Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

FID to FID pistol sale?

Featured Replies

Never bought a pistol from a private owner. Can this be legally transferred with a valid permit, or does it need to go thru an FFL?

 

Thanks~

You can do a FTF with a valid permit and FID card no FFL needed

Must have a pistol purchase permit. I believe you each keep one copy, and the third copy is mailed to police within 5 days. Or something like that.

 

FID does not cut it.

In fact an FPID is not required at all for a pistol purchase but a PtPP is needed in every case, face to face or through an FFL. The buyer keeps one copy, the seller has another, the 3rd copy goes to the issuing authority and the 4th goes to NJSP. If NJSP are the issuing authority then 2 copies go to them. The seller is responsible for sending the copies to the police.

And the transaction can occur (discretely) just about anywhere (WaWa, McDonalds, NJ Turnpike rest area, etc)

And the transaction can occur (discretely) just about anywhere (WaWa, McDonalds, NJ Turnpike rest area, etc)

How can that be, as that is not an exempt location for the seller to have the gun?  Or are you trying to say that under the governor's recent clarification you can claim that was a reasonable stop on the way from one exempt location to another??

And the transaction can occur (discretely) just about anywhere (WaWa, McDonalds, NJ Turnpike rest area, etc)

Unless of course you get caught then you'll find out it isn't.

Seller is transporting to place of legal sale, buyer is transporting from place of legal sale.

They each have their pink or blue copy of completed PPP.

Seller also has the top two copies for mailing.

Show me where in the statutes that this transaction is not legal.

Seller is transporting to place of legal sale, buyer is transporting from place of legal sale.

They each have their pink or blue copy of completed PPP.

Seller also has the top two copies for mailing.

Show me where in the statutes that this transaction is not legal.

The sale is legal not the location.  Who said transporting to a public parking lot is a place of legal sale?  What happens when buyer removes pistol from locked box to inspect in a public place?  You really believe a public parking lot is legal?  Like I said, it is only until you get caught, like any other law.

... Who said transporting to a public parking lot is a place of legal sale?  

And which statute says it is not??

And which statute says it is not??

 

The list of necessary deviations that are published don't include sales even under the new AG guidelines.  Repeat, stopping in a public place to make a sale is not listed in the statute.  Also, what happens when the you unlock the case and expose the firearm in a public place?  Is that legal?  Even if you are discrete you cannot uncase a firearm in a public place.  And, as I mentioned earlier there is no allowance under necessary deviations that allow for a sale--only the items listed.  I suggest you call the SP FIU and ask them if you hook up in a Walmart parking lot and transact a gun sale with proper forms if it would be a legal place to do so.  I'm gonna bet they say no.  Even if for some reason they accepted it under necessary deviation, which they won't, it would have to remain locked during the entire transaction.  Who doesn't want to see the firearm before purchase if for no other reason other to make sure it's actually in the box?  Or how about verifying the serial number?  I'm not even talking about inspecting it for condition.  

 

If you're so confident it's legal call the police or better yet let them know you're going to conduct a legal, all paperwork, firearms sale at the Dunkin' Donunts.  Let me know how it turns out and then we'll know for sure who's right and who's wrong.  Just make sure the next 7 years on your calendar is free.  

http://www.njsp.org/firearms/transport-firearm.shtml

 

First paragraph:

  • Shall be carried unloaded and contained in a closed and fastened case, gunbox, securely tied package, or locked in the trunk of the automobile in which it is being transported, and in the course of travel, shall include only such deviations as are reasonably necessary under the circumstances.
  • The firearm should not be directly accessible from the passenger compartment of the vehicle. If the vehicle does not have a compartment separate from the passenger compartment, the firearm and ammunition must be in a locked container other than the vehicle's glove compartment or console.

So even just accessing it is illegal.  

How can that be, as that is not an exempt location for the seller to have the gun?  Or are you trying to say that under the governor's recent clarification you can claim that was a reasonable stop on the way from one exempt location to another??

No way dude.  

 

White goes to the NJSP, address is printed on it for the data reduction unit, Yellow goes to issuing authority, Blue with seller for their records, pink with buyer for their's.

Just meet at a range... and Done.

I did a FTF on a handgun with a LEO Detective and he told me to meet him at a Dunkin Donuts parking lot.

I asked him if that was allowed and said "absolutely"!

 

I know most cops don't know gun law but he said he had always done it this way as do his LEO friends. I get it,

he is a cop transporting a handgun in his own town. Who is going to give him a hard time?

 

If the place of purchase or sale of a handgun is a public place, range, LGS, or K-Mart parking lot. I would say at

least for the buyer, that is the point of sale and he must then transport within the exemptions. It was a legal FTF transfer

with all paperwork completed and the buyer goes straight home or to a range or LGS. I can't see as how the buyer would ever

be in violation. The seller on the other hand might be when transporting the handgun to the public place.

 

PS.  PRNJ gun laws suck!

I did a FTF on a handgun with a LEO Detective and he told me to meet him at a Dunkin Donuts parking lot.

I asked him if that was allowed and said "absolutely"!

 

I know most cops don't know gun law but he said he had always done it this way as do his LEO friends. I get it,

he is a cop transporting a handgun in his own town. Who is going to give him a hard time?

 

If the place of purchase or sale of a handgun is a public place, range, LGS, or K-Mart parking lot. I would say at

least for the buyer, that is the point of sale and he must then transport within the exemptions. It was a legal FTF transfer

with all paperwork completed and the buyer goes straight home or to a range or LGS. I can't see as how the buyer would ever

be in violation. The seller on the other hand might be when transporting the handgun to the public place.

 

PS.  PRNJ gun laws suck!

The cop instructed you to break the law. He wasn't worried because if you two were caught nothing would have happened. There is no reasonable deviation that allows for gun sales in public places. A gun range and a gun shop are exempt places thus legal to stop and uncase the firearms.

 

Let me ask you a question did either of you remove the firearm from a locked container? Do you think it's legal to do that at a d&D? If so why not do it everyday? It's not legal just call the state police FIU and ask two questions: is stopping at a D&D to transfer a firearm an acceptable deviation and if I uncase a firearm in the parking lot and inspect it is that a crime? The answers will be no, yes.

 

Until the AG was forced to clarify even stopping at the D&D for any reason was a crime, let alone a gun sale.  With the new rules, if they really exist, you can stop and use the bathroom or get food but nowhere does it say transfer, however legal, a firearm.  There is no place in NJ except exempt locations where you can remove the firearm from the container.  As I said before who buys a firearm without looking it over?

 

Just because we want something to be true doesn't make it so.

:rolleyes:

Nothing in subsections b., c. and d. of N.J.S.2C:39-5 shall be construed to prevent a person keeping or carrying about his place of business, residence, premises or other land owned or possessed by him, any firearm, or from carrying the same, in the manner specified in subsection g. of this section, from any place of purchase to his residence or place of business, between his dwelling and his place of business, between one place of business or residence and another when moving, or between his dwelling

or place of business and place where such firearms are repaired, for the purpose of repair. For the purposes of this section, a place of business shall be deemed to be a fixed location.

As stated previously, the buyer is exempt from acquiring from ANY PLACE of purchase, however, the seller might not be.

 

Again, please refrain from making up laws. Where does it say that a gun shop is the only place you can buy a gun?

 

Sent from an undisclosed location via Tapatalk.

As stated previously, the buyer is exempt from acquiring from ANY PLACE of purchase, however, the seller might not be.

 

Again, please refrain from making up laws. Where does it say that a gun shop is the only place you can buy a gun?

 

Sent from an undisclosed location via Tapatalk.

I don't think anyone is dipsuting that you can do it at home, your place of business, etc, just public parking lots.

Place of purchase.

 

You can buy a gun anywhere and take it home. As the buyer. For the seller to possess it at a Dunkin Donuts, he needs to be a cop or have a carry license. Or perhaps a soldier in performance of his duties, but no idea how that would work, or if it would.

 

 

 

Not to be a nit-picker, but let's NOT interchangeably type hand guns & long guns into this scenario.  

 

mipafox and Rob above^^^^ are 100% correct!

 

Driving a hand gun to a public place like a donut shop isn't a crime PROVIDED you either pee or buy something to eat to enable the "necessary deviation" to actually take place.  The moment light-waves bounce off the hand gun (as it leaves my car trunk or my manufacturer-supplied "never-ready" plastic injection-molded POS case NAKED) it's now an "unsecured hand gun" in the Seller's possession (which is a crime).  So, as mentioned before, IF nobody opens the injection-molded POS plastic case TECHNICALLY the possession is still legal.  But who buys a Pig in a Poke, sight unseen?

 

As for a long gun, so long as the Seller and Buyer both have NJFPID cards that are valid and neither one of them is an "overnight Prohibited Person", selling/buying a long gun virtually ANYWHERE is legal PROVIDED that normal and customary "reasonable care" is given to the scenario.   Would I transfer a long gun at a non-exempt NJ location?  Depends.  But it would be much easier to do so in the parking lot of a commercial range that's not even open (since where in the statutes does it state that the exempt location has to actually be OPEN FOR BIDNESS, lol?), like 3:00 am on a Sunday morning.....

 

If you wanna "play Show and Tell" with scatterguns coming out of their cases and being pointed in a safe direction at the sky, then do it in Free America (such as in the parking lot at Grumpy's BBQ in Coplay, PA right down the street from Lehigh Valley Sporting Clays) where NOBODY EVEN BLINKS, lol (and YES, I was a co-conspirator)!

Place of purchase. You can buy a gun anywhere and take it home. As the buyer. For the seller to possess it at a Dunkin Donuts, he needs to be a cop or have a carry license. Or perhaps a soldier in performance of his duties, but no idea how that would work, or if it would.

I don't want to nitpick but if a cop is buying a handgun how is he exempt on carry?  I believe in most cases if they haven't qualified on the gun they can't carry it.  I am sure that no other cop would give them a hard time but technically I am not so sure it's that simple.

Not to be a nit-picker, but let's NOT interchangeably type hand guns & long guns into this scenario.  

 

mipafox and Rob above^^^^ are 100% correct!

 

Driving a hand gun to a public place like a donut shop isn't a crime PROVIDED you either pee or buy something to eat to enable the "necessary deviation" to actually take place.  The moment light-waves bounce off the hand gun (as it leaves my car trunk or my manufacturer-supplied "never-ready" plastic injection-molded POS case NAKED) it's now an "unsecured hand gun" in the Seller's possession (which is a crime).  So, as mentioned before, IF nobody opens the injection-molded POS plastic case TECHNICALLY the possession is still legal.  But who buys a Pig in a Poke, sight unseen?

 

As for a long gun, so long as the Seller and Buyer both have NJFPID cards that are valid and neither one of them is an "overnight Prohibited Person", selling/buying a long gun virtually ANYWHERE is legal PROVIDED that normal and customary "reasonable care" is given to the scenario.   Would I transfer a long gun at a non-exempt NJ location?  Depends.  But it would be much easier to do so in the parking lot of a commercial range that's not even open (since where in the statutes does it state that the exempt location has to actually be OPEN FOR BIDNESS, lol?), like 3:00 am on a Sunday morning.....

 

If you wanna "play Show and Tell" with scatterguns coming out of their cases and being pointed in a safe direction at the sky, then do it in Free America (such as in the parking lot at Grumpy's BBQ in Coplay, PA right down the street from Lehigh Valley Sporting Clays) where NOBODY EVEN BLINKS, lol (and YES, I was a co-conspirator)!

I agree with almost all of this but can you uncase a rifle in a non-exempt location in NJ, e.g. a Walmart parking lot?

I agree with almost all of this but can you uncase a rifle in a non-exempt location in NJ, e.g. a Walmart parking lot?

Yes, you most certainly can IF you have a NJFPID "get outta Jail Card" and Walmart store manager doesn't call you in for trespassing, lol.  Hell, Nappen is still telling folks that they can put a (closed-chambered) empty scattergun IN THEIR HANDS and WAVE IT OUT THEIR CAR WINDOW as they're driving, although he recommends NOT doing so, lol!  And there's video of the lecture he does.  The same identical interpretation exists TODAY, only difference is there's a LOT more scaredy-assed New Yorkers with 4G phones ready to SWAT honest gun owners!  So if yer gonna do a transfer of a Ruger Mini-14 with a "NON-EVIL" wooden stock, go right ahead you have my permission, lol!  On the other hand, if yer gonna transfer an AR-15 EVIL BLACK RIFLE with the Rocket launcher, serious-as-shit high-powered red dot sniper scope and that 'thing that goes up" (folding Bi-pod), well, you might not wanna do THAT parked in front of a Five Guys in New Jersey, lol!

 

In Hunting Season I can walk thru town with my O/U broken-open, no shells in the gun and carry it in my hands or over my shoulder.  NO transportation, possession or ANY other laws broken.  And I've had Cops give me a "thumbs-up" or shout "good luck" as I'm walking towards the woods!

 

FWIW, by definition (and the letter of the Law), the ONLY areas to be considered "Non-Exempt" as far as long guns possession goes are Military Bases and Installations, Schools, Government Buildings and other plainly-marked "Gun Free Zones".  A Walmart parking lot is considered "public domain" since there is ZERO expectation of privacy.  

Yes, you most certainly can IF you have a NJFPID "get outta Jail Card" and Walmart store manager doesn't call you in for trespassing, lol.  Hell, Nappen is still telling folks that they can put a (closed-chambered) empty scattergun IN THEIR HANDS and WAVE IT OUT THEIR CAR WINDOW as they're driving, although he recommends NOT doing so, lol!  And there's video of the lecture he does.  The same identical interpretation exists TODAY, only difference is there's a LOT more scaredy-assed New Yorkers with 4G phones ready to SWAT honest gun owners!  So if yer gonna do a transfer of a Ruger Mini-14 with a "NON-EVIL" wooden stock, go right ahead you have my permission, lol!  On the other hand, if yer gonna transfer an AR-15 EVIL BLACK RIFLE with the Rocket launcher, serious-as-shit high-powered red dot sniper scope and that 'thing that goes up" (folding Bi-pod), well, you might not wanna do THAT parked in front of a Five Guys in New Jersey, lol!

 

In Hunting Season I can walk thru town with my O/U broken-open, no shells in the gun and carry it in my hands or over my shoulder.  NO transportation, possession or ANY other laws broken.  And I've had Cops give me a "thumbs-up" or shout "good luck" as I'm walking towards the woods!

 

FWIW, by definition (and the letter of the Law), the ONLY areas to be considered "Non-Exempt" as far as long guns possession goes are Military Bases and Installations, Schools, Government Buildings and other plainly-marked "Gun Free Zones".  A Walmart parking lot is considered "public domain" since there is ZERO expectation of privacy.  

Fantastic explanation.

What if the buyers FID card is laminated?

What if the buyers FID card is laminated?

No problem to laminate them, my PD laminated mine for me.

The cop instructed you to break the law. He wasn't worried because if you two were caught nothing would have happened. There is no reasonable deviation that allows for gun sales in public places. A gun range and a gun shop are exempt places thus legal to stop and uncase the firearms.

 

Let me ask you a question did either of you remove the firearm from a locked container? Do you think it's legal to do that at a d&D? If so why not do it everyday? It's not legal just call the state police FIU and ask two questions: is stopping at a D&D to transfer a firearm an acceptable deviation and if I uncase a firearm in the parking lot and inspect it is that a crime? The answers will be no, yes.

 

Until the AG was forced to clarify even stopping at the D&D for any reason was a crime, let alone a gun sale.  With the new rules, if they really exist, you can stop and use the bathroom or get food but nowhere does it say transfer, however legal, a firearm.  There is no place in NJ except exempt locations where you can remove the firearm from the container.  As I said before who buys a firearm without looking it over?

 

Just because we want something to be true doesn't make it so.

So I was possibly right in my assertion that as the buyer, I broke no laws in that DD parking lot.

 

PK90 Stated: "As stated previously, the buyer is exempt from acquiring from ANY PLACE of purchase, however, the seller might not be.

Again, please refrain from making up laws. Where does it say that a gun shop is the only place you can buy a gun?"

 

So Rob0115, where did I go wrong?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.