Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Featured Replies

Just now, Zeke said:

Unfortunately pardons only come after convictions

He can get PTI quickly from just a Prosecutor decision. He can be pardoned then as well I think.  

  • Replies 132
  • Views 7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • We need these at every border crossing!  

  • Please let this thread die with 2017! NJ gun laws are unconstitutional and just plain wrong in every way. NO AMERICAN deserves to be treated the way NJ treats them and NONE OF US should ever wish ANY

  • Can we PLEASE stop attacking one another! We are all on the same side in the end. I don't think anyone here likes our stupid gun laws. We all look forward to the Feds giving us back our rights an

Posted Images

  • Author
2 hours ago, Mrs. Peel said:

Hmmm... though I understand your objection.. who's to say we can't fight on BOTH fronts, to work for more rights for NJ residents while concurrently helping out-of-staters who inadvertently get caught in our legal quagmire? These are not mutually exclusive positions! They're separate battles but part of the same war.

Besides, it's easy to fall into the pattern of the angry oppressed. But we shouldn't do it --- aren't we just letting the powers-that-be manipulate us into fighting each other? ("Ha! If WE NJ residents can't have it, then neither can THEY!") But, that attitude shifts a bit when we think of jammed up people like this young man - or the lady mentioned in Frenchtown - as "fellow citizens" or even as "our guests". It's morally incumbent on us, I think, to help them as we would try to help ourselves... and so I personally applaud the effort. 

^^^^THIS^^^^

Peel you hit the nail on the head again!  Sorry it took so long to read this & quote you!

I personally find it repugnant that there are those among us who insist upon debating whether to help.  I'm sorry to admit feeling that way, and I'm sorry for any butthurt, but as a Patriot FIRST, I feel my intentions are sound.  The fact that some here choose to even bring-up the thought of not helping saddens me and gives rise to the very reason for my initial post:  To rid ourselves of the necessity to get our noses out of joint, put the bickering that always seems to raise its' ugly head during these "debates" behind us, and roll-up our sleeves to help these poor bastards caught in the quagmire that is NJ gun law!  For without such "debate", we here on the forum sit at our keyboards attacking each other instead of working together to fight bad gun laws.  

I didn't make my initial post to pat myself on the back.  I did it to "break the ice and give the chest thumpers a chance to do their thing" before we get down to the real business at hand, namely saving this kid so he HAS A LIFE THAT'S WORTH LIVING.

 

4 minutes ago, JohnnyB said:

He can get PTI quickly from just a Prosecutor decision. He can be pardoned then as well I think.  

Not pardoned, but they could drop the charges. 

20 minutes ago, 10X said:

Not pardoned, but they could drop the charges. 

Shaneen Allen was granted PTI. The Governor then pardoned her on all charges, a possession charge and an ammo charge. She kept all her rights. It did take a couple years for the Prosecutor to allow the PTI though.

  • Author
10 minutes ago, Zeke said:

Unfortunately pardons only come after convictions

Yes, in most NJ gun law cases. 

When we were both "kids" ourselves, Ford pardoned Nixon for Watergate, and Nixon was never "convicted".

4 minutes ago, JohnnyB said:

Shaneen Allen was granted PTI. The Governor then pardoned her on all charges. She kept all her rights. Like it never even happened!

You’re right, I didn’t realize one could be pardoned from PTI

  • Author
7 minutes ago, JohnnyB said:

Shaneen Allen was granted PTI. The Governor then pardoned her on all charges. She kept all her rights. Like it never even happened!

Yes, and she spent 48 days in jail earning her pardon, after losing her job.  "Like it never happened", except every time she comes to NJ to help us, she gets a sick stomach, gets nervous, looks over her shoulder, and grips the steering wheel too hard.  And she's gonna do it AGAIN on Saturday January 13th!

Just now, Smokin .50 said:

Yes, and she spent 48 days in jail earning her pardon, after losing her job.  "Like it never happened", except every time she comes to NJ to help us, she gets a sick stomach, gets nervous, looks over her shoulder, and grips the steering wheel too hard.  And she's gonna do it AGAIN on Saturday January 13th!

I did not mean to imply she did not suffer!  Just that she was in PTI and was pardoned. Rightfully!  I removed the comment!

Just now, JohnnyB said:

I did not mean to imply she did not suffer!  Just that she was in PTI and was pardoned. Rightfully!  I removed the comment!

And if it weren't for Evan Nappen exposing the prosecutor (who granted PTI to Ray Rice), she might never have been granted PTI.  Initially, the prosecutor wasn't going to do it!

 

 

43 minutes ago, Zeke said:

Well let’s stay on topic. An American citizen that does not reside in nj got hung up on nj’s unconstitutional laws...

Yes. But since he doesn't reside in the great state of NJ, certain people here wish him pain and suffering...That's messed up.

 

Can we PLEASE stop attacking one another! We are all on the same side in the end.

I don't think anyone here likes our stupid gun laws. We all look forward to the Feds giving us back our rights and in the mean time, I don't think any of us wish to see ANYONE screwed over by our stupid laws!

I have to ask this because it is not stated in the original post, what state is the accused from and is it legal in his home state to have a loaded shotgun uncased in the main cabin of the vehicle? 

I hate seeing people get caught in the NJ suck as much as everyone else here but if what he was doing is illegal in his home state too, I suspect he’s not going to get to far with an NJ prosecutor and I am not too sure he should. It wouldn’t be a matter of unknowingly doing something common and legal in his home state that NJ law stupidly determines is illegal like Shaneen Allen was arrested for, it would be an act illegal in both states so there’s no real excuse. 

If it is legal in his home state he has a lot more solid argument against NJ.

JMHO

-Jim

9 minutes ago, JimB1 said:

I have to ask this because it is not stated in the original post, what state is the accused from and is it legal in his home state to have a loaded shotgun uncased in the main cabin of the vehicle? 

I hate seeing people get caught in the NJ suck as much as everyone else here but if what he was doing is illegal in his home state too, I suspect he’s not going to get to far with an NJ prosecutor and I am not too sure he should. It wouldn’t be a matter of unknowingly doing something common and legal in his home state that NJ law stupidly determines is illegal like Shaneen Allen was arrested for, it would be an act illegal in both states so there’s no real excuse. 

If it is legal in his home state he has a lot more solid argument against NJ.

JMHO

-Jim

Quote "Smokin .50"   " As to the geography question, yes there are several states in "MERICA" as Zeke just pointed out (THANKS Zeke--and I mean it!) where gun racks in pick-ups are as common as a key-chain.  His dad told him to bring the shotgun to protect himself, which he did.  Dad gave it to him when he was NINE yrs old (back in Texas).  Parents live in PA now.  Kid works a trade & just ASSUMED that since he wasn't robbin' banks or knockin'-over liquor stores, he had the SAME RIGHTS as he does where he lives."

So they were originally from Texas where it is legal. Now living in PA where it is not legal.

I don't think the "If it is legal in his home state he has a lot more solid argument against NJ." holds any water here in the PRNJ!

  • Author
43 minutes ago, JohnnyB said:

I did not mean to imply she did not suffer!  Just that she was in PTI and was pardoned. Rightfully!  I removed the comment!

It's all good JohnnyB, for I didn't type what I did to cause you any concern.  I was merely extolling the virtues of "the shoe being on the other foot" in how many times Shaneen has selflessly come back to Jersey to HELP US :)   So NO harm was meant by what I typed, just another example of how not hearing the inflection can cause things to go askew.  Carry on my friend!

13 minutes ago, JohnnyB said:

Quote "Smokin .50"   " As to the geography question, yes there are several states in "MERICA" as Zeke just pointed out (THANKS Zeke--and I mean it!) where gun racks in pick-ups are as common as a key-chain.  His dad told him to bring the shotgun to protect himself, which he did.  Dad gave it to him when he was NINE yrs old (back in Texas).  Parents live in PA now.  Kid works a trade & just ASSUMED that since he wasn't robbin' banks or knockin'-over liquor stores, he had the SAME RIGHTS as he does where he lives."

So they were originally from Texas where it is legal. Now living in PA where it is not legal.

Hmm, still clear as mud. I’m thinking if he is a PA resident now, NJ is going to say that he should know the laws of the state he lives in, and they’d be right. Since NJ and PA have the same law where this is concerned, I think this is going to be an uphill battle. I am still not clear though, does he live in Texas and his parents live in PA or does he live in PA? It’s hard to make the argument the he “had the same rights as he does where he lives” if he’s living in PA and he doesn’t have that right there. 

Either way is sounds like he should get some kind of a break but I am unclear if this is actually a “NJ law screwed someone else” issue. It sounds like if he was in PA he’d still be in trouble. 

-Jim

  • Author
1 hour ago, HBecwithFn7 said:

And if it weren't for Evan Nappen exposing the prosecutor (who granted PTI to Ray Rice), she might never have been granted PTI.  Initially, the prosecutor wasn't going to do it!

 

 

^^^^THIS^^^^

After Nappen was interviewed and let that little factoid "slip", her case for PTI went mainstream!  How could we jail a mother & put her boys into the system if we let Ray Rice's famous knock-out punch go unpunished?  People who don't even own guns were calling radio shows supporting her!

And NJ2AS was heavily involved with Shaneen's case.  Contribution collection, billboard, media campaign, etc.  They SHINED and did a spectacular job.  MSM was reporting on her case, and the phone calls POURED-IN to Trenton!  I was at the (now closed) Peter Pank Diner in Sayreville when Frank Fiamingo, NJ2AS President at the time, presented her a check at the Middlesex Co. Tea Party monthly meeting.  Shaneen was the featured speaker, and she had both sons with her.  That was YEARS ago now.

  • Author
26 minutes ago, JimB1 said:

Hmm, still clear as mud. I’m thinking if he is a PA resident now, NJ is going to say that he should know the laws of the state he lives in, and they’d be right. Since NJ and PA have the same law where this is concerned, I think this is going to be an uphill battle. I am still not clear though, does he live in Texas and his parents live in PA or does he live in PA? It’s hard to make the argument the he “had the same rights as he does where he lives” if he’s living in PA and he doesn’t have that right there. 

Either way is sounds like he should get some kind of a break but I am unclear if this is actually a “NJ law screwed someone else” issue. It sounds like if he was in PA he’d still be in trouble. 

-Jim

He lives in Texas.  Pick-up had Texas plates.  Hopefully the mud is clearing :) .  It's late & I've been at this all day.  Not trying to be blunt, just arthritis is killin' me so I have to stop.  Take care & be glad it's not your kid.  Enjoy the New year.

Rosey

17 minutes ago, Smokin .50 said:

He lives in Texas.  Pick-up had Texas plates.  Hopefully the mud is clearing :) .  It's late & I've been at this all day.  Not trying to be blunt, just arthritis is killin' me so I have to stop.  Take care & be glad it's not your kid.  Enjoy the New year.

Rosey

Thanks for the info Rosey. I’m not being negative on it or what you are doing at all. I just like to have the facts. Every time we call out one of these things as a “NJ laws screwed someone else” and it turns out to not be the case, it weakens the argument the next time we need it so I like when it’s unambiguous.

Seems much more straightforward now, he is legal to drive that way in TX, was caught in NJ and busted for it. The parents being in PA is sort of a non-relevant bit of info that was confusing the issue to me :)

-Jim

8 hours ago, Zeke said:

Unfortunately pardons only come after convictions

I think only Presidents can pardon.  Governors grant Clemency. Don'y ask me the difference although I'd like to know.  Perhaps another thread.....  

3 minutes ago, BobA said:

I think only Presidents can pardon.  Governors grant Clemency. Don'y ask me the difference although I'd like to know.  Perhaps another thread.....  

I would think that Governors can pardon state matters, whereas Presidents can pardon federal matters as well.  Gov. Christie's pardon of Shaneen Allen is a "pardon" in all contexts.  This, and I also believe one can be pardoned even prior to a conviction... as President Ford did with Nixon.

 

Just now, HBecwithFn7 said:

I would think that Governors can pardon state matters, whereas Presidents can pardon federal matters as well.  Gov. Christie's pardon of Shaneen Allen is a "pardon" in all contexts.  This, and I also believe one can be pardoned even prior to a conviction... as President Ford did with Nixon.

 

I see.  Then do we know what a Clemency is?

1 minute ago, BobA said:

I see.  Then do we know what a Clemency is?

According to "dictionary.com"

Clemency

noun, plural clemencies.

1.
the quality of being clement; disposition to show forbearance, compassion, or forgiveness in judging or punishing; leniency; mercy.
2.
an act or deed showing mercy or leniency.
3.
(of the weather) mildness or temperateness.
 
====================================================================

Thus, "clemency" might be something akin to a "commutation of sentence" or a reduction in the sentence or charges or things like that.   It won't erase any prior actions taken against the defendant (i.e. arrest, trial, convction, adjudication). A full "pardon," in most cases, does expunge those prior actions, as if they never happened.
 
 
9 minutes ago, HBecwithFn7 said:

According to "dictionary.com"

Clemency

noun, plural clemencies.

1.
the quality of being clement; disposition to show forbearance, compassion, or forgiveness in judging or punishing; leniency; mercy.
2.
an act or deed showing mercy or leniency.
3.
(of the weather) mildness or temperateness.
 
====================================================================

Thus, "clemency" might be something akin to a "commutation of sentence" or a reduction in the sentence or charges or things like that.   It won't erase any prior actions taken against the defendant (i.e. arrest, trial, convction, adjudication). A full "pardon," in most cases, does expunge those prior actions, as if they never happened.
 
 

Ahh.  To quote Zeke, "gotcha".  Thanks.

7 hours ago, Smokin .50 said:

^^^^THIS^^^^

After Nappen was interviewed and let that little factoid "slip", her case for PTI went mainstream!  How could we jail a mother & put her boys into the system if we let Ray Rice's famous knock-out punch go unpunished?  People who don't even own guns were calling radio shows supporting her!

And NJ2AS was heavily involved with Shaneen's case.  Contribution collection, billboard, media campaign, etc.  They SHINED and did a spectacular job.  MSM was reporting on her case, and the phone calls POURED-IN to Trenton!  I was at the (now closed) Peter Pank Diner in Sayreville when Frank Fiamingo, NJ2AS President at the time, presented her a check at the Middlesex Co. Tea Party monthly meeting.  Shaneen was the featured speaker, and she had both sons with her.  That was YEARS ago now.

As was Anthony Colandro on "Gun for Hire Radio."  He really came to Shannen's aid!  Bravo Zulu Ant!

  • Author
29 minutes ago, HBecwithFn7 said:

As was Anthony Colandro on "Gun for Hire Radio."  He really came to Shannen's aid!  Bravo Zulu Ant!

Anthony's podcast was also crucial in Shaneen's outcome fo' SURE!  He RAILED every week against the injustice, cracking the whip to get gun owners to respond and was proud to have supported her & still is.  They have a unique relationship, based upon trust & friendship.  Shaneen drives from Philly to shoot at Gun For Hire on a every-so-often basis during Tony Simon's "The 2nd is for Everyone: Diversity Shoot"!  There's always big hugs from everyone at GFH when Shaneen walks thru the door :)   Shaneen was at NJSAFECON again this year!  

I've been on the podcast several times, and am looking forward to my next trip to Sandy's Studio!

Well here is another one for those that like to help out of staters:

http://www.nj.com/hunterdon/index.ssf/2017/12/florida_woman_arrested_after_cops_find_loaded_hand.html

 

These laws need to be changed, and going out of our way to help non-NJ residents is the WRONG approach.  These people (again nothing against them as individuals) need to be prosecuted to the fullest extent and rot in a New Jermany jail - then and only THEN will the Dems in Trenton do something to change our laws.  They don't give a crap what the few conservatives in this state want.  However, when they get the angst of the rest of the country on them, well then they might do something.

47 minutes ago, Howard said:

Well here is another one for those that like to help out of staters:

http://www.nj.com/hunterdon/index.ssf/2017/12/florida_woman_arrested_after_cops_find_loaded_hand.html

 

These laws need to be changed, and going out of our way to help non-NJ residents is the WRONG approach.  These people (again nothing against them as individuals) need to be prosecuted to the fullest extent and rot in a New Jermany jail - then and only THEN will the Dems in Trenton do something to change our laws.  They don't give a crap what the few conservatives in this state want.  However, when they get the angst of the rest of the country on them, well then they might do something.

I respectfully disagree! I think your reasoning is overly optimistic. What on earth makes you think Dems will "do something" due to outside pressure over a few awful cases?  What makes you think anyone could even get the MSM to cover the cases? NJ anti-gun pols would gladly let those fellow gun owners rot in jail... forever! Hell, they'd be PROUD of it.

I'm not content to put any American citizen in jail due to bad laws... particularly when those laws are designed to trap people who had NO CRIMINAL INTENT. I don't care what state they live in.  

18 hours ago, Howard said:

While this sounds like a nice act of kindness, there is a flip side to it.  Why on earth should out of state residents get better treatment than actual residents of the socialist people's republic of New Jermany.  Nothing against any individuals, but I would like to see the full force of the law used on all these out of state residents with them given the maximum sentences.  Then and only then might something be done to change these laws.  Why should you or I face the cold hand of the law but those that don't live her get off - that is plain wrong.  The law should be the law, and most of these gun laws should not be the law.

Ummmm, hoping someone gets punished for an idiotic law just because you couldn't get away with it too?  We're not in third grade any more. Hoping this woman gets jammed up with a felony conviction accomplishes absolutely nothing.  How about we hope shen gets treated fairly because it's the right thing to do?  This should be advertised everywhere CCW is a common everyday thing.  Maybe that will help with national reciprocity, because NJ laws won't be changed from within.  Make her the poster child for who carries outside NJ - you know, teachers, grandmothers, utility linemen, plumbers - everyday folks that aren't a threat to anyone except the "bad guys".  There should be a map of the states where people have been jammed up in NJ, sending it to every rep from those states to support national reciprocity. 

10 minutes ago, Mrs. Peel said:

I respectfully disagree! I think your reasoning is overly optimistic. What on earth makes you think Dems will "do something" due to outside pressure over a few awful cases?  What makes you think anyone could even get the MSM to cover the cases? NJ anti-gun pols would gladly let those fellow gun owners rot in jail... forever! Hell, they'd be PROUD of it.

I'm not content to put any American citizen in jail due to bad laws... particularly when those laws are designed to trap people who had NO CRIMINAL INTENT. I don't care what state they live in.  

Precisely.  As I've stated previously, even if "National Reciprocity" were to be passed by the Federal Govt., states like NJ will find ways around it, or simply ignore it altogether. "So Sue us..." will be the mindset... knowing that no single entity has the legal and financial resources to do so against the State Govt. which can tie things up in the courts far beyond the remainder of my lifetime (I'd imagine). And imagine if the Soros' of the world pitch in as well... Definitely a Herculean effort.

The only way I believe to get states like NJ to comply would be to tie the "federal funding" it receives for various projects to compliance with any such reciprocity law... just as they did for raising the drinking age to 21 (tied to Federal highway funds). That might not be "legal" now, but they should restore it.

 

 

Precisely.  As I've stated previously, even if "National Reciprocity" were to be passed by the Federal Govt., states like NJ will find ways around it, or simply ignore it altogether. "So Sue us..." will be the mindset... knowing that no single entity has the legal and financial resources to do so against the State Govt. which can tie things up in the courts far beyond the remainder of my lifetime (I'd imagine). And imagine if the Soros' of the world pitch in as well... Definitely a Herculean effort.
The only way I believe to get states like NJ to comply would be to tie the "federal funding" it receives for various projects to compliance with any such reciprocity law... just as they did for raising the drinking age to 21 (tied to Federal highway funds). That might not be "legal" now, but they should restore it.
 
 
It would be legal to take away 19.9% of law enforcement funding and they probably could take away 19.9% of highway funding too. Also the Federal Government has the resources to go after the states in the courts. If National Reciprocity passes and SCOTUS upholds it, which they will, states will eventually have to comply. Especially the Communist States like NJ that are nearly broke due to all the waste and corruption.


Notice how the Communist States in America mirror the Soviet Union. Official Corruption, Police States with far too many police, state is broke. Hopefully the Communist States fall just as Communism did in the USSR.

Sent from my XT1585 using Tapatalk

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.