJ firearms attorney and you will hear some real horror stories.

 

In my opinion these are the worst kinds of situations because the defendant's peers behave the same way and have never gotten in trouble for it.  So they assume the defendant must have done something really bad.  "There must be more to this story", etc..

 

I don't cower either.  But I shudder at "selective prosecution" and its derivatives.  And those who support it by accusing those concerned of being "tin foil" types.  Shame on you!

I'd like to add to your excellent response that we would not have attorneys retained by NJARPC, and other independent gun rights lawyers in NJ, if the only people accused of firearms violations were career criminals belonging to gangs and who participate in drug dealing. There are 100s of ways of getting into serious, serious trouble, 1000s of cops out there who would love to snag one of you, and 10s of 1000s of juries -- including those comprised predominantly of Republicans -- who are salivating to send you to prison for acts that have no legal consequence in most other states. It's a sad, sick, perverted, spiteful system but every component works with every other to maximize cruelty (and revenue).

I agree with caution.

 

I will add this word too - discretion. 

 

Both of them, used together will keep you out of trouble. 

I'd like to add to your excellent response that we would not have attorneys retained by NJARPC, and other independent gun rights lawyers in NJ, if the only people accused of firearms violations were career criminals belonging to gangs and who participate in drug dealing. There are 100s of ways of getting into serious, serious trouble, 1000s of cops out there who would love to snag one of you, and 10s of 1000s of juries -- including those comprised predominantly of Republicans -- who are salivating to send you to prison for acts that have no legal consequence in most other states. It's a sad, sick, perverted, spiteful system but every component works with every other to maximize cruelty (and revenue).

 

^^^Time to adjust that Tin Foil Hat a little?  Meh......  Please keep in mind that Lawyers run for-profit Corporations.  Even those who write books, give lectures and deal with getting people off on technicalities.  They have a vested interest in maintaining the status-quo and the resultant fear mongering seen in this thread.  If all of NJ's convoluted firearms law went-away, business would dry-up.......

 

Seriously folks, you really can be active in the shooting sports for almost half a century and not get jammed-up.  Driving a few friends to the range is something I wouldn't think twice about.  But ya gotta do it SMART--no throwin' beer bottles outta the car windows, smokin' joints at red lights, aggressive driving, peelin'-out via power-brakin' and other such poor technique that draws obvious attention to how much of a Douche Canoe you might be......so just keep yer nose clean and mind yer manners and you'll be just fine.  

 

Plenty of Cops out there are the Griz's of the world.  Some are Heroes.  Some I call friends.

Be discrete and be smart.  If you know you are going to the range and you are out doing errands, pick up a sub sandwich before you put your handguns or hollow point ammo in the car.  Make sure you don't go unnecessarily onto school property, etc.  If you could take a short-cut through the local high school parking lot to get to the range, I would probably avoid doing so.  Shaving, not putting on a goth outfit, etc. would also be prudent.  A clean-cut appearance helps. 

 

The problem is that anything is a felony, and you are guilty until proven innocent.  I would err on the side of caution as much as possible in this state.   And, always in the back of your mind, think about what you can live with. 

 

I try to follow the rules to the letter whenever doing anything with my guns in this state.  Remember, they are illegally illegal, and you have the burden of proof.  I would rather not have to say to the judge, I just oculdn't hold it and had to stop somewhere. 

 

BTW FOPA was not needed because our method of transportation was legal in both NJ and PA (unloaded & cased to/from range).

 

Just an FYI - PA laws for having a handgun in a car are not the same as NJ laws and "reasonable deviations" is not mentioned in the Commonwealth UFA.

 

Most of you have carry licenses from some state at this point so it wouldn't actually be an issue to have a handgun in a car under those circumstances in PA.

 

Seriously folks, you really can be active in the shooting sports for almost half a century and not get jammed-up.  Driving a few friends to the range is something I wouldn't think twice about.  But ya gotta do it SMART--no throwin' beer bottles outta the car windows, smokin' joints at red lights, aggressive driving, peelin'-out via power-brakin' and other such poor technique that draws obvious attention to how much of a Douche Canoe you might be......so just keep yer nose clean and mind yer manners and you'll be just fine.  

Auto collisions are not voluntary, no light goes off on your dash when one of your brake lights dies, and cops are not saints.

 

I've had more interactions with traffic cops through no fault of my own than through traffic violations. It's not something that happens every day, month, or year, but I know I don't have the only vote.

^^^Time to adjust that Tin Foil Hat a little?  Meh......  Please keep in mind that Lawyers run for-profit Corporations.  Even those who write books, give lectures and deal with getting people off on technicalities.  They have a vested interest in maintaining the status-quo and the resultant fear mongering seen in this thread.  If all of NJ's convoluted firearms law went-away, business would dry-up.......

 

Seriously folks, you really can be active in the shooting sports for almost half a century and not get jammed-up.  Driving a few friends to the range is something I wouldn't think twice about.  But ya gotta do it SMART--no throwin' beer bottles outta the car windows, smokin' joints at red lights, aggressive driving, peelin'-out via power-brakin' and other such poor technique that draws obvious attention to how much of a Douche Canoe you might be......so just keep yer nose clean and mind yer manners and you'll be just fine.  

 

Plenty of Cops out there are the Griz's of the world.  Some are Heroes.  Some I call friends.

I'm not quite as cynical as you are about the pro-2A lawyers in this state. I've met a few, including Scott Bach. They are all smart enough to make very decent livings providing routine legal services. Many attorneys take on causes. We should be thankful that some have taken up ours.

 

I've been saying for months that if you drive like a human being and don't act like an asshole if you're stopped that you'll be safe 99.99% of the time. 

 

Go back to my post about risk = probability x consequences. You're free to feel as safe as you like doing anything that you like. It's only a crime if you're caught :)

^^^Agreed.  I'm as much of a Realist as a Cynic.  Scott and others do us a fine service and earn a FANTASTIC living doing it.  It's a shame that they HAVE TO.  

 

Have the rest of a wonderful week.  It's time for me to put my 12 ga. in the car and go do my errands, shoot a round at the club, go to the Diner with the Guys, and go shopping for dinner.

  no light goes off on your dash when one of your brake lights dies

 

Actually in my vehicle a light goes off on my dash, when I have a bulb out.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.