April 24, 20179 yr http://www.nj2as.org/supreme_court_reschedules_concealed_carry_case_again?utm_campaign=peruta5&utm_medium=email&utm_source=nj2as
April 24, 20179 yr Just saw on facebook Peruta is now scheduled for conference on 4/28. Edit - confirmed - via supreme court site: https://www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=%2Fdocketfiles%2F16-894.htm ... Apr 20 2017 Rescheduled.Apr 24 2017 DISTRIBUTED for Conference of April 28, 2017.
May 1, 20179 yr Cert decisions came out at 930 and Peruta was not on the list, but was also not listed as denied. So no word on status. I don't know what that means.
May 1, 20179 yr Regarding Peruta V. California and the fact that there was no action on the case - " Amy Howe This case has been repeatedly distributed for conference but then rescheduled; last week was the first time that it was actually considered at the conference. 9:41 AM Amy Howe The Court has been giving most cases a second look before granting, so the fact that the case wasn't on this week's order list could mean (a) that someone is trying to pick up a fourth vote to grant cert.; (b) there are four votes but they want to do their due diligence; (c) they are denying but someone is writing a dissent or statement respecting the denial. 9:43 AM
May 1, 20179 yr Author Re-scheduled again ... http://www.nj2as.org/supreme_court_reschedules_concealed_carry_case_for_a_third_time?recruiter_id=10251 https://www.supremecourt.gov/Search.aspx?FileName=/docketfiles/16-894.htm
May 9, 20179 yr 31 minutes ago, Bklynracer said: Just saw this update May 8 2017 DISTRIBUTED for Conference of May 11, 2017. They're meeting to discuss on the 11th. Fingers crossed.
May 15, 20179 yr Like all the other 2A cases recently, they will reschedule it a few times then deny it.
May 16, 20179 yr 10 hours ago, diamondd817 said: Like all the other 2A cases recently, they will reschedule it a few times then deny it. I am certainly hoping that is not the case. My disappointment with the Drake case not being heard is still fresh in my mind. We shall see.
May 16, 20179 yr I predict they will take the case and rule on it! It may be bounced a few more times before they take it on however!
May 16, 20179 yr Realistically, they are (at best) exactly where they were the last time they got a case like this. 4 for 4 against and 1 maybe. Last time they couldn't relist forever, so without some other change to the line up, I'm not sure why this would go differently.
May 16, 20179 yr Agree with that, unless 1) for some reason Gorsuch is more persuasive than Scalia or perhaps perceived as more likely to compromise in some way or 2) Peruta is different than the Drake and the other carry cases. I'm not sure why that would be -- the good cause issue seems pretty identical to justifiable need and both NJ and CA ban open carry so this really isn't just a concealed carry case (which might have an uphill battle even with the pro-2A judges) but rather a "bear arms" case. One other possibility is that there is just more room on the calendar, or perhaps the justices were waiting for all of the pending cases, including Peruta, to make their way through the appeals process before granting cert. I'm not optimistic, but have some hope.
May 17, 20179 yr 5-4 peruta. phone calls are being made. Ginsburg wheeled towards the landing of a long flight of stairs. My prediction
May 17, 20179 yr 3 hours ago, PDM said: ... both NJ and CA ban open carry ... I think that NJ doesn't distinguish between open and concealed carry. If you have a carry permit you can either carry open or concealed.
May 22, 20179 yr Yup: May 22 2017 DISTRIBUTED for Conference of May 25, 2017. I wonder if this is some kind of record?
May 22, 20179 yr I already told you guys what's going to happen. This is the same pattern for every 2A case that comes in.
May 22, 20179 yr 2 hours ago, diamondd817 said: I already told you guys what's going to happen. This is the same pattern for every 2A case that comes in. That has come in. This one is happening me thinks
May 22, 20179 yr 16 minutes ago, Zeke said: That has come in. This one is happening me thinks Double or nothing on that case of beer?
May 22, 20179 yr FBI director is gone! Ill bite, if it's winter lager. I drank your last case. It's good... But seasonal
May 22, 20179 yr 11 minutes ago, Zeke said: FBI director is gone! Ill bite, if it's winter lager. I drank your last case. It's good... But seasonal Comey is gone and Hillary is, and will continue to be a free bird.
May 22, 20179 yr Just now, diamondd817 said: Comey is gone and Hillary is, and will continue to be a free bird. Ok! Winterbrew it is. no holiday 6 packs either, joker.
May 22, 20179 yr Historically, if a case has been rescheduled 2 times or more, the chances of it being heard by the SC is significantly reduced.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.