Everything posted by JHZR2
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
I agree on us winning and nobody getting caught.
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
Two word response, huh? Do tell, enlightened one...
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
The comment I saw above, unless I misread, was really more oriented towards LEO, and their potential willingness to strip and arrest in light of blatant disregard for constitutional rights as has been recently legislated The fact that vets and hunters were listed, wasn’t an attack on those groups, but rather because those groups tend to be more cherished than others, vets because of their sacrifices, and hunters, because they’re supposed to be benign and the embodiment of what the left things 2A is for (well, that plus muskets). I think the point was to arrest a tacticool desk jockey commando, or an actual criminal, would shake the public at large up less than if it were one of these more cherished groups. Just my interpretation.... not a dig against vets.
- Shooting In CA Country Bar
-
epoxy mag pistol floor plates with magblocks
Recently I saw a picture of an AR mag like that. Essentially a riser on the floor plate, then a shirt spring. Break off the riser and you can’t use the spring. Therefore the baseplate need not be permanently attached. The baseplate needs to be epoxied with a magblock because the spring is still full length. ... is my non professional observations. I’m sure this has been discussed ad nauseum, but if a roll pin is good enough for pinning an AR stock, I can’t see why it wouldn’t be good enough to pin a mag. But do your own due diligence.
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
Is there precedent in other states for this? The former seems like a major hassle that out of state vendors would ignore. The later seems like an interstate commerce issue.
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
So since we are soon a damaged class due to faulty lawmaking (forget the matter of capacity for just a second, assume that sticks), where we are felons without severe financial ramifications on our private property. So where are the lawyers? Where is NJ2AS with their whole “there will be repercussions” strong talk? Where is someone suing the governor, bill sponsors and all representatives who voted yes, for the real and personal financial penalty this puts on the citizens? There was a post in one of these threads about the tax loss form. Why aren’t we attempting tomtake this out personally on the basis of financial damage? Are these people immune by law???
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
Poorer people tend to not have vices. Therefore this law is an attack on the poor. Perhaps someone can be professionally outraged about that. Though I guess kids safety trumps that...
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
Joke about it and/or my commentary above, but that IS what was stated in the guidance document they provided . Use a vice to crush. Must be some reason to state that explicitly. Frankly I found all the guidance disappointing. Nothing but very rudimentary items that are common sense, and a sales pitch for gunsitters. The “non-obvious” approaches they defined were obvious and not particularly innovative. They could have weighed in on a variety of things in more detail, and provided more value. For the hundreds of dollars I’ve provided for this, I’m not seeing that guidance as an appreciable value added, personally.
-
ANJRPC RELEASES GUIDE TO COMPLY WITH MAGAZINE BAN
They talked about crushing in a vice. To me that means that there is potential for scrutiny based upon intrinsic size/length. Springs could easily be acquired out of state. I wouldn’t want to be the schmuck caught with mag bodies that an overzealous prosecutor could claim to be easily manufactured back with some springs. After all, Home Depot sells springs, right??? (roll eyes, but never underemphasize the stupidity of the public). Insane, but wouldn’t put it past some.
-
Magazine Ban Upheld
Yeah, sure, we were given 180 days. On a contentious topic that had a suit filed how many days after? The law causes permanent, irreversible damage. The law can not assume that law abiding gun owners have a place in PA or some other state to stash their property. So the only options are to dispose (making a sa firearm either a single shot firearm or useless without new acquisition of an item to make it functional), or, irreversible, permanent change to their existing mags. So now the bill sponsors, one’s representation if they voted for the bill in “representing” you, the governor who signed it into law, and the court who owes a timely response ALL have a fiduciary responsibility to the population whose private property they affect. So if the law is upheld, there is financial damage that should be recovered against legislators and the governor. If the law is struck down, anyone who already bought, disposed or damaged their property should be able to recover damages for faulty law writing. Because it is reasonable and prudent for a reasonable, rational human to wait for an outcome on a contested topic, the court inherits a fiduciary responsibility, and an owed responsibility to the population to make a decision at law with sufficient time for a person to take action BEFORE the enaction date. If the court is unable to maintain this responsibility, they should too be liable and responsible for damages which could come from people waiting upon their action and responsibility and then left with insufficient time to act. The discriminator here is an effect, an irreversible effect, on private property, with zero grandfathering or other methodlogy to prevent private property from being rendered useless or else incurring substantial cost. I find it hard to believe that there is such immunity for these people that there is no recourse whatsoever, even on a person by person basis in something as simple as small claims court.
-
Magazine Ban Upheld
Serious thought. If that work out that way, it creates an impractical amount of time for law abiding citizens to react. What recourse do the citizens at large have against such irresponsible behaviors? Technology issues causing a redo is a very weak argument. They need a sense of urgency and held to a standard. Similarly, not that representation cares, but given the time this has taken, how about petitioning/demanding the legislature defers enaction?
-
Magazine Ban Upheld
I doubt the masses have spoken on this topic. As much as the demand action type groups would make you think everyone is on their side, I think when the actual basis of how the law currently stands is clearly stated, most people wouldn’t agree with going much further. But I think the wanting things for free; the “it’s the economy stupid” group thinks they’re always deserving something more that the left will give them; and those who are wanting other social justice are voting for other reasons and it sticks. Ive been out in CA a few days and was listening to talk radio (all liberal on the radio in the Bay Area) for entertainment at first. Made me sick. So many half truths spoken as fact. At least we can tune into balanced programming on the east coast...
-
Magazine Ban Upheld
Ive often wondered if there is grounds or ability for every party harmed to sue, in small claims court, the gov and at least the sponsoring parties, if not your local “representative” assuming they voted for it. All have a part in financial harm caused to you through no fault of your own. Standard language could be written, and people could adjust it to their specific need. Sue every one of them. They’ll call the cops and report it. The mags will become theirs. Are cops grandfathered??
-
Magazine Ban Upheld
I like it. I’m in at least for a legal review of prior precedent.
- Shooting In CA Country Bar
-
Shooting In CA Country Bar
Unfortunately the associated logic behind this results in justification for nationwide high capacity ban. As an agenda item while ignoring the 800 lb gorilla in the room. Their logic is simple, and easy for us to relate. Anyone from NJ could drive to PA or DE tomorrow and buy high cap mags. And since they’re crazy and likely to be dead in a few hours, who cares if having them breaks the law. That makes the case for nationwide “common sense” gun laws. Again, ignoring the fact that the 99.999% of law abiding people pose zero risk with these items, and the 0.001% of crazies will just find another way to harm people.
-
Magazine Ban Upheld
$12? TD charged us $75/yr for not a very big one, and we keep a decent balance. Where so you bank?
-
National reciprocity?? where are we
Again, read my whole post. Perhaps there are other strategies in play. To chalk it up to unwillingness - you’re saying that some small group pandering to our agenda was unwilling to champion? There wasn’t a single person trying to ignore the spark? You’re right - they could find time, if the handlers said to. None of us are that smart. Certainly the political strategists who lay this all out daily, as opposed to us spending 20 minutes a day on a web forum, have given it some thought. Perhaps I’m wrong and assume too much. But I think there’s a strategy to everything. To me, there’s an established basis that the legislature changes hands mid term. It happened with Obama, it’s happening with Trump, and likely happened countless other times. Is the play to have a success now, knowing that will happen anyway, or is the play to empower your 2A voting base to either react or affirm, in 2020?????? “I don’t care what you did for me yesterday. I care about what you’re doing for me today” type of logic.
-
Magazine Ban Upheld
I have an issue with a lack of aggression and action on part of ANJRPC and NJ2AS. Primarily on the basis that so much of what the state enacts either inconveniences, or could turn normal people who would be doing normal things in 47 or so of the rest of the states, into felons over minutiae. There’s a level of protection against that, which even if not resulting in CCW or other doctrine, should be blatantly critical. I don’t know how many didn’t vote or didn’t donate. Some data analysis may shed some light into notional scenarios at least. But some better game plans and definition of how much of a war chest is needed might help. Clear and definite communication. Overwhelming cases.
-
National reciprocity?? where are we
On the other hand, look how much other/worse stuff could have happened when Obama had both the House and Senate. AWB? Yes I know they were pushing ARRA and healthcare, but they did have the opportunity for a streamlined free for all. Point is, majorities all over don’t always get everything done, and swings midterm happen. If anything, the polarity pendulum is swinging more wildly cycle after cycle. With that being the case, next swing could be further in the favor of our side. I wouldn’t doubt this was all a ploy - that often there is a shift midterm, now create the optic of who is holding up these rights, and force the discussion and balance of power again in 2020. After all, SCOTUS should be favorable, and only more favorable as time goes by, but that’s a last ditch effort amongst the slow roll of politics. And they want to slow roll stuff to keep getting certain groups’ vote. Seems to me that a midterm victory on this wouldn’t be as beneficial for Trump getting a second term, as either a late-term win, or the polarizing optic of just whomis preventing it, right before people go to the polls in a Presidential year. But maybe Immway off base?
-
NJ SUPREME COURT TO ISSUE OPINION THIS MONDAY ON JILLARD CASE!
“Given that the justifiable need requirement does not infringe upon a clearly enumerated right, and, even if it did, it has been upheld under traditional judicial scrutiny, our holding in Wheeler should not be disturbed on the basis of Jillard's meritless misunderstanding of Heller. Simply put, Heller precluded untethered subjective judicial inquiries into firearm regulations to determine their constitutionality, not valid subjective case-by-case justifiable need inquiries under constitutional firearm regulations.” So they assume that Jillard doesn’t understand and apply Heller appropriately, via an assumption on justifiable need. They did not provide their objective standrd that defines the basis of their assumptions and faith in defining and employing justifiable need, including the fact that it may be determined on a case by case basis with variable human involvement. What a terrible ruling, and misunderstanding of the statistics and reality of the situation!
-
S2465 Passed Assembly Today
Not trying to be argumentative; but to learn. Can’t buy a handgun across state lines except for via an ffl transfer, no?? The burden of proof lies on the prosecution or on one of us that would love to learn about gunsmithing by making one of these (or a flintlock kit for all it matters I guess). This my discriminator, if you can’t prove that you have a residence elsewhere that makes you eligible as a resident of that state for some time, then I’d suspect they could try to throw the book at you. The only case then is that manufacture isn’t illegal in _____, and that comes back to who has he burden of proof. You may be innocent until proven guilty, but if they want to make an example, may get $$.
-
S2465 Passed Assembly Today
The AG claimed these were illegal months ago. https://www.nj.com/politics/index.ssf/2018/06/murphys_ag_fires_warning_shot_at_ghost_gun_makers.html if this was overstepping bounds, where is the NRA suing over restrictions on interstate commerce and misrepresentation of current law? I suppose they purposely left out the manufacturing part back then. Whats not clear to me is possession in NJ after manufacture out of state. If some overzealous officer/DA wanted to make a situation out of it, where’s your P2P for this unserialized item?? Notionally any NJ resident who can’t make the case as a part time resident of another state, shouldn’t own such things or be able to acquire handguns without a P2P, right??
-
S2465 Passed Assembly Today
How do you register a serial number on an unserialized item? I think I saw that CA allows these 80% if they have a SN engraved, so some of these companies do it. It seems sensible that if you buy and make outside of NJ, it's yours and you can own it. But if you were ever pressed on it, especially if something like an 80% P320 or similar very new firearm (as opposed to, say an 80% AR or 1911 made out of state) was in question, they would be able to date your time of residence in NJ and maximum age of the gun, and start to assume the worst in trying to charge you. i thought the AG had sent "cease and desist" letter to many of the 80% manufacturers/resellers, to prevent sale and shipment to NJ on the premise that these are "illegal" in NJ. I don't think it holds water without the clarification that manufacture is illegal in NJ. As I understand it, currently ownership of the 80% parts, or the finished item are both legal at least until this bill flies through.