Everything posted by rauchman
-
You really need to hold it or shoot it to know for sure
I once rented a G30 in Las Vegas and couldn't believe how accurate and how controllable it was!!! I have refallen in love w/ my M&P40 w/ Apex sear and polished internals. Had it for sale forever on this site, but glad I held onto it. The M&P is a very very nice shooting platform. My wife has a Beretta 92FS that I find hard to shoot good groups with. Sig P226.... outstanding pistol. Recently picked up a Gen4 G23.... really digging that pistol as well. I have 2 permits ready to use, but have no idea what I want to get. M&P9c, Gen4 G19 (although I already have a Gen2 & Gen3 G19), Gen4 G26, G21SF/G30SF, M&P45. I'd love to get another .45, but ammo is pricey. Yup after reading this thread, my lust for a Glock .45 grows.
-
whats the deal with not being able to pick up your brass
I shoot at the Bullet Hole. I've gotten looks a few times, but I always pick up my brass. They will nonchalantley try brushing my brass into another area for pick up, but as soon as I see them coming my way, I start picking up my brass. I normally shoot 5 round strings and immediately start picking up as soon as I'm done w/ my string. They didn't pay for it They are not giving me a discount for it. It's mine!!!
-
Glocks or XD's
Just an update.... M&P - Was at the Bullet Hole last weekend w/ the newly acquired Gen4 G23 (w/ Glock 4.5lb connector..used to be called the 3.5lb connector and Mepro NS), Gen3 G19 (Mepro NS) and M&P40 (factory Trijicon NS and Apex Tactical sear and polished internals). My buddy brought along his Gen2 G23 (Hartz recoil reducer, Wolf 20lb recoil spring, Hoque Handall, Mepro NS)and Sig P229 .40 (some kind of stainless guide rod, Hoque grips, Mepro NS). In my previous post, I mentioned that the M&P while a very comfy feeling pistol, w/ a now vastly improved trigger over stock, was very hard for me to shoot accurately. I don't know what changed. Maybe the stars aligned right, the Force was strong w/ me that day, nearing 2012...., but the M&P shot INCREDIBLE!!! My buddy found it surprising that he was shooting the M&P better than his trusty P229 also. W/ my G19, my best groups are right around 1" at 15 yards for 5rnds slow fire freehand. The Gen4 G23 is still a work in progress, but I'm not shooting it anywhere near the G19's capability for me. Surprisingly, very very surprisingly, I was able to pull a couple 1" groups w/ the M&P. I've shot 9mm and .45 well (for me), but never .40. The M&P40 is the 1st .40 that I can really shoot well (for me). Also, as with the G19, repeat shot accuracy was outstanding. As anyone who shoots at Bullet Hole can attest to, they frown on rapid fire. I got there before 10:00am and they were letting me get away with roughly 2 shots per second. Was able to hold some tight groups w/ the M&P shooting at a quickened pace. Overall, I've always had a favorable impression of the M&P. I just couldn't shoot it that well. Now, after my very very favorable shooting experience w/ the M&P last weekend, the M&P has definitely gone up a notch. Couple of points though. I, without a doubt, think the Glock, and possibly HK, have the best finishes in the business. On a Gen3 G22 I used to own, I tried changing out the sights to night sights using a hammer and screwdriver. Dumb, I know. At one point, when hit w/ a forefull blow from the hammer, the screwdriver jumped off the night sight and ssssccccrrrraaaaaapppppeeeeddddd along the entire length of the slide. I COULD NOT BELIEVE the slide was not gouged. It had a light line that was left by the screwdriver that was easily buffed out. The M&P does not have that same toughness. Also, from an armorer's/tinkerer's perspective, in order to get to the firing pin plunger on the M&P, the rear sight has to be removed. I had to buy the M&P rear sight pusher to work on mine. Upside is, that the 9mm/40/357Sig/45GAP Glock slides fit perfectly on this sight pusher as well. Also, I s/w an S&W rep yesterday. One of things that came up in the conversation was that the extractor is a factory only installed part. Appartently, they have some kind of heavy press that they use to install the pin for the extractor. I've never tried to remove the extractor on my gun, so I don't know how hard it is, but I've read in a couple of places that it is a **** to remove.
-
Glocks or XD's
I voted Glock. I've owned examples of all 3. Currently have a Gen2 17 & 19, Gen3 G19, Gen4 G23, M&P40 w/ Apex sear and have owned and sold a Gen3 G22 and XD9 Tactical and XD45 Tactical. XD - I thought the XD9 was the lowest sample of quality of pistols mentioned. The rear of the slide would move maybe 1mm upward when the trigger was being drawn. Also, I really couldn't shoot it well. I had shot an XD9 that I rented in Las Vegas and directly compared it to a Gen3 G19. Shooting at the same pace I was slightly better on the G19. Shooting slow fire, I was a lot better w/ the G19. I bought the XD9 Tact anyway, liking the long slide aspect of it. The best I could shoot the pistol was about a 3" group of 5 rounds / 15 yards slow fire. I've shot 1" 5rnd / 15 yard groups w/ my G19 and typically average less than 2". Lastly, the XD9 has factory 15rnd mags available. The XD45 Tact I liked. I didn't like the trigger, but I could get a 2" group at 15 yards for 25 rounds.... really concentrating!!! It had a nice lockup to it, but I did not like the shooting characteristics of the high bore. Also, the grip was a little long. Would consider another XD45 Tact w/ the idea of doing something about the trigger. M&P - My only experience shooting the M&P is w/ the M&P40. It is a really nice gun now that I've put in the Apex sear and latest striker. Unfortunately, I can't shoot it well. I've tried all 3 backstraps and I'm not feeling the Goldilocks thing w/ any of them. Now that I've polished the trigger internals and added the Apex sear, the trigger is the best of the polymer bunch as far as smoothness and tactile feel. However, the Glock still edges it out in reset and can be made as smooth. I'd like to give an M&P9C and 45 a whirl though. Glock - My 1st Glock experience was a Gen2 G23 in the early 90's and I hated it. Yet, I would up getting a Gen3 G22 in the mid-late 90's and would up selling it. Tried a G30 on a trip to Las Vegas and LOVED IT!!! Was amazed at the recoil control and accuracy. Bought a used Gen2 G19 at the Bullet Hole in the late 90's. Dry fired that gun so much I shattered the breach area of the slide where the firing pin peeks through into the chamber (which Glock replaced for free). My favorite pistols for a long time was my Sig P226 9mm (German made) and HK USP45F. Since learning the Glock trigger, the Glocks are right there as well. They have a hard trigger to master, but worth while to do so. A lot of people, and at one time, myself included, criticize the blocky frame of the Glock and sing praises of the comfort of the grip of the XD and especially, the M&P. I've found for me, that blockyness really allows me a solid grip on the frame, where I find my hands easily losing their grip on the frames of the XD and M&P. Last Friday, I picked up a Gen4 G23 and the Gen4 really takes the Glock up a notch. Just the redesigned frame is worth it alone. Ultimately, it really comes down to what you like. I've gotten to really like and appreciate Glocks through my experiences. I do think that all the pistols are pretty much equally reliable. I do think, but have no way of knowing for sure, that the Glock and M&P's are built a little better than the XD's that I've sampled. The fellow member who bought my XD45, LOVED THEM. I believe mine was going to be his 10th. Lots of fans of all brands listed. Shoot as many as you can. If you're at the range and see someone shooting one that interests you, ask to shoot 5 rounds or so. I've gotten to shoot more pistols that way and always try to return that favor when asked. Also, consider buying used. Unless these guns are heavily beat on, they should be fine for a used purchase.
-
I did it.... bought a Gen4 G23
I just joined the GSSF a month or so ago. The woman I spoke with mentioned that there are only 2 places in NJ that honor the GSSF pricing. The Bullet Hole in Belleville, Essex Cnty and Mikes Gun Shop in Cliffside Park, Bergen Cnty. I've dealt w/ both shops and I've had good experiences w/ both. However, I've only bought this pistol using the GSSF program and this pistol was purchased at the Bullet Hole. Also, according to the Bullet Hole, GSSF pricing only applies to LAW ENFORCEMENT models. How this actually differs from a normal civilian purchase, I don't know. I think there's a blue label on the box vs. whatever other color they use.
-
Night Sights.... what do you suggest
Greetings, Just bought a Gen4 G23. Thread can be viewed here.... rauchman's Gen4 G23 I'm going to order a set of night sights for it and would like some input. I currently have Trijicons on my Gen2 17 & 19. Also have Mep's on my Gen3 G19. They are both good and very comparable in sight picture layout. Mep's have slightly larger vials/dots, the Trij's seem finer and more precise, ...... but they are not all that different. I'm looking for something a little different Some possibles that come to mind are some flavor of Heine's, Warren's, whoever makes the TFO fiber optic/tritium sights, etc. I want something different. I've have Big Dots on a Beretta 96 Centurian some years back and DID NOT like them. While the front dot was really big (IIRC, they had a smaller than their normal front sight, which was what I ordered), precision was out the window. I have to believe there is something that offers a better solution. I shot an HK45 owned by a fellow sight member that had, I believe Heine's, w/ a dot over dot configuration. Dont' know how I feel about the dot over dot, as the Big Dots had a similar layout and found it easy to loose my sense of vertical distance between the sights when being in a nonlit area. I did like the sights themselves though. Liked the proportion of front sight blade size in relation the size of the notch in the rear sight. Can I also have your opinions on various color combo's between front and rear sights? I think I'm starting to buy into this idea. In the couple of years or so, I've starting practicing 2 eyes open using my dominant eye. I'm righty but w/ a left dominant eye. It's made a difference in my shooting for the better. I would think the contrast between front and rears using different colors would allow for great front sight acquisition on the draw.
-
I did it.... bought a Gen4 G23
Thanks!!! I have very high hopes/expectations for the break in shoot this Sat. AFAIK, and from what I've read and so far experimented w/, the lower parts pretty much carry over outside of mag release parts. The slide, barrel and recoil spring do not interchange. I don't know for sure, but I think the firing pin plunger, extractor, striker assembly and that little tabby thing on the rear end of the slide, do interchange.
-
I did it.... bought a Gen4 G23
Greetings fellow lead slinging brethren!!! Picked up a brandy new Gen4 G23 using my GSSF membership, at the Bullet Hole last Friday!!! For reference, I also have a Gen2 G17, Gen2 G19 & Gen3 G19, as well as bunch of other pistols. Although I haven't shot it yet (plan on going to the BH 1st thing Sat morning), I think it's going to be a great shooter. My buddy is coming along and he'll be bringing his Gen2 G23 w/ Hartz recoil reducer and heavier recoil spring.... sorry, I forget the weight. I'll also be bringing my M&P40. I'll post back after the shoot w/ pics. So far, I'm loving this pistol though. Amazing how much 2mm difference can make in the comfort/control of the grip. The pad of my trigger finger lays at a more natural angle as compare to pre Gen4's. The texture is great and really gives a better "grip". Pistol feels a lot tighter as well. Personally, I like the Gen3 slide finish the best of all the gen's. The Gen4 has much more of a matte finish, much more phosphate finish looking. The only downside that I've noticed so far, is the heavier trigger. I understand, somewhere along the line recently, the trigger bars were changed to a different geometry giving a heavier pull. I had Glock do some work done on my Gen2 G19 last May and the gun's very smooth and nicely worn trigger internals were replaced w/ the new stuff (was not pleased!!!). Definitely heavier there as well. In both instances, it sounds like the striker is smacking w/ more authority. The good thing is that w/ the revised grip geometry of the Gen4, it allows me to pull the trigger straight back easier than on the previous Gen's. So while the trigger is heavier, the new grip design allows for an easier pull. I popped in a spare LW 3.5 connector and while it worked and did drop the weight a little, it A.) like the Gen2 G19 that I also dropped an LW connector in, stages the weight differently...feels more tightly sprung but definitely lighter than stock and B.) unlike the Gen2 G19 w/ LW connector, the reset is very slow and pushing back w/ the same authority... it feels like something is grabbing/dragging somewhere where it shouldn't be internally. I'll have to do more testing a switch the LW units to see if the LW unit itself is not working or something other. I'll be ordering some more trigger parts to experiment. All in all, I'm very anxious to shoot this baby. I think I'm a set of night sights and possibly a connector or so, from what could be my newest favorite pistol.
-
Turkey Day!!!!
HAPPY THANKSGIVING TO ALL!!! A big +1 to the above. Have a great day!!!
-
Compact 9mm
Excellent choice and congratulations!!! Expecting range report soon!!!
-
Sig offering E2 conversion on existing 226/229
Is it what you would consider 2lbs or so lighter though? I'm considering having this package done as well. Definitely going for the E2 setup. I held a P226R Elite E2 in .40 recently and wow, what a nice pistol. This comes w/ the SRT, short trigger and of course, the E2 grip. The E2 grip really changes the ergos of the pistol for the better. Very much reminded of the P30L a fellow member let me shoot. What impressed me also was the Short Trigger and the Short Reset Trigger. Reset was considerably shorter and precise and the Short Trigger seemed like it a gave a wider flatter surface to pull against. With some polishing and lightening this would be a DA/SA trigger/grip setup that could really work for me. For FFL transfers, I've dealt w/ Craig from Police Products in, I think it's Midland Park. Pretty good rates and a nice guy who has some decent police trade in deals.
-
Sig SRT for 226
I have a '95 P226, older German made w/ folded carbon slide. Can the SRT be retrofitted in my pistol? Also, can the Short Trigger be retrofitted? Was at Bullet Hole today w/ my buddy. I saw they had an E2 in the display case. Turned out it was a P226 E2 Elite R in .40. I can't stop thinking about this pistol. The trigger was REALLY nice!!! The SRT totally changes the trigger. As mentioned, I have a '95 P226 for comparison. Also, my buddy had a P229 in .40 at the range. The combination of the short trigger/SRT trigger combined a wide flat surface that let the pad of my finger perfectly envelope it. The draw of the trigger, while expectedly being a little gritty and what not from it being a new in the box trigger, felt precise and intuitive. I cycled the slide while having the trigger depressed to check the SRT reset. Outstanding!!! The distance is at most 1/4", very Glock like. While it doesn't have quite as much spring push back as a Glock trigger, it's very good. I can't stress enough the feel of precision in everything about the trigger. All this combined w/ the new E2 grip provides probably the nicest pistol of this type I've ever put in my hands. I've had occasion to shoot an HK P30. I thought the E2 grip somewhat resembled the feel of the P30 grip, which is to say great. The great grip, great new trigger setup....... I WANT!!! While the P226's of the generation that I own were always known as a better example of a DA/SA trigger, the new setup is a substantial jump forward. I had my 2 G19's (Gen2 & Gen3) w/ me at the range today. I shot some really nice groups today w/ it. Feeling this Sig in my hand today, really made the Glock feel like a staple gun in comparison. Bottom line..... get the SRT trigger!!!
-
Thoughts on VLTOR rifle-length modstock...?
I like that. Are the fixed stocks A2 length only?
-
Thoughts on VLTOR rifle-length modstock...?
I'm running this very stock on my M&P15T(F). I bought it used on the EE at AR15.com. I'd prefer if it was the clubfoot design, but not a big deal. I can only compare it to the fixed, at full length out, collapsable that it came with. I do notice the 5/8" shorter length of the A1 length and prefer it. Since the M&P15T comes with a Troy free float (forget the specific model name, but it's the pre-Extreme model) it's kind of front heavy. The VLtor stock balances it very nicely. It's not that noticeable, but there is a difference in recoil. It's smoother. I picked this up just before Vltor announced the A5 buffer tube that is longer than the standard carbine tube. At some point, I may go this route w/ another rifle and pin a stock to the A5 tube. Call me a wuss, but I like having my cheek rest on plastic vs. the metal of the carbine tube. Lastly, it has tons of storage space w/ long tubes running down both sides of the stock. Everyone who has shot the rifle has commented on it being a big improvement over the faux collapsable that it came with. A couple of fellow NJ'ers I know w/ AR15's are considering doing the same to their rifles. I'm running an ACE skeleton stock on a Bushmaster and while the ACE is definitely lighter, I prefer the VLtor on the M&P for the better weight balance and all of what's mentioned above. As much as I like this stock, I do wish it was just a couple of inches shorter still. It would allow it to be pulled in nice and tight. Overall, I'm very happy w/ the stock. I figure, what's the point of having a collapsable that's not collapsable. Some pix...
-
P226 vs P229 9mm
I'm curious. Are you comparing the 229 to a stainless slide 226 or older stamped slide? I have an older German stamped slide P226 and I've shot my cousins P229 w/ Hoque grip. I found the recoil to be just about the same. Maybe it was the Hoque grips, I don't know. OT..... One big difference I find is the grip. I feel I can get a tighter better grip on the P228/229 frames vs. the P226. My buddy has 2 P229 .40's. The P229's seem to have better out of the box triggers over the P226's I've sampled. I shoot the P226 better though. The P226 is consistently the easiest pistol to shoot very very accurately for me. I can shoot just as well w/ other pistols, but for whatever reason, I feel I have to concentrate more and there is more effort involved. Please keep in mind, I do not like having a DA trigger. I always shoot the pistol in SA. Having said that, I've shot 5 or so different P226 9mm's and they have all shot superbly. It is my wife's favorite pistol to shoot and she shoots pretty decently w/ it.
-
Compact 9mm
Cool, glad the info helped!!! Some excellent choices your choosing from. Did you get your pistol yet???!!! What did you get???!!!
-
Compact 9mm
Greetings, My experiences.... Glock's My fav' is the G19. I have a 2nd and 3rd gen G19, a 2nd Gen G17 and have fired a Gen4 G19. If I were you, I'd get the Gen4 G19. I love my G19's, but, especially if you're buying new & as you noted, the Gen4 ergo's are better. I'm, very probably, going to purchase a Gen4 G23 tomorrow. I myself was considering getting a Gen4 G19, but I want to give the .40 a whirl in the Gen4 setup. From the reviews I've read, the new double recoil spring setup of the Gen4 makes a fairly noticeable difference in recoil control over the Gen3 and prior. If I buy the G23 tomorrow, my buddy is coming along w/ his Gen2 G23 to compare against. Also, you get the flexibility of changing to 357 Sig w/ barrel change and 9mm, with a barrel, mag, extractor and possibly recoil spring change. Having said that, I would not get a Gen3 or prior G23. I've shot the G26 and REALLY liked it. It was more accurate and controllable than I though it would be. However, I'd rather have the midsized G19/G23 if I'm only going to have one or the other. Also, I've read that the Gen4 G26 is coming quickly down the pipe. Mags average $25. I'm guessing they be had as low as $20 or so. Parts and very cheap, the gun is among the simplest to work on. All parts can be removed w/ a punch, except the front sight which only requires a hex head. Lone Wolf sells a combo tool for $20. Does everthing except rear sight installation/removal. Sig's Another option that I like is the Sig P228/P229. The 228 is a smidge lighter w/ better slide serrations and a recoil signature that can border on slightly snappy w/ hot ammo. Although I'm sure w/ some practice, it wouldn't be an issue. The 229 in 9mm is chunky but handles recoil like a W German P226, which is to say... beautifully, but has, bordering on too small, slide serrations. I have a German P226 from '95 and my buddy has numerous Sigs, including 2 P229 .40's from the 90's w/ really nice triggers out of the box. If you like DA/SA type pistols, Sig has among the best of the type. Both the P228 and P229 are among the best you can find in this class. Used examples can he had for very close to your price. Mags run $35 or so new. Last time I checked, it's been a while though, CDNN sold used factory mags in great condition for $20. Keep MegCar mags in mind as well, as they are sometimes the OEM for Sig mags. My buddy took the Sig armorers course and bought the Sig tools. I may be wrong, but I believe you're looking at somwhere around $100 for tools minus sight pusher. HK Another excellent option if you're willing to go used, is the HK USP9C. I have a USP45F and it is a fantastic pistol. I've shot the USP9C once for 5 rounds. For me, this was one of those pistols that, having never shot it before, that shot beautifully. I pulled a 1.5" 5 round group at 15 yards. On a gun I'm familiar w/, I've had some bests right at 1", but usually shoot 1.5-2" for 5 rounds, slow fire at 15 yards. Also, the recoil signature was probably among the easiest of comparable guns I've shot, to work with. If you like the idea of cocked/locked, this is one of the few of the type available. Once the trigger is broken in, SA is decent, DA is not the greatest. LEM trigger variants are available. If you can deal w/ a single stack, I believe you can find a used HK P7. It is heavy for what it is, only holds 8 rnds in the mag and has a really different action setup. It is amazingly accurate. The gun is capable of firing 1" groups at 25 yards w/ the right ammo. It has the, very unique, squeeze cocker that allows for extremely fast to action w/ a manual safety. It is gas operated, like a semi auto rifle, but differently done. The recoil signature is very unique. It cycles very fast, but with an extremely low bore axis, shot to shot strings are very fast while providing excellent shot to shot recovery. The downside to the gas system is uses, is that the frame heats up quickly. Put a box or 2 of ammo through the gun at a quick pace and you'll notice a temp difference. Mags in general for HK are among the most expensive of all brands. The USP Compact 9/40 mags, are among the cheapest of the brand. Last time I looked, a while ago, they could be had for $35 or so new. P7 mags are about $50 or so. So far, any of the aforementioned I would feel equally well armed with in terms of reliability, durability, accuracy and my ability to shoot well with them. M&P I have not shot the M&P9. I have the M&P40 that I picked up used about a year ago. The trigger the gun comes with absolutely sucks. It's not consistent, it's gritty as hell and the reset blows. I put in the Apex sear and polished the internals, based on Dave Burwell's instructions. I had to buy a sight pusher to remove the rear sight to get access to the firing pin plunger. Anyway, the trigger is now really nice. Reset is decent, the pull is lightened, but most importantly it's one of the smoothest triggers you'll find on a polymer gun. Having said that I'm selling it since the ergo's just don't work for me. I can't a good grip on the frame to where it doesn't move on me. I do very well w/ guns like the Glock w/ a blocky frames. I don't do as well w/ thinner more rounded frames. The gun is very reliable. I've put 500 or so rounds on the gun w/out a hitch. I'd love to give a M&P9C a whirl and see what that's like. ToodG on m4carbine.net has an M&P9 w/ something like over 65K rounds on the thing and he pulled a sub 2" group on the pistol at recent round count. I still may keep my pistol as I love everything about it, except the ergos. I understand S&W has recently released 15 rnd mags for the M&P9. This makes the pistol much more compelling. New mags are between $25 and $30. AR15 punches work on the pistol for tools. This and a sight pusher and you're good to go. XD I've owned and sold an XD9 Tactical and XD45 Tactical. My 1st experience w/ an XD was a rented XD9 directly compared to a Gen3 G19. I initially thought the XD was easier to shoot w/ better ergos. Upon firing more rounds, I discovered that even though it felt like I could shoot the XD better, my spreads were 2" bigger. Even slow fire, I couldn't shoot it well. A few months later, I bought the XD9Tact to give it a true try out. The idea of a long slide 15 round (we live in NJ after all) 9mm w/ rail sounded intriqueing. I put 400 or so rounds through it and wound up selling it. While I fire/dry fired it enough to smooth it out, the trigger was mushy w/ a bad reset. The gun was reliable in the 400 rounds, and factory 15 rnd mags sound great. I think mags are around $25, not positive on that. Don't know what's involved armorer wise. The Glock, M&P and XD seem to be among the more popular mid priced pistols. I've read quite a few accounts by people that seem to know their stuff that say the Glock and M&P are equals on a functional level. They've also mentioned that the XD is not in the same durability / reliability class as the Glock and M&P. I'm no expert, but the Glock has somewhere around 25 years history now and is pretty well proven. I do believe that the M&P is a great pistol on a functional level w/ a shitty trigger from the factory and ergo's that just don't work for me. Also, for me at least, I don't think they are as accurate as Glocks. The XD feels nice in the hand, but has the least refined feel of the 3. I should mention I thought the XD45 was a better built pistol than the XD9. On the other hand, I've read numerous accounts of very happy XD users. Other considerations... Walther P99 - Really accurate midsized pistol w/ a somewhat unique feeling DA/SA trigger. The one I've shot had a ski hump in the trigger guard that rubbed my finger raw when shooting it. Also, one of the more snappy midsized 9mm's. CZ75/P01 - I have a CZ75SA in .40 that is one of my most accurate pistols. 1" 5 round 15 yard groups are very doable w/ this gun. I've never shot a 9mm, but they have a great reputation. The triggers have a crude feel from the factory. While it is an accurate pistol, if you look in the slide, the finish is not in the same class as the more popular pistols. Personally, guns such as the Ruger centerfire autos, Taurus and what not don't interest me. Good luck in your search and shoot as many as you can. That will help a lot in your decision.
-
Glock 17 vs. Glock 21
I've got a 2nd gen G17, 2nd gen G19 and 3rd gen G19. I shot a G30 once in Las Vegas and slept at a Holiday Inn You mention you already have a G19. So, you already have a hi-cap fighting 9mm. I can only say great things about the G17 I own. I have the 2nd gen and prefer than gen. for the full size frame. I got mine used w/ Trij night sights, a trigger job and 4 10 rnd mags. I used to think the Sig P226 that I also own was a superbly accurate 9mm, and it is. I find the G17 w/ better sights, is just as accurate out to 25 yards. Recoil is very light and shot to shot recovery is very good. It's recoil signature feels slightly softer and more refined than a G19. It does seriously bother me that I can only get 10 rnd mags for a gun that's designed for 17rnd'ers. By the way, I've looked high and low and know of no place to get G17 15 rnd mags. I've never seen any for sale either. I could live w/ a 15 rnd mag in this gun. All in all, if you can live w/ the mag limitation, it is a truly superb fighting 9mm. I wonder if getting a G22 and a 9mm conversion would a more versatile choice? I've been lusting after a G21SF since they came out. I got to shoot a G30 in Las Vegas some years ago..... and I loved it!!! The G30 was what got me back into Glocks after owning and selling my 1st Glock, a G22. The G22 just never gelled w/ me (although I'd be curious to shoot one now after some years of shooting 9mm Glocks). I was somewhat of a newbie then and didn't like the .40 so much. What surprised me about the G30 was how easy it was to be accurate on, how controllable it was and how low the recoil felt. I have a USP45F and my buddy as the USP45C. I thought the G30 blew away the USP45C. Having blabbered about all that, I have to believe the G21(SF) is a great shooting .45 w/ really good capacity. I've read of a few instances of various reliability/durability issues w/ the G21 though. Was surprised to read Larry Vickers thought the least of the G21 in a comparison w/ an HK USP45F and some flavor of 1911. On the other hand, I've read a lot of great reviews as well. On one of the LEO forums, there are quite a few guys on there that love the G21. And then...... I've never read anything about any kind of issue w/ the G17. The only things I've ever read on the G17 have been extremely favorable, outside of the normal subjective criticism of the trigger and geometry of the grip. Good luck and let us know what you get.
-
My first AR. KAC SR-15 E3
That rifle is sweetness!!! Congrats on a great purchase. I've read nothing but outstanding things about that rifle. Any particular reason you went with this vs. say, some flavor of LMT, Noveske, etc? I've been giving thought to the MSAR AUG clone. After seeing this thing, the SR-15 is changing my mind. I'm running an Aimpoint C3 in a LaRue cantilever mount. I love it. Was at Ramsey Outdoor in Ramsey a few weeks ago and they had a surprisingly pretty decent selection of optics. They had a fullsize Aimpoint unit similar to the C3 and an H1, as well as various ACOGS and Accupoints and Leupolds/Nikons (including the M223 series). The gent behind the counter let me look though the H1 as I've been lusting after this. I loved the compactness and lightness. I did not like the view through the optic. The dot was big and seemed exageratingly so when coupled with the smaller inner diameter as compared to the fullsize units. I prefer the 2 MOA fullsize Aimpoints. My buddy has a 512 Eoteck. Love the reticle, but the battery life is a dealbreaker for me. I'm really digging the Accupoint. They had the 1.1x4 variant w/ 30mm tube and green triangle. If the unit were compact like an ACOG and had a BDC, this would be perfect.
-
big shout out to TRUGLO
Any idea what happened to the optic? How did it fail?
-
Battle Comp, NJ Legal?
You have the coolest toys!!! I have to ask, where did you get the Sr-15 and how much did it run you?
-
What is the most desireable GLOCK???
I have 3 permits in process. I'll, in all probability, wind up using 1. It will probably be a Glock. In the last 1.5 years, I've bought and sold an XD45 Tactical, XD9Tactical, and bought and am now selling, an M&P40 w/ Apex sear and trigger job. Neither the XD or the M&P work for me. Other than some flavor of P30, SigE2 P226/9 (both pistols I'm VERY interested in, but they are going to be more money than I want to spend. Glocks are the only other pistol I'm itching for. So, I find myself in a dilemma that' similar to the question asked here. I currently have a 2nd Gen 17 that I bought used and came w/ a trigger job. Also have a 2nd gen G19 and a 3rd Gen G19 (Austrian proofed :mrgreen: ). I've owned and sold a Gen3 G22. G26 - For me, the G26 is really high up there. I'm already stocking 9mm Glocks, and this would be a great compliment. Also, the smallest pistols I own are the G19, HK P7 and Walther P5. None of which are really that CCW worthy. I'd like to have A pistol I could comfortably use for that purpose. I shot one at the Bullet Hole not that long ago and shot a pretty tight group w/ it. Very surprised at the recoil. It was as, if not better, in it's pulse as compared to a G19. Lightly snappy w/out much muzzle flip. Nice combo for repeat hits. Yeah, this one is high on my list. 4th Gen G19 - I REALLY like the G19. Everything I'm reading about the new one is gravy to my ears. I've held a Gen4 G22 and immediately noticed the improved (for me) grip w/ the smaller frame. I've read numerous reviews that praised it's controllability when shooting fast. A lot of folks are mentioning improved accuracy over previous Gen's. Some folks have theorized that the slide barrel lockup in better on the Gen4's. But.... I already have 2 and there is something to be said about variety. 4th Gen G23 - I've shot my buddy's Gen 2 G23 quite a bit, and while I've learned to deal better w/ the snappy recoil it provides, I'm nowhere near as comfy on it as the G19. I understand the Gen4 has somewhat less recoil than earlier versions. I wouldn't mind having a Gen4 G19 sized .40 if I could control it well. G21SF - My only experience w/ a .45 Glock was a rented G30 in Las Vegas. I was really surprised how controllable it was and how accurate I was shooting it. I credit this pistol w/ giving me desire to try another Glock after not liking and selling my 1st Glock, a Gen3 G22. I've held a G21SF in Ramsey Outdoor, and while it was large, it was much better fit for me than the standard G21. I have a USP45F that is also large in the grip. Holding the G21SF reminded me of the girth of the USP. I find I shoot better w/ chunky fat grips. And come on....... it's a .45. G35 - Always really liked this pistol, although I've never fired one. I had the opportunity to shoot a G24C and shot the best group of my life w/ it. A one hole 3/4" for 5 rounds at 15 yards, witnessed. Even though I really didn't gel w/ the G22 I owned, dry firing a G35 in a gunstore left me w/ the impression that A.) I could keep the sights steadier than the G22 and B.) the longslide/barrel would probably make shooting this thing a joy. I've shot the G34 and it underwhelmed me w/ it's very wimpy feel in recoil. The slide felt it like it was lubed in molasses in recoil and took forever to get back to battery. I always thought the more pronounced recoil of the .40 would make a better balance w/ the longer slide/barrel. Only downside here is, AFAIK, Glock has no plans to do a Gen4 version. G30SF - As mentioned above, after renting one and putting 100 rounds through, I fell in love w/ this chunky monkey. It holds like a brick, but it shoots really well. Recoil control was better than my buddy's USP45C and SA Champion, and felt less snappy that these pistols as well. Within 3, 5 round strings, I was making 2" groups at 15 yards and had a few that were a bit smaller. The downside to this thing is, unless you just like smaller .45's, it looks too thick to comfortably carry. For HD, I would be using the G21SF before the G30SF. G20SF - If I was of the mind to try something different, this would be it. I like the feel of the G21SF frame and 15 rounds of 10mm....uber Zombie shooter. Gen4 G22 - While not high on my list, I've held one at the Bullet Hole and REALLY liked the feel of the new grip (one of my chief complaints of the Gen3). I always liked the idea of a 15 round .40 pistol. I understand the snappy recoil has been abated a bit w/ the new recoil spring setup. I'd be very curious to shoot one. The 357Sig and 45GAP models, I have no desire for. I've shot a G34 and it felt like driving a Corvette w/ only 6 cyclinders running. I like the G17 wayyyy better. The G27 would probably be a little brute to shoot.
-
Battle Comp, NJ Legal?
I called the NJSP today to ask about the legality of the Battlecomp. I s/w an officer DiPoulo (spelling?). I explained the Battlecomp was advertised as a compensator/muzzlebrake and is CA legal. According to the officer, if it's advertised as a compensator/muzzlebrake, that's what NJ would consider it. When I mentioned it was CA legal, he said it would definitely be NJ legal as well. How this would stand up in an NJ court of law, I can't absolutely say for sure. However, for myself, I have no hesitation in purchasing this unit for my AR's.
-
Battle Comp, NJ Legal?
For starters :text-bravo: , nice shooting!!! Where does one go to do that type of shooting in NJ? I'm up north, anything up this way would be great!!! To the OP, I had a thread going on this also. I got the same exact response that you did when inquiring if the BattleComp was NJ legal. I'm going to try calling the NJSP and see what they say. I would think this would be ok for NJ, but in this case being wrong could have serious ramifications. Has anyone ever tried calling the NJSP on matters such as this? Any pointers?
-
Bi-Weekly meetup at Bullet Hole
This sounds like a pretty hot load. Is recoil comparable to a .40 at that point? Do you have to use a specially chambered barrel for this load? Do I dare ask how much a pistol, such as the one being fired in the video, goes for?