Everything posted by BigHayden
-
NJ2AS FREE BRIAN AITKEN RALLY CANCELED
Brian's guns were locked in his trunk, so keeping them out of sight does no good of you consent to a fishing expedition.
-
NJ2AS FREE BRIAN AITKEN RALLY CANCELED
According to the news reports, the police asked to search his car and he agreed. They had no probable cause to search, so if he would have refused, the cop probably would not have been able to obtain a warrant. Let this be a lesson boys and girls. Never, ever consent to a search. No good can ever come of it!
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
Before OGAMadden flipped on us (flipped us off?), the 3 Democratic hold outs on OGAM were Sweeney, Van Drew, and Madden. Sweeney is now Senate president (and isn't going to risk sticking his neck out for us; that's from a source fairly close to him) and Van Drew has introduced two versions of a shall-issue carry bill. Madden's bill was introduced in July (right around the time Van Drew's bill was first introduced, I think). Call me eternally optimistic, but this smells like Sweeney is using both of those guys as political cover to try and get some positive legislation through... Maybe I'm wrong, but I agree with kenw, the timing is suspect.
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
Even if he is a chump, we still should do everything we can to oust OGAMadden. If he does get beat, we should take the credit in the papers and brag about the clout of the NJ gun lobby! :ph34r:
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
Not to whizz in your cheerios, but if you want to get them all back at once, move. There are ~800,000 gun owners in NJ (pop. ~8,000,000), many of them are FUDDs who don't give a rat's a** about the 2nd amendment. Hell, most of them don't care about any gun other than the one NJ has so graciously allowed them to have. Bottom line? We don't have the numbers to just march into Trenton and demand our rights back (short of fully utilizing the 2nd amendment...), nor do we have the money to challenge every NJ gun law in court all at once (a tactic that would surely fail, even if we did have the funding). The only way we're going to regain our rights is if we eat the elephant one bite at a time. We all agree that we deserve the same freedom that the rest of the country enjoys, but stomping our feet and crying "foul" isn't going to help our situation any. You say you moved here from somewhere else. I'm not sure how long you've lived here, but the "ruling elite" in NJ know better than you do how you should lead your life. At least, that's what they think. And while it isn't right what they do to us, it is the reality. They buy votes from the elderly and the poor so they can continue this game of theirs. We aren't going to beat that all at once. SAF/ANJRPC are attacking on the legal front in federal court. We can do our best to educate the masses. But ultimately, we're going to need the legislature to enact (or repeal) meaningful laws that move us in the right direction. If we approach this like the anti's did, and everytime they pass a law that moves us in the right direction, we should come out with a statement that says "While this doesn't restore all of our rights as Americans in NJ, it's a good first step."
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
I think we're all a little surprised that a gun bill, introduced by a Democrat, in New Jersey, isn't the typical "kick in the balls" law that we're all used to. Some of the original comments in this thread seemed to predict doom and gloom that simply isn't in this particular bill. Having said that, I'm sure that we all agree with you. ALL of NJ's firearms laws should be repealed for being unconstitutional, but we didn't lose our rights all at once, so we're going to have to regain them incrementally. This bill makes the process of buying a handgun in NJ a little easier for law abiding citizens. Is it constitutional? Hell no. Is it better than what we currently have? Hell yes. It's a step, albeit a small one. I want to see all of these stupid permits gone; if you need a permit to exercise a right, it's not a right, it's a privilege. Eventually it will all be struck down, but until "eventually" gets here, I'll take any improvement I can get.
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
That's an interesting speculation... FWIW, PA's LTCF law says the possessor must be 'of good character' too. Not the I trust the Dems, but they may be laying a foundation for a quick law change in the face of the SAF federal lawsuit.
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
+1 Like I said before, FPID/HPP is of ZERO value for us and exists solely to discourage legal gun ownership. That being said, OGAMadden's bill isn't the worst thing we've seen from the Democrats in NJ in the last decade.
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
We shouldn't need any of it. The FPID and HPP (and if this passes, the HPID) all do absolutely NOTHING. The only check that matters is the NICS at the point of transfer. The FPID doesn't allow you to bypass NICS, so we gain nothing by having it. The same holds true for the HPP/HPID. All it does is makes the process more onerous for legal gun owners and puts a little $$ into the coffers at the same time.
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
It's just one more thing to challenge in court. Actually, the 2 personal references for each HPP does the same thing. Technically it's not introducing really new, though its wording lends itself to abuse. ETA: Damn kenw, I have to start typing faster... you keep beating me to the answer.
-
Bill S2190: Adjustments to NJ FID Card
I think some re-reading is in order. This doesn't touch the FPID section of the law. What it does is introduces an HPID, which would replace HPP's for the holder of the HPID when buying from a dealer. If you choose not to get the HPID, it's business as usual (still need FPID and still need HPP's for each handgun you want to buy), but if you opt for the HPID, you don't have to get HPP's to buy handguns from a dealer. If you want to do FTF, it sounds like that would still be done the same way it is now; HPP + COE. Am I the only one reading it this way? I'm certainly not defending OGAM Madden, but this wouldn't make things "worse". ETA: Looks like replies are coming in that echo what I'm reading...
-
Update: It Broke today... - JUST IN! MY mossberg 930!!!!!!
There are different variations of the SPX. The pistol grip version is illegal in NJ, but the standard 930 SPX is A-OK.
-
1911 - please post pics
Damn, you guys have some beautiful 1911's. I don't have pictures of mine (yet), but I have a Kimber Compact Stainless II, a Springfield EMP 9mm, and a Dan Wesson CBOB. I think if I had saved the money I spent on all three of those, I could have had a sizable down payment for one of those Wilson's.
-
Explain your handle...
My first name is pretty common (John), so in college we used last names a lot when we addressed our friends. When my wife was pregnant with our first child, we told everybody that it was going to be a boy, but we kept his name a secret. A good friend of mine said that it didn't matter what we called him, that my son would always be known as "Little Hayden". If he's "Little Hayden" that makes me "Big Hayden", and since nobody else ever has it on any of the forums I frequent, I figured it was as good as anything else.
-
Brian Aitken, in jail in NJ for 7 years for owning legal guns
http://www.examiner.com/gun-rights-in-seattle/new-jersey-case-sparks-national-outrage Workman really lays into Miller in that article. Gave me the warm and fuzzies.
-
Bryan Miller of CeasfireNJ on Brian Aitken
I'm a civic minded person, so I never dread jury duty. I think we all should serve at least once in our lives. A few years ago, I was summoned for state and local jury duty for back to back weeks. The state was first, and my number was called. So I go up to the bench and answer the questions. Then I'm told to go sit in the jury box. My butt no sooner hit the seat, and the defense attorney had me dismissed. Now, I'm a fair person, so the defense attorney may have missed out on a "good" juror for his client, but they will dismiss people based on averages and, dare I say it, stereotypes. Here's why I was dismissed. The defendant was a black man. I'm a white guy, in my 30's, shaved head. The attorney took one look at me and thought there was no way his client would get a fair shake from me. I wasn't offended (some people would have been, but the lawyer has to play the odds). When I showed up for the local jury duty, they counted my service in the state jury and dismissed me immediately. So, like you, I'd love to serve, but it just hasn't been in the cards.
-
Bryan Miller of CeasfireNJ on Brian Aitken
Wrong, wrong, wrong! As a juror, you have two duties. One, is to determine if the person is guilty under the application of the law, and second (more important), you can determine if the law itself is valid. It's called jury nullification, and it's a way for the citizens to keep a bad law from putting good people in jail. No judge in the U.S. is going to tell you about jury nullification, and in fact, many will dismiss you if they even think you know about it.
-
Adjustable Knoxx Stock...Legal?
As others have said, legal on a pump and illegal on a semi-auto. Because, as we all know, a 00 buck blast from a semi-auto with a pistol grip is much more deadly than one from a semi-auto with a regular stock or a pump shotgun of any flavor.
-
NJ S2379
Reading some of the comments, you'd think that gun owners in NJ actually had the power to sway elections.
-
Let's play devil's advocate. What would be NJ's best defense against the SAF suit?
How about, "Because Bryan Miller says so." Wasn't that their justification for OGAM? Or maybe they'll get some advice from the teachers' union and say, "But it's for the children!" In all seriousness though, NJ firearms laws are all based on Burton v. Sills, which at this point is invalid under Heller/McDonald. Any defense they offer is ultimately going to trace back to that case and won't stand up to a challenge in Federal court (had the suit been filed in NJ court, the state wouldn't have to worry about a defense, since the court would throw it out without even hearing it). And if our larger than life governor truly does have aspirations that are beyond the NJ governor's mansion he better start showing some genuine conservative leanings, including loosening restrictions on gun rights in NJ. He's sorely mistaken if he thinks the NRA isn't watching this unfold along with the guv's presidential aspirations...
-
SAF and ANJRPC files suit against the state of NJ!
It was filed this week. In a few months, there will be a motion to dismiss filed by the State. If the motion is granted, the process ends there. If it doesn't, then a hearing gets scheduled (maybe a year later?). After it's argued and decided, then it'll likely be appealed. Somebody said earlier that it'll likely be 2 years before it's ultimately settled. I think that sounds about right.
-
SAF and ANJRPC files suit against the state of NJ!
I'm still not 100% convinced, but since it failed last year there's no use :thsmiley_deadhorse: I'll concede that I agreed with you in that discussion, but I may have been hasty in my post there too. Either way, it's water under the bridge at this point, so back to the OP's topic.
-
SAF and ANJRPC files suit against the state of NJ!
You didn't highlight the part in section (2) that says "and is otherwise than as described in paragraph (1)". Read the whole statement, not just the part you highlighted. The second section says, if you don't have a permit issued from any State (that's all in section (1)), but you can carry in your State of residence, then you can carry under this amendment. I'm sorry, but you misread/misinterpreted this bill.
-
SAF and ANJRPC files suit against the state of NJ!
Please provide a link to the text that excluded reciprocity in the home state. The bill said any valid permit issued by a state is good in any other state that has CCW provisions in its laws. The "home state" text provided a way for the people of VT to carry in the other 48 states by just showing proof of residency (i.e. a driver's license) since VT has no permit system. If you can prove this interpretation wrong, I'll stand corrected. But the text of the bill didn't say anything about having to be a resident of the state from which you hold a permit.
-
$500 CCW - would you?
#1. All the shall issue states that have restrictions on where you can carry are codified in state law. The NJ statute says that a judge can place limitations on when and where (on an individual basis), and that would be in addition to what's codified in state law. #2. We're in complete agreement on this.