Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Luger with Stock NJ Legal if Federally Exempted?

Featured Replies

I have read multiple threads on here dating back to 2009 and there was no clear answer. Seemed those who are usually overly cautious say it is not legal and others said it is. Does anyone have any proof as to the legality.

 

I am only referring to those models explicitly exempted under federal law.

 

It is not a shotgun so it does not become a sawed off shot gun with a stock as I saw one member posted in an earlier thread.

 

It should not be a SBR since federally law explicitly says it is not a SBR. There certainly is no tax stamp needed for the models that are exempt.

 

That brings us to NJ law and it's pitfalls. Could NJ even pass a law that is contrary to federal law? This is not a situation where it is not banned under federal law, but is explicitly allowed under federal law.

 

Lastly I know certain Broomhandles and Radom pistols are also exempt under federal law but what about Lahti Pistols. Specifically Finnish L-35 Lahtis. There were only 50 Finnish Stocks made but Swedish Lahti Stocks can fit on a Finnish Lahti. Is that allowed under federal law?

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

That law above doesn't say pistol anywhere. It says any firearm made from a shotgun or rifle.

There definitely is a ATF ruling permitting Radom, Lugers, Broom handles,FN/Browning Hi Powers, and a few others listed from being class 3 item. 

  • Author

Now the way I read sawed off shotgun it says any shotgun. Which a Luger is not. Rifle which a Luger is not. Or any firearm made from a rifle or shotgun which a Luger is not.

 

Here is the definition of a rifle

 

 

2C:39-1 Definitions.

 

k."Handgun" means any pistol, revolver or other firearm originally designed or manufactured to be fired by the use of a single hand.

 

That is a Luger. States Originally Designed with use of a single hand.

 

m."Rifle" means any firearm designed to be fired from the shoulder and using the energy of the explosive in a fixed metallic cartridge to fire a single projectile through a rifled bore for each single pull of the trigger.

 

That is not a Luger even with stock added because the firearm wasn't designed to be fired from the shoulder.

 

n."Shotgun" means any firearm designed to be fired from the shoulder and using the energy of the explosive in a fixed shotgun shell to fire through a smooth bore either a number of ball shots or a single projectile for each pull of the trigger, or any firearm designed to be fired from the shoulder which does not fire fixed ammunition.

 

Definitely not a Luger with or without stock because bore is not smooth.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Author
That law above doesn't say pistol anywhere. It says any firearm made from a shotgun or rifle.

There definitely is a ATF ruling permitting Radom, Lugers, Broom handles,FN/Browning Hi Powers, and a few others listed from being class 3 item. 

I agree.

 

Also there is the matter of the Supremacy Clause that says states do not have the power to nullify federal law.

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

Now the way I read sawed off shotgun it says any shotgun. Which a Luger is not. Rifle which a Luger is not. Or any firearm made from a rifle or shotgun which a Luger is not.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk


If you look, there is a comma after the shotgun description in that definition... then a "or a rifle..." That means it is a separate example, which is clear. I didn't put the definition of a rifle. But let's say you have a Beretta Neos pistol... there is a carbine kit for those, which you put the barrel on first, then the stock. Even though it is registered as a pistol, the stock being installed makes it a rifle. If you forget the barrel step, you made a SBR (SBS under NJ's definition). Technically, you broke Federal law, as well as NJ law.

Put a stock on a Luger...

36ee01d5ffe721b248811037746598b1.png

Doesn't matter what BATFE says is ok, as there is not one exception in any of those NJ statutes. You would be safe from Federal charges, as they call a Luger an exception, but still NJ prohibited.

Do I agree with the law? No, of course not. However, a Luger with a stock attached is considered a SBS within NJ law... and is a third degree crime.
  • Author
 

If you look, there is a comma after the shotgun description in that definition... then a "or a rifle..." That means it is a separate example, which is clear. I didn't put the definition of a rifle. But let's say you have a Beretta Neos pistol... there is a carbine kit for those, which you put the barrel on first, then the stock. Even though it is registered as a pistol, the stock being installed makes it a rifle. If you forget the barrel step, you made a SBR (SBS under NJ's definition). Technically, you broke Federal law, as well as NJ law.

 

Put a stock on a Luger...

 

36ee01d5ffe721b248811037746598b1.png

 

Doesn't matter what BATFE says is ok, as there is not one exception in any of those NJ statutes. You would be safe from Federal charges, as they call a Luger an exception, but still NJ prohibited.

 

Do I agree with the law? No, of course not. However, a Luger with a stock attached is considered a SBS within NJ law... and is a third degree crime.

 

I disagree though because of the Supremacy Clause as well. The Luger is explicitly not a SBR and is allowed under Federal Law. NJ saying it is an SBR would be contrary to Federal Law. If Federal Law didn't mention the Luger Specifically that would be different. 

 

 

I agree a sawed off shotgun in NJ is a Rifle or Shotgun but a Luger is neither. I think the originally designed part is important in the definition of what is a handgun.

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

 

 

I disagree though because of the Supremacy Clause as well. The Luger is explicitly not a SBR and is allowed under Federal Law. NJ saying it is an SBR would be contrary to Federal Law. If Federal Law didn't mention the Luger Specifically that would be different.   I agree a sawed off shotgun in NJ is a Rifle or Shotgun but a Luger is neither. I think the originally designed part is important in the definition of what is a handgun.

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

Correct, BATFE took it off the NFA registry... but doesn't mean that adding a stock doesn't turn it into a rifle. It just states you don't have to file for a tax stamp to SBR a Luger (one that was originally designed to accept one; modification to a Luger to accept one, I'm pretty sure would require SBR paperwork).

 

NJ's statute says specifically a rifle with a barrel less than 16", or overall length under 26". Their definitions define a Luger with a stock as a rifle, since that stock was designed to allow you to fire from the shoulder... no other reason for it. Unless you toss a 16" barrel on it (people don't do elsewhere, since it is exempted with NFA), NJ calls it a SBS.

 

BATFE doesn't define blackpowder guns as firearms... NJ does. BB guns aren't defined as firearms in other places... but we still see attempts to change the laws to change that in NJ up to this day. Never gets through.

 

If you want to get a stock and a Luger with a lug... so be it. If it gets to court, it is a third degree crime. That would make you a felon. If you feel that you can argue it, best of luck. However, with it being very clear in 2C:39, you likely are going to lose your ability to own firearms afterwards.

 

As I've said, I'll file for a SBR/suppressor stamp as soon as I get settled in Maine... for a CZ Scorpion Evo pistol. If I find a Luger or Broomhandle Mauser in for a decent price, I'd get one. If I can put a stock on it, then will do it there... without issue.

 

 

Key words... Any firearm MADE FROM..... MODIFIED....ALTERED....

 

If it came from the factory with a stock, It should meet the federal criteria.

 

If it did not come from the factory with a stock, and you add one, that is a grey area, as that may be considered a modification to the original firearm as manufactured.

 

I understand the law as if it came as a box set, you're golden.  If it came rom the factory as a stand alone and you add any kind of stock after the fact, you're boned.

  • Author

From reading past threads there are at least 2 members on the forum in NJ that have Lugers with stocks that have said it is legal. I am not sold on it being illegal. Regardless it really doesn't apply to me because I can't find where a Lahti L-35 is exempt under Federal Law.

As for the whole antique thing. It seems NJ law is really only different than Federal Law when it comes to handguns and Mosins. It seems most other longguns are Antiques in NJ. 8mm Mauser S I wouldn't call commercially available and for that matter neither is 7mm Mauser with Round Nose Bullet. You could even argue that Finnish M/28-30 without D Mark but with Antique Receiver falls under having ammo not commercially available, 7.62x53R you will not find in any NJ Gun Shop.

a."Antique firearm" means any rifle or shotgun and "antique cannon" means a destructive device defined in paragraph (3) of subsection c. of this section, if the rifle, shotgun or destructive device, as the case may be, is incapable of being fired or discharged, or which does not fire fixed ammunition, regardless of date of manufacture, or was manufactured before 1898 for which cartridge ammunition is not commercially available, and is possessed as a curiosity or ornament or for its historical significance or value.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

  • Author

While on the subject of NJ Laws that I have never been able to get a definitive answer on what about MAS-49 in NJ? My understanding is the MAS-49/56 is legal because there is not a bayonet lug because the bayonet slips over the barrel. Leaving just one "evil feature" the grenade launcher. I would say the same argument applies to the MAS-49 being it's bayonet slips into a tube also not a bayonet lug.

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

 

1 hour ago, capt14k said:

I agree.

 

Also there is the matter of the Supremacy Clause that says states do not have the power to nullify federal law.

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

States can have laws that are more restrictive.  State laws can't be contrary to Federal law.  There is a difference between restrictive and contrary.

 

  • Author
States can have laws that are more restrictive.  State laws can't be contrary to Federal law.  There is a difference between restrictive and contrary.
 
Wouldn't NJ calling something a SBR that Federal Law says isn't be contrary to Federal Law? However in this case I don't think it actually applies the more I look at it. The question really is does adding the stock to a pistol originally designed as a pistol make it a sawed off shotgun? Being it was never a Rifle or Shotgun by the definition of of a Rifle or Shotgun and a Sawed Off Shotgun must be one of the two. It seems to me it is chicken or egg type situation.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

  • Author
Key words... Any firearm MADE FROM..... MODIFIED....ALTERED....
 
If it came from the factory with a stock, It should meet the federal criteria.
 
If it did not come from the factory with a stock, and you add one, that is a grey area, as that may be considered a modification to the original firearm as manufactured.
 
I understand the law as if it came as a box set, you're golden.  If it came rom the factory as a stand alone and you add any kind of stock after the fact, you're boned.
Yes I am referring to Lugers with original stocks.

I think for the Lahti L-35 I am beat. Unless I drop $10k on one with an original factory stock, but even then I'm not sure Federal Law exempts the Lahti.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

Wouldn't NJ calling something a SBR that Federal Law says isn't be contrary to Federal Law? However in this case I don't think it actually applies the more I look at it. The question really is does adding the stock to a pistol originally designed as a pistol make it a sawed off shotgun? Being it was never a Rifle or Shotgun by the definition of of a Rifle or Shotgun and a Sawed Off Shotgun must be one of the two. It seems to me it is chicken or egg type situation.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk


Nope...

They didn't say that a Luger with a stock isn't a SBR; they said that because of the collector statue of the firearm/stock, that tax stamps are not required.

You are kind of taking an exception of the NFA, and making it a standard. By definition, a Luger with a stock is a SBR. Not requiring a tax stamp for one isn't the same as saying it is not a SBR. NJ doesn't allow SBR/SBS.

NJ calling a rifled barrel firearm a SBS is not a question, as they define it specifically as any of three combinations. In regards to members/people saying they have a Luger with a stock, far from makes it legal. I'm sure there are still people with M1 Carbines in the state, doesn't mean they are legal (unless they registered them).
  • Author
 Nope... They didn't say that a Luger with a stock isn't a SBR; they said that because of the collector statue of the firearm/stock, that tax stamps are not required. You are kind of taking an exception of the NFA, and making it a standard. By definition, a Luger with a stock is a SBR. Not requiring a tax stamp for one isn't the same as saying it is not a SBR. NJ doesn't allow SBR/SBS. 

NJ calling a rifled barrel firearm a SBS is not a question, as they define it specifically as any of three combinations. In regards to members/people saying they have a Luger with a stock, far from makes it legal. I'm sure there are still people with M1 Carbines in the state, doesn't mean they are legal (unless they registered them).

 

 

 

 

 

 

That is what I meant by doesn't apply here. NJ law is really regarding Sawed off Shotgun not Short Barreled Rifle. So we are in agreement about the Federal and NJ part. The first sentence of my last post was a general question you could replace SBR with Apples. Meaning can NJ say something is legal or illegal or defined as or not that the Federal Government specifically says is the opposite?    

 

 

However getting into the definition of rifle, shotgun, handgun, and sawed off shotgun I don't think it is so open and shut. For instance some of these "pistols" I see that are new and NJ Legal. I don't know new firearms but[mention=3597]Remixer[/mention] maybe able to chime in with the names. One was a small Lever Action. Another was an AR Pistol. The third was some other ugly thing in 5 and 7 that someone picked up a couple weeks ago. I certainly could have shouldered all 3 of them. Why wouldn't the Luger with stock be the same thing? Meaning one that came from the factory with the stock.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

1 hour ago, capt14k said:

Wouldn't NJ calling something a SBR that Federal Law says isn't be contrary to Federal Law? However in this case I don't think it actually applies the more I look at it. The question really is does adding the stock to a pistol originally designed as a pistol make it a sawed off shotgun? Being it was never a Rifle or Shotgun by the definition of of a Rifle or Shotgun and a Sawed Off Shotgun must be one of the two. It seems to me it is chicken or egg type situation.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk
 

NJ can write whatever definitions it wants to write for state laws. If NJ wanted to say anything under 24" is an SBR in NJ they could do that.   That would be more restrictive not contrary and only apply within NJ.

Federal law doesn't even consider a shoulder stocked black powder revolver a firearm.  NJ sees it as a firearm and a SBR.

 "Assault weapon" laws are another example where states are more restrictive.

There was the time that all shoulder stocked pistols were considered SBRs. However as Screwball said ATF changed that as they ones our there were collectable.

  • Author
NJ can write whatever definitions it wants to write for state laws. If NJ wanted to say anything under 24" is an SBR in NJ they could do that.   That would be more restrictive not contrary and only apply within NJ. Federal law doesn't even consider a shoulder stocked black powder revolver a firearm.  NJ sees it as a firearm and a SBR.  "Assault weapon" laws are another example where states are more restrictive.

There was the time that all shoulder stocked pistols were considered SBRs. However as Screwball said ATF changed that as they ones our there were collectable.

 

 

 

I am in agreement Supremacy Clause does not apply to this situation.  Well it does because NJ Firearms Laws are all Unconstitutional as are most Federal Laws, but that is for another day.

 

 

Looking at just NJ Law and why are these newer pistols legal, but a Luger is not.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

2 minutes ago, capt14k said:

So I am in agreement Supremacy Clause does not apply to this situation.

 

So then it is just NJ Law and why these newer pistols are legal, but a Luger is not.

 

 

 

Lever action "mare's leg" and AR pistols are legal because they never were rifles. While some of these you can fire from the shoulder that's not how they are designed.

  • Author
Lever action "mare's leg" and AR pistols are legal because they never were rifles. While some of these you can fire from the shoulder that's not how they are designed.

 Wouldn't that be exactly the same as a Luger with a stock? One that came from the factory with the stock. I don't think anyone would call it a rifle.   

 

 

Mare's Leg was one of them I was referencing thank you for the name.

 

I know it's off topic, but I can change the title for those that get upset rather than starting a new topic, what is your opinion on MAS-49 and Antique Longguns? Seems NJ only differs by where they included cartridge ammunition that is not commercially available. Which makes the definition of commercially available important?

 

 

1 minute ago, capt14k said:

Wouldn't that be exactly the same as a Luger with a stock?

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk
 

No.  A Luger or any other handgun with a slotted grip for a shoulder stock is a legal pistol.  Add the shoulder stock and it's a SBR under Federal law (if not on ATF's list) and NJ law.

If you look on the Curio and Relic list (which ATF adds to from time to time) there are a few SBRs that are classified C&R.  There are also more modern guns that have C&R status due to rarity and collectability.  That really doesn't change their status as far as NJ law is concerned.

  • Author
No.  A Luger or any other handgun with a slotted grip for a shoulder stock is a legal pistol.  Add the shoulder stock and it's a SBR under Federal law (if not on ATF's list) and NJ law.

If you look on the Curio and Relic list (which ATF adds to from time to time) there are a few SBRs that are classified C&R.  There are also more modern guns that have C&R status due to rarity and collectability.  That really doesn't change their status as far as NJ law is concerned.

 

I thought we agreed federal law doesn't really matter when it comes to NJ law pertaining to sawed off shotguns? NJ Law doesn't use the term SBR does it?

 

 

So because the Luger stock can be removed it is no good? Can the mare's leg stock be removed? I honestly don't know. If it can why is that ok?

 

 

 

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

11 minutes ago, capt14k said:

 

I thought we agreed federal law doesn't really matter when it comes to NJ law pertaining to sawed off shotguns? NJ Law doesn't use the term SBR does it?

 

 

So because the Luger stock can be removed it is no good? Can the mare's leg stock be removed? I honestly don't know. If it can why is that ok?

 

 

 

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

NJ doesn't use the the term SBR or SBS.  I used SBR in my response for clarity.  If you read the definition Screwball posted above NJ would call a SBR a "sawed off shotgun".

If you removed the stock from a mares leg it wouldn't matter.  It never was a rifle. 

  • Author
NJ doesn't use the the term SBR or SBS.  I used SBR in my response for clarity.  If you read the definition Screwball posted above NJ would call a SBR a "sawed off shotgun". If you removed the stock from a mares leg it wouldn't matter.  It never was a rifle.   

 

I know we are going around in circles, but why is a Mare's Leg never a Rifle but a Luger becomes a rifle? Say Luger is in box the way it left the factory and the stock is attached why is that a Rifle or sawed off shotgun but the Mare's Leg is not?   

 

 

I understand adding a repro stock to a Luger could be an issue but I am talking about a Luger that was made with the stock like a Mare's Leg is made with a stock. What is the difference?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

39 minutes ago, capt14k said:

I know we are going around in circles, but why is a Mare's Leg never a Rifle but a Luger becomes a rifle? Say Luger is in box the way it left the factory and the stock is attached why is that a Rifle or sawed off shotgun but the Mare's Leg is not?   

 

 

I understand adding a repro stock to a Luger could be an issue but I am talking about a Luger that was made with the stock like a Mare's Leg is made with a stock. What is the difference?

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A mares leg was never a rifle as it was manufactured as a handgun.  Never had a full stock, never had any other barrel on it.  It was built from the start as a handgun.  Never intended to be fired from the shoulder.  If you put a full stock on it becomes a short barrel rifle.

The stock for the Luger is designed to be attached to a handgun and fired from the shoulder. A handgun with a slot for a shoulder stock is just a handgun. Attaching the stock to that handgun makes it a short barrel rifle.

I know we are going around in circles, but why is a Mare's Leg never a Rifle but a Luger becomes a rifle? Say Luger is in box the way it left the factory and the stock is attached why is that a Rifle or sawed off shotgun but the Mare's Leg is not?    
 
I understand adding a repro stock to a Luger could be an issue but I am talking about a Luger that was made with the stock like a Mare's Leg is made with a stock. What is the difference?


A firearm designated as a pistol from the factory didn't have a stock attached. The Mare's Leg... while it looks functional, is not something you'd shoulder easily. If you took a true stock and fitted it onto a Mare's Leg, then you have a SBR. Same as if you put a stock on a CZ Scorpion Evo or SIG MPX pistol.

If the Luger has the slot for the stock, it is a pistol... first and foremost. The stock is an add on, and it doesn't matter if it came from the factory like that or not. You have a pistol, add a stock, and considering you did not change the barrel out to a 16+"... you have a SBR.

Likewise, if you take a Beretta CX4, and chop the barrel down to right past the forend... it never turned into a pistol, just an SBR. The stock is the defining characteristic of an SBR, as the same firearm with a brace (under Federal eyes), would be considered a pistol... if it was never stocked before.

Another pistol that is big with these issues are Thompson Center pistols. It is smarter to get it as a pistol, then get the longer barrels/stock, to turn it into a rifle. As long as you don't put the stock on before the longer barrel, you legally have a rifle.
  • Author

We will have to agree to disagree about the Mare's Leg. That stock is just as functional as a Luger's Stock IMO. If a Mare's Leg isn't a Sawed Off Shotgun under NJ Law then neither should a Luger with a factory stock be a sawed off shotgun. Assuming they both left the factory with the stock attached. The Mare's Leg started life as a rifle. The Luger started as a Pistol. The Mare's Leg is more a Rifle than a Luger ever will be.

 

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

 

 

 

 

 

 

  • Author
2847ca1f6215f814a25f4f2b6abf29f6.jpg

59375a2f582261de5008447988143316.jpg

Think the length of pull is very apparent between the two...

I'll agree with that, but the Mare's Leg looks a lot more like a sawed off shotgun than the Luger does. Wouldn't the intent of the law be to ban something like the Mare's Leg rather than the Luger?

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

I'll agree with that, but the Mare's Leg looks a lot more like a sawed off shotgun than the Luger does. Wouldn't the intent of the law be to ban something like the Mare's Leg rather than the Luger?

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk


Considering the Mare's Leg is a pistol... nope. Looks aside, it doesn't meet the SBS definition.

The SBS statute doesn't ban the Luger, or the Mare's Leg... it bans shotguns with barrels under 18", rifles with barrels under 16", and rifles/shotguns under 26" overall length. Putting a stock on a Luger creates at least one of those instances.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.