Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Any authority that says it is legal to have unloaded long gun as long as you have the FID card?

Featured Replies

We all know, or should know, that transport of a handgun in New jersey must be by the most direct route, and adult diapers are advised.

However, my reading of the New Jersey Statutes indicates that as long as you have the FID card, it is legal to possess an unloaded long gun outside your home.

 

Is there any New Jersey Court case which in fact held that it was not a crime for an FID holder to possess an unloaded long gun outside the home? 

If something is legal, why would you need a court case to prove it?  

 

It is my understanding that you are correct, that one can possess an unloaded long gun at any time.  The catch is that in loading it, one commits a felony.

So according to our absurd NJ laws, it can't be used in self defense (unless you hit someone over the head with it, and I'm not even really sure about that).

  • Author

 

 

If something is legal, why would you need a court case to prove it?  

 

In practical terms, it's not legal unless a judge says it's legal.

 

For example, the statutes might say that it is legal to have a handgun at your place of business, but at least one New Jersey Appellate Court has held that it must be a business owned by you and not merely the place that you work.  Get nabbed with a handgun at work and it's bad day at the office.

 

Thus my question:  Has any New Jersey Court held that possession of an unloaded long gun outside the home by the holder of an FID card is not a crime?

Is breathing AIR legal?  I surely hope so since I do it with impunity!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

This subject has been written about ad nauseum............and here's some mind-blowing gasoline for the fire:  One needn't even have a NJFID, or be a state resident to posses a shotgun.  An out of state resident can visit NJ and shoot a competition w/o a NJFID!

 

AND THE WHEELS ON THE BUS GO ROUND AND ROUND, lol!

We all know, or should know, that transport of a handgun in New jersey must be by the most direct route, and adult diapers are advised.

However, my reading of the New Jersey Statutes indicates that as long as you have the FID card, it is legal to possess an unloaded long gun outside your home.

 

Is there any New Jersey Court case which in fact held that it was not a crime for an FID holder to possess an unloaded long gun outside the home?

Here's what Nappen has to say about it.

 

The card is also a permit to carry... anywhere where it is lawful to carry

Is breathing AIR legal?  I surely hope so since I do it with impunity!!!!!!!!!!!!

, lol!

only after you buy into obamacare.

so what do people that move into the state do? if they don't buy anything here? are they committing felonies going to/from shooting?

so what do people that move into the state do? if they don't buy anything here? are they committing felonies going to/from shooting?

No. You then just may transport the exempted way.

 

Let's review this again. Do you want to possess a handgun? Have a license? Yes? Then possess anywhere. Don't have a license? Then possess in exempted areas and transport in exempted way.

 

Want to possess a long long gun? Have an FID? Then you can possess anywhere. Don't have an FID then possess only in exempted areas and transport in exempted way.

Somebody made a possession flow chart awhile back. Can somebody find it?

I remember the "is my rifle legal" flow chart.

I would love to see a flow chart. I am still not sure where in the NJ 2C does it say FPID exempts one from having to "securely tie" while transporting. Yes, I read the FAQ and I cannot find it clarify it either.

 

Without such language, NJ would be open carry for long guns (unloaded of course). Isn't it ?

 

 

Barms knows what I am talking about :-)

I would love to see a flow chart. I am still not sure where in the NJ 2C does it say FPID exempts one from having to "securely tie" while transporting. Yes, I read the FAQ and I cannot find it clarify it either.

 

Without such language, NJ would be open carry for long guns (unloaded of course). Isn't it ?

 

 

Barms knows what I am talking about :-)

As long as you were in a place you could legally posess said unloaded rifle. The stairs of the state house may not be one of those places. Nappen says theoretically you could drive down the road with the gun hanging out the window, with a FPID uncased unloaded. But he doesn't suggest anyone actually try it.

I remember the "is my rifle legal" flow chart.

 

I made the legal rifle and legal shotgun flow charts, but not a where can I have a gun chart.  That shouldn't be very hard.

I made the legal rifle and legal shotgun flow charts, but not a where can I have a gun chart. That shouldn't be very hard.

I never saw the shotgun one. Could you post it here please? Or a link to the thread. The search feature on this forum blows.

 

Nevermind I found it thanks!

5a77e9ff98706797689bb22ec2eeaa69.jpg

so what do people that move into the state do? if they don't buy anything here? are they committing felonies going to/from shooting?

^^^^THIS is exactly why some form of common sense has to be applied to the equation, along with a dose of reality.  Does anybody else here think we're being "trolled" again?  Less than 16 posts and we're answering heavy, pointed questions and going nuts spinning our wheels ON THE BUS, lol!

I would love to see a flow chart. I am still not sure where in the NJ 2C does it say FPID exempts one from having to "securely tie" while transporting. Yes, I read the FAQ and I cannot find it clarify it either.

 

Without such language, NJ would be open carry for long guns (unloaded of course). Isn't it ?

 

 

Barms knows what I am talking about :-)

The problem isn't you not finding the language the problem is you are not "understanding" the language. You think Transportation is it's own state off existence. POSSESSION is the existence. You're hung up on this thing about Transportation overrides Possession. That's why you can't find it

 

Once you establish Possession is legal (with FID) then Transportation doesn't apply to you.

 

Look if you had a handgun license you wouldn't be asking where is the transportation exemption for licensed holders. The FID makes you a licensed long arm holder.

 

Please stop looking for the transportation exemption language.

We all know, or should know, that transport of a handgun in New jersey must be by the most direct route, and adult diapers are advised.

No, we all know that having a handgun is illegal in NJ outside of a very small number of places and circumstances. It is not the transportation of a handgun that brings any special legal peril.

No, we all know that having a handgun is illegal in NJ outside of a very small number of places and circumstances. It is not the transportation of a handgun that brings any special legal peril.

THIS.

 

Now we know the basis of the doubters confusion. They think TRANSPORTATION is a state of POSSESSION. It's not. Focus on "am i allowed to own this?" Then you transportation exemptions flow from that.

The problem isn't you not finding the language the problem is you are not "understanding" the language. You think Transportation is it's own state off existence. POSSESSION is the existence. You're hung up on this thing about Transportation overrides Possession. That's why you can't find it

 

Once you establish Possession is legal (with FID) then Transportation doesn't apply to you.

 

Look if you had a handgun license you wouldn't be asking where is the transportation exemption for licensed holders. The FID makes you a licensed long arm holder.

 

Please stop looking for the transportation exemption language.

Handgun license doesnt give you all "manner of possession and transportation". It limits such activity to "concealed only".  So "possession" is not a all-inclusive-do-whatever-card.

For long guns, not all "possession" is same either. For example, you can possess a long gun at home and also outside home with FPID. But at home you can have loaded gun in possession but outside home (and other exempted places), you CANNOT have loaded long gun in possession.

 

I am debating that even possession comes with various restrictions (and manner in which to possess) depending on place, FPID or not etc.

 

Note: I will send question to Nappan and see if I get any reply. I am looking for NJ Code and logical explanation based on that code.

and the very sad part is that we shouldn't even NEED to be having this conversation, as all of these laws are technically speaking.....illegal.

I would carry a long gun in my car at all times, but I go to high schools all over the state on assignment.

 

When not working, I get to pick up my 2nd grader at his school.

 

Gun Free Zones = No long gun in car for me 

Handgun license doesnt give you all "manner of possession and transportation". It limits such activity to "concealed only".

No it doesn't.

No it doesn't.

Can one opencarry handguns with NJ CCW ? If so, nice and I will take my words back.  I owe a Beer when we meet next time for that :-).

But can you apply same logic to long guns with FPID  and say it can be carried in open without being wrapped / tied in something at the least ?

 

But can you apply same logic to long guns with FPID  and say it can be carried in open without being wrapped / tied in something at the least ?

 

Watch the Nappen video linked above.  He says it's legal to do so, but probably not advisable.

Watch the Nappen video linked above.  He says it's legal to do so, but probably not advisable.

Yep, I posted that link myself few times with same understanding. But trying to figure out where that conclusion came from..

Can one opencarry handguns with NJ CCW ? If so, nice and I will take my words back. I owe a Beer when we meet next time for that :-).

But can you apply same logic to long guns with FPID and say it can be carried in open without being wrapped / tied in something at the least ?

There is no distinction in NJ about carry. If it is legal concealed it is legal open. So a carry permit for a handgun is valid concealed or not.

There is no distinction in NJ about carry. If it is legal concealed it is legal open. So a carry permit for a handgun is valid concealed or not.

not only will that change stupidly quick......i'd almost bet the farm that they've got plans in place in case any of the national reciprocity bills make it......

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.