Everything posted by rauchman
-
M&P40 -> M&P9 - conversion barrel
I believe (don't know for sure) that you can not use a Glock G19 barrel in the G23 as there is enough of a difference in dimensions that it can't be used. Having said that, I believe companies like Lone Wolf, Storm Lake, etc., do make dimensionally correct conversion barrels for the G23 to shoot 9mm.
-
What's your fav .40?
Greetings OGG, Yes, the M&P40 provides less snap than pre-Gen4 G23's. Having both an M&P40 and a Gen4 G23, I'd say they are very similar. I'd go out on a limb and say the Gen4 G23 has slightly less snap, but I think that's because the Gen4 G23 fits my hands better. I've shot my Gen4 G23 against my buddy's Gen2 G23 w/ Hartz recoil reducer and we both agreed the Gen4 handles the snap of the .40 better. I have permits coming, one of which is spoken for (M&P45). I'm contemplating a Gen4 G22 or G35, since I'm so impressed w/ the Gen4 G23. Let me know if you'd like to do a comparison. I shoot at the Bullet Hole and will be there the Saturday after Labor Day.
-
My new shooting sport toys
Wow, BLINGALICIOUS!!!!
-
The one that sleeps close to me...show me the one that sleeps close to you...
Totally agree on the hearing protection. If you have time to put it on, it would be a wise thing. No pic, but currently have a P226 9mm and Surefire 6P for the wife on her side of the bed, and a Gen3 G19 w/ Streamlight TLR-1 for me. Debating on switching out the G19 for the Gen4 G23 that I also have. Mental note to self...... have to get a shotgun.
-
Another "which 3rd handgun" query
Maybe I missed it, but I'm not sure what function the 3rd pistol will be used for. Is it for gaming, HD, just to have??? You currently have 2 great pistols in 9mm. How do you like them? How would you rate their Pro's/Con's? What do they not do that you're currently missing? Of the pistols you have listed, I think one of the CZ variants or BHP would be my pick. Beware, that the BHP comes w/ a horrid trigger and potential hammer bite. I had one that I picked and loved the pistol..... outside of the worst trigger I've ever experienced (and yes, I took the mag safety out) and repeated hammer bite in the web of my right hand. If you're willing to drop a few bucks on a trigger job and a Cylinder & Slide hammer kit, it is a really nice pistol. I have a CZ75SA (single action only) .40. I'm sorry I didn't get the 9mm, but the pistol is laser beam accurate. I understand the newer CZ's are built w/ better fit/finish as compared to the 75/85 series. I've owned and sold an XD9 Tactical (not to be confused w/ the XDM). I didn't like it at all. It fit the hand very well, but had a terrible inconsistent trigger and the rear of the slide would raise every so slightly in an inconsistent manner just before the trigger would break. I couldn't shoot it very well at all. As for the 1911, this can go so many ways. You could spend $500 or so for a low end 1911, or you could spend a fortune and get a real quality pistol. Off the top of my head, for your max of $1300 a SA Trophy Match or similar, or mid-level S&W would be my choice. I'm sure there a lot of makes available in this price range. While I have P226 and an HK USP, I'm really a Glock fan. My recommendation would be for a Glock of some flavor, especially the G26 since you don't have a subcompact of any type. If you don't go for the Glock, I'd still recommend something in the compact to subcompact since you don't have one. Otherwise, you're really just getting another flavor of what you already have. Good luck and let us know what you get
-
M&P40 -> M&P9 - conversion barrel
Already purchased mags. 15rnd'ers of course Excellent info. Didn't realize Midway sells M&P uppers. Already have 5 (and still like them better than the M&P's, but want to use the M&P as an experimental platform). Should mention, I came across a used M&P45 for $360 OTD at Bullet Hole that has been bought. Just waiting on my permits. Should be very soon (hopes it's very soon). In handling the 45 (holding not shooting), the frame is just different enough that it fits my hands perfectly, whereas the 9/40 platform feels like it's almost there. I found this thread on ar15.com. From what a few people have posted, the M&P9 barrel will work reliably in a M&P40. I should say I picked up an M&P9 barrel, but won't be able to shoot it until the weekend after labor day. Very excited to see how this works.
-
S&w .223 sport
The Nitride coating on the barrel w/ 5R progressive 1/8 twist on the barrel sounds REALLY interesting. I wish they could use 4150 steel instead of the 4140 steel, but I don't think it's that big of a deal. I would guess that this barrel will be more accurate than a typical chrome lined barrel.
-
Ordered a PSA Hammer Forged 16"
Nice!!!! I've read some great things about the PSA uppers lately. I came really really close to really pissing off the wife and getting a 20" upper.
-
MSAR STG-556 reviews
Doesn't Steyr now offer an AUG that takes AR15 mags?
-
M&P40 -> M&P9 - conversion barrel
Greetings, I have an M&P40 and have read that it will take a S&W M&P9 barrel and work. Anyone have experience w/ this? Does it work and work well?
- Sp-01 vs 75b
-
beretta 96d
My 1st pistol was a Beretta 96 Centurian, bought just as the '94 AWB was hitting. My wife, then girlfriend, bought the 92FS at the same time. I thought the 92FS was a cream puff to shoot. Really light recoil, w/ a heavy'ish trigger and a super smooth action (common to all 92/96 pistols...refering to the super smooth slide action). I held onto the 96 for about 6 years or so. At some point, I picked up a G22 and had experience w/ a G23 and a variety of Sig .40's. I thought the .40 was less than ideal for the 96 design. It really felt stout in this frame and, for lack of better term, felt like it was really beating up the pistol. From what I've seen, a lot of PD's that were originally issued some flavor of 96, are not using them anymore. I remember Beretta came out w/ the Brigadier model that was supposed to be a beefed 96, but I don't know if Beretta even offers these anymore. I have no experience w/ the DAO trigger, except to say I dry fired one in the old Navy Arms. I remember the trigger as being very long, but smooth and lighter than the DA of a DA/SA Beretta trigger, but not near as light as the SA trigger of a DA/SA.
-
sig Pro series
I've gotten one of my co-workers into shooting and she just picked up her 1st pistol... a SigPro 2022 (9mm). She had been looking at an HKP30, G19/G17 and a S&W M&P9. There were no P30's available to play with at any of the local stores. She's so-so on the Glocks and found the M&P heavy and the grip so-so. Meltzer's had the 2022. I had shot a SigPro .40 some years ago and was really surprised at how well it shot. I have a '96 Sig P226 and my buddy has just about every P22X Sig made as a comparison. Basing my observations on my co-worker's Sig 2022, of all the Sig's I've shot, for whatever reason, the SigPro has about the best DA/SA I've felt, next to my buddy's well worn P229. Accuracy is as good as my P226, which is to say.... excellent!!! I personally find the grip ergo's a little weird (read... kind of an awkward fit), but that's me. There are, I believe, 3 different grip panels that are available for fit preference. Again, the pistol had a great trigger and was very accurate. I understand these pistols are very popular w/ Euro police dept's.
-
What's your fav' NJ legal stock config?
Greetings, I have a couple of AR's and I always find myself wishing for something better than the current options out there for Ban type rifle stocks. I love the LMT SOPMOD and VLtor A5 Emod setups, but I can't stomach spending $200 + on one of these setups to wind up pinning them. Right now, I'm running... Vltor Riflestock ACE Skeleton Stock ACE Entry Stock A2 I should just design a true "BAN" compliant stock, have someone build it and be done with it.
-
What's your fav .40?
.40 guns I've owned... Beretta Centurian 96, Gen3 G22, CZ75SA, M&PF, Gen4 G23 .40 guns I've fired other than owning... Sig P229/P226/P239, Gen3 G23, Beretta PX Storm, XDM, USP40 F & C. Of them all, I like the Sig P229 and Gen4 G23. My buddy owns the P229 and it is a superb .40 pistol. Only downside is that it's heavy. The Gen4 G23 that I recently picked up is really nice as well. Those subtle ergo differnces, new texture and dual recoil spring turn it from a snappy, hard to control pistol, to a perfectly ergo'd (for me) pistol that tames the .40 snap just enough to be controlable. I also find the Gen4 easier to be accurate on. Have to say, I've been lukewarm on the .40 for awhile. The Gen4 G23 rekindled my .40 love. Seriously thinking of a Gen4 G22 or G35 now.
-
Glock 26, 27 and 23 need info
I've got a G26 (along w/ a Gen 2 G17, Gen2 G19, Gen3 G19 and Gen4 G23). I shoot at the Bullet Hole and will probably be there this Sat morning. I mostly shoot the G19. Going to the G26 from the G19, takes real focus for me to be accurate with it. If I only shoot the G26 at the range, I can shoot it well. If I'm mixing in other pistols, my accuracy degrades quickly on the G26. For me, I'm sure it's about lack of practice on the platform. Mechanically, I think it's very accurate. User interface wise, again for me, it takes more focus than the mid and fullsize frames.
-
What do the increments mean on the elevation dial of an AR-15 rear sight?
Read this.... Molon's RBIZ sighting setup info
-
Ideal first handgun? - Glock 19 Gen 4 vs Beretta Commercial M9
I have a Beretta 92FS, a Gen2 G19, Gen3 G19 and Gen4 G23. As others have said, try to shoot them first and handle them. Very different feels. Beretta Pro's Accurate Cheap Mags (btw, if you stick w/ Beretta factory and/or MecGar mags{MecGar does runs of mag production for Beretta and Sig}, you should have no mag issues) Very smooth and low recoiling - The Beretta 92/96 slide feels like it's on glass. Smooth trigger Large - Nice for a range gun Sights - At least on mine, that was from '94, the sights are kind of small and are excellent for accurate shooting. I don't know if they've changed from mine, but mine can not be changed out as there is no dovetail. Con's Grip is big and the DA trigger is a long reach Long / little heavy trigger pull. If you replace the main spring w/ the one from the 92"D" model, this will lighten the trigger nicely Heavier than the Glock Slide mounted safety - Most folks prefer a frame mounted safety, for others, this is no big deal. Large- Big for carry (living in NJ, this is probably not an issue) Typical weakness in the design is the locking block. I forget the expected lifespan of these (I want to say 20K, but not sure if that's correct). Sights- While the small sights are great for accuracy at the range, they aren't the best for a quick sight picture. Gen4 G19 Pro's Accurate - I know many people don't find Glocks to be accurate, but in my experience, Glocks will run w/ just about anything comparable Lightweight Mags and parts are cheap and plentiful Consistent trigger w/ very good reset Trigger can be customized w/ parts and polishing relatively cheaply Long sight radius for size of pistol. Compact - The G19 is arguably, the most efficient marriage of firepower and size. Con's Trigger does not have the graceful feel that is found on the Single Action trigger of a Beretta, Sig, etc. Trigger, for me, was hard to master and took A LOT of dry fire and range practice. Many reports of "issues" on the Gen4 G19. I LOVE the G19, but have to admit, the many "issues" I've read about would prompt me to research how far fixes have evolved. Having said that, my Gen4 G23 has been flawless in 750 rnds so far. Lack of a manually operated safety. The Glock does require the user to be very cognisant of firearms safety. Compact - The G17 is a better range gun (have one of those too). Typical weakness in design - I shattered the breach area of my Gen2 G19 from excessive dry fire w/out snap caps. I also broke the trigger spring. I understand the trigger bar in the new Glocks have a slightly redesigned tang that holds the trigger spring and is supposed to help lengthen trigger spring life. As far as the breach shattering, don't dry fire w/out snap caps. Stock sights are not the best. If you want to shoot for accuracy, change out the sights or buy w/ night sights already installed. I have a mix of Trijicons and Meprolights Night Sights for my 5 Glocks and they both have a much superior sight picture as compared to the stock sights. The stock sights do work well for reactive tactical type shooting, but are too coarse for finer shooting. Most night sights give a good combination of both fast and precision. Both guns are really nice and excel in the type of pistol they are. If it were I, I would probably start w/ the Beretta as a newbie shooter. It's an easier to gun to learn on for accuracy at the range. The Glock, for me, was harder to get good on. I can now put 5 rnds into 1" or so at 15 yards on a good day. Took a lot of dry fire and range time to get there, and I know there are a lot better shooters than me. For me, the Glock is more rewarding to shoot. The Beretta, along w/ Sigs, are a little easier to shoot for accuracy w/ their smooth SA trigger. I think the Glock is a better expression of a modern combat pistol, pure tool. The Beretta, being a metal pistol and being Italian, has an elegance and grace to it that the Glock will never have.
-
Steyr M9-A1 in 9mm, compact
Have no direct experience, but anytime I've read threads about the Steyr M series, they were ALWAYS favorable. I understand the trigger is supposed to become very good after some rounds are on it, as compared to other striker pistols , such as the Glock.
-
Excellent deal on Fed .40 EFMJ 165gr
Was finally able to run a few rounds of this ammo. I only shot 25 rounds or so of this, but it was easily consistent w/ the Blaser Brass practice ammo I was also shooting yesterday. Shot out of a Gen4 G23 w/ Meprolights night sights. The attached is a 5 rnd group at 15 yards. Other groups were w/in this range. This is the only one posted since the rest of the target was also showing a newbie shooter I had brought along w/ me. Felt like I pulled the upper right shot a little. BTW, that' just over 1 3/8". At 25 yards, this would be about 2 1/3". Not bad.
-
What choice for a 2nd gun?...
Sweet!!!! Congrats!!! While I'm not too crazy about the .40, the Gen4 G23 is one of my fav's in my inventory.
-
Brought home the second baby
Wow, beautiful pistol!!! Congrats and give us a range report!
-
Not exactly another "What should I get next?" thread
Definitely agree that hand fit is going to make the difference here. For me, the texture of the M&P is way too slippery to get a consistent hold shot to shot. I find myself resetting my grip after just about every shot. Also, it's hard to explain, but the very high hold grip on the backstrap doesn't flow w/ the front strap. The area under the trigger doesn't place my middle finger in a good position. Have to really give the nod to the Gen4 Glocks on their texture. My hand does not slip at all from shot to shot when shooting the G4 G23. As mentioned, individual hand geometry will be the deciding factor here. ETA - Was doing sight presentations w/ a G3 G19 and the M&P40 last night. The M&P does come to line of sight a bit easier.
-
Not exactly another "What should I get next?" thread
I'll throw my $.02 in.... I have a Gen4 G23 and an M&P40. Recoil signature is very similar...that is to say, the .40 just isn't a fun round to shoot. While I like the M&P, it doesn't fit my hand as perfectly as I would think, considering it comes w/ 3 backstraps to play with. Actually, I find the midsized Glocks (especially, the Gen4) fit my hands better. OTOH, the M&P45 fits my hand like a glove. The M&P45 is very high up on my list of pistols I'd like to shoot. Sticking purely w/ 9mm and .40 .40 - As mentioned, the .40 is well known as a snappy round. The only pistols I've fired it in where I thought it was close to enjoyable were metal framed pistols. I have a CZ75SA in .40 and the .40 is not bad in that pistol. Also, my buddy has a couple of Sig P229's. That, along w/ the P226, are the nicest pistols I've fired a .40 out of. The extra weight helps negate some of the snap of the .40. Having said all of that, I'm really hot on someday getting a Glock 35....in my mind, the ideal .40 pistol. 9mm - Wow, lots to choose from here. HK P30/P2000/USP© are high in my book. Excellent accuracy and reliablity/durability. Sig P226/P228/P229, all excellent and accurate 9mm's. Surprisingly, the CZ75/85/P-01 9mm's are very very accurate pistols. At least on the CZ75 .40 I have, while accuracy is excellent, quality of construction is a little crude. HK P7/M8, extremely accurate pistol, but it does have it's quirks. The P7 should be able to be picked up for between $550-$650 as a German police trade in. It has a recoil signature like nothing else. M&P 9, mentioned because S&W actually produces 15rnd mags for this pistol, unlike Glock w/ the G17. I should say here, that while I do like the M&P, I don't think it is quite fully evolved yet. Others may disagree w/ me on this, but I think S&W still has a bit to go. I understand new manufacture pistols are supposed to be pretty well sorted out though. 9mm's that I lust over.... HK P9/S, Steyr GB, HK P7M8, Sig P210. Good luck and let us know what you get.
-
XD OR GLOCK
Why one is comparing a fullsize 9mm w/ 17rnd mags to a fullsize .45 is a little off for me, but to each their own.... Owning 5 Glocks, an M&P and having owned and sold 2 XD's...... The only one I'd stay away from is the XD. I know some people love them. The fellow member who bought my XD45Tactical, was on his 10th. No, not buying and selling 10. The one he bought from me was the 10th in his collection. To be fair, of the XD's, the .45 is the one to get. It seemed to be slightly better constructed, had a more consistent trigger and was easier to be accurate on vs the XD9 Tactical, that I had also purchased at that time (remember those days of buying 2 handguns at once???? ). I'd be curious to try one w/ a trigger job. Both Glocks and M&P's have their own quirks. Users are finding out that new production Glocks (both Gen3 and Gen4) have issues w/ the extractor. I have both a Gen3 and Gen4 that I have ZERO issues with. Also, Gen4's may have issues w/ recoil spring weights. Again, mine are fine. Have 1K plus through both pistols. M&P's generally get after market trigger parts through Apex. Also, for me, even though the M&P comes w/ different backstraps, I can't say the ergo's on any of them are ideal. I'm sure this is blasphemy to the M&P world, but I find my Glocks better ergonomically, especially, the Gen4's. You really have to go shoot them to see the differences.