Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Arcane NJ law prevents retired cops from carrying concealed weapon

Featured Replies

Im not interested in throwing statistics around till I puke. Im sure if I looked hard enough I can find why statistically im more likely to die from rabbit hamsters. Reports from legitimate sources back up logical conclusions. You may just be hard wired to come from a place of emotion and anxiety, I am not. Interviews with the bad people of this world about what they fear most is armed people. All your talk about competency, your hand wringing fearful position, none of it means anything to me. It is my right to protect myself and my family no matter how you feel. The totality of context makes it VERY clear this was our forefathers intentions. NJ has an issue, a legal one, because they don't see it that way. Unfortunately there are too many like you here that unlawfully cause an infringement on my rights. So in the end I will vote with my wallet and move my family and my employees out of here to a state that sees more clearly. Oddly enough it will be a statistically safer state too!

 

 

Your "right to protect yourself and your family" ends when it puts me and my family's safety in jeopardy - and an untrained, irrationally scared individual putting WAY too much faith in a loaded gun as his great protector -- and who lacks proper training in safety, proficiency, use-of-force, and retention -- does just that, jeopardizes me and my family and the public-at-large.

 

It's ironic that you talk about not acting based on "emotion and anxiety" -- then, you state that you're going to move your family out of NJ because you can't carry a gun here.  Yet, the odds of you actually ever being in a situation where you would need to defend yourself with a firearm are SO remote, that you statically have a far greater chance of being hit by lightning!!!  

 

So, if you decision to move, was in fact NOT based on "emotion and anxiety," wouldn't you be moving your family to a location based on where the lowest number of lightning strikes occur annually?  Or some other threat that is far more likely to effect your family than a defensive gun incident?? 

 

Clearly, your decision is based ONLY on "emotion and anxiety" and NOTHING else.  And I don't think you're stupid -- but that is a completely stupid reason to move.

 

:read:

 

  • Replies 261
  • Views 15.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Your argument is flawed. People wanting the ability to legally carry a gun for personal protection are not asking to be able to "use deadly force to ensure public safety; and indemnified by the state during the commission of his responsibilities". They simply want to be able to carry for personal protection.  Should a person that "s willing to receive and pass the same initial training AND the same continuing in-service training that is required by police officers AND indemnify himself with a substantial insurance policy, all at no expense to the state" also have the power to arrest?  I think not, nobody is asking for that.  They are only asking to be able to protect themselves and their families.

 

No, it's not.

 

Read for content -- I clearly stated, "initially and continually trained by the state in the use of firearms in the course of his duties."  Never once did I state that John Q. Citizen should be granted arrest authority that is indemnified by the state by completing the firearms section of police training.  That makes no sense anyway, I think you're making shit up or attempting to divert the topic off on a ridiculous tangent because my point makes perfect sense.  Stay on topic and counter my contention that if John Q. Public wants to carry a gun then he should have the same training as a police officer and an insurance policy - and pay for it himself.

 

:good:

Do me a favor, take all your PBA cards and tear them up. Better yet, never distribute another one.... To what purpose do they serve?   Don't worry, I wont hold my breath.

 

It is funny, the second we talk about having a level field its like were Anti-cop....pretty pissy attitude, were not talking about extravagant investigative and arresting powers...lol

 

I don't even know what that means?

 

Point is -- it's not a level playing field and was never intended to be.

 

A sworn/appointed police officer in NJ is initially and continually trained by the state in the use of firearms in the course of his duties; legislated by the state as justified to use deadly force to ensure public safety; and indemnified by the state during the commission of his responsibilities.

 

John Q. is not.

 

If John Q. has the desire to perform dental surgery, should he be allowed to do that too without the proper training?

 

:think:

A retired cop = John Q citizen and is no more a " special " class so the playing field is level

 

The other 46 free states do not require " police training " or " insurance " and have no problems keeping your family or others safe ....... Could every single member be wrong that goes against everything you say & blocks you ? Or can it somehow be you AK ?

As someone who trains(including stress and aggression training) on a regular, and ongoing basis, I sort of agree with this opinion. Although I don't think that an ordinary citizen should have the same level of training as a police officer, as an ordinary citizen will likely not run into the same frequency of violent encounters as an officer might. Given that, IMO a lower level of training is fine. Personally I'm ok with encouraging training, I learned a lot more than how to shoot and proper, safe firearm handling...ETC.

 


that if John Q. Public wants to carry a gun then he should have the same training as a police officer and an insurance policy - and pay for it himself.

 

:good:

Your "right to protect yourself and your family" ends when it puts me and my family's safety in jeopardy - and an untrained, irrationally scared individual putting WAY too much faith in a loaded gun as his great protector -- and who lacks proper training in safety, proficiency, use-of-force, and retention -- does just that, jeopardizes me and my family and the public-at-large.

 

It's ironic that you talk about not acting based on "emotion and anxiety" -- then, you state that you're going to move your family out of NJ because you can't carry a gun here.  Yet, the odds of you actually ever being in a situation where you would need to defend yourself with a firearm are SO remote, that you statically have a far greater chance of being hit by lightning!!!  

 

So, if you decision to move, was in fact NOT based on "emotion and anxiety," wouldn't you be moving your family to a location based on where the lowest number of lightning strikes occur annually?  Or some other threat that is far more likely to effect your family than a defensive gun incident?? 

 

Clearly, your decision is based ONLY on "emotion and anxiety" and NOTHING else.  And I don't think you're stupid -- but that is a completely stupid reason to move.

 

:read:

 

I disagree here, a person's right to defend themselves, and their family never ends, not even in the face of your fear of their means of doing so. This is the very issue I have with some police officers, as many believe that concern for their own safety trumps that of my safety. Not all believe this, but this very notion has been expressed to me on several occasions during training. They did not feel I had the right to take the training at the same level they did. IMO that makes them the very worst kind of officer. 

I don't even know what that means?

 

Point is -- it's not a level playing field and was never intended to be.

 

A sworn/appointed police officer in NJ is initially and continually trained by the state in the use of firearms in the course of his duties; legislated by the state as justified to use deadly force to ensure public safety; and indemnified by the state during the commission of his responsibilities.

 

John Q. is not.

 

If John Q. has the desire to perform dental surgery, should he be allowed to do that too without the proper training?

 

:think:

Sure, on him/herself.   You dont need some degree or my permission to pull your own teeth. Feel free. 

 

There is personal space (individuals, his/her car, possessions etc), semi-public space (business open to public) and public space.   Then there is some "gray" space.  Free speech is big deal because words leave personal space and reach other person's space. However requiring training or putting other restrictions on free speech would generally be considered ridiculous. For extreme scenarios where such free speech actually causes severe public harm,we got legal means to deal with that case by case. 

 

Its seems you are of opinion that every time John Q leaves house, he/she is encroaching in something that doesn't belong to him.  Strong support of such thought eventually leads to "papers please" every time John Q steps outside. 

 

In fact, its the other way around. Agent of an appointed Gov is encroaching (albeit with permission from an elected Govt) on the public space, hence the additional training, requirements, insurance and indemnification. 

 

A blanket assumption that something carried on person will always leave that space and cause harm everyone around is plain irrational. We can debate until cows come home, but any tool intended to be carried on person for the purpose of self protection is fair game and no additional requirements  be imposed. IF and WHEN that tool leaves the person in public space, we have legal system to evaluate the situation and do justice. 

Your "right to protect yourself and your family" ends when it puts me and my family's safety in jeopardy - and an untrained, irrationally scared individual putting WAY too much faith in a loaded gun as his great protector -- and who lacks proper training in safety, proficiency, use-of-force, and retention -- does just that, jeopardizes me and my family and the public-at-large.

 

It's ironic that you talk about not acting based on "emotion and anxiety" -- then, you state that you're going to move your family out of NJ because you can't carry a gun here.  Yet, the odds of you actually ever being in a situation where you would need to defend yourself with a firearm are SO remote, that you statically have a far greater chance of being hit by lightning!!!  

 

So, if you decision to move, was in fact NOT based on "emotion and anxiety," wouldn't you be moving your family to a location based on where the lowest number of lightning strikes occur annually?  Or some other threat that is far more likely to effect your family than a defensive gun incident?? 

 

Clearly, your decision is based ONLY on "emotion and anxiety" and NOTHING else.  And I don't think you're stupid -- but that is a completely stupid reason to move.

 

:read:

But it doesn't seem to work out the way you in vision. I travel a lot to the Midwest to places where when I walk in the door of an office and ask who's carrying, almost every shirt goes up to reveal a handgun. Oddly these places aren't the death traps you describe. So your handwringing theory about how the sky will fall if people carry just doesn't play out. As for your quip about my emotion and anxiety, luck favors the prepared. My life experience paints a very different picture for me that doesn't line up with the statistics you like to tout. I wont go into detail but there are about 5 times in my life where a gun was desperately needed. One was when a literal axe murderer tried to get my wife in his car where he had a hatchet under the seat! As for my motivations to move, yes, my rights being infringed are beyond my toleration in all aspects of firearm ownership here in NJ. Its funny to me that you paint a ccw holder with such an unflattering brush. It has not aligned with the personalities of those I know that CCW. Im not sure how you tolerate all those people out there that.... drive a car! I have personally improved the shooting skills of way to many LE to believe there is a great divide in the skillset of the average officer and the average recreational shooter. Response under stress, not something really teachable IMO. You can indoctrinate a bit, but those that will fold, will, those that are strong, wont, regardless of who they are.

I disagree here, a person's right to defend themselves, and their family never ends, not even in the face of your fear of their means of doing so. This is the very issue I have with some police officers, as many believe that concern for their own safety trumps that of my safety. Not all believe this, but this very notion has been expressed to me on several occasions during training. They did not feel I had the right to take the training at the same level they did. IMO that makes them the very worst kind of officer. 

 

No one is suggesting taking away your "right to defend yourself."  Just endangering others by using a gun in public without adequate training to perform that act.

 

Without taking a stance on an officer expressing "concern for their own safety trumps that of my safety" I will add this: a protector cannot provide protection if he is unavailable to do so. 

 

Kinda like the logic on airplane safety that says, "put on YOUR oxygen mask first, then assist others."

 

:yes:

 

But it doesn't seem to work out the way you in vision. I travel a lot to the Midwest to places where when I walk in the door of an office and ask who's carrying, almost every shirt goes up to reveal a handgun. Oddly these places aren't the death traps you describe. So your handwringing theory about how the sky will fall if people carry just doesn't play out. As for your quip about my emotion and anxiety, luck favors the prepared. My life experience paints a very different picture for me that doesn't line up with the statistics you like to tout. I wont go into detail but there are about 5 times in my life where a gun was desperately needed. One was when a literal axe murderer tried to get my wife in his car where he had a hatchet under the seat! As for my motivations to move, yes, my rights being infringed are beyond my toleration in all aspects of firearm ownership here in NJ. Its funny to me that you paint a ccw holder with such an unflattering brush. It has not aligned with the personalities of those I know that CCW. Im not sure how you tolerate all those people out there that.... drive a car! I have personally improved the shooting skills of way to many LE to believe there is a great divide in the skillset of the average officer and the average recreational shooter. Response under stress, not something really teachable IMO. You can indoctrinate a bit, but those that will fold, will, those that are strong, wont, regardless of who they are.

 

First, response under stress can absolutely be perfected with training -- a misnomer on your part -- and likely the part of many others.

 

As far as your perception of the midwest, where "almost everyone is carrying" as not being "death traps" I would offer this logic -- most drunk drivers make it to their destination without killing someone -- is that justification for a civilized society to condone drunk driving?

 

And firearms training is not just "shooting skills" and accuracy, as many "civilians" imagine.  There is SO much more involved with carrying a firearm.

 

So, how did you survive those 5 incidents without a gun?

 

:think:

Yawn

Sure, on him/herself.   You dont need some degree or my permission to pull your own teeth. Feel free. 

 

There is personal space (individuals, his/her car, possessions etc), semi-public space (business open to public) and public space.   Then there is some "gray" space.  Free speech is big deal because words leave personal space and reach other person's space. However requiring training or putting other restrictions on free speech would generally be considered ridiculous. For extreme scenarios where such free speech actually causes severe public harm,we got legal means to deal with that case by case. 

 

Its seems you are of opinion that every time John Q leaves house, he/she is encroaching in something that doesn't belong to him.  Strong support of such thought eventually leads to "papers please" every time John Q steps outside. 

 

In fact, its the other way around. Agent of an appointed Gov is encroaching (albeit with permission from an elected Govt) on the public space, hence the additional training, requirements, insurance and indemnification. 

 

A blanket assumption that something carried on person will always leave that space and cause harm everyone around is plain irrational. We can debate until cows come home, but any tool intended to be carried on person for the purpose of self protection is fair game and no additional requirements  be imposed. IF and WHEN that tool leaves the person in public space, we have legal system to evaluate the situation and do justice. 

 

Disagree.  Again, I would cite the drunk driving analogy.

 

When John Q. leaves his house he is "encroaching in something that" belongs to everyone.  And John has no right to infringe on the safety of others in that realm.  I don't think that creates a "papers please" scenario at all.  It's more of a "take responsibility for your own actions" situation.

 

As far as your contention in the paragraph "it's the other way around" -- interesting.  Kinda like the chicken and the egg dilemma.  Who belongs on the street first, the citizen or the representative of the civility that is mandated by the peoples law.  I don't have an answer but I like the question.

 

:yes:

Disagree.  Again, I would cite the drunk driving analogy.

 

When John Q. leaves his house he is "encroaching in something that" belongs to everyone.  And John has no right to infringe on the safety of others in that realm.  I don't think that creates a "papers please" scenario at all.  It's more of a "take responsibility for your own actions" situation.

 

As far as your contention in the paragraph "it's the other way around" -- interesting.  Kinda like the chicken and the egg dilemma.  Who belongs on the street first, the citizen or the representative of the civility that is mandated by the peoples law.  I don't have an answer but I like the question.

 

:yes:

Simple. Govt Agent, in the official capacity, cannot step onto the street without permission (conferred by the job appointment). John Q Citizen can, rightfully so. 

 

On Drunk Driving, wrong again. Drunk Driving and Legal Carry are not same. Trying to equate them shows million ways we differ in understanding lot of things.

 

State of intoxication it typically caused by deliberate action altering an otherwise normal mental state. Laws against drunk driving are NOT asking people to get better training, rather imposing restrictions on purposeful manipulation of otherwise normal mental state, which are reasonable. 

 

Sure, impose laws on person carrying firearm IF they were to do so with purposeful manipulation of otherwise normal mental state - be it be with drugs, alcohol etc. 

Your "right to protect yourself and your family" ends when it puts me and my family's safety in jeopardy - and an untrained, irrationally scared individual putting WAY too much faith in a loaded gun as his great protector -- and who lacks proper training in safety, proficiency, use-of-force, and retention -- does just that, jeopardizes me and my family and the public-at-large.

 

It's ironic that you talk about not acting based on "emotion and anxiety" -- then, you state that you're going to move your family out of NJ because you can't carry a gun here.  Yet, the odds of you actually ever being in a situation where you would need to defend yourself with a firearm are SO remote, that you statically have a far greater chance of being hit by lightning!!!  

 

So, if you decision to move, was in fact NOT based on "emotion and anxiety," wouldn't you be moving your family to a location based on where the lowest number of lightning strikes occur annually?  Or some other threat that is far more likely to effect your family than a defensive gun incident?? 

 

Clearly, your decision is based ONLY on "emotion and anxiety" and NOTHING else.  And I don't think you're stupid -- but that is a completely stupid reason to move.

 

:read:

 

 

This has got to be Steve Sweeney trolling the forum.

Simple. Govt Agent, in the official capacity, cannot step onto the street without permission (conferred by the job appointment). John Q Citizen can, rightfully so. 

 

I'm interested but I'm not following this logic...what do you mean?

 

:think:

I'm interested but I'm not following this logic...what do you mean?

 

:think:

Great question. The day you understand it is the the day we all can have real, reasonable, meaningful dialog. 

On Drunk Driving, wrong again. Drunk Driving and Legal Carry are not same. Trying to equate them shows million ways we differ in understanding lot of things.

 

 

 

Drunk driving and carrying a gun without proper training BOTH have the potential to hurt innocent people -- the inference was made that, just because the potential for harm exists it doesn't mean it is going to happen, so let's disregard the possibility....

 

The two are identical in that respect.

 

:yes:

Great question. The day you understand it is the the day we all can have real, reasonable, meaningful dialog. 

 

Thanks for explaining.

 

"Govt Agent, in the official capacity, cannot step onto the street without permission"  ???

 

WTF does that even mean?  Something to you -- but you can't or refuse to explain it?

 

I thought we were having a civil discussion here...I guess not.

 

:scratchhead:

No one is suggesting taking away your "right to defend yourself."  Just endangering others by using a gun in public without adequate training to perform that act.

 

Without taking a stance on an officer expressing "concern for their own safety trumps that of my safety" I will add this: a protector cannot provide protection if he is unavailable to do so. 

 

Kinda like the logic on airplane safety that says, "put on YOUR oxygen mask first, then assist others."

 

:yes:

 

 

First, response under stress can absolutely be perfected with training -- a misnomer on your part -- and likely the part of many others.

 

As far as your perception of the midwest, where "almost everyone is carrying" as not being "death traps" I would offer this logic -- most drunk drivers make it to their destination without killing someone -- is that justification for a civilized society to condone drunk driving?

 

And firearms training is not just "shooting skills" and accuracy, as many "civilians" imagine.  There is SO much more involved with carrying a firearm.

 

So, how did you survive those 5 incidents without a gun?

 

:think:

Your like a little kid, so sure their answer is correct, they don't even consider they may be wrong. If training can perfect behavior, how do you explain all the cases of highly trained individuals that either fled or froze at the moment of truth. Particularly observed in the sniper community when they froze and failed to take the shot when called upon.

 

You assume I was unarmed.

 

You seem to want to look down your nose at what you think civilians think and thus you imply a non civilian view. So here I am, calling you out. What verifiable credentials do you bring to the table that your opinion should be given any more weight than the youthful belligerence it appears to be. I have known many people that talk like you do, until they got a few years of experience in the real world under their belt.

This has got to be Steve Sweeney trolling the forum.

Either him or a relative

Drunk driving and carrying a gun without proper training BOTH have the potential to hurt innocent people -- the inference was made that, just because the potential for harm exists it doesn't mean it is going to happen, so let's disregard the possibility....

 

The two are identical in that respect.

 

:yes:

I appreciate you coming into this with open mind, but,  wrong again. 

 

EVERY second in life is filled with "potential harm".  If we were to make laws and restrict people by mere existence of "potential harm", then everyone needs to stay home, tied to bed in straight jackets, including you. 

 

You want possibilities in daily life ? All real examples, but none impose "additional training" on John Q, because requiring so is patently ridiculous and serves no real benefit

 

* People spitting, biting, scratching with intent to transmit deadly deceases 

* People knocking helpless, old people down onto sidewalks

* People getting trained in martial arts or other techniques, supposedly for self defense, that can take a grown man down

 

Then the question is, extent of potential harm, intent leading upto it and factors that drive such potential.  Drunk Driving (or drugs), being severe alteration of an otherwise normal mental state is in COMPLETELY DIFFERENT league all together compared to, say, John Q minding his own business with a concealed defensive tool for example. 

 

So, NO, they are not identical. Not even anywhere near being identical. 

Your like a little kid, so sure their answer is correct, they don't even consider they may be wrong. If training can perfect behavior, how do you explain all the cases of highly trained individuals that either fled or froze at the moment of truth. Particularly observed in the sniper community when they froze and failed to take the shot when called upon.

 

You assume I was unarmed.

 

You seem to want to look down your nose at what you think civilians think and thus you imply a non civilian view. So here I am, calling you out. What verifiable credentials do you bring to the table that your opinion should be given any more weight than the youthful belligerence it appears to be. I have known many people that talk like you do, until they got a few years of experience in the real world under their belt.

 

Are you claiming to have been in 5 gun fights?  Wow, you're a very special person!!

 

You don't need to call me out -- I'm right here.  Do you really expect me (or anyone) to provide personal information to others on an internet chat site? 

 

Look, regard me as verified credentialed or regard me as a belligerent youth - WGAS?  What difference does it make?

 

Attack my positions with valid counter arguments... if your able to -- if you're not, then concede.  Simple.

 

:good:

I appreciate you coming into this with open mind, but,  wrong again. 

 

EVERY second in life is filled with "potential harm".  If we were to make laws and restrict people by mere existence of "potential harm", then everyone needs to stay home, tied to bed in straight jackets, including you. 

 

Then the question is, extent of potential harm and factors that drive such potential.  Drunk Driving (or drugs), being severe alteration of an otherwise normal mental state is in COMPLETELY DIFFERENT league all together compared to, say, John Q minding his own business with a concealed defensive tool for example. 

 

So, NO, they are not identical. Not even anywhere near being identical. 

 

You're going off on an unnecessary tangent -- I'll reposition here;

 

You make the choice -- instead of drunk driving, insert ANY human activity that has the potential to hurt innocent people that society prohibits or restricts by law.

 

YOU choose -- and use that activity in our discussion.

 

Make sense?

Snap out of it, pothead. This is important stuff!!

 

:sarcastichand:

Are you sure?

You're going off on an unnecessary tangent -- I'll reposition here;

 

You make the choice -- instead of drunk driving, insert ANY human activity that has the potential to hurt innocent people that society prohibits or restricts by law.

 

YOU choose -- and use that activity in our discussion.

 

Make sense?

Yawn

Again, competency is already a qualifier in this state.

You're going off on an unnecessary tangent -- I'll reposition here;

 

You make the choice -- instead of drunk driving, insert ANY human activity that has the potential to hurt innocent people that society prohibits or restricts by law.

 

YOU choose -- and use that activity in our discussion.

 

Make sense?

I will repost what you said ...you picked the drunk driving as an example. 

 

Quote - "As far as your perception of the midwest, where "almost everyone is carrying" as not being "death traps" I would offer this logic -- most drunk drivers make it to their destination without killing someone -- is that justification for a civilized society to condone drunk driving?

"
 
So you took an example and tried to equate that to firearms carry for self defense. 
 
I am not going on tangent, I just provided severe, glaring, distinguishing factors that challenges YOUR assertion.  
Donkey and Stallion belong in the same pen,  both got 4 legs, appear similar, may even have a relative a million years ago, hence identical - thats essentially your assertion. 
 
Pick another example and I got all day for a reasonable discussion and show you WHY such comparison serves no legitimate purpose. 

Your like a little kid, so sure their answer is correct, they don't even consider they may be wrong. If training can perfect behavior, how do you explain all the cases of highly trained individuals that either fled or froze at the moment of truth. Particularly observed in the sniper community when they froze and failed to take the shot when called upon.

 

You assume I was unarmed.

 

You seem to want to look down your nose at what you think civilians think and thus you imply a non civilian view. So here I am, calling you out. What verifiable credentials do you bring to the table that your opinion should be given any more weight than the youthful belligerence it appears to be. I have known many people that talk like you do, until they got a few years of experience in the real world under their belt.

He was probably a traffic cop [emoji6]
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.