Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Bryan Miller of CeasfireNJ on Brian Aitken

Featured Replies

"What little I can glean about the transportation issue leaves me puzzled, but a person with common sense would not be moving illegal products from one place to another by car," said Bryan Miller, executive director of CeaseFire NJ, an organization devoted to reducing gun violence.

 

http://www.philly.com/philly/hp/news_update/20101130_Family__New_Jersey_man_serving_7_years_for_guns_he_owned_legally.html

  • Replies 73
  • Views 6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Cemeterys Gun Blob
    Cemeterys Gun Blob

    It's about him getting railroaded. He did not get a fair trial, and the Judge did not let the jury here about exemptions. As you know, firearms, and firearm related stuff is illegal in NJ, unless yo

  • And I agree with you 100%. I think that NJ's gun laws are absolutely stupid and foolish. The second I heard about the SAF and ANJRPC lawsuit, I was on their site joining both organizations. Once I

  • Ain't that a ****... I'd go in a heart beat if called but I never get called...   Funny story; in 1990 I lived in Howel and I worked for ADT in East Rutherford. I was laid off in March of 1991 a

We have like 15 different threads on this one dude :facepalm:

 

Edit, after doing a QUICK search, there are 9 threads with his name in the title. Thats not counting any threads that DONT have his name in the title, but he is the topic of conversation. Seriously, cant we limit it to just a couple threads?

15 doesn't seem like enough to me. This is terrible. This POS state is robbing a man of 7 years of his life.

  • Author

We have like 15 different threads on this one dude :facepalm:

 

Edit, after doing a QUICK search, there are 9 threads with his name in the title. Thats not counting any threads that DONT have his name in the title, but he is the topic of conversation. Seriously, cant we limit it to just a couple threads?

 

This wasn't meant to be a thread on Aitken, but on Bryan Miller's views of Aitken.

My apologies to the administrators if this is out of line, but there is a thread about Bryan Miller and his comments about the Aitken case over on PAFOA also. Here's the thread...

 

http://forum.pafoa.o...ian-aitken.html

 

I just love the way GunLawyer001 unloads on Miller (post #2). Enjoy.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

My apologies to the administrators if this is out of line, but there is a thread about Bryan Miller and his comments about the Aitken case over on PAFOA also. Here's the thread...

 

http://forum.pafoa.o...ian-aitken.html

 

I just love the way GunLawyer001 unloads on Miller (post #2). Enjoy.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

thanks for sharing that with us. It was an amazing post! Miller is just another Brady. These people have no common sense.

15 doesn't seem like enough to me. This is terrible. This POS state is robbing a man of 7 years of his life.

Do you know EXACTLY what happened? You DONT. I am not saying this guy is guilty....but without knowing the FULL details of the case, you cannot determine whether he is truly innocent or guilty. This is exactly like other gun forums I have been on, EVERY SINGLE TIME a "law abiding citizen" is arrested, they immediately throw up their arms and throw out any insults they can think of at the government based on what a biased media report told them. Its absolutely ludicrous to jump on a bandwagon like this based on what the media reports.

 

Dont get me wrong, if it is found out that this guy actually WAS innocent, I will be one of the first ones to actually be PROACTIVE about it. Not complaining on here, but actually writing letters to the Governor. I would support this guy past his facebook page and gun forums....but I wont support him unless I know he is innocent.

 

This wasn't meant to be a thread on Aitken, but on Bryan Miller's views of Aitken.

Im sorry if I offended you, I didnt mean to. Im just saying that there are MANY threads about this dude.

  • Author

 

Dont get me wrong, if it is found out that this guy actually WAS innocent, I will be one of the first ones to actually be PROACTIVE about it. Not complaining on here, but actually writing letters to the Governor. I would support this guy past his facebook page and gun forums....but I wont support him unless I know he is innocent.

 

 

It's about him getting railroaded. He did not get a fair trial, and the Judge did not let the jury here about exemptions. As you know, firearms, and firearm related stuff is illegal in NJ, unless you can prove you fall into one of these exemptions. On the surface, Aitken is/was exempt on two of the charges, but who knows about the mag issue. Judge would not allow these exemptions into the trial.

 

This could of happened to anybody.

 

Think about it next time you go to the range. The FID and permits are for *purchase*, not *possession*. You fall into the exemption when you're going to the range/gunshop/gunsmith from your home. You could get stopped for speeding, somehow firearms are found in your possession, you go to court, and Judge could say *Sorry Charlie, we're not allowing the exemption into this trial*. Hello 7 years.

No offense taken.

 

The only thing that offends me is the gun laws of NJ.

 

I am not behind him because he is wrongly accused. I am behind him because the laws are retarded.

Do you know EXACTLY what happened? You DONT. I am not saying this guy is guilty....but without knowing the FULL details of the case, you cannot determine whether he is truly innocent or guilty. This is exactly like other gun forums I have been on, EVERY SINGLE TIME a "law abiding citizen" is arrested, they immediately throw up their arms and throw out any insults they can think of at the government based on what a biased media report told them. Its absolutely ludicrous to jump on a bandwagon like this based on what the media reports.

 

You know what I know? He didn't kill anyone or even threaten to kill anyone. He was convicted of merely possessing a weapon in his vehicle. That makes him innocent of any gun related crime in my book.

No offense taken.

 

The only thing that offends me is the gun laws of NJ.

 

I am not behind him because he is wrongly accused. I am behind him because the laws are retarded.

And I agree with you 100%. I think that NJ's gun laws are absolutely stupid and foolish. The second I heard about the SAF and ANJRPC lawsuit, I was on their site joining both organizations. Once I get a couple extra bucks in my pocket (I am in between jobs right now) I will be making donations to both organizations. If they needed volunteer help for their cause, I would be there. I am not trying to advocate NJ laws by any means, simply trying to be the mediator, try to show people that we DONT know exactly what happened.

 

You know what I know? He didn't kill anyone or even threaten to kill anyone. He was convicted of merely possessing a weapon in his vehicle. That makes him innocent of any gun related crime in my book.

And therein lies the problem. Your book does not make the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he actually broke the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he should be exempt from breaking the laws. This statement you made shows ignorance to the N'th degree. Simple possession was the crime here, and it is in fact a crime on the books. It DOES NOT matter how stupid, how unconstitutional, how much of a violation of rights a law is. If the law is on the books, then you either have to obey it or pay the consequences. If you dont like the law, then move out of NJ. It sucks, but YOU dont have the power to make laws or decide innocence.

Manipulating the system to get a conviction by disallowing exemptions shows the judge to be subjective. An appelate court would recognize this immediately if it has any objectivity. Not likely in this state though.

 

To get back on track: Miller's lack of knowledge of firearms laws (calling hollowpoint ammunition illegal) is exactly why I feel the same way as the guy in post #2 on that PA forum.

  • Author

Simple possession was the crime here, and it is in fact a crime on the books. It DOES NOT matter how stupid, how unconstitutional, how much of a violation of rights a law is. If the law is on the books, then you either have to obey it or pay the consequences. If you dont like the law, then move out of NJ. It sucks, but YOU dont have the power to make laws or decide innocence.

 

 

We, as gun owners, are guilty of simple possession every time we travel to the range, gunshop, or gunsmith. In the eyes of NJ, it's our problem to prove we're exempt. There are exemptions under the law for us, and Aitken who even as a non resident on his way to become a resident, but the Judge would not allow those into the trial

 

That's why so many people are behind Aitken.

We, as gun owners, are guilty of simple possession every time we travel to the range, gunshop, or gunsmith. In the eyes of NJ, it's our problem to prove we're exempt. There are exemptions under the law for us, and Aitken who even as a non resident on his way to become a resident, but the Judge would not allow those into the trial

 

That's why so many people are behind Aitken.

I understand that. My comment was in reference to the "he didnt kill or threaten to kill anyone" comment. Just because someone doesnt put another persons life in danger does NOT mean that a crime was not committed.

 

As for the bolded part.....thats what is extremely sad. In a justice system where the burden of proof is on the government, its extremely sad that we as gun owners need to prove we are innocent. There are SO MANY measures that must be taken in NJ in order to make it appear as if the defendant is in fact innocent, regardless of the charges. Did you guys know that during the actual trial, a defendant, regardless of the offense, can NOT be cuffed and must be dressed appropriately. Even worse, the burden of making sure that the defendant is dressed appropriately is on the Prosecutors Office :facepalm:

 

 

 

And therein lies the problem. Your book does not make the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he actually broke the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he should be exempt from breaking the laws. This statement you made shows ignorance to the N'th degree. Simple possession was the crime here, and it is in fact a crime on the books. It DOES NOT matter how stupid, how unconstitutional, how much of a violation of rights a law is. If the law is on the books, then you either have to obey it or pay the consequences. If you dont like the law, then move out of NJ. It sucks, but YOU dont have the power to make laws or decide innocence.

 

The problem is that our own state doesn't recognize the laws they made! You can't make a law, and then decide that only half of the law matters. You cant expect people to foresee something like this. If i were on my way to the range with my 9mm 15rd mags and HP ammo, and i got stopped by a cop and searched this very well could have been me. All legal through exceptions of the law, i guess that part of the law don't matter much. I'm not a fan of if you don't like the law move out... It should be if you follow the law you still go to jail... :icon_rolleyes:

And therein lies the problem. Your book does not make the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he actually broke the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he should be exempt from breaking the laws. This statement you made shows ignorance to the N'th degree. Simple possession was the crime here, and it is in fact a crime on the books. It DOES NOT matter how stupid, how unconstitutional, how much of a violation of rights a law is. If the law is on the books, then you either have to obey it or pay the consequences. If you dont like the law, then move out of NJ. It sucks, but YOU dont have the power to make laws or decide innocence.

 

So Mcdonald vs Chicago does not mean crap? The state is breaking a law... a Constitutional law... why aren't you upset or defending the people on that? It is ok for the government to disregard fundamental laws but people can not disregard Unconstitutional ones? Who is the actual criminal here? Where the hell is that logic from? So if they make it illegal for you to grow vegetables then tough crap? Move out of the state? If you are forced to only use government contractors when doing work on your house, is that now a fair law? Just because it is a "law" does not mean it is LEGAL or Constitutional...People are fed up with this BS and when the left disregards our fundamental rights I hear lame excuses like yours that tick me off. Why... why is it OK for the left or corrupt legislatures to trample on our Constitutional right to defend ourselves? Why are you defending the obvious government intrusion and Unconstitutional takeover of OUR rights?

My apologies to the administrators if this is out of line, but there is a thread about Bryan Miller and his comments about the Aitken case over on PAFOA also. Here's the thread...

 

http://forum.pafoa.o...ian-aitken.html

 

I just love the way GunLawyer001 unloads on Miller (post #2). Enjoy.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

 

 

That is a very good point GunLawyer001 is making. I am glad he is pointing out what we all know and driving the point home.

Pretty much all of NJ gun law is illegal. So whats the issue here? Our gov wont waste any political capital on trying to get the legislature to pass some legislation that does not make us criminals in general. Scumbags like Miller capitalize on death of someone who was not saved in an official capacity so now we all have to suffer.

Sometimes when dealing with state government you wonder why we elect such stupid people who in turn elect their stupid friends to judgeships. This judge sounded like a douche. Why would the guy have a car full of cars and dishes if he was not moving?

I dont drive around like that each day, and the only times my car has been full of clothes and dishes has been during a move.

So being that a judge has an obligation to consider the spirit of the law, and not be a drone on the bench, he should have had the jury consider that if they asked him for it several times. I think the jury should have chose not to convict this man. Just look at State of NJ vs. Pellitieri (sp). The judge states 'When dealing with guns, the citizen acts at his own peril' We need to apply pressure. More pressure.

Just FYI...

 

The jury did not have to convict - jury nullification.

 

The judge in this case was forced to resign over improprieties resulting from another case.

 

The crux of the matter was that the judge refused to allow the jury to hear the exemptions that Nappen felt applied in this case.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

FWIW, the story has gone around the Right blogosphere, and was on Instapundit, and Drudge report, if that hasn't been covered

My apologies to the administrators if this is out of line, but there is a thread about Bryan Miller and his comments about the Aitken case over on PAFOA also. Here's the thread...

 

http://forum.pafoa.o...ian-aitken.html

 

I just love the way GunLawyer001 unloads on Miller (post #2). Enjoy.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

 

Bob while I am saddened when anyone dies in the line of duty that is one funny a$$ed post on pafoa :)

And therein lies the problem. Your book does not make the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he actually broke the laws. Your book does not determine whether or not he should be exempt from breaking the laws. This statement you made shows ignorance to the N'th degree. Simple possession was the crime here, and it is in fact a crime on the books. It DOES NOT matter how stupid, how unconstitutional, how much of a violation of rights a law is. If the law is on the books, then you either have to obey it or pay the consequences. If you dont like the law, then move out of NJ. It sucks, but YOU dont have the power to make laws or decide innocence.

 

Lets say hypothetically he wasn't moving or driving to the range (therefore transporting illegally) and he had a 17 round Glock 17 mag. If you were on the jury would you convict him even if you believe the law is unconstitutional and illegal?

Personally I wouldnt convict him if I was on the jury. Thats what I find so hard to believe about this case. Wasnt there 1 f**king juror who realized this was all wrong convicting this guy if in fact it was just transporting guns from 1 place to another. I still feel some facts are missing from this case that are not being told in the media.

 

Lets say hypothetically he wasn't moving or driving to the range (therefore transporting illegally) and he had a 17 round Glock 17 mag. If you were on the jury would you convict him even if you believe the law is unconstitutional and illegal?

Personally I wouldnt convict him if I was on the jury. Thats what I find so hard to believe about this case. Wasnt there 1 f**king juror who realized this was all wrong convicting this guy if in fact it was just transporting guns from 1 place to another. I still feel some facts are missing from this case that are not being told in the media.

 

 

I doubt the media was inside the jury room when they voted so what would you like the media to tell you?

What I meant to say was I dont think everyone knows the all the facts of this case. I wasnt implying that the media should make up facts which they never do anyway.

 

I doubt the media was inside the jury room when they voted so what would you like the media to tell you?

Personally I wouldnt convict him if I was on the jury. Thats what I find so hard to believe about this case. Wasnt there 1 f**king juror who realized this was all wrong convicting this guy if in fact it was just transporting guns from 1 place to another. I still feel some facts are missing from this case that are not being told in the media.

The judge probably dismissed anyone who owned guns during jury selection. He obviously didn't like gun owners.

If he were to be judged by his peers then wouldnt it be biased to not have some one with a gun on the jury?

The prosecutor and defense attorney pick the jury. The defense attorney should have had some gun owners on the jury. And how do you know there weren't any gun owners on the jury?

 

As a juror, your job is uphold the law, not rule as you see fit.

 

I still want to know what was in Brian's trunk. Neither side is releasing the full details of the case.

 

So Mcdonald vs Chicago does not mean crap? The state is breaking a law... a Constitutional law... why aren't you upset or defending the people on that? It is ok for the government to disregard fundamental laws but people can not disregard Unconstitutional ones? Who is the actual criminal here? Where the hell is that logic from? So if they make it illegal for you to grow vegetables then tough crap? Move out of the state? If you are forced to only use government contractors when doing work on your house, is that now a fair law? Just because it is a "law" does not mean it is LEGAL or Constitutional...People are fed up with this BS and when the left disregards our fundamental rights I hear lame excuses like yours that tick me off. Why... why is it OK for the left or corrupt legislatures to trample on our Constitutional right to defend ourselves? Why are you defending the obvious government intrusion and Unconstitutional takeover of OUR rights?

 

Seriously, is reading beyond you? Read my other posts, because the post you quoted was my response to an ignorant comment.

 

However, in response to your post.......Yes I am VERY mad that the gun laws in NJ are unconstitutional. Yes I want the laws changed. No I do not think we should fight for the law to be changed. But what you are not understanding is we do not have the power to get any of that done immediately. We need to help fund and back up organizations like the SAF and ANJRPC, which I have already done. Get it through your head dude, this isn't grade school anymore. Crying that something isn't right does NOT get things changed, and nobody is going to give you a freebie when they have different motives. If the NJ government wants to restrict our gun rights, they will do EVERYTHING they can to restrict them....right or wrong. I have never said that it was okay for the NJ government to "trample on our Constitutional right to defend ourselves." I believe it should be my right, and I guarantee you that if the law was changed tomorrow, I would sell my rifle in order to buy a pistol. But right now, the state of NJ says we don't have the right to carry. And until the state of NJ says we are allowed to, we CANNOT carry. If you don't like that, if you don't want to wait for SAF and ANJRPC to get things changed, then leave. Its that simple. Nothing I have said, on this forum or any other forum, defends the state of NJ regarding the gun laws.

The prosecutor and defense attorney pick the jury. The defense attorney should have had some gun owners on the jury. And how do you know there weren't any gun owners on the jury?

 

As a juror, your job is uphold the law, not rule as you see fit.

 

I still want to know what was in Brian's trunk. Neither side is releasing the full details of the case.

 

 

Wrong, wrong, wrong! As a juror, you have two duties. One, is to determine if the person is guilty under the application of the law, and second (more important), you can determine if the law itself is valid. It's called jury nullification, and it's a way for the citizens to keep a bad law from putting good people in jail.

 

No judge in the U.S. is going to tell you about jury nullification, and in fact, many will dismiss you if they even think you know about it.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.