Everything posted by rauchman
-
What choice for a 2nd gun?...
I agree about the comment of the .22. At least, consider a G23 .22 conversion. If you want to stick w/ the .40, I'd suggest a Glock 35. You already have the G23 going. This covers the CCW thing just about as well as the G27. I have a G23, 2xG19, G17 and G26. Size wise, there really isn't that much difference between the G23 and G27. The G35 would probably be an outstanding fullsize range gun.
-
GunForHire Tactical Carbine 1
Interesting. I have much to learn!!!
-
GunForHire Tactical Carbine 1
Thanks!!! I'm guessing 2.5 hours or so from where I am. Thanks for the info. Yeah, having the weapon bang into your nuts on a single point sling can have a, hmmmmm, rather detrimental effect on your shooting performance.
-
Ace entry skeleton stock....INSTALLED!!!!
I have both the A2 length and Entry sized ACE stocks on my AR's. I vastly prefer the Entry stock, even though it's still a little short for me. At some point in the very near future, I'll be adding a 1" extender that goes between the receiver and stock w/ QD sling mount hole. Knights and Fulton Armory both offer this (both in the $45-50 range) and DPMS offers the same w/out the QD sling mount (about $35). I'd like to purchase a Magpul, or similar type, collapsable stock (something w/ a cheek slope and possibly storage) and cut out the middle out to take the place of the foamy section on the ACE. I find the topside of the charging handle wears a little heavily since the foam pushes it up when being actuated. It absolutely sucks that the ACE Entry stock, the Sully stock and the miniturized A2 stock that I think DPMS carries, are the only smaller than full length fixed stocks available. I'd love to see something based on VLTOR's new A5 system w/ storage capability and different lengths available. I'm just not a fan of pinned collapsable stocks.
-
GunForHire Tactical Carbine 1
Excellent thread Cylinder Head. Thanks!!! I've been trying to find the time/$ to take that course. I agree that it's probably the best forum to test your gear. I recently picked up a Spike's 16" midlength upper w/ standard handguards that I want to run through a course 1st, before deciding on what to add/upgrade. Aside from having to pin the brake, are there any negatives at all to the Battle Comp you're running? This is the forerunner for a muzzle brake right now for me. Also, where the hell is Winslow, NJ?
-
Which AR barrel configuration?
Ironically, a barrel that I'm very interested in, is the Sabre Defense 18" CMV steel chrome lined midlength gas system w/ flutes both fore and aft of the gas block w/ 1/7 twist. Since Sabre's demise, I haven't found this barrel anywhere. I've come across a few users of this barrel on the 'net, and all had great things to say about it's accuracy. The only niggle w/ that barrel is the midlength gas system, vs an intermediate or rifle length system. From what I've researched, it was one of the better accuracy offerings using CMV steel vs. SS. As to the OP's barrel quest, CMMG may have what you're looking for. I know they make/made an 18" CMV steel, chrome lined, rifle length gas system, 1/7 twist in a medium weight contour (it might have been an HB contour...it's been a while). BTW, I voted 20" 1/7 chrome lined. I think this gives the most versatility in ammo weights, w/ negligable accuracy loss combined w/ the corrosion resistance of CL.
-
Finally picked up my Sig
Appreciate the info. Is there a link or something for more info on the range? Have you ever looked into the private clubs in Tenafly and Riverdale (always get Riverdale and Rivervale mixed up)?
-
Pure Sex
Thanks Cylinder Head!!! I'm guessing the dual recoil spring has as effect on slide speed as well. I have to believe that the different spring rates of the recoil spring unit, slow the slide in stages as it goes through it's firing cycle. As to your HK45, yeah, I'd like to shoot it and really compare the differences to the USP.
-
Finally picked up my Sig
Congrats on a choice pistol!!!! I have an older stamped steel slide P226 and have handled some the newer offerings. Really nice!!! In regards to the club, is that Northvale Bergen County? I've been looking for another option in addition to the Bullet Hole for local shooting.
-
So your only allowed to have 1 handgun for the rest of your life
I voted semi. Apart from that, choosing is tough. Ideally, some flavor of .45 would be the ONE. But, .45 is expensive. I'd probably go 9mm in any of the following flavors...in order HK P30 USP9C M&P9 G17,G19 If I could afford .45, then any of the following would work... in order HK45 USP45/C M&P45 G21SF
-
Range Report - Inaugural Outing For New Beretta 92A1
Congrats!!!! Very classy pistol. Glad you enjoy it. Have to get down to Shore Shot one day. I always hear nice things about that range. Only option in my neck of the woods is the Bullet Hole. Would like more options.
-
Glock inventory
Try either the Bullet Hole or Mike's Gunshop in Cliffside Park. They both honor GSSF pricing. Mike's, more so.
-
First Handgun!!!
I've got an M&P40F that was purchased as a used LEO trade in at the Bullet Hole about 2 years ago. The trigger I remember as being very crunchy w/ a very vague and long reset. The trigger now is the best of any polymer pistol I've put my hands on. I did the home trigger as outlined on the Burwell site and also installed an Apex sear. This was before the DCAEK trigger kit was out. Basically, all the contact points of the trigger bar have been polished, as well as the striker and firing pin safety. I would up buying the M&P sight pusher as you need to remove the rear sight to get to the firing pin safety. I may at some point install the Apex RAM setup, which is supposed to give a more pronounced and quickened reset. I have to say though that the reset is much better now than how I remembered it being stock. By the way, to the OP, congrats on your pistol. Excellent choice as a 1st. It's a gun that's very easy to shoot accurately and quickly. If you ever decide to put the DCAEK kit in from Apex, want to polish the firing pin or install new sights... let me know since I have the rear sight pusher.
-
Which 9mm RANGE Handgun $600 or less? (no conceal and no carry)
If accuracy is the overriding criteria, then the CZ. No other pistol you have listed here will match its mechanical accuracy potential. If you want THE most accurate pistol to be found in the $600 range, then the HK P7 will be the one to get. There have been a run of these as German police trade in's for the last few years. They typically run from the high $500's to the high $600's last I looked. I bought mine a few years ago for $650. No other pistol at that price point will have more mechanical accuracy unless you come across a screaming deal for a Sig P210 or something of that nature. The question is, can you as the shooter exploit that accuracy potential? If you want something where other factors come into play a little bit, then any of the pistols you have listed will be roughly equal in terms of performance. You really have to shoot them to understand their differences in things like recoil characteristics, reset, muzzle lift, how it handles in your hand when firing vs. how it feels just holding the pistol, etc. My pistol preferences are for Glocks, M&P's, HK's and Sigs. I like the CZ's for accuracy machines. I have an SA (Single Action)in .40 and it's THE most accurate .40 I've shot. I don't like that the pistol somehow seems cruder in manufacture and the trigger, while light, is not the best. I have, rather I should say, my wife has a Beretta 92FS, that is very accurate, but for me, hard to be accurate on. The grip is big and the trigger, while being very smooth, is heavy. I understand the main spring from the 92D model helps the trigger pull. As mentioned, I have an HK P7 that shoots laser beams and has a feel of sophistication that I haven't found elsewhere. But, past the accuracy and finesse equation, it's not what I would consider ideal for much else. It is small, but is far from light. I've shot an HK USP9C. It was very easy for me to be accurate on this little gem. It is VERY high on my list of "next pistol". I've shot a USP9/C, USP40/C, own a USP45F and have shot a USP45C & P30's of various flavors. I would have no hesitation buying a USP9/C, P2000 or some flavor of P30 if I came across one used in the $600 range. While most I've come across use a DA/SA type trigger, LEM (forget what this stands for) triggers are increasingly becoming popular. These allow a consistent SA weight trigger in a DA pull length. Sort of like a Glock trigger, but w/ 2nd strike capability in DA trigger weight. I've owned and sold a Springfield XD9mm Tactical. Of any pistol I've ever owned (somewhere around 20 or so), I thought the quality of the XD was the lowest. Extremely hard for me to be accurate on. Had very high hopes for that pistol. I've only shot an M&P in .40 (mine) and it has a lot going for it. Downside is, stock, the triggers leave a lot to be desired. I understand triggers in newer guns are better. If you're like most, plan to spend an additional $100 or so for better trigger parts, such as the Apex DCAEK. On mine, I've polished the internals and installed an Apex sear. The trigger on my M&P40 is now probably the best of any polymer gun I've handled. For myself and others I've read about, even though the pistol offers 3 different grips, the ergo's are "off" a little bit. Many do stippling or other grip mods. Overall, a really nice pistol, but for it to be optimal, plan additional funds and or time for your trigger. Sig has really nice offerings in the P226, P228, P229, if you're willing to go used, and the SigPro series for new purchase. Sig P226's are among the most accurate service type pistols. They've always maintained their accuracy and have been known for "To Hell and Back Reliability", whereas quality control on post 2004 models has been in question. The SRT (Short Reset Trigger) now available on newer Sigs, and as a retrofit to older Sigs, make's the Sig DA/SA trigger into the best trigger of this type, IMHO. I've gotten heavily into Glocks in the last few years. For me, they are the most rewarding pistols to shoot. For me, it took some time of frequent practice to get the Glock trigger down. The Glock is more accurate than most give it credit for. If it weren't for the mag situation, I would get a Gen4 G17 in a heartbeat. I have a Gen2 G17 and Gen4 G23, along w/ 2 G19's and G26. Of any, I like the G17 best for range time. It hangs w/ any service pistol out to 25 yards or so. Haven't fired much past that. W/ the Gen4 changes, I think the pistol would be perfect. G19 is a great choice, but if you really want to shoot for accuracy, this pistol is a little harder to be accurate on. I've read a lot of reports of Gen4 9mm's having issues, particularly the G19. I firmly believe Glock will sort this out at some point. I don't know if that point has been reached yet.
-
S&W M&P9 Pro Series 5"
That's outstanding!!! I have an M&P40. Love the pistol, not so hot on the caliber. Would love to replace w/ a 9mm. Can anyone recommend a FFL for transfer?
-
Glock inventory
Nice choice on the pistol. I have about 500rnds so far though mine. Changed out the trigger bar to a Gen3 (w/out the "hump"), polished it up and shoots very nicely. Has some of the snap of the previous Gen's taken out of it. The grip is a great improvement in size and texture.
-
Pure Sex
P30 - Excellent handgun in 9mm or 40. Probably, THE most ergonomically perfect in existence right now....purely subjective of course. I've shot Cylinder Head's P30L w/, I believe, Heine sights. I believe his was/is a DA/SA variant. I'd like to spend a day shooting 250rnds or so through one. The guns I've been practicing w/ lately are mostly 9mm Glocks and an M&P40. The P30 has a recoil pulse that has a distinct feel to it. The Glocks/M&Ps feel like they have a faster cycling sequence to them vs. the P30. Not to say that's good or bad, just an observation. The only real complaint I've read of the P30/HK45are the sights. They use a luminous substance that glows in the dark after holding a light source to them. I understand that's for Europe as they don't all tritium of nigh sights over there. But I understand it is very common to replace the stock sights w/ something else. Also, I understand they are more coarse than precision sights. A P30 or USP9C are very high up on my acquisition list. HK USP45/HK45 - I have a USP45F, my buddy has a USP45C and I've shot the HK45 a few times . Between the USP45 and the HK45, the ergonomic feel goes to the HK45. Like the P30, they feel great in the hand. Amazing feel, especially for polymer. Shooting them, they feel remarkably similar. The recoil signature has pretty much the same pulse to it. LIke the P30, the cycling doesn't feel to be as fast and gives a controlled pace to firing quickly (I know I'm not describing this correctly). Something for me that I've noticed when I really starting shooting Glocks heavily was that I shoot better w/ the blocky'er style grip frames. This applies to the USP45 and HK45 as well. The USP has a more rectangular grip frame, while the P30 is more oval. The trigger's have more or less the same feel w/ better reset going to the HK45. That is to say, long heavy smooth (smooth when broken in) DA and smooth (again, when broken in) long pretravel (more so on the USP) in a medium'ish 4.5lb SA trigger. I think the HK45 is a really nice pistol. I can't say I'm in any kind of rush to run out and get one w/ already having the USP. I think a good way to put it, at least to me anyway, is that the HK45 is the evolved version of the USP. Everything about the HK45 is a slightly more refined version of what the USP offers (outside of magazine capacity dropping on the HK45 to 10 from the USP's 12, this was done to keep the grip frame of the HK45 a smaller size). It absolutely goes w/out saying that, in my mind anyway, HK pistols are at the top of the heap in terms of reliability, as well as durability and accuracy. In terms of accuracy, at worst, HK's are among the best examples of other service type pistols. At best, they are among the elites. I have a P7 that is THE most accurate pistol I've ever fired (again purely subjective). I remember all the hype when the USP's appeared on the scene, and especially for the USP45, reading about all the testing done on these pistols. I went out and bought one and was seriously impressed w/ it. I've never had a bobble w/ mine and accuracy has always been superb. Controlled pairs are pretty decent w/ it. The ONLY major downside I see is the rail. The USP pioneered the concept on the onboard pistol rail. It's unfortunate that they didn't have the foresight to see the desire for a standardized rail, such as that found on the P30/HK45, vs the USP only rail. I have such an itch for a USP9C lately. Yeah, I know the P30 is the "uber'ist" HK 9mm pistol right now, but..... Was at the Bullet Hole and had the occasion to put a few rounds through a USP9C. I've never taken a pistol I've never shot before and shot so well w/ it. Again, I like a more blocky grip. Everything about it was perfect. Having said all that, I still like my Glocks. I, for some reason, find them more rewarding to shoot. Ehhh, it takes all kinds.
-
Glock 22 vs. XD 40
What's w/ the software. It keeps on translating "the" as "teh". And block keeps on coming out as block.
-
Glock 22 vs. XD 40
I've never shot the XD40, but have owned and sold, both an XD45 Tactical and XD9 Tactical. I've also and owned and sold a Gen3 G22, and now own a Gen4 G23, among a bunch of pre Gen4 block 9mm's. XD - I thought the XD45T was the better of the 2 XD pistols. The XD9 had a great grip feel, very reminiscent of a BHP. I did not like the trigger, nor the very high bore axis. For me, this was one the hardest pistols to be accurate with that I've ever shot. I can shoot a G17 and G19 considerably better... on a good day 1" 5rnd groups at 15 yards. The best I ever shot the XD was about a 3" spread for 5rnds 15 yards. I kind of liked the grip frame safety and definitely liked the ambi mag release. I understand wey're are some good aftermarket trigger solutions to the, for me, less then desireable XD trigger. G22 - Let me preface by saying... I LIKE GLOCKS!!! I bought my G22 at a time when I shot considerably worse then I do now. It was also at a time when I really didn't like the .40 and couldn't shoot a block to save my life. I've since learned the block trigger and find the .40 much more tolerable. Having said all that, the G22 would be my choice of teh 2 pistols your interested in. Especially, the Gen4 G22. I have nothing but blissful things to say about my Gen4 G23. The slightly smaller grip frame and slipfree texture are excellent. Also, I do believe that the recoil signature of the Gen4, w/ the dual recoil spring, is more pleasant in the .40 then previous Gen's. Slightly less recoil, less muzzle flip and less snappyness. Also, I believe the Gen4's are somehow a smidge more accurate. I did a direct comparison w/ my Gen4 to my buddy's Gen2 G23 and I could shoot the Gen4 a smidge more accurately. One word of caution on the Gen4's. wey have changed the trigger bar slightly for the new Glocks (I understand for all Gen's) and it makes the trigger a little heavier. You can still buy Gen3 trigger bars, but block just announced that wey will be only producing the newer trigger bars. Try to find part # GL0357. This is the smooth trigger faced trigger bar that would fit the G22. Of course the other popular option is the M&P40, which I also have. Also, a recommended buy. Different set of ergo's as compared to the block. Accurate, reliable and quickly becoming proven by various police departments. Get an APEX trigger package and you're set. If you go this route, let me know. I have the M&P sight pusher, which you will need to install the polished firing pin plunger from the APEX kit. I only have the sear and polished the internals myself. Makes a huge difference in the trigger for the better.
-
My .45 Sig P220 Match...
Wow, beautiful pistol!!! That should be a real tack driver. Enjoy that fantastic pistol and thank your dad by buying him a BMW or something
-
You really need to hold it or shoot it to know for sure
I had the opportunity to shoot a G21SF at the Bullet Hole a few weeks ago. I LOVED it. Totally floored me on it's soft shooting characteristics and recoil control. Shot it as accurately as a HK USP45F that I have, which is to say GREAT. Either that or a G30SF is my next pistol!!!
-
Range report Sig 226r w/ NS
Definitely check out the SRT. Makes the trigger have a more precise feel and of course, the reset is considerably shorter and not nearly as vague. Can't find anyplace that has the kit for sale though. Excellent info the "D" spring. Where did you get yours?
-
Range report Sig 226r w/ NS
Congrats on the P226!!! I remember when you got the G26, then, I think, the Taurus and the Beretta. I have the Beretta 92FS and P226 also, and for that matter, now the G26 as well. I know what you mean about the 2 pistols being very similar. I prefer the P226, but I'm very reluctant to get rid of the Beretta. It's a '94 model (bought in answer to the then new AWB) and it has no plastic parts in it. I find the Beretta a little challenging because of the heavy trigger. The pistol is very accurate, but because of that trigger, it's hard for me to be accurate on. And it's a huge grip frame. But, the slide feels like it rides on ball bearings...really smooth. I have to get a few parts for various guns, but amongst them, I do want to get the hammer spring from the 92D model. Supposed to be lighter, but still provides reliable primer ignition. I've read it's supposed to bring the DA weight to about 8lbs, vs. the normal 10+lbs of the 92FS. While the DA pull is heavy, it is very smooth. As others have mentioned on the slide not locking back, it's a thumb thing. I run into the same problem w/ Glocks. I've modified my grip to have my strong thumb (right hand) tucked under the left thumb. Slightly modified from the thumbs forward grip. I'm planning on getting the E2 grip and SRT for my P226 also. I held a P226 E2 Elite in .40 at the Bullet Hole and I REALLY REALLY liked it. Gives it a feel reminiscent of a Browning High Power.
- M&P 9
-
G17 VS G19
Uhhhhh.... Not getting into caliber debates here. In answer to the OP's question... I have a Gen2 G19, Gen2 G17, Gen 2.5 (I think) G26 (recently purchased used), Gen3 G19 and Gen4 23. I am the most accurate shooting the G17 slow fire. The G19's & G23 are right behind as is the G26. However, when shooting faster than slow fire, I find the G19's and surprisingly, the G26 to excel over the G17. The difference I notice is the hump on the backstrap of the grip. The G17's sits very low, the G19 higher and the G26 higher yet. The higher the hump, the better control I have in shooting. I find the G17's grip to be vague, whereas the smaller offerings give me more control on repeat shot recovery. If the G17's backstrap hump were higher up in the grip, I have to believe greater control could be obtained...for me. Also, changing out the sights dramatically increased accuracy capability for me. I have yet to change out the sights on the G26, but I was pulling 12 yard 5 round groups averaging 2" during my one outing w/ it. Having said all this, I am most impressed w/ the Gen4's slightly smaller grip design as well as the newer texturing. My next 2 Glocks are a Gen4 G35 & Gen4 G21 or Gen3 G21 SF....maybe a Gen4 G19 too!!! As a side note, at some point I want to purchase a Gen3 G17 and chop it to take G19 mags. I'd like to experiment w/ raising the hump in the backstrap as well.